The Vicious Dog - Reviews

The Vicious Dog
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay, let me just—I need to sit down after this chapter. The phone call scene. The absolute gut punch of it. Xu Luling hears Pei RuXiao's voice (or what she thinks is his voice) and she's already falling apart, and the man on the other end just says "Luling, I love you" and hangs up. Not even a real answer to her question about whether the killing was intentional or accidental. Just... those three words. And then he disappears off the face of the earth. "You're not him! Don't act like you know me!" — and oh my god, she's right, right? Pei Ruyin was reserved for five years and never said anything like that. But this voice is so similar, and the man calling her is clearly someone who planned this down to the smallest detail. Who are they even talking to? Because this whole time we've been following this thread about the twin brothers, about who killed whom, and now it just... unravels. And then Pei RuXiao jumps from that building. The police arrive too late. Just like they arrived too late for everything else. The ring in the snake, the deer symbol, the whole Shitong River case — it's all neatly tied up with a bow that still feels deeply, profoundly untied in my chest. The case is closed. Case closed, I repeat. But how can it be? There are still so many pieces that don't fit.
... Read More
The dialogue in this passage is razor-sharp and I'm obsessed with how each character's voice is instantly distinguishable. Jiang Ruosheng's lines are the coldest weapons in fiction. Let me just drop this one: "Of course I know you—you're my biological mother." That's it. That's the entire sentence. No elaboration, no emotional framing, just this blunt surgical strike delivered with zero ornamentation. He doesn't hate her. He doesn't love her. He simply states a fact, and the fact itself is the violence. I read that three times and each time it got worse. Then there's Du Luzhu's dialogue—she's illiterate, she stammers, she says 'W-what about you?' like an afterthought. Her voice is all hesitation and self-interest, and the author makes you hear that in every word she speaks. She can't even articulate guilt properly. And Pei Ruxiao! His voice is sneering, crude, full of envy. 'There's no way a gutter rat like Pei Ruyin could ever get her.' But then Pei Rujin just looks up from his book and says 'You like her too'—and it's not even a question, it's just... stated. Flat. Knowing. This younger brother sees everything and says the minimum necessary. The author's narrative voice is also something special. It's almost clinical when describing horrific events—nearly every year of his life involved hospitalization, but survived, barely. The detached tone makes the horror louder. The prose doesn't flinch, and that refusal to dramatize is what makes it devastating.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about Pei Ruyin because THIS MAN is walking around with some seriously unsettling behavior and I am NOT okay with how casually it's presented. The scene where he stands in the dark less than a meter from her bed and says 'It's me' — then later she wakes up multiple times finding him just staring at her — this isn't romantic, folks. This is someone who is clearly carrying guilt or fear to a point where his behavior has crossed into something almost predatory, even if the narrative frames it as devotion. And then there's the bedsheets moment. He says 'I suddenly don't like them anymore.' After five years together, after she explicitly mentions he spent ages picking them out — this is such a small detail but it screamed SO LOUD to me. Is he trying to erase something? The cameras were found. Something was in their home. And now he can't stand the reminders of the life they built there? That's not fickle, that's trauma response disguised as preference. The kiss scene is interesting too. 'Unfamiliar clumsiness — clumsy yet intense, two contrasting emotions intertwining.' This isn't the Pei Ruyin from before. Something changed. Three hours of not knowing if he was alive or dead — or maybe knowing something she doesn't? He prepared all those meals ahead of time. Frozen, ready to reheat. That's not just a good boyfriend, that's someone preparing for a scenario where something might happen. What kind of scenario, huh? And Xu Luling? She's so accommodating. 'You're so fickle. Whatever, do as you like.' She absorbs his mood shifts, his weird nighttime surveillance, his sudden intensity. I love her but also — girl, what are you sitting on?
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this attic reveal because honestly it completely restructured the entire story. Up until this point, the plot was basically a voyeurism mystery—cameras found, suspicious husband, blah blah. Routine. Then Xu Luling climbs up that folding ladder and the whole thing just detonates. The way the author layers the reveals is masterful. First the empty attic looking normal, then she steps on something—CRUNCH—and it's another camera. Not one, but MORE than the 23 the police already found. That detail alone should have been enough to make my skin crawl. But then she lifts the white cloth and it's Cream. Their cat. Preserved. Skinned. Eyes gouged out. And the bloodstain directly below her bedroom? That's when I actually had to put the book down for a second. This isn't just a mystery anymore—it's a horror story wearing a mystery's clothes. "Who was trying to watch them? More accurately, who was trying to watch her?" That line right there is the whole story in one sentence. The plot pivots from 'is someone spying on me' to 'someone has been watching me this entire time and I slept next to their preserved head.' The surveillance wasn't the crime—it was the trophy case. And then Pei RuXiao showing up the next morning like nothing happened, walking out with that black garbage bag, and the police later finding a human head three kilometers away in a trash bin? The reveal that he's been 'dead' for twenty days while simultaneously living in the same house as his victim? That's not just a twist—that's a gut punch. The plot structure here is doing something really smart. It makes you think you understand the rules (voyeurism case, missing husband), then systematically breaks every single assumption. The attic wasn't a hiding spot—it was a museum. And Xu Luling wasn't a potential victim who got lucky—she was the exhibit the whole time.
... Read More
This entire chapter is built around the symbolism of rings and what they represent - commitment, evidence, identity, and the circular nature of deception. The opening image of the ring catching light isn't just atmospheric, it's thematic. Light reveals truth, but it also creates shadows. Let me just sit with that for a moment - the ring on her finger, the ring found in the snake, the ring thrown off during the struggle. Each ring represents a different layer of the truth. One is worn, one is evidence, one is discarded. And now Xu Luling is wearing a replacement while harboring suspicions that the original belongs to someone else entirely. The name Ru Xiao meaning before dawn is doing some serious symbolic work here. This twin was supposed to rise before the original, but instead he's stuck in perpetual darkness - literally and figuratively. He's the ghost brother, the shadow self, the identity that was erased so the other could flourish. And now he's back from the dead, which raises the question: when one twin dies, does the other get to live freely, or does guilt haunt them both? Water imagery pervades everything. Rain, drowning, drowning accidents, the rainy season. Water is where life begins and where bodies disappear. The Shitong River where the headless corpse was found - that's not random. It's where truth gets deposited, where evidence gets drowned, where identities get washed away. The snake finding the ring is such potent symbolism. Snakes shed their skins, they're associated with deception and rebirth. A ring inside a snake - the ultimate symbol of commitment consumed by betrayal. And no one claimed it. Who would claim a ring when claiming it means admitting you know what really happened? I'm also thinking about the computer ad - If you're my brother, come slash me! - as a meta-commentary on identity itself. The story is literally asking readers to investigate, to dig, to slash through the surface. And Xu Luling's performance of shutting down the computer while staying awake all night is the perfect metaphor for modern deception - we all hide our searches, our suspicions, our fears behind closed screens.
... Read More
The rings are the obvious symbol, but they're also the tip of an iceberg. Two matching rings—one for a man, one for a woman—that form a specific design when placed together. This is a promise made visible, a commitment encoded in metal. Their disappearance isn't just a plot device; it's a rupture in the sacred geometry of the relationship itself. But the real symbol isn't the absence of the rings—it's the presence of the marks they left behind. Xu Luling's finger bears the indentation of five years of wear. Pei Ruyin's doesn't. This is the story's central metaphor made flesh: she is marked by their history, and he is not. Or rather, the thing wearing his skin is not marked by it. The ring mark becomes a barcode, a diagnostic tool, a way of reading truth from the body itself. The glasses are another symbol worth tracking. Pei Ruyin doesn't need them—he has perfect vision—but he wears them anyway, prompted by a memory of Xu Luling praising an actor's look. Is this adaptability? Is this performance? Is he learning to become someone she finds attractive, and if so, where does that end? The vase that faces a different direction is perhaps the smallest and most powerful symbol in the passage. It represents the violation of private space, the sense that the familiar has been rearranged by unfamiliar hands. It's domestic instability rendered in wood and ceramic. And the rain—the constant, seasonal rain that soaks everything—functions as an atmospheric symbol of obscuration. Nothing is clear. Everything is damp and heavy and hard to see through.
... Read More
Let's talk about stakes because this story is masterfully raising them without ever shouting. Every chapter adds another brick to the wall of uncertainty, and by chapter 17 I am genuinely incapable of knowing what's real anymore. The initial conflict is supposed to be simple: someone broke into Xu Luling's apartment. But the guards find NOTHING. No hidden spaces, no one there. And she was watching the door the entire time. So either she imagined it, or the intruder is so skilled that they literally phased through walls, or—and this is the thought that keeps me up at night—what if PEI RUYIN was the intruder and he's the one who doesn't remember? The white fur in the garden is such a small detail but it vibrates with dread. Scattered tufts of white fur STAINED WITH BLOOD under a bush. Whose fur? A pet? An animal? Or something else? The fact that she notices this while rushing out of her traumatized apartment shows how hyper-vigilant she's become. She's not just scared—she's SCANNING. Then Pei Ruyin resigns. Right before a promotion. On the exact day of the rainy season—the same night she went to pick him up at the airport. The author connects these dots deliberately, making the reader assemble the evidence alongside Xu Luling. But here's where it gets BRILLIANT: Pei Ruyin doesn't act suspicious. He ACTS LIKE PEI RUYIN. He's warm, attentive, immediately tends to her injuries, explains his resignation logically (a job offer with double salary). If you didn't know better, you'd think he was the most devoted husband alive. And maybe he IS. But the glasses. The fake prescription glasses. The man who supposedly has 20/10 vision is wearing costume frames. The stakes escalate in the parking garage when a light goes out and footsteps approach. Xu Luling's reaction is instantaneous—backpack to front, hand on the knife, strikes first. She's trained for this. Or maybe she's just finally living in a world where paranoia is rational. And then she almost kills the one person she's supposed to trust. The physical proximity—the blade stopping 0.001cm from his throat—is the closest the story has come to actual violence. But the REAL stakes reveal themselves in the resolution: the ring. The guard who found it described a whole chain of events—from trash bag to security office to girlfriend's finger to confession. This ring WAS thrown away by Pei Ruyin. Deliberately. And if the janitor hadn't emptied that bin, if the guard hadn't recognized it, if the girlfriend hadn't shown it off... she would NEVER have known he discarded their symbol of commitment. The stakes aren't just "is he alive" or "is he human." The stakes are: did he ever love her at all, or was that performance as calculated as those fake glasses? And the final image—dark clouds, pouring rain, her holding up the ring catching lightning—this isn't a confrontation, it's an execution. She's not asking questions anymore. She's presenting evidence. The suspense isn't whether she'll find out the truth. It's whether the truth will destroy them both.
... Read More
'In the past, his kisses were always gradual, like gentle spring rain, full of tenderness and affection. But this time, it felt like strong liquor, carrying a hint of wildness.' That line hit me like a truck. Five years of relationship history compressed into one sensory comparison and suddenly I understand everything about how fragile this couple's peace actually is. The whole chapter is basically a masterclass in emotional whiplash. You start with this quiet domestic tenderness — he tilted the umbrella toward her, she wiped rain from his forehead, there's this almost childhood sweetness to it. And then BOOM, you're diving into two months of attempted murder and surveillance paranoia. But what really got me was the contrast between the nightmare sequence and what follows. She wakes up screaming, heart pounding, and instead of running to him, SHE reaches for her phone like she's bracing for impact. That's not trust, that's survival instinct. And then the ending — 'Ah Yu, I'm here.' That nickname. After everything, after the fear and the shaking and the three hours of hell, she still reaches for his childhood name like it's an anchor. That's the most romantic thing I've read this year and it made me so uncomfortable because I know what's coming. The pizza delivery, the early bedtime, the mundane morning after — this is what the author does best. She sandwiches the most terrifying moments between scenes of such ordinary warmth that you forget, for a second, that these two are living in a nightmare. And then she reminds you.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this out loud—Pei Ruyin is NOT who he seems and I am HERE for it. Like, the way Xu Luling discovers those dark hoodies in his wardrobe? That moment when she connects them to the tall man in the video? That is the most chilling realization in the entire book because it means everything she thought she knew about her husband has been a performance. She literally says nothing—just her fingers tighten. No screaming, no accusations. Just this cold, dawning horror that she's living with a stranger. And what's worse? He's been changing slowly enough that she didn't notice until now. "Subtle, gradual ones. By the time she noticed, she had already grown accustomed to this new version of him." That line is brutal because it means Pei Ruyin has been manipulating her perception this entire time. But here's the thing that got me—she still loves him. She still considers ignoring the oddities and continuing to live her life like this. That's not weakness, that's human complexity. Xu Luling isn't some damsel who needs saving; she's a woman who has built a life with someone she thought she knew, and even as evidence mounts, she still can't fully let go. That tension between love and suspicion is what makes this character dynamic so devastating. And don't even get me started on the neighbor situation—she's basically a ghost in her own home, trapped between two apartments that shouldn't have a connection.
... Read More
The setting here is surprisingly vivid for what should be a boring bureaucratic space. An airport security office—sounds like the least cinematic place ever, right? Wrong. The author paints it with just enough detail to make you feel the fluorescent lighting, the sterile frustration, the hum of people waiting. But the real atmospheric winner is Pei Ruyin's entrance. "His hair was a bit disheveled, with water droplets clinging to the tips, and even his usually neat suit was soaked with rain, as if he had rushed over without even having time to use an umbrella." Rain. Soaked suit. Disheveled hair. This man literally materialized out of a storm, and the imagery hits like a cinematic wide shot cutting to close-up. You can SEE him through the glass door. There's also this wonderful environmental detail about Xu Luling's right eyelid twitching non-stop—a physical manifestation of anxiety that grounds the scene in her body rather than just describing her emotions. The sweat on her forehead, the watch glances, the phone she stares at hoping for his name to appear. Every sensory beat pulls you into that cold, anxious waiting room. And the shift when the mood changes—from sterile tension to warm relief, even the previously stern security staff can't help but smile. The world feels inhabited. Not overbuilt, not exposition-heavy, just right.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the hidden cameras. Twenty-three of them. Found in HER home. No fingerprints. Deliberately damaged wiring. This detail is mentioned almost in passing—just a line in a police recollection—but it echoes through the entire chapter like a low hum you can't quite locate. What does it mean that Xu Luling's私人 space was violated before this whole airport drama even starts? The theme of visibility vs invisibility is everywhere here. Hidden cameras = someone watching without being seen. Death threats = someone reaching out from the shadows. And Pei Ruyin's absence = the ultimate invisibility, a man who simply vanishes from every trackable space. Yet when he returns, the author describes his eyes as "piercing through the camera lens." Eyes that see through surveillance. There's something deeply symbolic about that image—a man whose gaze can penetrate the very technology that was used to violate her privacy. The rain-soaked entrance also strikes me as symbolic. Water as purification, washing away the tension, emerging from chaos. I'm not saying the author intended all of this consciously, but these motifs are layered thick enough that you can't unread them once you notice. The story seems to be asking: who is watching whom, and who has the power to look without being seen?
... Read More
I need to talk about structure because the author just played me. Let me trace this: the phone call scene is the nerve center. Everything vibrates out from there. Short. Stuttering. "Beep, beep, beep." The call is over before it really begins, and the police can't trace it — because of course they can't. Then the cut to the other side of the city, the old house, the SIM card breaking. Snap. Game over for that thread. Then the jump. The police arriving too late. Pei RuXiao dead. Case closed. And then — and this is where I was really caught off guard — TWO YEARS LATER. Just like that. A full narrative leap that could have felt careless, but instead feels like the only honest way to tell this story. You can't linger in that grief. You have to keep moving, even when you're hollowed out. The office workers gossiping about "President Jiang" and "eighty-one challenges" — it's such a casual, almost comedic moment that makes the weight of everything that came before it hit harder by contrast. And then Jiang Ruosheng driving to a cosmetic surgery clinic to delete his records. The pacing here is genius because it doesn't announce its revelations. It buries them in mundane detail. You think you're done. You think the story has moved on. And then it pulls the rug from under you again. The chapter structure mirrors Xu Luling's psychological state: fractured, jumping forward, trying to escape the past but always circling back. Just like her life.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or