This Question Has Been Taught 12 Times - Reviews

This Question Has Been Taught 12 Times
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this immediately: the relationship between Bai Tong and her mom Bai Jingru is somehow both heartbreaking and exhausting in equal measure. You have this mom who barely works anymore, comes home, expects her daughter to wait around, and when Bai Tong doesn't answer calls promptly—BAM, psychological appointment made. Like, that is some next-level passive-aggressive energy. And Bai Tong? She's not stupid. She knows exactly how to read the room. When her mom asks what's wrong, she doesn't come out swinging. Instead she tells this half-truth about staying late to solve a math problem, and honestly I respect the survival tactics. But then there's this moment I need to talk about because it wrecked me. Bai Tong actually FEELS sorry for her mom. She thinks 'maybe I shouldn't bully her like this.' And then immediately deflects with the math problem excuse. It's like her brain can't sustain empathy because the whole dynamic is so fractured. Meanwhile you've got Sun Daining entering the picture and she's just... so soft. Bringing yogurt, tending the wound with iodophor and gauze, saying 'you are indeed a very, very good person' with this genuine warmth. And Bai Tong's reaction—blushing, looking away—shows she's not used to being treated with this kind of care. Who is she to these two girls? The top student everyone calls 'Xueba' gets shoved into a alley but the 'school bully' type apologizes and brings medicine. Who does the healing and who does the hurting here?
... Read More
Let me just lay this out straight because the conflict in this story is NOT subtle and I love it. On the surface you've got a girl who gets pushed into a wall by classmates and can't even fight back. That's external conflict, basic but effective. But the real stakes are inside that house. Bai Tong stays late at school NOT because she's studying—she's DELAYING. The text says it directly: 'It would be nice if I could not go home.' That's not a passing thought, that's a survival mechanism. Every minute in the classroom is a minute she doesn't have to face the psychological landmine that is dinner with her mother. And the stakes? They're raising. The mother mentions a psychological counseling appointment like it's nothing, but the implication is devastating—'I think there's something wrong with you.' Bai Tong's response? She lies. She tells her mom she stayed late because she couldn't solve one math problem. The truth—being pushed, falling, getting hurt—is completely invisible. The mother has no idea. Who is actually protecting whom here? Then you throw Sun Daining into the mix and suddenly there's a THIRD conflict zone. Bai Tong wants to apologize, wants to teach her, wants to do something good. But when she actually tries, she loses patience. She 'almost to the point of overflowing.' She's trying to be kind and failing, and that internal conflict—wanting to connect but not knowing how—is where the real tension lives. The author never lets you settle. Every scene ends with someone feeling something they can't quite name.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is a masterclass in controlled suffocation. Let's break it down. Chapter 40 starts in media res—poison already administered, cup already spilled. No slow buildup, just immediate consequence. We're thrust into the bathroom rinse scene, and the prose is short, clipped sentences that mimic panic. 'Let's go to the hospital.' 'Tomorrow is the last day, what else is there to do?' Boom, boom, boom. The structure here forces you to breathe with them, then denies it. But then—chapter 41—everything shifts. Bai Tong fakes a rotten egg excuse, goes to school, sits in the back. The pacing slows dramatically. Long paragraphs of internal monologue for Sun Daining, describing her shaking legs, her ordinary nature, her calm crumbling. The author stretches time here, making you feel every second of that walk to the podium. Why? Because the tension isn't about will she solve it; it's about whether she'll survive the exposure. And then—the classroom, the wrong drawing, the kind dismissal. Just when you think it's over, Bai Tong pulls her out to the playground gap. The structure collapses inward again: tiny space, murmured dialogue, the realization that this hiding spot might be permanent. The pacing here is almost claustrophobic, but then—lights flick on. One by one. The world returns. The structure mirrors their emotional arc: trapped, exposed, hidden, then illuminated. The cliffhanger isn't a question; it's an image. 'Until the world lights up.' And then we cut to chapter 42 with test papers, 145 points, and 'a=-2.' The pacing snaps back to urgency. Every transition feels intentional, never rushed, never dragged. The author understands that tension isn't about speed; it's about release valves.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment to appreciate how different these voices sound? The mother-daughter conversations are like walking on ice—every sentence calculated, every silence loaded. 'What time is it?' 'You can eat first.' 'We're waiting for you.' Three sentences and you know exactly whose life is on hold. Then you've got the alley confrontation and Yin Yi literally grabbing Bai Tong by the collar while saying 'She is so rude' like that's a personality trait. The casual violence in that dialogue is wild. But Sun Daining—oh man, Sun Daining's voice is completely distinct. 'Hello, Xueba, I'm sorry for yesterday. I made this for you myself.' The self-correction mid-apology, the way she explains about her mom being on business trip without being asked, the yogurt that was clearly homemade (blueberries GROWN on the balcony). Her sentences breathe differently. They're longer, warmer, less defensive. And Bai Tong's internal monologue when she says 'I'm sorry, I'm sorry' wasn't hers but Sun Daining repeating what Yin Yi did—that repetition mimics the actual apology being delivered, which is a nice touch. The math lesson scene is basically a masterclass in how dialogue reveals character. Sun Daining asking 'Why?' about the domain 0
... Read More
The title alone gave me chills and I need to sit with it. 'This Question Has Been Taught 12 Times.' Twelve times. That's not arbitrary. It's the number of Apostles, the number of hours on a clock face, it circles back to itself. This entire story feels like it's built around the mathematics of human relationships—and I don't mean that lightly. The math problem itself functions as a symbol for everything Bai Tong can't express directly. She can work through derivatives and domains and inequalities, but asking her mom 'why did you wait two hours for me?' that equation has no solution. Consider the domain constraint 0
... Read More
This story isn't about time loops. It's about visibility. Let's talk about the poison packaging first—that fluorescent orange with the □□ characters. It's described as 'disgusting,' as pushing 'the boundaries of cognition.' Why? Because it's meant to be rejected, to mark the act as monstrous. But Sun Daining chooses it precisely because it's unappealing. She wants her desperation to be visible, ugly, undeniable. 'You chose such a disgusting one for me. In your mind, I am worthy of sharing a pot with mice?' That line isn't about self-pity; it's about worth. She's asking whether her pain is valid enough to poison someone, or whether she's merely vermin. And Bai Tong's answer is the entire theme: he drinks it. Not because he wants to die, but because he refuses to let her believe she's less than human. Then there's the gap between the stands—a 'tiny space, just enough for the two of them to squeeze in.' It's a womb, a tomb, a confessional. They hide there because the world outside is too bright, too revealing. The darkness isn't fear; it's protection. And when the lights finally come on, one by one, it's not salvation—it's exposure. The theme of the loop isn't repetition; it's the struggle to be seen without being consumed. Sun Daining's 'ordinary' nature is her armor and her curse. She accepts invisibility until Bai Tong forces her onto the podium. The question 'a=-2' is the ultimate symbol: a mathematical truth that requires no explanation, only recognition. It's their secret language, a fragment of logic that exists outside the loop's chaos. And Bai Tong's 145 points—the one question he misses—is the hole where understanding should be. He knows the answer but can't articulate it. The theme closes there: some truths are felt, not solved. The orange package, the dark gap, the cipher—they're all about the desperate, ugly, beautiful attempt to say 'I'm here' in a world that keeps resetting.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or