This Loving Traitor - Reviews

This Loving Traitor
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just start with the dialogue and then I might need to lie down. "I hate you." / "I know." "I despise you." / "I know." "I wish you were dead." / "That too… I'm not unaware of." This exchange. This ABSOLUTELY PERFECT exchange. Four lines of hatred, four lines of acknowledgment, and not a single defensiveness from him. No "I'm sorry" — not yet, anyway. No deflection. No romantic grandstanding. Just… he hears her. He actually hears every word and he doesn't look away. The narrator's voice in this passage is incredible too. It's intimate without being purple, observant without being clinical. Take this line: "But she didn't want to deceive herself. The Bjorn of then and the Bjorn of now were not the same person. It would be easier on her heart to think of it that way." That's not just narration — that's Ivnen's entire psychological architecture laid bare in two sentences. She's already done the work of separating the man she loved from the man who destroyed her, and yet her body still remembers the warmth. And then there's the request that becomes the whole scene: "Carry me." Three words. Absolutely nothing more elaborate than that. After everything — after the regression, after the poison, after the mistress, after the death — she reduces her entire plea to a physical act that means everything and nothing simultaneously. The banter from the flashback is tonally jarring in the best way. "Just like a squirrel" — this is the voice of a man who once found joy in watching her eat, who stretched meals out just to look at her face. It's so domestic and so tender that it makes the present-day silence between them hurt even more. Bjorn's dialogue is notably sparse throughout this section. He barely speaks past the instructions to Felix. But when he does — "Carry me" reversed — it lands with the weight of someone who's being handed something he never thought he'd deserve again. The author's voice here is restrained to the point of surgical precision. Every word earns its place. I cannot overstate how good this restraint is.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about what's actually at stake in this scene, because on the surface it looks like a domestic dispute and underneath it's an existential gamble. Ivnen is betting her entire emotional survival on one question: can she look at Bjorn without drowning? She's not asking for his love. She's not asking for apologies. She's asking for him to STAY — not as her husband, not as the man who betrayed her, but as evidence that she can still exist in the same room as him and not collapse. "Until I've had my fill of it. Until I can see the bottom of my heart." That's the real stakes. It's not about whether they'll reconcile. It's about whether she can process grief without running from it. In her previous life, she ran. She threw herself into serving him, into making him happy, into becoming smaller and smaller until there was nothing left. This time, she's choosing to stand in the wreckage and actually look at it. Bjorn's stakes are different but equally high. He's walking away from everything — his estate, his position, his comfort — and the text makes it clear this isn't cowardice. "Nothing out of the ordinary while I was away?" "No, my lord." The calmness of that exchange suggests he's been expecting this reckoning for a while. He packed his sword and armor like a man preparing for war, except the war is against his own inertia. The external conflict — the mistress, the betrayal, the poisoning — hangs over everything like a storm cloud that never quite breaks. We know it's there. We feel it in every silent glance between them. But the author is smart about not letting it dominate; the real tension is internal, psychological. Will Ivnen use him as an emotional crutch one more time? Will Bjorn fail her again in a different way? And the physical stakes — Ivnen literally clinging to his back, arms around his neck, saying her legs hurt — that's not vulnerability as weakness. That's vulnerability as strategy. She's choosing to be physically close to the source of her trauma, testing whether she can withstand it. Every step he takes is a test. Every warm moment is a risk. This is what makes the scene so tense: neither character knows how this ends, and that uncertainty is what keeps you turning pages even when nothing "happens" on the surface.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or