This Loving Traitor - Reviews

This Loving Traitor
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The structure of these chapters is doing something really clever and I need to talk about it. Start with the lakeside — quiet, almost serene after the storm. The sky is "clear as a lie," which is such a loaded phrase because we know exactly what kind of lie this clarity represents. Petunias at the lake. Bjorn's blue eyes matching the sky. It's almost too beautiful, and that discomfort is the point. The author is setting up a paradise that the reader already knows is built on a foundation of betrayal. Then the climb onto his back. Then the flashback. Then the return journey. Then the confrontation. Each beat lands with deliberate spacing — the author isn't rushing to the emotional climax, she's building toward it like someone slowly lowering themselves into water that's too cold. What's brilliant about the pacing here is how the confrontation itself is delayed. We get all this internal monologue, all this backstory flooding through Ivnen's mind, and Bjorn is just... walking. Carrying her. Not speaking. The silence between them is actually louder than any dialogue could be. Felix and Dek are basically background characters in their own house, terrified to interrupt whatever unstable equilibrium exists between these two. And then — the masterstroke — when Bjorn announces he's leaving. Just when we think the scene is about resolution, about them finally talking things out, he pivots HARD. "I am leaving Valder Estate today." The tension snaps taut. Felix's confusion mirrors our own. And then Ivnen grabs his coat. The structure here mirrors the emotional arc perfectly: false calm → building pressure → sudden disruption → grasping for stability → reluctant acceptance. The author knows exactly when to let scenes breathe and when to yank the rug out. By the time Bjorn says "Carry me" reversed — now he's the one offering his back — we've traveled through an entire emotional universe in what reads like twenty minutes of story time. The cliffhanger ending, with her arms tightening around his neck and the shadow of two bodies merging into one, is exquisite. Not a traditional cliffhanger, but an emotional one. We're left wondering: is this redemption or ruin? And the beauty is, the book isn't ready to answer that yet.
... Read More
I want to dissect why this chapter works so well structurally, because the pacing here is genuinely masterful. The chapter opens at a glacial pace. Several days pass. Nothing changes. Bjorn stays in his study. Ivnen sits on the bed. The prose itself slows down to match the mood — long sentences, heavy punctuation, thoughts that loop and double back on themselves. "All this time, Ivnen's feelings had swung wildly from one extreme to the other, day after day without rest — but today was a little different." And then — BAM. Mother's memorial day. The pacing SHIFTS. Suddenly we're moving through memory, through revelation, through Dek's dialogue. The emotional velocity increases. We learn about the mother's death. About the duchess's drunken confession. About the rape, the beatings, the hanging. All compressed into a few paragraphs that hit like a sledgehammer after the slow build. Then — the garden. The petunias. The pace slows again, but now it's a different kind of slow. It's the slow crawl toward dread. Every sentence adds weight: "Still there. Fresh as though they had just been cut and set down — petunias beaded with dew." The description lingers. The past comes rushing back in fragments. Bjorn's voice from before the wedding. Dek's assumptions. The realization building like pressure. "And in that moment of confusion, something caught Ivnen's eye." Felix. Appearing like a plot device but also like fate. The pace quickens — she calls his name, he stops, she approaches, she asks, he hesitates. The dialogue becomes clipped, staccato. "So you do know, Felix." "My lady, I—" "Is it the Count?" And then — the walk to the study. This is the chapter's heartbeat. "Ivnen's steps toward the study were urgent." Short paragraphs. Short sentences. The internal monologue fractures: "What do I even intend to say to Bjorn? Why am I going to him like this?" The pacing mirrors her panic — it jumps, it stutters, it accelerates. The collision in the corridor is the climax. Physical impact = narrative impact. And then the final exchange, which the author deliberately fragments: "I don't understand what you are thinking. Not even the slightest bit." "..." "It doesn't matter if you don't understand..." CUT OFF. The sentence is literally incomplete. The chapter doesn't end with a resolution — it ends with a sentence that can't finish itself. Which is PERFECT for a chapter about a woman who has spent her entire life unable to finish understanding the man beside her. The pacing from start to finish moves through: stagnation → grief → suspicion → realization → confrontation → interruption. Six movements. Each one shorter than the last. By the time we reach the end, the emotional tempo is frantic and the unfinished sentence leaves us gasping. This is how you control a reader's breathing.
... Read More
Okay so I need to just sit with this for a second because the petunia reveal absolutely wrecked me. Think about it — throughout the entire past life, petunias were on that garden table. Every. Single. Day. Since the wedding, when Bjorn's behavior already started shifting, right up until Ivnen was too sick to go outside. And she always assumed Dek left them there. Dek even confirmed it in passing: "I'd assumed so all this time." But it was NEVER Dek. It was Bjorn. Him. The same man who poisoned her. "Since you tell me it's the flower you love, I suppose it does look prettier to me than the others." He literally told her once — almost carelessly — that petunias looked prettier BECAUSE she loved them. And then he spent... what? Years? — quietly putting them on that table every day without ever saying why. Without ever claiming credit. Not even when she walked past that table a hundred times. And then after she finally confronted him about the mistress, the first thing that changes is — the petunias. They get BIGGER. A massive bouquet takes up nearly the whole table. This isn't coincidence. This is a man who just got REBUKED by his wife for the first time ever, who's been hiding in his study refusing to come out, and who responds by... escalating a gesture he's been making silently for years. Does he not know how this looks? Does he know exactly how it looks and does it not matter to him? "I simply wanted the flower I liked to be where I wanted it. As you know, this is my estate, and I am its master." WHAT A MANIPULATIVE LIE. Because we KNOW he didn't like flowers. He literally said so. This is the most transparent excuse I've ever heard, and the fact that he offered it instead of saying anything honest is either breathtaking arrogance or... I don't know what. Something worse. And then the chapter ends on "It doesn't matter if you don't understand what I'm thinking" — trailing off, cut short. I AM NOT OKAY. The plot is just... peeling back layers like an onion and I am crying. Also — the mother's backstory drop? Duke Denia forced himself on her "day after day without rest," beat her, chased her when she tried to run. She hanged herself. And Ivnen overhears this. This is the origin of everything — the trauma, the hollow space in Ivnen's chest, the way she clings to Bjorn as "the first person who ever reached out his hand." FIRST. Not best. Just first. And now Bjorn is being revealed as someone who both held out his hand AND put poison in her cup. The narrative architecture here is just SO deliberate. Every thread is connected.
... Read More
Okay so this part just completely reshaped my understanding of the entire setup and I need to process this out loud. So Bjorn commissions a ring a full month ago—during the betrothal period, before everything went to hell—and never gives it to Ivnen? He lets the jeweler hold onto it, and then we find out the mistress gets THE ring while the wife gets poison? That's not just neglect. That's calculated. That's deliberate. And then the timeline clicks into place even harder. The physician visit, the secret checkups, the gold pouch payment—all of this happened BEFORE the flower tea incident. She was already dying. She was already slowly being poisoned, just not openly yet. And she figured it out on her own, sneaking around like a ghost in her own home. The plot has been playing 4D chess this whole time and I only just noticed. Every "nice memory" we thought was real—that warm engagement period, the sapphire comment, the tender moments—suddenly feels contaminated. Because now we know Bjorn was either lying then too, or... what? Did he genuinely love her once and then switch? Or was he always capable of this duality? And let's talk about those love letters. "Yours alone — your Bjorn, who loves only you, so much he could die from it." Written while he's married. While his wife is slowly dying. The sheer AUDACITY of writing something like that and folding it neatly on your desk. The narrative structure here is brutal in the best way. We get Ivnen's internal breakdown, then the jeweler scene as the catalyst, then storming into the study, then reading the letters, then the confrontation. It's a perfect escalation chain. No filler. Every beat pushes her closer to the edge until she can't hold it in anymore. "Bjorn Valder, you... you are truly the worst." That line. That's not a wife talking to her husband. That's a survivor naming their abuser.
... Read More
There's a moment in Chapter 7 where Ivnen remembers her past life—the night before the wedding, lying awake, heart pounding, thinking 'what should I say to him first?' and imagining herself being the perfect wife. I read that paragraph five times because the devastation is in the contrast. The same body, the same white dress, the same trembling anticipation—but this time, the emotion behind it is completely inverted. In her first life, those feelings were genuine hope. In this life, they're torture because she remembers exactly how it ends. 'I have not the slightest intention of disappointing myself and burdening you in the process.' This line made me put the book down for a full minute. It's not anger. It's not even sadness. It's exhaustion so deep it's become surgical. She has removed herself from the equation entirely—not through drama, but through cold, precise calculation. And Bjorn—oh god, Bjorn. His reaction to her newfound detachment is so painfully human. He doesn't know how to handle a woman who doesn't want his cruelty. For someone who built his entire identity around being the one in control, her refusal to play along is the one thing he can't manipulate. The romantic tension here isn't between lovers—it's between two people who are learning, in real time, that the script they were given doesn't apply anymore. That's somehow more compelling than any traditional love story.
... Read More
I need to talk about this memorial day scene because I am actually not okay. Like physically not okay. Ivnen's mother hanged herself when Ivnen was three years old. THREE. She can barely remember her face. "A mother whose face Ivnen could barely remember anymore. And no wonder." That phrase — "and no wonder" — is just so casually devastating. It's not tragic in a dramatic way. It's tragic in a quiet, resigned way. Like Ivnen has accepted that not knowing her mother is just... the way things are. There's no hope of change. No future version of this where she gets to know her mother. She just has to carry the absence. And then Dek shows up. Just Dek. The one person besides Ivnen who remembers this day. Who brings rose tea. Who bakes the cake Ivnen likes. Who says "Your mother would worry, seeing you like this." And Ivnen's thought — "What a blessed thing it was, to have someone to mourn alongside you" — made me just stop reading and stare at the wall for five minutes. Because grief without a witness is just... noise. It bounces around inside your head and nobody hears it. But when someone ELSE shows up and says "I remember too, let's remember together" — that transforms it. That makes it real. Dek isn't family. She's a childhood friend of the mother, a servant. But she chose to stay. She chose to remember. "Her mother's memorial came around every year, but it was a day only Ivnen remembered. It had been the same when she lived in House Denia, before she married Bjorn. They had been entirely indifferent — as though her mother had never existed at all." Not even her own household cared. Not her father, not her step-family, not the duchess who probably felt guilty enough to drink herself into oblivion. Only Dek. Only this one woman who served alongside Ivnen's mother remembered that a human being existed who then died alone in a house that treated her like furniture. And then — RIGHT AFTER this tender, heartbreaking scene — Ivnen goes to the garden and finds petunias. The flowers Bjorn has been leaving as some kind of half-love-letter to a wife he's simultaneously destroying. The timeline is just... cruel. The author places the mother's memorial directly before the petunia revelation like two knives twisting in opposite directions. One knife is grief for what was lost. The other is grief for what never was. "If Mother had lived. If she hadn't gone… Would I have had to swallow my feelings alone like this? Perhaps not." YES. That's the thesis of Ivnen's entire existence, isn't it? Everything she can't process, she swallows. Because there's no one to share it with. No mother to tell. No friend who truly understands. Just Dek, who tries, and Bjorn, who... does petunias and poison in equal measure.
... Read More
I need to talk about Bjorn because I literally cannot stop thinking about him and I don't even know if I'm more angry at him or just deeply fascinated by how completely he operates. Here's a man who commission a ring for his wife with her favorite stone. Amethyst. He gathered every jeweler in the empire to make it. He told her "You mean that much to me." And then... he never gave it to her. Instead, a month later, the mistress gets it. So which one is the real gift? The words spoken during engagement, or the actions taken during marriage? And the letters. Oh god, the letters. Dek thought she was protecting Ivnen by hiding them, right? Classic enabler energy. But Bjorn himself—the letters are on HIS desk, neatly folded, presumably written regularly. "Even today, without fail." This isn't a passionate affair that slipped out of control. This is a SECOND LIFE he's living alongside his marriage. The most chilling moment for me though isn't the ring or the letters. It's when he says: "Don't hope for anything, Ivnen. I have nothing to give you." Not "I can't love you." Not "I don't love you." He says he has NOTHING to give. Like her existence as his wife is a transaction he's already defaulted on, and he's letting her know the account is empty. And Ivnen's response breaks me. After everything—the poisoning, the mistress, the humiliation—she still says: "So please, love me just a little. Even a fraction of a fraction of what you give that nameless woman." She's not asking for loyalty. She's not asking for justice. She's asking for ONE PERCENT of what he gives someone else. ONE PERCENT. And that tells you everything about how thoroughly he's destroyed her sense of self-worth. The relationship dynamic here is so toxic it makes my blood boil. He controls her access to information (the letters), he controls her access to truth (the ring), he controls her physical environment (Felix blocking the study), and he controls the narrative of their marriage entirely. She's a prisoner in her own home with a title she doesn't value anymore.
... Read More
Okay so let me just process this because I am STILL not over the opening hook. The girl dies—poisoned by the man she loves, no less—and then wakes up on the day of her own wedding. That is such a clean, brutal loop. She goes from total despair to confused disorientation to... what exactly is she feeling now? Ivnen's internal monologue when she first opens her eyes is genuinely unsettling. She sees Dek standing there and her immediate thought isn't 'am I alive'—it's 'did I infect her?' That tells you everything about how broken her self-perception was. She expected to die alone, burdened. The fact that she immediately assumed the worst about her own existence is heartbreaking in a way that has nothing to do with romance. And then the reveal about Bjorn—that the proposal letter was never meant for her, that he wanted Lilien all along—landed like a physical blow. She knew this in her past life and still went through with it. And now she's going through it AGAIN with full knowledge. The dramatic irony here is absolutely suffocating. The wedding scene itself is so sparse—four people in a small temple—and that minimalism works in the story's favor. It strips away any romance or celebration and leaves only the cold machinery of a transaction. Bjorn didn't want this either. They're both trapped in roles they never chose. I did have one question though: why did she come back? Is this some kind of karmic loop, or is the narrative setting her up for something specific? The author hasn't given us a clear mechanism yet, which I think is deliberate. She doesn't need to understand the 'how' right now—she just needs to survive the 'what.'
... Read More
Let me just say this outright: I have never seen a relationship portrayed with this kind of brutal, almost surgical honesty. Ivnen and Bjorn are not normal. They are not healthy. But god help me, they are REAL. The opening of this passage hits me like a physical blow every time: "face into his broad back once more — but this time, unlike before, she did not cry." Just one sentence. ONE. And it contains an entire history. In her past life she cried against his back. Now she doesn't. What changed? What broke? What survived? And Bjorn — don't get me started on Bjorn. The man is a walking contradiction wrapped in silk and violence. He doesn't come to the bedroom. He hides in his study. He won't look at her. But he also — PETUNIAS. Every single day. For years. While she was dying, he was leaving flowers on a garden table like some kind of haunted ghost of a husband. "Ivnen, who had been her entire world. He was the reason she had lived, and the reason she had wanted to go on living — and in a world that had shown her nothing but harshness, he was the first, the only person who had ever reached out his hand to her." She loves him. Not despite knowing he poisoned her. NOTWITHSTANDING it. She still loves him. And that is the most devastating thing I have ever read. Her own words: "If those feelings had already changed, I would not have been so furious — would not have raged the way I had." She uses her anger as proof of her love. Her rage is a monument to something that still refuses to die inside her. But here's what fascinates me about their dynamic right now: for the first time, Ivnen is ASKING questions instead of accepting silence. She confronts him about the mistress. She interrogates Felix about the flowers. She walks straight to the study holding a bouquet like a weapon. In her past life she would have swallowed this. She would have accepted the poison without a word. Now she's demanding answers, even though every answer might destroy her. And Bjorn's response to that? "Why are you backing me into a corner over something like this?" He frames HER honesty as aggression. Classic. But also — he answers. He says "Yes." He doesn't deny it. The fact that he even considered lying and then just... confessed... says something. "I don't understand what you are thinking. Not even the slightest bit." That's Ivnen at her most vulnerable. And Bjorn's response gets CUT OFF mid-sentence. Which means the author is doing exactly what this relationship deserves — refusing to resolve it, refusing to give us the comfort of easy answers. These two will keep circling each other until one of them breaks. And honestly? I can't look away.
... Read More
Let's talk about this garden. Not the whole estate — I'm talking specifically about that ONE TABLE where Ivnen sits and the petunias appear, day after day, like some kind of daily ritual that nobody acknowledges except Ivnen and the dead. "The garden, visited for the first time in days, was as beautiful as ever." Beautiful. Unchanged. The world keeps turning while Ivnen's interior life is being dismantled piece by piece. This contrast — the indifferent beauty of the garden against the chaos inside her — is such a deliberate choice by the author. The garden doesn't care that her mother died. Doesn't care that Bjorn poisoned her. Doesn't care that petunias are blooming like nothing is wrong. And that table. Let me trace its significance: First time we see it: Ivnen sits there, alone, after confronting Bjorn about the mistress. The table holds a few stems of petunias in a vase. Now: an enormous bouquet takes up nearly the entire table. Dew still on the petals. Fresh. Like they were placed there moments ago. In her past life: petunias were always there. From wedding day to her deathbed. A constant she never questioned because she assumed Dek put them there. The table was a silent witness to Bjorn's secret devotion — or manipulation, or both — for the entire marriage. The spatial dynamics matter too. The bedroom where Bjorn refuses to enter. The study where he hides. The garden where he silently communicates through flowers. These three spaces map perfectly onto their relationship: the bedroom is absence, the study is avoidance, the garden is... something that can't be named. Something that happens when neither of them is directly present. And then the corridor scene — "The moment she turned the corner, she collided with something and let out a short sound, stumbling slightly. At the same instant, a large hand shot out and caught her firmly by the waist." BJORN. Right there. In the hallway between the garden and the study. Between the flowers and the fortress. He catches her. His hand on her waist. The same hand that held the poisoned cup, presumably. "Goodness!" Dek's delighted exclamation about the flowers contrasts so sharply with the cold tension in the corridor. Two rooms, two moods, happening simultaneously. The author is using space like a conductor uses tempo — accelerating and decelerating emotion through physical movement from garden to hallway to the threshold of the study. The estate itself feels like a character. Valder Estate has rooms that refuse to share air. The study is locked territory. The bedroom is a void. The garden is the only neutral ground — and even there, the petunias carry hidden meanings that only Ivnen (now) can decode.
... Read More
I need to sit down. I genuinely need to sit down. "I always loved hearing people call me Lady Balder." This single line broke me. Think about what it means. A woman born out of wedlock, whose mother died, whose father despised her, whose half-sister dominated everything — and the thing that made her feel most alive was a TITLE. The acknowledgment of being someone's wife. Of being chosen. Of belonging to someone. She wanted nothing more than to be loved by Bjorn. And when he finally showed her even a fraction of tenderness — smoothing her hair, commenting on the weather, bringing her tea — she felt like she'd won something impossible. "You can't imagine how good I feel." She said this while dying. While her body was shutting down from the poison he'd given her. She was so grateful for crumbs. The contrast between her inner world and the external reality is devastating. Inside, she's having the happiest moment of her life. Outside, she's choking on blood, gripping her husband's sleeve, understanding too late that the tea was never tea. And then the rebirth. Standing beside her past self, watching the moment everything began, and feeling nothing but sorrow. "If I could go back to that moment — would I be able to avoid making the same mistake? Would I be able to not love you?" That question haunted me for hours. Because the answer is probably no. She wouldn't be able to help it. Someone who has never been loved will love anyone who offers warmth, even if it burns them alive. That's the real tragedy here — not that Bjorn killed her, but that she would have let him kill her and still called it love.
... Read More
Let's talk about Bjorn because my god. On the surface, he's the cold husband who never showed interest in his wife for a full year of marriage. Simple, right? Abusive nobleman trope. But the text gives us something far more complex than that. The moment before Ivnen dies, she's looking at his face — trying to read it. Is he relieved? Irritated? The text says her darkening vision wouldn't let her see his face. But then — he bowed his head and whispered something against her ear. Not panic. Not guilt. Something else entirely. And that whisper, "Next time… you must…" — it changes everything we thought we knew about him. Then there's the rebirth scene where we see young Ivnen and Bjorn for the first time. He says things like "Today isn't quite the right weather for dying" and mentions petunias. This isn't just manipulation (though it is that too). There's something almost… observant about him. He noticed what she liked. He tracked the seasons. He knew the lake would be covered in flowers. That takes attention. Whether it's genuine or calculated, the text makes us wonder. And Ivnen — oh, Ivnen. "From the very beginning, you were all I ever had." The tragedy of her character isn't just that she loved a man who poisoned her. It's that she was never loved before him. Born a bastard, raised in contempt, watching her half-sister receive everything. Bjorn became her entire world because she had nothing else. That makes his betrayal cut so much deeper than simple heartbreak — it's the destruction of the only meaning she gave her own life. The relationship between Ivnen and her past self is also fascinating. She watches younger her blush and take Bjorn's hand, and she weeps. Not anger. Grief. She's mourning the person she was about to become, the person she'll spend a year loving a monster.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or