The Vicious Dog - Reviews

The Vicious Dog
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's this one line that keeps echoing in my head: "maybe Pei Ruyin had been replaced by some kind of creature wearing his skin." She dismisses it as sci-fi nonsense, but the story itself is built on this exact premise and it changes everything you think you know about symbolism. Let me start with the most obvious symbol: the ring. Arcobaleno means rainbow in Italian. A rainbow appears AFTER a storm. They engraved it on the day they finished language class, right after rain stopped and color returned to the world. But look at what happens in this chapter—dark clouds gather, heavy rain pours down, and she's holding the ring when lightning flashes. The rainbow symbol is literally being tested against the storm. Is their love the color that comes after, or is it just a memory of something that already passed? The fact that the ring fits perfectly but was discarded suggests that love can survive separation but not betrayal. The deer motif is equally loaded. Half a deer on her ring, half on his—when joined they form a complete animal. Deer in literature often symbolize gentleness, intuition, something wild that trusts humans. But here's the twist: deer are prey animals. They're always scanning, always alert, always one step from running. Xu Luling has become a deer in this story—hyper-vigilant, traumatized, striking before thinking. And Pei Ruyin? He's the hunter who's also been wounded. That scar on his shoulder from a stray bullet. He's not just her protector; he's someone who's been shot before and is still moving forward. But is he the wounded animal or the one holding the bow? Now the glasses—this symbol is so sneaky I almost missed it the first time. Non-prescription frames for someone with 20/10 vision. Why would a man who sees perfectly wear fake glasses? On the surface, it's a costume choice, a disguise. But symbolically, glasses represent perception, how we see the world and how the world sees us. If Pei Ruyin is wearing glasses that aren't meant to correct his vision, maybe he's trying to CONTROL how others perceive him. Maybe he's hiding something behind a frame that changes his expression. Or maybe—and this is darker—he's literally not the person who needs those glasses. The real Pei Ruyin might have perfect vision, but the thing wearing his face chose frames to seem more intellectual, more familiar, more HIM. The white fur in the garden is the most unsettling symbol because it's so inexplicable. White fur stained red. Not black fur, not brown—WHITE. Something pale bled under that bush. And the soil was disturbed. Whatever happened there, it happened recently, and it happened in secret. The garden is supposed to be a peaceful domestic space, the heart of the apartment complex where residents walk their dogs and their children play. Instead, it's a crime scene disguised as landscaping. And the rainy season itself—a recurring temporal marker. The resignation happened when the rainy season started. The ring symbol comes from a rainstorm. The chapter ends with heavy rain pouring. Rain in Chinese literature traditionally carries ambiguity: it can cleanse or it can drown. The word for rain (雨) sounds like nothing particular, but the imagery is consistent—water falling from sky, unseen until it's everywhere, impossible to hold, impossible to ignore. Xu Luling's doubts are the rain. They've been falling since chapter one and now they're drowning her. What's the story really about? I think it's about the horror of intimacy without certainty. You can know someone's scars, their favorite gestures, the way they take their coffee, and still not know if they're real. The rainbow was supposed to be proof of beauty after darkness. But what if the darkness never ended? What if the rainbow was just light bending through something that wasn't water at all?
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is absolutely razor-sharp, and I need to talk about how Xu Luling uses words as weapons. That opening line - Ah Yu, care to explain? - is delivered with such casual cruelty. She's not yelling, she's not crying. She's just... knowing. And that's infinitely more terrifying. The author clearly understands that what characters don't say is often louder than what they do. When Xu Luling says I'm a little hungry, can you make me something to eat? after peeling back all these layers of deception, it's the ultimate power move. She's saying everything without saying anything. The text even notes that Pei Ruyin recognizes this as her way of signaling she won't pursue the matter further. They have this whole unspoken language built on years of manipulation and counter-manipulation. Pei Ruyin's confession is where the dialogue really shines. His voice remains gentle even as he reveals the most horrifying details - the staged death, the insurance fraud, the years of living as a ghost. The contrast between his calm delivery and the monstrous content creates this chilling effect. He's not confessing to murder, he's explaining like he's reading a business proposal. I'm particularly struck by how the author uses psychological observations woven into the narrative. When someone says this, it often means they already know a secret but are giving the other person a chance to come clean. This narrator voice breaks the fourth wall in a way that makes you feel like you're being let in on the game. You're not just reading about psychology - you're being trained in it. The livestream dialogue is brilliantly integrated too. The influencer's excited commentary about random filming creates this documentary realism that contrasts with the manufactured drama of the reveal. And Wu Na's message - Doesn't this look like your jealous boyfriend? - is such a perfect modern relationship text. Casual, pointed, devastating. Xu Luling's internal voice is where the real genius lives though. She's thinking in patterns, connecting dots, testing hypotheses. When she says So this was something you needed to keep hidden? Her voice was light, but anyone familiar with her would know she was on the verge of anger. That's character assassination through subtext.
... Read More
I have to talk about how this book uses silence. Really. Xu Luling and Pei Ruyin barely have a single conversation in these chapters. She texts him, he replies with breakfast photos and traffic updates—"meaningless but familiar conversations." That's the author's voice telling us everything: their dialogue is empty, performative, and Xu Luling herself turns off her phone without reacting. BOOM. The most talked-about character is the one who NEVER shows up. Meanwhile, the actual dialogue we get—from the neighbor, from Wu Na via text—is warm, grounded, and deeply human. "Young lady, are you alright? You don't look well." Simple. Care. Real. But Xu Luling waves it off and retreats. Her own words to her neighbor are vague, evasive. She's building walls, not bridges. And Wu Na's texts—"Again with the police?!"—this is the voice of genuine friendship colliding with Xu Luling's isolation. The contrast between the text messages (which feel alive) and the spoken scenes (which feel hollow) tells us everything about where Xu Luling's heart is. She's surrounded by people but communicating with no one. The author's narrative voice here is clinical, almost detached—short sentences, plain observations. It makes us FEEL her dissociation because the prose itself feels like someone holding themselves together by force.
... Read More
Honestly? I went in expecting a generic missing person story and got genuinely hooked. The opening premise is dead simple—girl goes to airport, boyfriend is gone—but the author stacks the tension so smoothly it barely feels engineered. First there's the disappearance, then the police say 'it's only been three hours, chill,' then BAM—Officer Yang remembers the hidden cameras incident AND the death threats. Two subplots drop into the main narrative like stones into water, rippling outward. What I loved most was how the author never lets Xu Luling be just a anxious girlfriend. She's sharp, she pushes back, she cites legal authority and argues for special authorization. That line, 'human life is at stake. If he really is missing, waiting twenty more hours could be too late,' made me actually lean forward. And then the resolution comes not from some dramatic hero moment but from Pei Ruyin literally walking through the door. The blood sugar explanation is almost disappointingly mundane after all that buildup—which I think is intentional. Life isn't always dramatic; sometimes the terror was real even if the outcome wasn't. Did I want more plot twists? Sure. But the coherence was solid, and the pacing never dragged. Just one question though: those death threats and hidden cameras—are they coming back, or was that just flavor for this chapter?
... Read More
Let's talk about what these characters are actually fighting for, because the stakes here are absolutely brutal and they keep escalating in ways that left me gripping the phone. Pei Ruxiao sabotaged his own brother's college entrance exam food because he couldn't stand the widening gap between them. Jealousy as a weapon. Then he was drugged and left to drown—officially dead in the eyes of the law—and somehow survived only to end up in America, fleeing, illegal, carrying that hatred like a second skeleton. What does a person hold onto when they've lost everything—legitimacy, identity, family? That's the central tension of this entire narrative. But the masterstroke is Jiang Ruosheng's plan. He's been observing from the shadows for years while surviving abuse that would have broken most people. When Du Luzhu shows up asking for money, he doesn't refuse outright—he gives her a scheme to manipulate Pei Ruyin through an insurance brochure. He's using his biological mother as a pawn in a game she doesn't even understand she's playing. The stakes he's gambling with include his own freedom, his future, and potentially his brother's life. And what about Pei Rujin? The boy who studied criminal psychology specifically—was that research or preparation? The author leaves this hanging and I am losing my mind. What is this kid building toward? What happens when all these fractured pieces finally collide?
... Read More
The stakes start at zero and climb so naturally you don't even notice them rising until your heart is in your throat. Xu Luling isn't just worried—she's operating on instinct. Right eyelid twitching, no sleep, straight from work in business attire, rushing to the airport. Every signal her body sends says something is wrong. And then the system fails her. Security guards cite regulations. Police say 24-hour rule. Bureaucracy moves at its own pace while her boyfriend's life might be at stake. That conflict—individual urgency vs institutional slowness—is where the real tension lives. It's not just "is he okay?" it's "nobody will help me find out if he's okay." The death threats and hidden cameras from last week add another layer: this isn't random bad luck, someone is targeting them. When Xu Luling argues for special authorization citing previous evidence, she's basically saying "the context matters, you can't treat this as a normal missing person case." And she's right. The emotional stakes are clear—she loves him, she's terrified of losing him—but the external stakes are equally compelling because the threats have history. The resolution arrives almost too quickly, which is the only slight letdown. But the journey there? Genuinely nail-biting.
... Read More
I need to talk about Du Luzhu because honestly my blood is boiling just thinking about her. The woman sold her firstborn as a baby—just handed him over for a thick wad of cash—and then when she returns years later, she doesn't come with tears or guilt, she comes asking for money. For her favourite son. The one she kept. And she still calls the abandoned child "a rag she had thrown away." That line hit me like a truck. What kind of human being looks at their own flesh and blood and categorizes them like trash? But here's the thing that keeps me up at night—Jiang Ruosheng. He knew her before she even walked through that door. He'd been watching. A seventeen-year-old who survived beatings so severe his bones broke, who was locked in a dog kennel, whose so-called parents faked philanthropy to scam donations... and he still had enough clarity in him to trace his origins and plan his revenge. Not just revenge though, was it? Because when he hands her that insurance brochure and tells her what to say to Pei Ruyin, he's playing a long game. He's using her own greed against her. "Of course I know you—you're my biological mother," he says it with this dead, flat tone. There's no anger. No pain even. Just cold acknowledgment that somehow cuts deeper than any scream ever could. That is the most heartbreaking thing I have ever read in my life. And then there's Pei Ruxiao worshipping Pei Rujin like some kind of dark mirror. The way this brotherly bond formed through shared cruelty—teaching each other how to dispose of bodies—is genuinely sickening and I couldn't stop reading it.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say I need a moment because this chapter absolutely wrecked my understanding of who is pretending to be whom and for how long. Let's map this out because the plot structure here is like Russian nesting dolls gone wrong. First, Pei Ruxiao pretends to be Pei Ruyin to meet Xu Luling. That was established earlier—he's the duller brother who somehow kept pulling this off for five years because she kept confusing them. Then he KILLS someone thinking it's Pei Ruyin. Turns out it's NOT Pei Ruyin—it's some man in a suit who looks like Pei Ruyin. Then Pei Rujin shows up, assesses the situation in about thirty seconds flat, and hands his brother two options: surrender OR become his dead brother. But here's where it gets TWISTED. Pei Ruxiao says he can't impersonate Pei Ruyin for long. So he asks PEI RUJIN—the calm observer, the one who was reading Memento like nothing was happening—to step in. And Pei Rujin smiles this quiet, terrifying smile because... he was ALREADY planning to play Pei Ruxiao pretending to be Pei Ruyin. He's playing four levels deeper than anyone realized. The rooftop stunt with the mannequin that scared Xu Luling? That's apparently part of the setup. Pei Rujin needs twenty days to dismantle five years. Twenty days. That's a deadline that feels like a ticking bomb. And Xu Luling—she's sharp, observant, doesn't trust anyone but herself. The only way to make her fully believe something is for her to figure it out on her own. That's not manipulation, that's psychological architecture. I'm still processing the ring detail. Pei Rujin notices the ring mark on Pei Ruyin's finger but no ring on the body. Where did it go? Who took it? Is this actually Pei Ruyin dead or is that part of the mystery too? The plot has enough loose threads to hang me with, and I'm not even sure who the killer is supposed to be at this point. This is what happens when you take 'the double' trope and feed it to a chess master.
... Read More
Let me just say — the atmospheric writing in this chapter is NO JOKE. The author knows how to paint a scene and I am here for it. Open with this: 'night had fallen, and a light rain was drizzling down. The colorful lights blurred as they reflected in the rain.' And then immediately underneath that, Pei Ruyin holding an umbrella tilted toward her. Rain + artificial light + protection = instant mood. The author doesn't need a paragraph, she needs three sentences and you're already feeling the humidity. Then you have the flashback sequence — the stuffed animal camera reveal. 'When she picked up the bead to put it back, she noticed a faint light reflecting from the empty eye socket.' A toy bear. A bead eye. A faint light. This is the most violating image in the entire book and it's delivered with such clinical detachment that it makes it worse. No dramatic music, no internal monologue about horror — just a woman doing weekend cleaning and discovering someone has been watching her. The outdoor concert scene where she's held in a headlock watching a car aim for Pei Ruyin — 'a driverless smart car suddenly charged toward them like a rampaging bull.' The modernity of it! A self-driving car as a murder weapon. That's the kind of detail that makes you appreciate the worldbuilding. And the midnight scene — 'In the dark room, less than a meter from her bed, it looked as if someone was standing there.' Shadow play. The lamp clicking on revealing Pei Ruyin's face. The warm yellow glow. The author keeps toggling between cold darkness and warm light like she's directing a film in her head.
... Read More
The most devastating scene in this entire passage isn't the news report or the crime photos—it's a conversation that happens over a plate of shredded pork. When Xu Luling grabs Pei Ruyin's wrist and asks about his ring, she's operating from a place of genuine confusion mixed with something sharper, something she can't quite name. Five years of history between them, and yet the first instinct is accusation. But here's what's heartbreaking: she knows immediately after that her own ring was missing from her finger because she'd taken it off in the shower. She has no evidence. And yet she questioned him first. Pei Ruyin's response is chilling in its perfection. He doesn't flinch. He opens his palm for her to inspect. His voice is calm, tinged with what reads as genuine frustration—not guilt, but the annoyance of someone whose reasonable explanation is being met with suspicion. As an investment banker, the text tells us, he's skilled at deflecting attention with words. But is that a skill he's using now, or is it just who he is? Their dynamic has always been playful—hair-ruffling, teasing about his glasses, banter about student council presidents. But beneath the laughter, there's a power imbalance that this scene exposes. He cooks. He plans dinners. He remembers old conversations. She questions, doubts, and then feels guilty for doubting. The relationship reads as loving on the surface, but the reader can't shake the feeling that Xu Luling is the one constantly adjusting, constantly trying to make sense of a partner who may or may not be entirely himself. The final line of the passage—her gaze lingering on his back as he cooks—is one of the most unsettling images I've read in a long time. She loves him. She knows him. And yet something is quietly, invisibly different.
... Read More
I need a minute. A literal minute. Because when Xu Luling measures that ceiling and finds 1.5 meters missing, I felt it in my chest. Not because it's a supernatural reveal—it's because it's a perfect metaphor for everything that's been hollow between them. Her husband has been building something secret inside their home, inside their marriage, and she's been waking up next to him every day not knowing what's literally above her head. The worst part? She still makes him breakfast. She still remembers his breakfast preferences. Pan-fried buns, tofu pudding—"all hometown dishes Xu Luling had once mentioned missing during her time studying abroad." This woman has been caring for someone who doesn't exist, and the breakfast scene hits so different now. It's not romantic anymore, it's tragic. And the cat! Cream the cat comes into her lap and purrs and for one second the tension eases. I literally exhaled. These small moments of comfort make the horror worse because you realize how badly Xu Luling just wants to feel safe, and she CAN'T because her own home is a lie. The most heartbreaking line though? "She even considered ignoring all the oddities and just continuing to live her life like this." Not because she's foolish—because she's exhausted. She's been trying so hard to hold onto normalcy that the idea of just pretending everything is fine feels almost peaceful. That's not love, that's survival.
... Read More
Okay so Wu Na walks in and immediately becomes the most interesting person in the room. Like, her dialogue is so distinct and layered. She opens with this deadpan observation about the rose garden being a waste of money, then immediately pivots to 'wanna hear some juicy gossip about your jealous boyfriend?' and I just lost it. The way she says things like 'you'd be surprised. some people hide it well' with this conspiratorial grin while sprawled on Xu Luling's bed—this is a character who has no filter and absolutely loves drama. And Pei Ruyin's dialogue, or lack thereof, is equally telling. He's all practical actions—cooking, replacing sheets, switching to dark ties before his trip—but when it comes to his past? Radio silence. 'I have no family.' Classic deflection. The author clearly understands that what people refuse to say is just as important as what they do say. And Xu Luling herself—her internal voice is perfect. She's the kind of person who notices everything but tries really hard not to notice things. 'She didn't want to keep doubting every little thing.' That line broke my heart a little because it's so relatable. We've all been there, consciously choosing ignorance over pain.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or