This Loving Traitor - Reviews

This Loving Traitor
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay let me just... sit with this for a second because I genuinely don't know what to feel about Bjorn right now. He shows up at that lakeside villa, looks like he hasn't slept in days, literally carries her back on his shoulder like it's nothing — and the book drops this flashback so perfectly timed that I actually gasped. Remember that? The one where they were newly engaged, she tripped over her dress, and he insisted on carrying her home? The weather was clear, the petunias were blooming, and he told her "watching you eat is like looking at a little child — that's why I always enjoy it." He called her a squirrel. A squirrel, Ivnen! And now — now she's clinging to his back again, the same warm broad shoulders, the exact same rhythm of his steps — and she's crying silent tears because she knows, she absolutely knows, that this Bjorn is NOT that Bjorn. Not anymore. He's the one who gave her poisoned tea. He's the one who took a mistress and disappeared from their marital bed night after night. He's the man who watched her die alone while he was off being tender to someone else. But here's the thing that wrecked me: she still lets him carry her. She still wraps her arms around his neck and says "carry me." Not because she's weak — well, maybe partly because she's weak — but because she's admitting something brutal. She says it straight out: "Will I come to regret today's choice?" And the answer she gives herself, the one that really hit me, is that this is the first decision she's ever made purely for herself since becoming his wife. That line. That single line reframes EVERYTHING about their relationship dynamic. Every sacrifice she made in the past life, every time she adjusted herself to fit around his moods and his mistress and his absence — it all collapses under the weight of that realization. She doesn't want him anymore in the way she used to. She wants to finally, actually, choose something. And Bjorn? Oh my god, Bjorn. His face when she says "stay by my side until I've had my fill of it" — the book describes him as "a man who had just heard something he was never meant to hear." Can you imagine? The cold, detached, dismissive husband who never once looked at her like she mattered... and suddenly he's the one who doesn't know what to do with his own hands. Felix and Dek watching from a distance, holding their breath, waiting to see if he'll run or stay — and he stays. He crouches down and offers his back again. I need to process this relationship for at least a week minimum.
... Read More
The structural audacity of opening a chapter with a death and closing it with a remarriage announcement is not something I expected to work—but it absolutely does. Let me break down why this pacing choice is so effective: The chapter opens at the absolute floor—despair, darkness, finality. Then Dek pulls Ivnen out of that void with this breezy 'miss, it's time to wake up.' The tonal whiplash is intentional and disorienting, which mirrors exactly what Ivnen is experiencing. The reader is not allowed to settle into comfort before being yanked back into confusion. Then there's this long stretch of sensory reconstruction—the mirror, the dress, the voice, the memories flooding back. The author slows down significantly during this section, letting us sit in Ivnen's dazed realization. This is where the emotional weight builds, and it's done through detail accumulation rather than exposition. The wedding ceremony itself is handled in just a few paragraphs. Four people. One question. One answer. No music described, no guests, no ceremony details beyond the bare minimum. This restraint is brilliant—the sparsity forces you to feel the emptiness rather than being told about it. And then the return to the bedroom—the same room where she died—and the confrontation with Bjorn. The pacing accelerates again, sharp and clinical, matching the tone of their exchange. By the time Bjorn says 'What exactly are you trying to say right now?' the chapter ends on a note of genuine tension rather than resolution. Perfect cliffhanger.
... Read More
The imagery in this book is ridiculously cinematic. Let me just list the scenes that stuck with me: The opening bedroom scene — sunlight, a sick wife in bed, her husband's hand in her hair. It looks like a painting. Warm, domestic, almost tender. The tea pouring — "a clear, deep red" — the smell drifting through the air. It's described so vividly you can almost smell it. And then the cup shattering on the floor. The contrast between that warm, golden light and the cold truth of poison is devastating. Then the lakeside. "A day that had been terribly overcast, as though rain could pour down at any moment." This setting is doing so much work. The lake where she once considered suicide. The petunias that will bloom when autumn comes — beauty promised but never received by the younger Ivnen. The dual presence of two Ivnens in the same space, one weeping, one broken, watching each other across time. This is a scene I want to frame. The ducal estate mentioned in passing — House Denia, with its contempt and hierarchy. We get enough worldbuilding to understand this is a rigid imperial society where bastard children are discarded and true daughters bask in favoritism. Bjorn's common birth rising through military merit against noble houses adds political texture too. The empire, the Emperor's ear, the calculations behind every marriage — this world feels lived-in and dangerous. The visual of Bjorn standing alone by the lake — "solitary, luminous" — is one of those images that just won't leave my head. He's beautiful and terrifying and completely unreadable. The author has created something here that works on every sensory level.
... Read More
I need to talk about Dek because this character quietly stole the entire emotional重量of this section. Every time Ivnen spirals into self-loathing, Dek is there with a laugh and a gentle deflection. 'We are a little pressed for time, but it really isn't something to apologize that heavily for, Miss.' This line hit me so hard because it's the first time anyone has treated Ivnen's panic as manageable instead of catastrophic. Dek doesn't interrogate her. She doesn't make it a big deal. She just... stays. And notice something—Dek doesn't know about the poisoning. She has no idea what her mistress survived. She thinks Ivnen is just 'nervous about the wedding.' That gap between what Dek perceives and what Ivnen actually experienced creates this awful, aching distance between them. Dek is loving someone who is already grieving a death she hasn't told her about. Then there's Bjorn, who stands at the door and says 'Let's talk for a bit' with this cold, businesslike posture. 'I have nothing to give you.' In his past life, these words destroyed her. Now she meets them with a smile and says 'I won't be expecting anything from you.' Watch what happens to him—'Bjorn faltered visibly.' The first crack in his armor, and it's because SHE stopped playing the part he wrote for her. The power dynamic has fundamentally shifted in a single sentence. He expected a trembling bride who would accept his cruelty gracefully. Instead he got someone who already knows exactly what he is and is not asking for mercy. That's a relationship turning point that the author earned through restraint.
... Read More
Ivnen compares her heart to that lake. Let me just sit with that metaphor for a moment because it's DEVASTATING. "Even now, after living through all of it, her feelings for Bjorn were like that lake from her memories. Months without rain, and still it would not show its bed — still it would not run dry." A lake that months of drought haven't touched. A lake that should be empty, should be cracked earth and dead reeds, but instead stays dark and deep and impenetrable. And she decides, finally, that SHE will drain it herself. Not him. Not fate. Her own hands, scooping out the accumulated dust-like feeling that refuses to be swept away. This is the most honest romantic moment I have ever read in this entire genre. Not the sweet ones. Not the heated confessions. This quiet, heartbreaking admission that she STILL loves him even though loving him killed her. Even though she knows exactly what that love leads to — illness, abandonment, a lonely death while he visits his mistress. Even though she's lived it once and remembers every second. And yet. "But not right now." That pause. That devastating, fragile pause before she asks him to stay. It's not forgiveness. She literally tells him three times that she hates him and wishes him dead. "I despise you." "I wish you were dead." And he knows it. He accepts it. He says "I know" both times like he's been waiting for her to say exactly this. The sweetness here isn't in romance — it's in raw, unvarnished truth. Neither of them is pretending. She's not playing the noble wife who's moved on. He's not playing the remorseful husband who suddenly remembers his vows. They're two broken people standing at the edge of something terrible and beautiful, and she's choosing to step toward it anyway, on her own terms. When she says "My legs hurt" and he immediately crouches down — that domestic detail, that automatic response built from years of physical closeness before everything fell apart — it made my chest ache in a way I didn't expect. The body remembers what the mind tries to forget. I'm not okay. I'm genuinely not okay with this book.
... Read More
The stakes in this story are layered in the best way. On the surface: a woman dies from poison and gets sent back in time. The obvious conflict is revenge — or at minimum, self-preservation. Can she avoid the same fate? Can she expose Bjorn? But the text immediately complicates this by making us understand WHY she fell for him in the first place. The stakes aren't just life and death — they're about whether someone who has never been loved can ever learn to love herself. The external conflict is clear: Bjorn manipulated his way into House Denia for political power. The proposal was meant for Lilien. Ivnen was always the backup plan. He used her family's influence and then discarded her. The question now is — what does reborn Ivnen do with this knowledge? But the internal conflict is where this story really grips you. Ivnen knows the truth. She knows Bjorn is a monster. She's watched her past self fall into the same trap. Can she actually walk away from the one person who ever made her feel seen? The text asks this directly: "Would I be able to not love you?" That's the real stake — not just surviving, but whether she can break a lifetime of conditioning that told her she was worthless. And then there's Bjorn's whispered promise — "Next time… you must…" — which introduces the possibility that HE might also be aware of something. That the stakes could involve two people trapped in a loop, neither fully honest with each other, both carrying knowledge the other doesn't have. The tension here is absolutely electric. Every chapter since the rebirth feels like walking on glass. We know something terrible is coming, and we're desperate to see if she can dodge it.
... Read More
Let me just say this book has some of the most cinematically gorgeous scenes I've encountered and I need to unpack why they hit so hard. The opening image—autumn sunlight pouring onto the terrace in "brilliant streams," the wedding ring sitting beside a single petunia, both of them abandoned and alone—that's not just description. That's THEME made visual. The sunlight is beautiful but it's AUTUMN sunlight. Approaching the end. The petunia is alive but cut from its stem. The ring is precious but stripped from its finger. And then the contrast: "Outside, the weather was still insufferably bright." The world keeps turning. People are living their lives, shops are opening, strangers are shouting greetings. And Ivnen is this ghost moving through it all, disconnected, lost. "Everyone out there is rushing about so busily. I'm the only one who feels like a person who's lost their way." The study scene is where the atmosphere really gets visceral. Bjorn sleeping on the sofa, one hand over his face, looking exhausted. The text drops this line: "whether from a night spent lavishing love on his mistress without restraint." The narrator doesn't even try to hide it. That's not empathetic storytelling—that's accusatory narration. The author is basically leaning over our shoulders saying "yes, that's what happened, deal with it." The locked-away letters on the desk. The way Felix blocks the doorway like a prison guard. The fact that Ivnen has to PHYSICALLY SHOVE past him to enter her own husband's study—these details build a world where power isn't just held, it's enforced. Architecture becomes a weapon. And the jeweler's shop!突然出现 out of nowhere, almost comically convenient, but then it serves as the perfect trigger. A shop full of dresses and jewels and beauty, and the one object meant for the wife is sitting there, claimed by someone else. The juxtaposition is so sharp it practically cuts.
... Read More
Okay so I need a minute. I literally just read the first seven chapters and I am shaking. Let me process this properly. The structure here is actually genius. We open with what seems like a soft, domestic scene — sick wife, husband showing unexpected tenderness, tea by the window. It reads almost like a romance. Then Bam — she dies. Poison. And not just any death, but one orchestrated by the person she loved most. The betrayal isn't just romantic; it's existential. He didn't love her. The entire marriage, every moment of "gentleness" leading up to this, was calculated. Then the narrative does this thing I've never seen done this well — she wakes up at a lakeside, watching her past self. The dual-timeline storytelling within a single rebirth moment is so clean. We see her younger self being manipulated by Bjorn, and we (the reader) get the full dramatic irony of knowing exactly how this ends. The line "Shall we have some tea, Ivnen. I went and got it myself. I wanted to share it with you" as a flashback haunting her rebirth moment? Chilling. It recontextualizes the entire first section. And the ending — "Next time… you must…" — left me absolutely desperate for chapter eight. What did he whisper? Why did he say it? Is he also reborn? The plot hooks are set so effectively that I cannot stop thinking about this book. The pacing from domestic softness to brutal murder to supernatural rebirth to revelation about the marriage's true purpose happens so fast yet feels completely earned. This author knows how to build tension and release it in the worst possible way.
... Read More
I keep coming back to one question: what do petunias MEAN in this story? Because I'm pretty sure they mean everything. Let me build this from the ground up. Petunias appear on the wedding day — the moment Bjorn's behavior begins to shift. They persist through every day of the marriage, silently, without acknowledgment. They are present when Ivnen is at her most beautiful and at her most dying. They are the ONLY constant in a relationship defined by changing tectonic plates of emotion. "Was leaving petunias there meant to be a kindness toward me? Out of pity for me — groveling for your affection like a dog? Or… was there some other meaning behind it?" Ivnen herself can't decide whether the flowers represent love or mockery. And that IS the theme. The entire novel seems to be built on this ambiguity — every gesture from Bjorn can be read as either devotion or manipulation, and we can never be sure which reading is correct. The petunias are the physical manifestation of that uncertainty. Then there's the flower itself. Petunias are hardy. They bloom in difficult conditions. They're not roses — showy, famous, universally recognized. They're not lilies — elegant, symbolic, traditional. Petunias are... persistent. Quiet. Unassuming. Exactly like Bjorn's affection: not celebrated, not declared, not dramatic. Just there. Every day. Whether you notice or not. "Because Bjorn had been her entire world. He was the reason she had lived, and the reason she had wanted to go on living — and in a world that had shown her nothing but harshness, he was the first, the only person who had ever reached out his hand to her." First. Only. Those words carry the weight of a lifetime of abandonment — her mother's suicide, her father's cruelty, the duchess's indifference. Bjorn is the FIRST kind thing she ever experienced, and therefore he became irreplaceable. The petunias represent this — they are not the most impressive flower, but they are THE flower. The one that stayed. The poison and the petunias. The tea that killed her and the flowers that sustained her. Both administered by the same hands. This duality — love and destruction existing in the same gesture — is the central philosophical question of the text. Can something be both? Can a man who leaves flowers be the same man who leaves poison? The petunias refuse to let us separate these truths. They sit on the table, beautiful and unknowable, while Ivnen dies anyway. And what about the mother? She loved petunias? No — Ivnen did. But the mother's death is what created the hollow that Bjorn filled. So the flowers that Ivnen loves are planted by the man who became her replacement mother-figure / abuser / savior / victim. The petals carry the scent of both love and trauma, and neither scent can be washed away.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the tea. Not because it's mentioned often—because it's the one image that anchors everything else. In her first life, the poisoned tea was the instrument of her death. In this life, she sits in that same room, on that same bed, knowing exactly what is coming. The setting itself has become a symbol of inevitability—a loop she cannot escape unless she changes something fundamental. But the deeper symbolism is in the white dress. In her past life, it represented hope—the pure, hopeful garment of a woman believing she was marrying the man she loved. Now it represents the same hope, but she knows it's a lie. The dress hasn't changed. Her understanding of it has. There's also this recurring image of the mirror—'checking her reflection in the mirror again and again.' Mirrors in literature always mean identity, and here it's doubled: she's looking at a face she recognizes but a person she no longer is. The young woman who gazed into that mirror in her first life believed in love. The woman staring now knows it was a transaction. And Bjorn's blue eyes—described as 'impossible to read any emotion from'—have become a symbol of the emotional void at the center of this story. He is beautiful, composed, empty. He is the hole that Ivnen filled herself with hope, and now that hope is gone, the hole remains. The story seems to be asking: what happens when the thing you sacrifice everything for turns out to be nothing at all?
... Read More
"I could have you buried in petunias, Ivnen. I could do that for you. If that's what you wanted." Dek says this and something in Ivnen SHORT-CIRCUITS. Because suddenly she's remembering—a memory, warm and golden, from before everything broke. Bjorn saying something similar. Her responding that she'd rather see one bloom every day than be buried in them. ONE BLOOM EVERY DAY. Not a funeral. Not an ending. Just... continuation. Presence. Proof that someone notices. And now that memory sits beside Dek's almost-offered burial in petunias and it's so devastating I actually had to stop reading for a second. The scene where she takes off the ring is one of the most quietly violent moments I've ever read. There's no drama. No music swelling. Just a woman slowly removing a piece of jewelry and placing it beside a flower on a table, in the autumn sunlight. "The ring without its owner and a petunia were left behind, alone." ALONE. The word hangs there like a ghost. And then the emotional spiral that follows—she goes to the physician, she pays in secret, she walks through streets full of people who call her "Countess" like it means something, and then THE JEWELER appears out of nowhere with THE RING. All of it cascading into her storming into the study and reading those letters until she's sobbing and saying things she's never been able to say out loud. "She mocks me. Night after night without fail, she comes into my dreams and mocks me. And that is how she kills me." This isn't a woman having an emotional breakdown. This is a woman performing an autopsy on her own death, describing each wound with clinical precision while her hands shake. The progression from silence → secret physician visits → walking in public → the ring revelation → confronting Bjorn → the full emotional eruption is perfectly paced. Each step costs her something. By the end, she's given him everything she had left: the truth of how he's destroying her. And I'm sitting here wondering what happens when he doesn't care.
... Read More
There's a petunia on that table. Just one. Beside a ring that no longer has an owner. And I've been turning over what that image represents and I think it's the entire thesis of this passage. Petunias. Let's trace them. Dek offers to bury Ivnen in them—a death wish wrapped in floral courtesy. But Ivnen remembers Bjorn saying something completely different: that he'd rather see one bloom every single day. One bloom. Daily. Sustained. Expected. Trusted. One petunia vs. a grave full of them. Presence versus monument. That's the central choice of this entire relationship. Bjorn chose the monument—the grand romantic gestures of the past, the commissioned ring, the elaborate letters—while starving her of the daily, quiet presence she actually needed. And the ring itself—amethyst, her favorite stone, commissioned with "great lengths" and every jeweler in the empire gathered to create it—sits on a stranger's counter while its intended wearer drinks poisoned tea. The ring becomes a symbol of love as PERFORMANCE rather than love as PRACTICE. Bjorn performed devotion beautifully during their engagement and then abandoned the practice entirely once they were married. Then there's the letters. "To you, whom I love." No name. Anonymous. And Ivnen reads them and feels her entire history collapse because the words are real—the love is real—but the recipient is WRONG. The emotion was never the problem. The allocation was. The deepest symbolic act in this passage is Ivnen removing her wedding ring. Not throwing it. Not breaking it. Removing it, slowly, and setting it down. It's an act of surrender that's also an act of clarity. She's finally seeing the marriage for what it is: a label without substance, a title without partnership, a ring without a finger. And the physician scene—gold coins exchanged in secret, promised confidentiality—this is the symbol of her choosing herself over the role she's been playing. The gold is hers to spend. The body is hers to protect. The truth is hers to uncover. Everything else was borrowed.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or