To the One Who Doesn’t Love Me - Reviews

To the One Who Doesn’t Love Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is so distinctly voiced I can practically hear each character's cadence without seeing their names. Duke Bermund speaks in formal, measured sentences. Even his apology has layers — 'I misspoke. I apologize. Please forget what I said.' Three separate statements where one would do. He's performing politeness, not being polite. And when he observes Rachel afterward, his thoughts are analytical and precise. This man thinks in threats and calculations. Viola is all exclamation points and energy. 'Oh! I just remembered there's something going on with our family!' The parenthetical asides, the dramatic gestures, the fake confusion with Edward — her dialogue is performative even when she's not performing. 'You know, that thing' followed by a meaningful look? That's a person who communicates in subtext and still expects everyone to keep up. Edward is awkward and sincere. 'I wanted to confirm if the rumors were true.' He says exactly what he means, scratches his cheek, smiles bitterly at Viola's glare. No games. Tervan's dialogue is the quietest and the most loaded. Every sentence is deliberate. 'About the things you're hiding.' 'That's not true.' 'Finally, you neutralized the witch's poison, right? That's five in total.' Short. Precise. No filler. When he drops the revelation about five spells, he doesn't raise his voice. He speaks in a particular low tone. The contrast between his earlier silence in the group and this sudden verbal precision is everything. Rachel herself shifts her voice depending on who she's talking to — formal with the Duke, warm with Viola, guarded with Tervan. Her internal voice with Creon is almost playful, which shows their dynamic has evolved from transactional to something more companionable.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in controlled escalation. It opens with Duke Bermund — high tension, low warmth, political threat. We're in the world of power plays and hidden agendas. Then Viola bursts in like a sunshine explosion and suddenly we're in warm friend territory. The tonal whiplash is intentional and it works because Rachel's internal state grounds both. She's exhausted from the Duke encounter and the friends are her decompression. But here's what's brilliant: Viola's fake exit isn't just comic relief. It's a structural pivot. She removes the buffer characters and leaves Rachel alone with Tervan, shifting the chapter from ensemble warmth to intimate confrontation. By the time we reach the final lines, the entire emotional temperature has changed. We went from polite social interaction to a direct challenge about truth and deception. And the climax — Tervan revealing he knows about the five spells — hits like a gut punch precisely because it comes after what feels like a peaceful interlude. The author uses Viola's warmth as misdirection. We relax because the friends are here, and then Tervan destroys that safety in two paragraphs. The ending itself is cut off mid-sentence, which could feel lazy but actually functions perfectly. We've been given the setup — Tervan is about to reveal how much he knows — and now we're left hanging on the most important conversation of the arc. The pacing doesn't just build tension, it weaponizes it.
... Read More
I need to talk about Tervan because the tragedy of his character in this arc is DEVASTATING. He's this genuinely good guy—worried about Rachel, protective, suggesting she go back because she's not suited for combat—and he has NO IDEA what she's been through. The scene where Rachel is just staring at his face, memorizing his features, and he thinks she's being weird instead of realizing she's probably doing this for the twenty-sixth time? I actually had to put the book down. And then there's Creon, the Time Demon, casually sitting in her necklace like some kind of snarky therapist, telling her 'He's noticed that you're different. Well, it's only natural.' Rachel immediately changes the subject because she CANNOT deal with that conversation. Her relationship with her parents at the end is the softest thing in the entire text—she lets herself cry and melt into her mother's arms for the first time since... apparently ever. But the moment Tervan calls out to her at the end and she nods and smiles like nothing happened? She's carrying twenty-six lifetimes of trauma and he still sees the same Rachel he grew up with. That gap between them is heartbreaking.
... Read More
The line that absolutely destroyed me was: 'when she faced Tervan's death for the twentieth time, strangely, she felt no sadness. All that remained for Rachel was duty alone.' Do you understand what that means? She loved him enough to die repeatedly, but not enough to still feel it after two dozen losses. The emotional arc from the clumsy, laughing girl he knew to the cold person standing over Sara's corpse covered in blood—it's the most brutal character death I've read and nobody actually dies. The family reunion scene had me wrecked though. 'I'm back.' Those two words after however many loops of being alone in this hell, finally saying it to her parents who have no idea. And then she has to put on the smile and go to the banquet. She can't tell them anything because they're part of the story she's trying to protect. That scene where her mother cups her face and Rachel presses her lips together to hold back tears—she's surrounded by love and she's never been more alone.
... Read More
'Be quiet.' — two words from Creon and suddenly I'm questioning everything about who's actually inside Rachel's head. The author's decision to give us this internal voice without explanation is either bold or deeply unsettling, probably both. Is Creon a separate entity? A fragment of her own psyche? A guide from a previous regression? The text refuses to clarify, and that refusal is itself a kind of narrative voice — cold, clinical, withholding. Now let's talk about the dialogue between Ryan and Rachel. This is where the author really shines. Ryan's dialogue is warm, slightly formal, with this underlying earnestness that makes him feel like a genuine character rather than a plot device. 'Is it good?' after offering wine — such a small, human moment. And then his joke about her funeral face is both brave and awkward, and Rachel's deadpan response 'Do I really look like that?' is comedy gold wrapped in tragedy. Tervan's dialogue is purposefully flat and clueless. 'It's nothing like that. We didn't fight.' / 'I can't think of anything.' / 'Yes.' The man communicates in monosyllables when it matters most. Meanwhile Viola's dialogue bubbles with anxiety and manipulation — she's testing everyone, stepping on Tervan's foot deliberately, watching Rachel like a hawk. Her 'Oh, I'm sorry. My mistake.' with a 'prim smile' while clearly having done it on purpose — you can hear the teeth-gritting. The author's narrative voice itself has this dry, observant quality — never over-explaining, letting actions speak louder than internal monologues. When Rachel watches Tervan and Viola dance and 'briefly glanced' at them with a 'plain response,' the narrative doesn't tell us she's heartbroken. It just shows us the flatness of her reply and lets us sit with the devastation.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—this time loop mechanic is executed SO well. The reveal that Rachel was stuck in this cycle for twenty-six loops hit me like a truck. The way the plot slowly peels back layers is brilliant. At first it looks like a standard fantasy subjugation mission, then Rachel drops this weird warning about the sky darkening, and you're just sitting there going WHAT IS HAPPENING. Then the flashbacks dump twenty-six rounds of repeated death onto you. Twenty-SIX. The author doesn't even linger on the earlier loops—they just summarize them in a few sentences and move to the emotional point, which is that Rachel went from desperately trying to stop Tervan from joining to literally joining herself just to change the variables. And the real plot twist that wrecked me? It wasn't the time travel itself—it was the realization that she's in a NOVEL. That she's the villain destined for tragedy, and the only way out was to rewrite the story from the inside. Creon's line 'How many years of difference are there between your time and his?' is a masterclass in exposition that doesn't feel like exposition.
... Read More
The atmosphere in this chapter is SO rich. I could literally picture the banquet hall — the orchestral allemande playing, the way people part when the Crown Prince steps into the center, Viola and Tervan watching from across the room. There's this whole sensory experience layered in subtly: - The black half-glove on Ryan's hand (so specific and visual) - The gentle allemande music flowing between them - The bitter taste of Bellin tea from Mount Madovel (which alone tells you this is a world with elaborate geography and trade) - Bermund's cold light in his friendly gaze - Catrin rushing in breathless, almost falling And then the contrast between the bright, noisy ballroom and the quiet reception room where Rachel faces Bermund alone. The shift from public performance to private confrontation is seamless. I also loved the domestic touch of Rachel heading home to rest, the Pluret family carriage waiting outside, Catrin placing a cushion beside her. It grounds the whole high-stakes political maneuvering in everyday reality. The world feels lived-in. You can tell nobles have different tastes in tea, that carriages have designated waiting spots, that maids know exactly when to enter and exit. Every detail supports the fantasy setting without stopping the story to explain itself.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—the reveal that Rachel has done this twenty-six times? Twenty-six times. Not three, not five, not a cool little time-loop romance number. TWENTY-SIX. That changes everything you thought you knew about this character in a single paragraph. You go from reading her as some slightly eccentric noble daughter to someone who has literally worn out the fabric of reality trying to save one person, and nobody around her has any idea. What's genuinely brilliant about how this plot twist is handled is that it doesn't come as a dramatic exposition dump. Rachel doesn't sit down and monologue. Tervan is the one who notices first—observes her like she's some alien thing wearing his friend's skin—and asks the most devastatingly simple question: "Are you really Rachel?" And Rachel, who has spent twenty-six lifetimes learning to perform normalcy, can't even bring herself to lie to him anymore. The fact that she confirms it with a quiet nod and then deflects by asking "How was I?" instead of explaining anything? That's peak writer energy right there. The Tervan guilt spiral is also a masterclass in indirect conflict. He didn't know she liked him, or so he pretended, and now she's telling him directly that it hurt her that he pretended not to notice. Meanwhile, he's apologizing for something he didn't knowingly do, and she's saying she doesn't want his apology. It's emotionally tangled in the best way possible. The pacing of this revelation—slow, awkward, uncomfortable—mirrors exactly how real conversations about feelings go when everyone involved is sitting on top of half-truths. And then the second plot beat lands: the Tears of Licorice. A MacGuffin with a name that sounds like it came out of a fairy tale someone told a child who was never going to grow up. Rachel is bargaining with a Time Demon for powers she can't afford, and the cost is an object she doesn't even know how to find. That's a story structure that's basically just "mountain of problems, here's another mountain." I'm here for it.
... Read More
There is something deeply symbolic about the fact that the item Rachel is searching for is described as a transparent jewel. Think about it. Transparency, clarity, things that appear plain or invisible on the surface but actually contain extraordinary power. That is basically the thesis statement of this entire novel. Rachel herself is a transparent jewel. She walks into rooms and people see someone who 'wasn't initially exceptional'—as Edward himself put it. They see a girl who had to work hard, not a prodigy. But beneath that transparent surface is magical power that matches a creature like Creon, who is apparently ancient and immensely powerful. The Tears of Licorice, whatever it ultimately is, seems to be a physical manifestation of the same principle: something that looks ordinary to untrained eyes but radiates something extraordinary to those who actually know how to look. And then there's Creon himself, who communicates through thoughts rather than speech, who hides his true nature, who chooses to stay by Rachel's side across multiple lifetimes. He's basically the emotional anchor of this whole thematic structure. When he says 'Only breaking my seal enables its use,' it's not just plot exposition—it's the book telling us repeatedly that power, love, truth, and loyalty are all things that require the right conditions to be unlocked. They don't announce themselves. They wait. The fact that Rachel deliberately hides her full abilities throughout this entire chapter is the thematic climax. She is living proof that transparency doesn't mean emptiness.
... Read More
Can we just pause for a second and talk about how Rachel looks at Edward and notices his hair is the same color as Viola's? Like, that hit me out of nowhere. It's such a small detail—'His pink hair, the same color as Viola's, swayed softly'—but it landed like a brick. Because it means even in this moment, even when she's standing next to someone who has genuinely helped her through multiple timelines, her mind is already pulling towards someone else. Or remembering someone else. And then Edward says this line that wrecked me: 'I won't dismiss your efforts because of simple jealousy.' He's being so genuinely kind here, he really is. He sees she's grown, he acknowledges the work behind it, and he means it. But Rachel's entire reaction tells the real story—she smiles genuinely for the first time in what feels like forever, and then immediately gets uncomfortable looking into his eyes. Why? Because she knows something he doesn't. She knows how many times she's lived this life and how many times she's watched him be exactly this good to her without getting anything in return. What breaks me though is the Ryan moment at the end. He's holding the door for her, walking beside her, and she's making this tiny calculation about how much access to give him. She compromises on 'just to the entrance.' She's always calculating, always guarding herself. And somewhere in the middle of all that, Creon just sends her a mental message like a normal conversation. Not even shocking anymore, just... everyday. That's the life she's built across so many loops that I almost forgot how weird this all is.
... Read More
'If you're going to talk about that too, I'll take off this necklace and put it somewhere else.' Stop. The DYNAMIC between Rachel and Creon is absolutely COMEDIC GOLD. This thing sealed inside her necklace has the emotional range of a chaotic gremlin and Rachel treats it like a toxic roommate she can't evict. Look at how distinct their voices are: CREON: defensive, petty, trying to distance himself from 'that guy from earlier' (who apparently also died repeatedly), immediately gets flustered when threatened RACHEL: dry, sarcastic, completely unimpressed, weaponizes silence and threats with terrifying calm And then Tervan's dialogue - he's so earnest and slightly awkward. 'Just because. No particular reason. I wanted to go in together after a long time. Why? Is that not okay?' That's a guy who's trying SO HARD to play it cool and failing adorably. Rachel sees right through it obviously. Duke Bermund speaks in this polished, condescending-by politeness way that's genuinely unsettling. 'I can't understand why you would refuse a position to become the master of mages in such a place.' Translation: YOU WILL DO WHAT I WANT. The narrative voice itself is great too - it stays tightly focused on Rachel's internal experience while letting her observations do the heavy lifting.
... Read More
I need to talk about Tervan because this boy is genuinely perceptive and that makes him scary in the best way. Everyone keeps treating him like the soft one, the one who got played by the plot. But watch this — he pieces together that Rachel used FIVE spells during the Witch's Forest incident. Not three. Five. The barrier blocking lightning (x2), the physical speed enhancement for her disappearance, the spell that killed the witch, and the poison neutralizer. That's not guesswork. That's observation. He watched her fight. He was there. And he kept quiet this whole time. When he says 'I needed time to talk with you' after Viola drags Edward away, his voice is low and grave. This isn't a casual chat. He's been carrying this suspicion and now he's ready to confront her. The dynamic shift between them here is massive — in previous books he might have been the guy Rachel comforts, but now? Now she's the one holding all the cards and he just proved he's been watching. Viola's relationship with Rachel is also fascinating. She's the type of friend who notices everything but says nothing about the important stuff. She sees Rachel's demeanor change after the forest, she asks if something upset her, she pushes for honesty — but when Rachel deflects, Viola accepts it and just offers continued support instead of pressing. That's either genuine friendship or willful blindness. Probably both. And Edward — poor Edward came here thinking he was there for magic stuff and Viola had to physically drag him away mid-sentence. He's genuinely curious about Rachel's abilities, no jealousy, just excitement. Sweet but completely oblivious to the emotional minefield happening right in front of him.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or