This Question Has Been Taught 12 Times - Reviews

This Question Has Been Taught 12 Times
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's something SO cinematic about the riverside greenway scene. Bai Tong walking alone with three flavors of ice cream—rice good, mint terrible, matcha terrible, just straight-up honest review while feeling humble and insignificant—and then Yin Yi and Sun Daining appear like ghosts materializing out of the wind. The visual of the three of them walking, Sun Daining clinging to Bai Tong's arm, Yin Yi deliberately bumping into Bai Tong, the whole thing feels like a王家卫 film where everyone is orbiting each other but no one knows the gravity. Then the hot pot restaurant. Happy birthday singing places. Generic, loud, fluorescent. Completely ordinary. And yet Yin Yi presents that light green velvet box with such intimacy that the whole room seems to shrink around just the two of them while Bai Tong sits there watching like a ghost at their own birthday party. Not that it's THEIR birthday. That's the joke and the tragedy. But the real atmosphere goldmine is Sun Daining's apartment. Open-plan western kitchen right off the living room so Bai Tong can see them from where they sit. The way the space itself becomes a character—the kitchen pulling Yin Yi and Sun Daining away together, Bai Tong abandoned with their math paper, the entrance cabinet becoming a treasure hunt site, the silence that settles after Yin Yi leaves and how it gets colder. Every location tells you exactly where everyone stands emotionally. The house is too big when it's just the two of them and too small when all three are in it.
... Read More
There's this one detail that I need to obsess over. When Bai Tong and her mother arrive at the therapy center, the text says: "Any place he has never been to before is like a playground to Bai Tong, very novel." PLAYGROUND. A mental health facility, a place where her mother is desperately trying to diagnose her, and Bai Tong experiences it as novelty. As entertainment. This single word tells you more about Bai Tong's psychology than any internal monologue ever could. Then the author describes the doctor's office with these exact details: middle-aged woman, glasses, naturally curly hair slightly fried at the back, double sofa where they sit side by side. It feels so real, so lived-in, like you could walk into this room. The doctor's office has posters on the wall — "Grow toward the sun, be grateful and tolerant" — and Bai Tong reads them like she's killing time at a DMV. The contrast between Bai Jingru's intensity and the clinical, almost bureaucratic normality of the therapy center is stunning. Everyone else in this scene is taking it seriously — the doctor adjusting appointment types on her computer, Bai Jingru insisting on family diagnosis instead of individual consultation, the whole institutional machinery whirring along — while Bai Tong is mentally touring the hallway like a tourist. And the school setting? The yogurt scene plays out in a classroom with very few people present, which makes the whole interaction feel intimate despite being public. Sun Daining walking toward Bai Tong holding something in her hand — the composition of that moment feels almost cinematic. You can see it frame by frame. The author builds worlds through specific sensory details, not through exposition. Every scene has a physical texture.
... Read More
I need to talk about dialogue because this author has a genuinely distinctive voice and it's one of the reasons I can't put this book down. Yin Yi: "Are you following us?" Bai Tong: "Just on my way." That's it. That's the entire exchange. Bai Tong is caughtred-handed trailing someone home and her response is the most casual deflection in literary history. And it's perfect because it's exactly how Bai Tong would respond — no apology, no explanation, just pure unbothered energy. Then later when Yin Yi is escalating and grabbing Bai Tong's collar, Sun Daining comes back and says: "Okay, okay, you two go back to your homes, Yin Yi, don't do anything with others." DON'T DO ANYTHING WITH OTHERS. As in, don't physically assault people. This is the most Sun Daining line ever written. She's not addressing the gravity of the situation, she's just tired and wants everyone to go home. The therapist's dialogue is also remarkable — "If there is a family history, it does not necessarily mean that the child will inherit it" — said with the weary patience of someone who has had this exact conversation a thousand times. And then Bai Jingru's response: "I don't want to listen to these ambiguous words. What kind of test can you do here? Give me an accurate result." Bai Jingru doesn't speak in nuance. She speaks in demands. Every line she has is sharp, impatient, results-oriented. Meanwhile Bai Tong's lines are either minimal or performative — she only talks when she's either manipulating or mocking. The narrative voice itself is equally distinctive. It has this dry, almost sardonic quality that matches Bai Tong's internal perspective. Phrases like "not illegal to pick up trash" and "yogurt salesman, buying and selling by force" show an author who understands humor without forcing it. The voice IS the character, and that's rare.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is absolutely ruthless and I respect it so much. We start with what is basically a CRINGE COMEDY setup — Bai Tong searching for finger gloves and getting absolutely wrecked by the internet. It is funny. It is awkward. It is light. Then within the same scene, Sun Daining chases Bai Tong into an elevator and suddenly we are in Romantic Tension territory. The kiss happens, the fire escape scene happens, the confessions happen — all while the reader is still processing the finger cot trauma. This is the author saying hey want some fluff? Here is some fluff. Also your protagonist is being held hostage by their mother. And then BOOM. Bai Tong goes home and the tone shifts completely. Bai Jingru asks about the phone being off with this casual menace. Bai Tong tries to tell their mom they have a girlfriend and the mom responds with This semester you will be studying abroad. I will be with you. This is not a conversation. This is a sentence. The lockdown sequence is where the pacing really shows its teeth. Day passes. Bai Tong doesn't eat. Stomach burns. Legs weaken. Then the next day the door won't open. Then the camera gets smashed. Then the window barely cracks. Then doctors appear with IV drips and unmarked pills. Each beat escalates without a single melodramatic moment. It just accumulates like pressure. Then Sun Daining arrives with flowers and math notes and Bai Tong cries over a misunderstood calculus problem and the whole thing ends on this quiet note of broken people trying to connect through homework. The author knows exactly when to breathe and when to suffocate the reader. Masterclass.
... Read More
"Tomorrow will neither be better nor worse. Tomorrow just exists, nothing more." I need to sit with this for a minute. Bai Tong's internal monologue at the beginning of chapter 14 is genuinely haunting. She's been through... something... 12 times apparently based on the title, and what comes out the other side is this almost dissociative view of the world. She can't distinguish good from bad anymore. Scores are real because answers are real. Everything else is a question mark. But then you pair that with what happens with her mother — "If one day, you want to leave me, should I let go too?" — and you realize this book is digging into something much bigger than a school romance. It's about what happens when your entire reality gets rewritten and you don't know what's real anymore. The line "people have to hold on to hope in order to endure the pain day by day" hits different when you know how many times this has already happened. Hope as a survival mechanism, not a belief system. And Sun Daining's dagger shopping?? I keep going back to that. She's shopping for weapons. Not literally a weapon — she says she can find someone to customize one. A scalpel? A dagger? This girl is carrying 12 cycles of memory alone and her coping mechanism is apparently looking at knives. The symbolism writes itself but I'm too emotionally compromised to unpack it properly.
... Read More
OK so I need to talk about this diary entry because it absolutely wrecked me in the best way. Bai Tong writes this entire dramatic story about her biological father Sheng Yan showing up, being scary, crying in public, threatening to take her away — and then immediately undercuts it with: "This is just a bit of bad taste, just to tease Bai Jingru." WHAT. A. REVEAL. I laughed out loud. Bai Tong literally fabricated an emotional trauma narrative and posted it under a high-definition surveillance camera just to mess with her emotionally unstable mother. That is not a side plot, that is the MAIN plot energy of this entire book. And the way the author layers the plot is incredible. On the surface, you have the school storyline with Sun Daining and the yogurt incident. Then you have the mystery of Sheng Yan. Then you have Bai Jingru's psychological unraveling and the therapy appointments. None of these feel disconnected — they all feed into the same ecosystem of control and manipulation. Bai Tong manipulates her mother through fake diaries. Bai Jingru tries to manipulate her daughter's future through therapy. The whole story is about who has power over whom, and who's faking what. The biggest twist though? The ending where Bai Tong goes to therapy and literally plays along with the diagnosis. She cries on cue, agrees with everything, lets her mom do all the talking, and then WHEN SHE'S ALONE WITH THE DOCTOR she says: "We have nothing to talk about." They both tricked the system. Bai Tong is the one who proposed therapy in the first place and she turned it into a joke. That is peak plot construction.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is honestly masterclass-level manipulation of tension, and I need to break down why. Chapter 2 opens with Sun Daining desperately trying to explain to Bai Tong that she's stuck in a time loop. This is HUGE exposition — the core premise of the entire novel — and it's delivered through this incredibly intimate, almost confrontational scene where Sun Daining is leaning way too close, begging for help. Then immediately after the big revelation, Bai Tong literally just says 'I'm going home' and walks away. The contrast between the cosmic horror of eternal recurrence and Bai Tong's complete emotional flatness is comically effective. It resets the tension so completely that you're almost bored before the next chapter hits you with Yin Yi blocking an alleyway like a yakuza member. Then Chapter 3 does something really interesting: it takes the Yin Yi confrontation, which could have been a full-on action set piece, and immediately undercuts it. Yin Yi threatens to harass Bai Tong 'all day long' and Bai Tong's response is basically... she goes home and asks her mom for a car service. No drama, no retaliation, just 'sure, whatever, mom can fix this.' The threat dissolves into domestic convenience. And then — and this is the genius part — the very next scene is Bai Tong dragging a forty-kilogram flight case with two kittens because one wheel broke. From life-threatening alley confrontation to struggling with pet transport equipment. The tonal whiplash is intentional and it works. The pet shop scene then acts as a massive pressure valve. All that tension from the loop revelation and the alley threat just... deflates into two people buying cat snacks and making awkward small talk. Sun Daining commenting on Bai Tong's cats being overweight, Bai Tong deadpanning 'Xiaobao is a short-haired cat,' Sun Daining responding with '…' — this is the narrative equivalent of exhaling after holding your breath for three chapters. And then Chapter 4 ends on this note of domestic normalcy — Sunday morning, banana dolls, solving a math problem together — while the reader is still sitting there going 'wait, but she's in a TIME LOOP right?' The author is letting the supernatural premise simmer in the background while the foreground is just... two girls being normal. Which somehow makes the loop feel MORE real, not less.
... Read More
Okay can we just take a moment to appreciate how Sun Daining's voice absolutely dominates every conversation in this book? "Wel~come." — shop assistant mode activated, instantly. "I will cry every day from now on" / "I will never laugh again from now on" / "I will laugh every day from now on" — three emoticons, zero explanation, maximum chaos. This is how this person operates. No filter, no boundary between dramatic and sincere, it's all just... output. And Bai Tong's voice is the perfect foil. Completely deadpan. When Sun Daining leans in way too close and says something about time circulating and breaking out of a loop, Bai Tong's response is basically silent eyebrow raise and then "What do you mean?" — not even slightly freaked out. Later, when Yin Yi is literally threatening to beat her up in an alley, Bai Tong's internal monologue is: "Bai Tong would be afraid of Bai Jingru's silent threats, but when faced with people other than Bai Jingru, she didn't seem to care much about even such blatant personal threats." TRANSLATION: only my mom can threaten me. Not even you, Yin Yi. The WhatsApp exchange at the end is arguably the most emotionally significant dialogue in these chapters: Sun Daining: sends three cat emoticons Bai Tong: finds a [smile] from her own expressions and sends it back Sun Daining: sends [Smile Goodbye] Bai Tong: types "See you tomorrow" Sun Daining: voice calls, gentle and smiling, "Bye, see you tomorrow~" Bai Tong doesn't have a single emoticon of her own. She LITERALLY has to borrow a smile from her existing collection to respond to someone who just handed her their entire emotional spectrum in cartoon cat form. And yet — and yet — she agrees to come over the next day. She looks forward to it. The narrative literally says she had 'never felt this way before.' The author's voice in the narration is also doing a lot of work. Things like 'This is goodbye with a smile' and 'Sun Daining clearly smiled at the chat interface for a while' — there's so much unspoken emotion packed into these simple observations. The narrator is basically whispering 'something is happening here, pay attention' while keeping a straight face.
... Read More
Okay so the bus scene in chapter 14 had me absolutely wrecked. Bai Tong is literally sitting there, heart pounding, waiting for Sun Daining to come sit next to her — and what does Sun Daining do? She walks right past Bai Tong all the way to the back of the bus. Like... bro. The narrator says "Bai Tong couldn't control his head and turned around to see where she was going to sit" — I feel that. I have never felt that in my life. And then Bai Tong sits alone in the back anyway because apparently the back seat of a minibus is even worse. The text says: "Would she rather sit in that shabby place so far away than sit next to her?" And Bai Tong is like "I actually felt a little uncomfortable, although there was no reasonable reason." That is such a precise description of having feelings you can't even justify. And then the whole lunch scene — Bai Tong literally just sits down opposite her and tries to talk and Sun Daining is giving her these dead responses like "I can't learn, forget it" and "Thank you for asking me" like Bai Tong is some stranger who got the wrong table. But then Sun Daining is out there picking out daggers and scalpels?? What is happening in her head??? The chapter ends with Bai Tong thinking "she liked chatting with Sun Daining" and I am SCREAMING. You can't just say that after making us watch her reject someone for chapters. This CP is giving me whiplash and I love it.
... Read More
The botanical garden scene in chapter 15 is genuinely beautiful and I didn't expect that from this book. All that exposition and psychological drama and then suddenly — butterflies. "White butterflies, nymphals, and swallowtail butterflies come in different sizes and colors." The text just lets us sit there with Bai Tong watching them, no narration, no dramatic tension, just two girls standing in front of a stream of butterflies. And Sun Daining says "Do you like butterflies?" and Bai Tong says she used to, as a kid. The whole thing about caterpillars — "almost 1%" make it — is such a Bai Tong thing to randomly bring up. She's sharing something personal and the text wraps it in this weird educational detail that feels so much like how actual people talk when they're nervous. "It's indeed disgusting, but there are also very cute caterpillars." Then she pulls Sun Daining away. The physical contact — Bai Tong INITIATING touch — after the entire bus fiasco? Chef's kiss. Also the setting details are so vivid: the humid botanical garden, the slippery path under tall trees, the concern about snakes in the bushes. You can literally feel the humidity. The book has this habit of dropping atmospheric details without announcing them, which makes the quieter moments hit harder. Sun Daining handing her phone to choose a dagger right after the butterfly scene is tonally wild but it works because the book has earned the right to jarringly pivot.
... Read More
Okay, let's talk about the moment everything actually broke open. You know that scene where Sun Daining hands Bai Tong the poison? '□□'. I literally gasped. Not because it's shocking—the story's been leading here since loop one—but because of how casually she says, 'I can only buy this.' It's so mundane! She's holding this fluorescent orange package like it's toothpaste, and Bai Tong's reaction is just… 'You should have said it earlier.' Like, 'Thanks for the heads up, but next time, warn me before you try to murder me.' The plot doesn't just twist here; it folds in on itself. This isn't a suicide pact; it's a desperate communication. Bai Tong sees through it immediately: 'it's dangerous outside' wasn't about overseas danger, it was about the whole world being hostile. And then her follow-up—'Just give me the medicine'—that's the real pivot. She's not rejecting help; she's negotiating terms. 'Next time you use a dagger, I can accept your use of a dagger.' The absurdity of it! They're literally bargaining over murder methods while spilling poison on their clothes. The plot here does something incredible: it takes a supposed climax (the poisoning) and deflates it into something almost domestic, then rebuilds it into genuine alliance. The loop breaks later because they finally speak the same language. Not literally—the test question is just a code—but emotionally. 'Then we'll see you outside the loop.' That's not hope; that's a contract. And the fact that the cycle ends after she finishes writing and speaking? Perfect. The plot was always about communication, not action. The poison was just the loudest conversation they'd ever had.
... Read More
The information drops in these chapters are SLOW and DELIBERATE and I am HERE for it. Chapter 14 reveals that Sun Daining has COMPLETELY ACCEPTED that Bai Tong doesn't remember their past cycle. The text says: "Being forgotten is a very painful thing, especially being forgotten by someone who once liked each other." And Sun Daining's response? She pretends it never happened. She says thank you when Bai Tong offers to teach her. She deflects. She's been doing this for how many loops?? Then chapter 15 flips the script entirely. Bai Tong grabs Sun Daining's arm on the bus and literally stuffs her into the window seat. The narrator says "Bai Tong was originally a manipulative character who could do whatever he wanted" — wait, WHO is the male pronoun referring to here?? Did the translation slip or am I missing something?? But the point stands: Bai Tong is taking INITIATIVE for once instead of waiting around hoping someone will choose her. The daggers/scalpels subplot is the real plot engine though. Sun Daining is clearly planning something dangerous and is trying to... what? Prepare? Protect? The text never says but every time she brings up weapons it raises the stakes. And the ending note that Bai Tong remembers having a beautiful dagger at home from a trip, that her mother kept it in the living room... IS THAT THE SAME DAGGER Sun Daining is looking at?? I need to know what happens next because the loop hasn't been broken yet and neither of them seems close to figuring it out.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or