The Sun is but a Morning Star - Reviews

The Sun is but a Morning Star
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so this chapter starts with absolute chaos — three guys versus Qi Guang, and honestly? I was invested from the first punch. But what I love is how the plot pivots so smoothly from the fight into something much more intimate. Ye Xing treats Qi Guang's wound, they go get BBQ, drinks flow, and suddenly you're learning that Qi Guang is basically alone in this world. That reveal — "Yeah, I'm the only one left in my family" — hit me like a truck. The way the author handles it is everything. No drama, no sob story, just said it like he's ordering food. And Ye Xing's internal panic is so relatable. He literally tries to block Qi Guang from paying the bill and then fumbles through an increasingly desperate explanation in his head. "How to explain?" literally his thought process. Classic. The subplot with the phone and the "Goddess" photos also does double duty — it's both comedic relief and a quiet character moment showing Qi Guang's protective side without him saying a word. The whole arc from violence → vulnerability → awkward friendship feels earned, not rushed.
... Read More
There are so many subtle symbolic moments in this chapter that I keep coming back to. Let me start with the motorcycle helmet. This is Ye Xing's FIRST time ever riding a motorcycle—Fang Rong never let him because it was "too dangerous." And yet here he is, holding onto Qi Guang from behind, feeling not fear but excitement. The helmet becomes this symbol of permission, of being allowed to do something dangerous because someone you trust is in front of you. It's also kind of a barrier, right? He can't see Qi Guang's face clearly through the helmet visor, but he's close enough to feel the speed, the wind, the closeness. That tension between connection and distance is everything. Then there's the ice compress scene and the whole business about physical touch. Qi Guang has this lifelong discomfort with physical contact—only his grandfather ever broke through that wall as a child—and now Ye Xing is just... touching his face. Uninvited even. And the more intimate gesture, touching his nose bridge, that's where things get really loaded. Physical touch as a language these two haven't learned yet but are desperately trying to speak. The phonograph in the study is another one I can't stop thinking about. It's an old machine, something Ye Xing has wanted to use but was too embarrassed to ask about. Qi Guang offers it casually, almost teasingly, but the underlying gesture is one of sharing something personal. That room—with its yellowed books and peculiar smells—is Qi Guang's inner world, and he's basically handing Ye Xing the key. And then there's Shuai Xiaoyun, mentioned throughout as this figure of romantic tension that turns out to be completely platonic. The whole "are they a couple" anxiety that Ye Xing carries is resolved not by romance but by family. It's almost cruel how the author uses that relief to show us that Ye Xing's feelings for Qi Guang aren't about占有 (possession) but about wanting to be the one person Qi Guang lets in.
... Read More
Okay so the whole weekend hanging-out scene is giving me main-character-energy-wholesome vibes and I cannot deal. Ye Xing literally never eaten at a classmate's house before AND they're eating by the roadside because the mom runs a fabric shop?? The detail about kids getting adopted for free meals by random uncles and aunts in the neighborhood... that is SO specific and real, it made me stop and just appreciate it for a second. But then the real plot bomb drops at the end, right? One minute it's all breakfast-and-bike-riding sunshine, and then THIS STRANGER shows up at the school gate asking about Qi Guang. And Ye Xing's immediate reaction—redirecting the bike, stepping in front—is actually kind of brilliant characterization without the author saying a word. He's already protective of Qi Guang at this point and his body just moves before his brain. Then chapter 10 pivots hard into the Chen Town backstory. Eight years. Brother Xu tracking him down. The way the author reveals things through dialogue instead of exposition dumps is genuinely impressive. "You're thinking too much!" — that line when Brother Xu offers money instead of just saying "here, take this" — perfect character voice. And the bar offer isn't charity dressed up as opportunity, it's actually both, and the author makes you feel that complexity. I need to know what happens next with Brother Xu. Something about that reunion felt like the calm before a storm.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the WeChat exchange between Qi Guang and Ye Xing is peak relationship building and I am HERE for it. "Stop pretending!" — Ye Xing is already comfortable enough to be sassy to this guy he barely knows. And Qi Guang's response? "Mr. Ye Xing, did I serve you well last night?" ...the audacity. The absolute audacity. I was wheezing. But then he adds "It seems you can't talk properly" and suddenly I'm like okay they're actually good at this. And the coins! He kept the five-yuan coins Ye Xing gave him. Who does that?? That is a small detail that tells me EVERYTHING about Qi Guang's character — he holds onto things, he notices, he doesn't let go easily. But honestly, the moment that wrecked me was in the bathroom scene. Qi Guang saying to Zhou Tian, "Stay away from me," twice. Not mean — just... territorial? Protective? His instinct is literally to create distance between the people he cares about. That's not cruelty, that's someone who's been hurt before and is bracing for impact. And Zhou Tian, sweet stupid Zhou Tian, who thinks Ye Xing brings breakfast because "I'm loved by everyone" — man, he has no idea. The contrast between how he reads the situation and how Qi Guang reads it is everything. "Not competing with your brother." Qi Guang literally unzipping and peeing while delivering that line. DEAD.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say — the opening confrontation is basically textbook youth drama tension building, and I mean that in the best way. Five girls surrounding Shuai Xiaoyun, hair-grabbing, the whole deal. Qi Guang waits exactly ten seconds at the crosswalk like he's calculating something, then EXPLODES across the street. I love that detail. He doesn't rush blindly — he assesses. And then his speech to the red-haired girl? Chef's kiss. "A man who wants to flirt with other girls but won't deal with the mess, leaving a bunch of women to confront each other while he hides is trash." THAT LINE. I literally nodded at my screen. But honestly? The plot twist that wrecked me wasn't the fight scene. It was the medicine drawer. One second you've got this cool protective guy, next second he's swallowing Agomelatine tablets, closing his curtains, feeling like he's "falling into the ocean." Like what?! From hero to hollow in two paragraphs. That's not foreshadowing, that's a gut punch. And then the subplot threads keep stacking — Zhou Tian's always-hungry energy, Old Lin's obvious prejudice against Qi Guang, the suspicious breakfast-giver (Ye Xing??), and of course the hoodlum fight at the riverbank that loops right back to the red-haired girl's boyfriend. The narrative cross-cuts between the school drama and Qi Guang's internal collapse so smoothly I almost didn't notice I was getting emotionally wrecked. The author knows how to use contrast as a weapon.
... Read More
On the surface, this chapter opens with a conflict—a pervert who went into the women's restroom, Ye Xing trying to do the right thing by documenting evidence, Qi Guang handling it in his own way. But honestly? That whole opening sequence is just a vehicle. The REAL conflict is happening between Qi Guang and Ye Xing, and it's so much more interesting. Let's break down the layers. First, there's the class conflict—Qi Guang calling Ye Xing a "city kid" who's dependent on rules and systems, and Ye Xing firing back with "Is letting these scumbags go what you country folks do?!" That's not just banter, that's a genuine ideological clash about justice, about how the world works, about who gets to decide what's right. And it's fascinating because NEITHER of them is completely wrong. Then there's the interpersonal conflict—the fight they just had, the apology that goes sideways, the whole uncomfortable tension of two guys who clearly care about each other but don't know how to navigate it. Every line of dialogue is basically a landmine. When Ye Xing blurts out the girlfriend comment, it's not an accident. It's him testing the waters, seeing if Qi Guang is taken, and getting caught. But the stakes that really keep me hooked are the emotional ones. What does Ye Xing stand to lose if he pushes too hard? What does Qi Guang stand to lose if he lets someone in? The text makes it clear that Qi Guang has spent his whole life building walls—refusing hospitals, refusing closeness, refusing to be vulnerable—and Ye Xing is the first person who's just... kept showing up anyway. That's the real suspense here. Not whether they'll catch the pervert, but whether these two will figure out what they're doing before one of them gets hurt. And honestly, the author is playing with us. Every time I think I know where this is going, something shifts. The cousin reveal. The nose touch. The breakfast offer that's actually a proposal of ongoing contact. The story is constantly raising the emotional stakes while keeping the surface conflicts almost comedic. It's a tightrope walk and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
I need to talk about the scene where Brother Xu and Qi Guang sit on the curb eating takeout. This is everything. Eight years apart, life has pulled them in completely different directions, and yet the first thing Brother Xu does is roll up Qi Guang's sleeve to check a new scar and immediately threaten someone. That's not just friendship, that's this deeply ingrained protective instinct that time hasn't touched. And Qi Guang — "Qi Guang became more talkative in front of Brother Xu" — this line hit me so hard. He doesn't open up like this with anyone else. The contrast with how he carries himself at the KTV, all cold and untouchable, makes this moment on the curb feel almost sacred. Then there's Zhou Tian dragging Ye Xing to that KTV like a golden retriever who found his best friend's best friend. Simple, loud, loyal. These three guys — Xu Ge, Zhou Tian, and Ye Xing — they all love Qi Guang in different ways and it's fascinating to watch how each relationship reveals a different facet of him.
... Read More
Time really does change a person. That line about Xu Ge hit me because it applies to everyone in this story. The blank signboard isn't just a naming problem — it's about how these kids grew up in a town that didn't have room for their ambitions, and now they're building something from nothing. The scars on Qi Guang's arm, the bruises on Shuai Xiaoyun's legs, the silence between Ye Xing and his parents — all of these are physical reminders of things that happened to them while they weren't looking. There's this recurring idea that the adults have answers but won't give them, that the truth is out there but protected behind walls of 'you're not ready' and 'focus on your studies.' I keep thinking about that last line before the chapter cuts off: 'Without saying anything, he rushed into the...' Into what? Into danger? Into responsibility? The story keeps pushing these boys toward moments where they have to choose — to protect someone, to confront the truth, to stop being children. The question is whether they're ready, or whether they'll be forced into it.
... Read More
I came for the fighting. I stayed for the bread and soy milk. Think about it — Ye Xing wakes up early EVERY day, buys buns and soy milk at the school gate, hides them in his backpack, and slips them into two different desks. One for Qi Guang. One for Zhou Tian. No announcement. No fanfare. Just quiet, consistent care disguised as coincidence. And Qi Guang — this kid who takes depression medication and fights three guys at the riverbank and talks to nobody about anything — notices. He hesitates. Then he goes down and swaps his usual bread for something different. He doesn't say thank you out loud but he eats it with "a clear conscience" and thinks "it really was pork and cabbage." That's his version of gratitude. But the real emotional landmine is Qi Guang's relationship with his grandfather. The text gives us these small, devastating details: "His grandfather didn't move with them. The old man always wanted to stay in the familiar place and didn't want to be troubled anymore." Qi Guang sulked for YEARS about it. Eight years later he's still carrying that abandonment, still taking pills in a dark room, still feeling like he's falling into an ocean with no shore in sight. The romance hasn't happened yet. I can feel it building though — the way characters orbit each other, the unspoken understandings, the breakfast rituals. When it finally lands it's going to wreck me and I'm already preparing.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this author writes dialogue because IT'S NOISE. Every character sounds completely different and I can hear their voices in my head like they're actual people sitting across from me. Qi Guang's lines are short, sharp, and loaded with restraint. "I'm tired, going home to sleep." That's it. He says five words and I feel his entire internal collapse. Later: "May I ask who you are?" said to a threatening hoodlum with complete calm. This is a guy who could level a building but chooses surgical precision with words instead. Then you've got Ye Xing, who is PURE COMEDY RELIEF with hidden depth. "Grandpa is going to teach you a lesson!" to a hoodlum who just kicked his bike. "Are you Qi Guang? If you're not, get lost!" — Ye Xing defending his boy without even realizing he's doing it. The bread and yogurt routine he sets up for Zhou Tian? The guy's a softie and he doesn't even know it. Old Lin is the worst kind of teacher — the one who genuinely thinks he cares but only cares about bonus points. "Look at what your grades are like now. Do you even want to go to university?" Meanwhile the narration tells us he suspected Qi Guang CHEATED his way into the top class. This man has done ZERO self-reflection in his entire career. And the red-haired girl: "This bitch has seduced so many people with her looks that if you're with her, you'll be cheated on so badly that your own mother won't recognize you!" Okay first — WHO talks like this? Second — this line literally triggers Qi Guang's entire trauma response because someone mentioned his MOTHER. The dialogue DOES narrative work here and I respect it.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—this opening is doing SO much with very little. Ye Xing arrives in Chen Town, falls off a skateboard (literally), gets handed a Doraemon band-aid by a guy who won't leave him alone, and then bumps into a mysterious skateboarder who also paid his taxi fare. That's chapters worth of setup compressed into what, two days? The plot doesn't waste time. What really got me was how the author threads the narrative without any exposition dumps. We learn about Ye Xing's life situation through his conversation with his mom on the phone—transferred to a new town, she's sending money, there's a whole 'Transformation' joke that implies this might be some kind of makeover or change-of-life storyline. Meanwhile, Zhou Tian just barrels in like a golden retriever with a quilt and an egg from his mom, and somehow you believe these two could be friends by the end of it. The Qi Guang reveal at the teppanyaki place? Chef's kiss. He's the guy from last night—the one who helped pay the taxi and disappeared. Now he's working at a restaurant in the small town. The author dropped that detail so casually but it immediately made me sit up. Who is this kid? Why does he help strangers and then vanish? And why is he so good-looking that Ye Xing internally wants to force him into a talent contract?! I also love how the subplot of the quilt functions as a tiny but complete narrative arc—Aunt Shen mentions Xiao Bao needs one, Zhou Tian delivers one to Ye Xing, and then next day Zhou Tian returns it with an egg. Three beats, no wasted words.
... Read More
This chapter is perfectly structured for binge-reading and I need to unpack why. It opens at maximum intensity — fists flying, a knife appears, blood is drawn. You're on the edge of your seat. Then it drops you into something unexpectedly tender: Ye Xing carefully cleaning a wound, wrapping it with a school uniform. The pacing breathes here. No rush. Just two guys being quietly decent to each other. Then the T-shirt moment — a beat of levity that lets you exhale. And then the BBQ scene, which starts casual and slowly, over six beers, opens up into something much deeper. The author controls the tempo like a musician. Each scene gets exactly as long as it needs to be and no longer. The transition from the hospital question to "let's go to your place" feels natural, not forced. Even the ending lands perfectly — Ye Xing hesitant about going back after dark, Qi Guang essentially inviting him with zero pressure. The chapter doesn't end on a cliffhanger; it ends on a note that makes you want to immediately open the next one. That's pacing mastery.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or