The Sun is but a Morning Star - Reviews

The Sun is but a Morning Star
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's a scene where Qi Guang rides on the back of Ye Xing's bicycle, being chased by three people, and it plays out like a movie sequence in my head. Just pure visual storytelling. You've got the riverbank, the grass, the distant city sounds, mud splattering everywhere when Ye Xing tumbles off the bike. The location shifts matter too. We start at school — uniform-clad, controlled, Shuai Xiaoyun's fair skin glowing in sunlight like she's in a K-drama opening. Then we move to the street corner where the confrontation happens, the green traffic light as background, the exact ten-second countdown before Qi Guang decides to act. Then to his apartment — dark, curtained, the Agomelatine pills lined up like soldiers. Then back to school the next day with that beautiful breakfast ritual that says more about care than any dialogue could. The town itself feels alive. "Stealing bird eggs, catching fish, raising tadpoles, and watching them slowly grow legs and turn into frogs" — this is the world Qi Guang lost when he was ten. The contrast between the rundown small town (where he was spoiled and loved) and the big city (where he had a nanny but felt nothing) IS the worldbuilding. The physical spaces map onto his emotional geography. And that one sentence — "The curtains blocked out the light well, and the room plunged into darkness" — is basically a metaphor wearing a pantsuit. I can't unsee it.
... Read More
Okay so let me just start by saying the blank signboard thing? That is such a deliberate choice by the author and I keep coming back to it. Eight years of waiting, construction nearly finished, and still nothing on that board. It's like the bar itself is waiting for something to give it meaning. Meanwhile, all these other plot threads are firing: Qi Guang's family history getting peeled back layer by layer, Ye Xing's parents hiding something massive, and then BAM — Shuai Xiaoyun stumbling out of a restroom with a torn shirt and bruised legs. The chapter just ends there. No resolution, no explanation, just Qi Guang reacting. This author knows how to build tension and then yank the rug out from under you. The main storyline feels coherent in a weird way — like everything's moving forward but nobody actually knows where they're going, which I think is kind of the point.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is actually insane when you think about it. You go from YE XING SOBBING IN A BATHROOM â†' full-on physical fight â†' ice water splash â†' emotional support speech â†' quiet surveillance room monitoring—all in the span of a few thousand words. And it WORKS. The fight scene itself is chaotic in the best way. Short paragraphs, rapid dialogue, actions bleeding into each other. It reads like the camera is shaking because everyone involved is losing their minds. The author doesn't slow down to explain every punch or every emotion—they just let youFeel It. But then, right after the adrenaline dumps, we get the ice water scene which is almost comedic. "What the hell!" / "Damn it! Who is it?!" These two grown men just got dunked on like elementary schoolers. And then immediately after the comedy beat comes Ye Xing's genuinely moving speech to the girl. The tonal whiplash is intentional and it's brilliant. The chapter closes on such a quiet note—Qi Guang staring at a monitor screen, the actual attacker visible but unreachable, Zhou Tian still yapping in the background. All that built-up tension just... sits there. Hanging. We know this isn't over. The pervert is still out there. And the reader is left wanting the next chapter immediately. If this were a TV show, this would be the episode that makes you immediately hit "next episode" without even thinking about it.
... Read More
The imagery in this chapter is unexpectedly cinematic. Let's start with the fight — Ye Xing covered in mud after picking up his bicycle, Qi Guang with blood seeping through his sleeve, the small hoodlum frantically digging through his pockets for change. The author paints these scenes with such economy that every detail lands. "The scene was still strange just now, but now it looked like Qi Guang was robbing him" — I literally laughed out loud at this visual. Then we cut to Qi Guang's house, and the description is almost haunting: "the house was so clean and tidy that it didn't even look like anyone lived there." Clean, sterile, empty. Perfect for someone who is the "only one left." And the T-shirt moment? YE XING is wearing a shirt that says ARE YOU STRESSED with the NO box scribbled over in red pen like a maniac. This is such a small detail but it tells you everything about Qi Guang's inner state. The barbecue stall scene with the owner rushing home to his pregnant wife adds this extra layer — everyday life continuing normally while our two leads are carrying completely different weights. The contrast between the mundane and the heavy is the author's signature move here.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about the whole ice-compress scene because this is where everything between Qi Guang and Ye Xing just... shifted. Like, officially. Before this, they were in that weird post-fight zone where Ye Xing kept apologizing and Qi Guang kept being sarcastic, but now? Now Ye Xing is literally touching his face. And Qi Guang is LETTING him. That is HUGE for these two characters. Think about it—Qi Guang has NEVER let anyone get close to him physically. The text literally says he was disgusted by physical contact with anyone who wasn't related to him, and the only person he was ever close to was his grandfather as a kid. And yet here he is, sitting still while Ye Xing presses an ice-wrapped towel to his cheek like it's the most natural thing in the world. He doesn't push him away. He doesn't snap. He just... stays. And then the moment where Ye Xing asks about his nose—"Is your nose natural?"—and actually reaches out to touch it? That's not just friendship. That's something else entirely. Qi Guang almost jumps out of his skin, which is hilarious because he's usually the one doing the provoking, but this time the tables are completely turned. The part that really got me though is Ye Xing's internal realization that he felt... relieved? That they're just cousins? He didn't even realize he'd been fixating on them before. That's such a small detail but it tells us SO much about where his heart actually is. He's single, he's confused, and he's definitely not over Qi Guang. Also can we talk about how Qi Guang keeps calling him "Young Master" but there's this undercurrent of genuine care underneath all the mockery? When he refuses the breakfast offer, the narration explicitly says "Because even if you didn't bring it, I could still eat the breakfast you buy every day." That's not rejection. That's him already imagining a future where Ye Xing is there every morning.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in layering. You've got three separate storylines running in parallel and instead of giving you clean breaks between them, the author braids them together so tightly that by the time you realize what's happening, you're already committed. Start with the quiet scene — construction site, takeout, childhood nostalgia. Feels like a breath of fresh air. Then it cuts to Zhou Tian's house, the dinner table, casual dialogue that casually drops the rumor about Qi Guang's father killing his mother. Almost slips by if you're not paying attention. Then the KTV, Ye Xing's phone call with his mom, and right when you think the emotional peak has been reached — the bruised girl, the torn shirt, the blood — the chapter ends. The author never lets you settle. Every time you catch your breath, something else drops. I stayed up way too late reading this batch and I have nobody to blame but myself.
... Read More
Can we just appreciate how natural ALL the dialogue is in this passage? Every character has a DISTINCT voice and I can tell who's speaking even without the tags. Ye Xing's dialogue is sharp, angry, slightly unhinged—but also unexpectedly thoughtful when he needs to be. "Are you freaking sick?" / "I am crazy, messing with me is your bad luck!" / "With your thin arms and legs, and fair skin, you're not far off from a little girl." Bro goes from zero to a hundred in half a second and it's hilarious. Qi Guang is the opposite—minimal words, maximum impact. He barely says anything during the fight itself, and when he does speak it's functional: "Calm down!" / "Your clothes are soaked, why don't you go home." But then he GIVES HIS SHIRT to the girl and that SAYS everything. His silence is louder than anyone else's dialogue in this scene. Shuai Xiaoyun is pure chaos energy. She arrives like a hurricane, throws ice water without hesitation, and then immediately starts bossing people around. Her text message exchange with Qi Guang is so casual and real—"Really? I see your face is swollen." / "It's swollen, it'll be the same if you come"—this is how actual friends talk. And Zhou Tian. Sweet summer child. He's just there asking questions the whole time like "Hey hey! What happened?!" The comic relief that nobody asked for but everyone needed. The narrative voice itself is also doing a lot of work—especially those internal moments like "If Ye Xing said a word to Qi Guang, Qi Guang would definitely tell him to get lost" and "Not only did he not speak, but he also stuck to him like a piece of gum." This narrator knows these characters INSIDE OUT.
... Read More
Okay so this whole bathroom scene is peak misdirection and I am HERE for it. Ye Xing is literally in the middle of a complete emotional collapse because of some phone call—his parents situation, clearly—and then Qi Guang kicks the door open thinking this guy in the hoodie is some pervert harassing the glasses girl. The twist is that the real attacker had already RUN AWAY. Like, the author just let the actual villain escape and these two idiots fought each other instead 😂 But here's what really got me: Ye Xing was already at his breaking point emotionally, and then getting physically attacked pushed him OVER the edge. He wasn't just fighting Qi Guang—he was fighting everything. The anger explosion, the choking, the biting... this guy was a wild animal. And honestly? He was WINNING. Which is hilarious because we know he was the wrong person. The surveillance scene at the end is such a good button to close the chapter on. They finally see the actual creep on camera, stagger ing drunk. Meanwhile Ye Xing is still standing there in soaked clothes like 'I just want to know who THAT is so I can avoid him in the future.' Bro is out here treating a sexual assault like a pedestrian inconvenience lmaoo but also... fair? After everything that happened to him today, this IS just another bad thing on a very long list. The plot here is doing SO much heavy lifting with very little exposition. We don't know what the phone call said, we don't know the full history between Ye Xing and Qi Guang, but we FEEL it all. That's good writing, guys.
... Read More
I need to talk about Ye Xing's moment with the glasses girl because WOW. This guy just got choked, bitten on the shoulder (by HIMSELF apparently... wait no, Qi Guang bit HIM? Or Ye Xing bit Qi Guang? I need to re-read this because the fight is so chaotic), drenched in ice water, AND is still processing some devastating personal news—and yet when this girl starts apologizing for BEING HARASSED, something clicks in him. "Even if you wore even less than you are now, even if you went out wearing a bikini, nobody can touch you without your permission, understand?" This man just came out of a full-on brawl and delivered THE line. And it's not just that it's a good line—it's the context. He's someone who understands what it feels like to be helpless, to have your world knocked sideways by something completely outside your control. That's why his speech lands. It's not performative allyship. It's coming from a place of raw, personal understanding. And then there's Qi Guang. The guy who kicked Ye Xing in the first place, who was so distracted during the fight he couldn't even focus on defending himself properly—and later gives his own wet shirt to the harassed girl without a word. Silent, practical care. Classic Qi Guang energy. Their dynamic post-fight is SO interesting though. Ye Xing follows Qi Guang around "like a piece of gum" and Qi Guang is clearly annoyed but also... not actually pushing him away? And then Ye Xing roasts Zhou Tian's arms and calls him a little girl?? The group dynamics are giving chaotic found family vibes and I am consuming this.
... Read More
I can't stop thinking about the WATER imagery in these chapters. It's everywhere and it's NOT accidental. First, Ye Xing is in the bathroom, crouched by the sink, tears he "hadn't flowed during the phone call" being FORCED out. Water as suppressed emotion finally breaking through. Then the ice water bucket—Shuai Xiaoyun dumping it on both fighters like a divine intervention, a baptism of sorts that snaps them both back to reality. And Qi Guang wringing out his own wet shirt to give to the girl, water as something that can still be shared, offered, used to protect. But the real theme here is about WHO gets to be heard and WHO gets silenced. The glasses girl couldn't scream in the soundproofed bathroom. When she finally escaped, her first instinct was to APOLOGIZE—to take blame for something that wasn't hers. Ye Xing had to literally FORCE her to hear: "If anyone thinks it's your fault, then they're going to be the first to be eliminated by society." Meanwhile, Ye Xing himself is silenced throughout this entire sequence. He can't speak about what happened on the phone. He can't explain himself to Qi Guang. He just... takes it. Gets kicked, choked, bitten, drenched—and says almost nothing until he's ready to speak for someone else. And Qi Guang? His silence is different. It's not about being unable to speak—it's about choosing where to direct his energy. He fights, he watches the footage, he gives his shirt, he checks the surveillance. Action over words. Always. The chapter ends with all of them gathered around a screen, watching the attacker on a loop while unable to do anything about him yet. That image—that collective powerlessness in the face of someone who chose to hurt another person—stays with you long after you finish reading.
... Read More
There's something really special about how this chapter handles setting and atmosphere. Let me start with the motorcycle ride—that scene where they're heading through Chen Town at night is one of those moments that just plays like a film. The text describes it perfectly: small shops closing early, only late-night snack stalls still open, the occasional sounds of drinking games from somewhere nearby. It's quiet, it's intimate, it's the kind of nighttime that makes you feel like you're the only two people in the world. And then Ye Xing's reaction to the speed—"he felt a hidden sense of excitement, and wasn't afraid at all." That single line tells us everything about how safe he feels with Qi Guang, even on a motorcycle going fast through dark streets. The helmet becomes this weird barrier that somehow makes them closer instead of further apart. But the real atmosphere goldmine is Qi Guang's apartment. The study especially. The description of the bookshelf with its "unique smell, not a pleasant one, nor a musty smell, but the smell unique to old yellowed paper"—that's the kind of detail that makes you WANT to be in that room. Ye Xing taking a big inhale of it? Chef's kiss. It shows how different this world is from whatever urban environment Ye Xing comes from. This is a place with history, with books, with a phonograph sitting around because someone cares about music. The barbecue stall downstairs is another great touch. The owner recognizing Qi Guang, calling him "Xiao Guang," not even noticing his half-swollen face because the smoke is in the way—it's so specific and real. This isn't a generic Chinese town, this is a living, breathing place where people know each other and life moves at its own pace. It contrasts so sharply with whatever city Ye Xing is from, and I think that contrast is doing a lot of thematic work without the author having to say a word about it.
... Read More
I need to talk about the pacing because honestly it's really well calibrated. The first part—the arrival, the fall, the band-aid incident—moves at a snail's pace in the best way. You feel Ye Xing's exhaustion, his awkwardness, the way even boiling instant noodles becomes a whole production. It mirrors his emotional state: everything takes more effort when you're trying to survive in a new place alone. Then Chapter 3 hits and the rhythm shifts. Phone call → waking up late → Zhou Tian already at his door → tricycle ride → restaurant. The tempo quickens, and by the time Qi Guang appears, you're leaning forward. The author uses this structure deliberately: the slow build makes the encounter with Qi Guang feel like a genuine surprise rather than a planned plot moment. The chapter breaks are also smart. Ending Chapter 2 with Ye Xing passing out on the sofa after a Doraemon band-aid was placed on his ankle is such a specific, human detail. It's not a cliffhanger—it's just... life. And that's what makes the pacing work. The author trusts you to stay engaged without manufacturing artificial tension. One thing I'll say though—the teppanyaki scene with Zhou Tian waffling about food options goes on a touch long. Not a problem, just noticing. The author clearly enjoys letting characters breathe. I respect it, even if my patience for lunch menu discussions is limited.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or