This Question Has Been Taught 12 Times - Reviews

This Question Has Been Taught 12 Times
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let us talk about stakes because they just went THROUGH THE ROOF in these chapters. On one level, Bai Tong has a simple mission: help Sun Daining answer twelve questions to break some kind of cycle. Two questions remain. That is the surface plot. It sounds almost academic until you realize the stakes are literally about survival — Bai Tong cannot finish this while locked in a room by their mother. The mother-daughter conflict is where the real terror lives. Bai Jingru does not yell. She does not threaten explicitly. She simply removes Bai Tong's agency one layer at a time. First the phone gets taken (accidentally shut down, apparently). Then the door fingerprint is deleted. Then the curtains are closed. Then doctors arrive with needles and unmarked pills. Bai Tong tries to resist — lies in bed refusing to eat, smashes the camera, tries the window — and each act of defiance meets a calm, impenetrable wall of maternal control. Bai Tong thinks about killing their mother. Just thinks it. And then immediately thinks about going to beg for mercy because their arms cannot twist their own thigh. This is not a parent-child conflict. This is imprisonment with love as the justification. Meanwhile the romantic conflict is equally dangerous. Bai Tong kissed Sun Daining without knowing if Sun Daining actually reciprocated — and now Sun Daining is the only person coming to visit, the only source of warmth, the only one bringing math notes and flower bouquets while Bai Tong sits drugged and isolated. What happens if Bai Jingru finds out? What happens if the cycle cannot be broken because Bai Tong is too chemically sedated to think? What happens to Sun Daining if they get caught up in this? The suspense is suffocating because every scene cuts off at the worst possible moment. Sun Daining copying the questions. Bai Tong finally understanding but still not understanding. The mother watching through the cracks. I need the next chapter immediately.
... Read More
Okay so the hat moment. Let me just... can we talk about how Bai Tong literally GIVES Yin Yi their hat and then Sun Daining just silently shifts to C position and stops holding Bai Tong's arm? And then Bai Tong is like, hmm, weirdly quiet, let me reach out and touch her arm to check? And Sun Daining just... accepts it. Let me give you a fulcrum, babe. I'm losing my mind. This whole chapter is just a masterclass in quiet romantic tension. Sun Daining's birthday is the backdrop for everything crumbling and rebuilding at the same time. She doesn't tell Bai Tong it's her birthday. Yin Yi doesn't remind Bai Tong. Bai Tong shows up empty-handed and apologizes like it's some kind of crime. And Sun Daining is like, I just wanted you to come. Which is both incredibly sweet and devastating because clearly she wanted MORE than that and didn't know how to ask. Then the finger cot scene. I SCREAMED. Yin Yi turning beet red, shoving things into her bag, begging Bai Tong not to tell Sun Daining. What are these for?? But also WHAT DOES THAT SAY about what's happening between Yin Yi and Sun Daining that Bai Tong absolutely cannot be a witness to? The fact that Sun Daining is aware enough to just look between them and say "you two find something... Is it so difficult?" while having zero idea what's actually going on?? My chest hurts. And Bai Tong writing out all those math steps, every detail, hoping to help Sun Daining escape the loop. That's love language number one and I respect it.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the therapy scene because on the surface it's supposed to be comedic — Bai Tong pretending to cry, her mom being intense, the doctor being professional — but underneath it is absolutely devastating. Bai Jingru's desperation is palpable in every line. She's so terrified of hereditary mental illness that she's trying to control every variable in her daughter's life. Genes can't be controlled, so the environment must be controlled. That line alone tells you everything about what kind of mother she is. And Bai Tong — sweet, manipulative Bai Tong — sees exactly what her mother needs and gives it to her. She holds her mom's hand, whispers "I'm scared," lets Bai Jingru answer for her. But when they're alone with the doctor, it all drops. She suppresses laughter. She makes fun of the word "Tongtong." This kid has zero emotional investment in any of this performance except one thing: keeping her mother occupied, distracted, spending money on the highest-tier therapy package. The most heartbreaking moment is when Bai Jingru says "I will always be with you, don't be afraid, Tongtong" and Bai Tong feels the collar of her uniform tightening. Not because she's anxious — because she's been holding her breath this whole time, performing for a mother who only knows how to love through control. "I'm scared. I think I look like him." Bai Tong says this to the doctor and I literally stopped reading for a second. Is she referring to Sheng Yan? Is she using that fake diary against her mother now? Or is she, for one destabilizing moment, actually afraid? I don't know and that's what makes it beautiful.
... Read More
There is one image in these chapters that I cannot stop thinking about. After the fire escape kiss, Bai Tong's last thought before closing their eyes is The small skylight above the fire escape. The afternoon sunlight shone in from the outside. The dim and cold light scattered endlessly on the gray wall, and finally disappeared into the narrow darkness. Let that sink in. The light is dim and cold. It scatters. It disappears into narrow darkness. And right next to that image is the fact that Sun Daining is warm. The contrast between that collapsing light and that human warmth is honestly some of the most cinematic writing I have encountered in any novel. It reads like a film direction. You can SEE it. You can hear the hum of the city outside the skylight. The apartment itself is another character. Closed curtains. Softer-than-necessary lights. Switches that Bai Tong never wants to touch because God said there must be light before there can be light — which is such a perfectly twisted way for Bai Tong to internalize their mother's control. The bedroom monitor that looks pitch black at night instead of showing those annoying red recording dots. The door that requires fingerprints from the inside and then simply stops accepting Bai Tong's. These are not just setting details. They are the architecture of a cage. And then there is the school setting implied throughout — the finger cot discussion happening during what seems like a hangout session, Sun Daining showing up with a schoolbag full of test papers and notes, the casual mentions of next semester and studying abroad. It all feels like a real Chinese high school environment where teenage romance and academic pressure and parental control collide in ways that are painfully specific yet universal.
... Read More
Bai Tong walks past that ice cream shop and orders ALL THREE flavors they mentioned. Then eats them alone by the river while the mint and matcha taste terrible. This is not a detail. This is the entire conflict of the novel compressed into one heartbreaking sequence. Bai Tong hears something said in passing and carries it around like sacred text, and the world responds with terrible mint flavor and wind that's only moderately comfortable. The stakes keep escalating and I'm not even sure the characters fully grasp what they're up against. Sun Daining is stuck in a temporal loop—currently on her fourth cycle—and Bai Tong is the only one who seems to be building something across repetitions. The math paper. The detailed steps. The hope that if they can just solve this problem, they can break the cycle. But what's the cost? Every time Bai Tong tries to help, they get dragged into situations they're fundamentally unequipped to handle. Social situations. Birthday surprises. Finding hair ties in bags that contain... finger cots... And the interpersonal stakes are just as volatile. Sun Daining's quiet displeasure when Bai Tong suggests leaving after Yin Yi goes home—You just want to stay with her?—that line hit me like a physical blow. It's not jealousy exactly, it's something worse. It's the fear that you are replaceable in someone else's emotional geography. Meanwhile Yin Yi exists in this constant state of energetic overload, creating WeChat groups, making everyone add each other, playing the role of eyes that watch forever, while simultaneously hiding things in her bag that make her blush through the roof. Bai Tong's internal conflict is the engine: they want to help but don't know how, they want to connect but don't know the language, they give everything they have (math solutions, hats, presence) and it's never quite enough. The tension isn't whether they'll succeed—it's whether succeeding will cost them whatever fragile normalcy they've managed to construct. And the suspense? Relentless. Every conversation has double meaning. Every silence means something. I can't stop reading and I don't know why but my heart is in my throat.
... Read More
The way this author uses domestic spaces as character mirrors is absolutely insane. You've got Bai Tong's house—'Yilan Garden, panoramic duplex house' with 'ceiling height of more than six meters,' marble floors, crystal chandeliers, described explicitly as 'hotel lobby-style decoration.' Cold. Impressive. Empty. The cat has a GOLD GRADIENT LAYER. I'm not even joking. This is a home designed for showing off, not for living. Then you step into Sun Daining's place and suddenly the prose WARMS UP—'warm wood tones,' blueberries growing on the balcony, yogurt gone sour because someone tried too hard, a kitchen that smells like someone's actual life being lived. And Bai Tong notices this. She says she 'liked it at first sight.' One sentence and you understand everything about her loneliness. Even the alleyway scene is worth sitting with. It's 'dimly lit'—not scary dark but just enough shadow for those girls to be visible but not fully seen, smoking phones, calling out to the Xueba. There's something almost cinematic about how the light works in this story. The home scenes feel like they're lit differently than the school scenes. And that final image of Bai Tong solving the math problem at midnight, alone in her enormous expensive bedroom—that's a visual that's going to stick with me. Light from a desk lamp, a girl conquering a problem nobody else in the school could solve, at 12 AM. What is that about?
... Read More
Let me just say this once: Sun Daining bringing homemade yogurt to class and saying "if you eat it you have to teach me" is the most unhinged romantic approach I have ever encountered in a novel. And Bai Tong's response? She doesn't eat it, takes it home, puts it in the fridge, and THEN follows Sun Daining home like a weirdo. These two are genuinely bizarre together and it works. What I find most interesting is that Bai Tong — who is basically a sociopath-in-training when it comes to social interaction — actually finds Sun Daining FUNNY. She literally thinks to herself: "Why didn't he find it so interesting to see someone embarrassed before?" She's never found embarrassment amusing, but Sun Daining turning red while offering yogurt? That's content. And then the follow-home sequence — Bai Tong trailing behind her at three to five meters like a stalker shadow, and Sun Daining is COMPLETELY UNAWARE. The guy's insensitivity level is off the charts but in a way that's kind of endearing? Or maybe just concerning. Either way, it's hilarious. Then Yin Yi shows up — sharp, athletic, protective — and immediately sizes up Bai Tong as a threat. The whole dynamic between these three is so charged. Yin Yi grabs Bai Tong's collar, Sun Daining rushes back to de-escalate, and Bai Tong just stands there doing nothing while everyone else loses their minds. It's messy and chaotic and I cannot stop thinking about it. "Bai Tong, I really hate you," Sun Daining says at one point. I think that's the closest thing to affection in the entire novel.
... Read More
The elevator scene broke me. Like actually physically broke me. Bai Tong asks Sun Daining two direct questions — Do you like Yin Yi? Do you like me? — and Sun Daining does not answer the second one. She STALLS. She says What kind of like do you mean like a person who knows exactly what is happening and is deliberately making Bai Tong suffer. So Bai Tong kisses her. Not a gentle test-of-the-waters kiss. A grab-her-face-and-press-your-lips-against-theirs kind of kiss. And then walks away like nothing happened. And Sun Daining pulls them into a FIRE ESCAPE and gives them THE REAL KISS. The one where she rubs Bai Tong's lips afterward like she is committing the taste to memory. Then comes the line that destroyed me: I have liked you since the first time I saw you. You are so kind, smart, good-looking, and very polite to others. This is Sun Daining essentially laying their entire heart on the table and Bai Tong is over here thinking wait did she admit to liking the WRONG person because I am not particularly polite to anyone?? And Bai Tong's answer is not some grand declaration. It is I like being with you. I want to be with you forever. That is it. Four words that hit harder than any novel speech ever has. Because it is honest. Because Bai Tong does not perform love, they just STATE it. Meanwhile Sun Daining is the only warm thing in Bai Tong's entire life and Bai Tong describes it as simply That person is warm. The only source of heat. I literally said out loud oh my god this is so beautiful while reading this.
... Read More
Can we just talk about how these two speak? It's everything. Bai Tong's dialogue is flat, almost deadpan, but layered with subtext. 'You should have said it earlier.' Not 'Why did you poison me?' but 'you should have warned me.' It's bureaucratic. It's domestic. It's perfectly Bai Tong. Sun Daining, on the other hand, is all fragmented sentences and apologies. 'No more, used up.' 'Forget it, I'm sorry.' 'I'm planning to memorize the answer and write it down to try.' She's constantly hedging, constantly apologizing for existing. But then—the classroom scene. When she raises her hand, her dialogue is pure internal panic. 'Ah ah ah ah help.' That's not speech; that's a scream encoded. And Bai Tong's response? 'Go.' Two letters. A whole relationship compressed into an imperative. Their exchange in the gap is also remarkable. 'When will this cycle end?' 'I don't know.' 'Would that mean that you have actually broken the cycle?' 'Really?' The dialogue here is so sparse, so stripped-down, that every silence screams. And then the final scene—Sun Daining following Bai Tong home, saying 'a=-2?' That's not a password; it's a lifeline. It's the only thing she has to offer that's entirely theirs. Bai Tong's response? Silence. He doesn't answer. He just lets her walk beside him. The dialogue throughout these chapters isn't about information exchange; it's about the space between words. The way Sun Daining says 'If you really don't remember me at all, then forget it'—it's not resignation; it's an offering. And Bai Tong's refusal to let her forget? That's shown, not told. Their voices are so distinct, so intimately flawed, that by the end you don't need narration. You just hear them. And that's when you know the author nailed it.
... Read More
Okay so let me just start by saying I AM STILL SHAKEING from the finger cot search scene. Bai Tong pulls out their phone, types something in casually, and BAM—spiked balls and middle-aged doctors explaining things they should not be explaining. The narrator goes full on-camera-shake mode like "the door to the new world opens slowly and automatically" which is honestly the most understated horror narration I have ever read. This kid just wanted to know what Yin Yi was hiding and instead got a lifetime trauma dump. But then the PLOT SWING is everything. Bai Tong storms out, Sun Daining chases them into the elevator, and suddenly we are in ROMANCE territory. The fact that Bai Tong just GRABS Sun Daining's face and kisses her in an elevator because SUN DAINING DID NOT ANSWER THEIR QUESTION is both unhinged and honestly the most Bai Tong thing ever. Like the question was Do you like me and the answer was silence and Bai Tong was like well then let me show you what kind of like I mean. And then the mother subplot drops like a bomb. Bai Jingru locks Bai Tong in their room, disables the door fingerprint, installs surveillance cameras, administers what are almost certainly psychiatric drugs, and controls literally everything including the light switches. Bai Tong tries to smash the camera and can barely open the window. The stakes just went from awkward teen crush to full-blown psychological thriller and I am HERE FOR IT. Also Yin Yi disappearing because her parents transferred is either a setup for a massive betrayal reveal later or the author is just casually removing characters like chess pieces. Either way I need answers.
... Read More
This question has been taught TWELVE TIMES and we're only on the fourth cycle for Sun Daining. The math problems aren't just plot devices—they're the only thing Bai Tong has that actually works across timelines. While everyone else is repeating conversations and birthdays and strawberry milkshakes, Bai Tong is sitting with a pen and A4 paper, building a ladder out of theorems and derivatives, trying to pull Sun Daining up. The finger cots though. Let me sit with this symbol for a moment. Yin Yi buying them for fun, hiding them, Blushing to the top of her head. What are they hiding? What body? What act? The fact that Sun Daining is trapped in a loop but Yin Yi isn't—or maybe Yin Yi is and Sun Daining doesn't know it—opens up this entire territory of physical intimacy that exists outside of time. They've done this before. They've done it many times. And every time the loop resets, it doesn't count. It erases. Unless Bai Tong remembers. Unless someone writes it down. Bai Tong's hat becomes Yin Yi's hat becomes nothing. Sun Daining's bracelet fits perfectly because of course it does—she chose it, or will choose it, in a timeline that hasn't happened yet. And the down jacket with the fluffy terry collar, the one from junior high that Bai Tong completely forgot about but Sun Daining has been looping back to recall over and over... that's memory as anchor. The only things that persist through repetition aren't grand gestures, they're tiny domestic details. A collar that looks like a fox tail. A handwriting style. The way someone walks slowly on the way home because they don't want to go there. The title itself is the thesis: this question has been taught twelve times, meaning twelve times someone tried to explain it and twelve times it wasn't understood. Love works the same way.
... Read More
I need to talk about Sun Daining's bedroom because it is THE most revealing character moment in this entire batch and I am not even being dramatic about it. So Bai Tong goes over to Sun Daining's place on a Sunday morning, already feeling this weird anticipation she's never felt before — which is wild because we've established Bai Tong is basically a robot who communicates in [Smile] emojis and deadpan remarks. And then she walks into Sun Daining's room and what does she see? A row of BANANA DOLLS on the headboard. Like, actual plush bananas with arms, legs, and smiles. Some are stubby ladyfinger bananas huddled together like they're in a fight. This is a person's BEDROOM. This is not a subtle character detail, folks. And here's what I love: Bai Tong notices this completely mundane thing while simultaneously dealing with the fact that the room is noisy, the window faces an artificial lake full of children, and there's this fragrance in the air that makes her mind wander. She's trying so hard to focus on the math problem but her brain is like... is this person's entire aesthetic just fruit plushies? The banana dolls tell me everything I need to know about Sun Daining. She's trapped in an endless time loop, repeatedly failing to solve one derivative question, possibly going insane — and her sanctuary is decorated with smiling bananas. It's either the most wholesome coping mechanism I've ever encountered or it's a cry for help wrapped in cuteness. Probably both. Then there's the whole dynamic with Yin Yi, who is genuinely threatening Bai Tong in an alley like some kind of shonen anime villain. 'Even if I beat you up, no one will notice.' CHILL, bro. And Bai Tong's response is basically 'sure, whatever, I'm walking home now.' The fact that she asks Sun Daining 'Do you have a good relationship with Yin Yi?' with the emotional warmth of someone reading a weather report is peak Bai Tong energy. But Sun Daining's answer — 'We are good friends and have known each other for many years' — hits different when you realize Sun Daining is the one living through this hell loop and Yin Yi is just... trying, in their own chaotic way, to help. Who is actually the weirdest person here? I can't decide between the banana enthusiast and the top student who doesn't smile when saying goodbye.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or