The Sun is but a Morning Star - Reviews

The Sun is but a Morning Star
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let's be real — this passage has FIGHTS everywhere. Not just physical ones, but the quiet ones that hurt more. Qi Guang vs. the world basically. Let me break it down. On the surface: five thug-girls versus Shuai Xiaoyun, then three hoodlums versus Qi Guang and Ye Xing. Standard high school brawl energy. But the real stakes? Qi Guang is fighting a war on every front. There's the external stuff — he gets followed after school, has to dodge because he knows what happens if it's more than three people. He literally calculates risk like a combat veteran. Which, okay, we now know why. But the INTERNAL stakes are what got me. Old Lin calling him hopeless. The fact that Qi Guang's entrance exam was the highest score in the entire school and now he's skipping class and smoking and nobody — NOT EVEN his grandfather, who's gone — is fighting for him. The text says: "Now, he was all alone." That's it. That's the whole book right there. And then Ye Xing shows up. Why? Does he know about the depression? The meds? The abandoned apartment? Nobody asks. They just fight back-to-back by a riverbank while mud-soaked and bruised. "Hurry up, I need to go eat after the fight" — bro is handling trauma with humor and that's somehow more heartbreaking. The stakes keep rising and I'm here for it.
... Read More
Ye Xing's phone call with his mom. I read it three times. Each time it got worse. The way Fang Rong keeps saying 'no' — not no to his questions, but no to letting him in. 'Your task right now is to study hard. No matter what happens to us, we can bear it.' Those words. She's literally telling him something terrible is happening and she won't tell him what, and she's asking him to just... accept it? And Ye Xing, sweet desperate Ye Xing, he basically begs her: 'Please don't treat me like a child, okay?' And she doesn't answer. She just hangs up. I was genuinely upset. The worst part is that she loves him — you can hear it in the way she's sobbing, the way she covers her mouth trying not to let him hear. She's a cornered animal. But that doesn't make it hurt any less. Meanwhile Qi Guang is out there working at a KTV carrying the weight of his own family's destroyed reputation, and these two boys are both drowning in secrets they weren't ready for. My heart.
... Read More
I keep coming back to two images from this text: the Doraemon band-aid on Ye Xing's ankle, and the broken peephole in his door. The band-aid is small but it carries so much weight. It's from a child, it's cartoonish, Ye Xing internally calls it sissy but then puts it on himself anyway. It's a symbol of accepting help when you'd rather not—of letting someone see your vulnerability and choosing to wear it openly. And then Zhou Tian saying "It's kind of cute!" while Ye Xing forces a polite smile? That's the exact texture of new friendship: awkward, slightly humiliating, but undeniably warm. The broken peephole is darker. Ye Xing can't see who's at his door. He has to ask through the wood. It's a small detail but it speaks to his whole situation—he's isolated, he doesn't know who's coming and going, he's been dropped into a town where everyone seems to know everyone except him. Zhou Tian finds his apartment anyway: "Figuring out where you live is easier than solving an equation." The irony is that the one person who breaks through Ye Xing's isolation has no lock he can't pick. There's also the recurring image of falling. Ye Xing falls off a skateboard. He describes himself as "helpless in fighting." Qi Guang literally appeared out of nowhere last night—crashed into him, paid his fare, vanished. The town itself feels like it could swallow you whole. But then there's the morning light, the name Qi Guang (bright as sun and moon), the title of the story itself. The sun is but a morning star. Even in a run-down town with a broken peephole and a Doraemon band-aid on your ankle—there's something starting.
... Read More
The dialogue in this is genuinely good. Like, actually good—not just functional, but each character sounds like a different person. Try reading Zhou Tian's lines and Ye Xing's lines in your head and they don't overlap at all. Zhou Tian: "Classmate Ye Xing, where did you move from? Why are you living alone?" — enthusiastic, no filter, the kind of person who asks three questions in a row. Ye Xing: "From the next village over." — deflects, makes a joke, refuses to engage. Immediate pattern established. And then the moment where Zhou Tian says "Germaphobe!" and Ye Xing fires back "If I were a germaphobe, I wouldn't come here, understand hygiene?" — THAT is a real exchange. Real people talk like that. It's funny, it's sharp, and it reveals everything about their dynamic in two lines. The narrative voice is also doing heavy lifting. Ye Xing's internal monologue has this wonderful mix of self-deprecation and chuuni energy. Pushing his bangs back in the mirror and smirking? That's a character who knows he's attractive but also knows he's ridiculous. The line "Even if it's Transformation, he would be the center of attention!" is peak Ye Xing. Also: "Lazy in body, clueless in farming, illiterate in writing, helpless in fighting." Zhou Tian reading this from his WeChat and completely missing the reference to a song? Perfect comedic timing. The author didn't need to explain it—we get it.
... Read More
Let's be real — that knife scene had my heart in my throat. Three against one should be dangerous, and when the small hoodlum pulls out a blade, the stakes suddenly feel very concrete. Qi Guang takes a cut on his arm. Blood on the blade. Blood seeping through his sleeve. And then the shift — he turns the tables so fast, knife at the guy's chest, forcing a recorded apology. This isn't just about winning a fight anymore. It's about control. About making sure these people understand consequences. But the real conflict here isn't physical — it's emotional. Qi Guang is clearly someone who has learned to survive by being sharp, by being scary when necessary. But underneath all that competence, he's a guy who grew up mostly alone, who had an epiphany about school and suddenly became excellent at something. The stake isn't just whether he wins a fight — it's whether someone will actually STAY. And Ye Xing staying, helping with the wound, getting mud everywhere, failing at paying the bill, offering to wash the uniform — these are all tiny acts of someone choosing to be present. The tension between Qi Guang's hardened exterior and his quiet vulnerability drives every interaction in this chapter. Each one feels like a small victory.
... Read More
There's something really specific about how this author writes places. Not a lot of description, but what they give you sticks. The bar construction site — dust, noise, unfinished — sitting right in the commercial center of Chen Town where bars are basically novelties. You can feel the irony of it. Boys like going to remote bars, girls won't, so they stay empty. It's a metaphor for a bunch of things but it works on its own terms too. And then the KTV scene — 'the busiest time at the KTV,' Qi Guang dodging between rooms, Zhou Tian's voice cutting through the noise. The contrast between the dusty construction site and the neon-lit chaos of the KTV really captures this town's energy. Small place, big dreams, nobody quite knows how to carry them. That one detail about Shuai Xiaoyun's glasses and baggy school uniform making her almost unrecognizable in her work clothes — it's a small observation but it tells you everything about what kind of place Chen Town is.
... Read More
Chapter 9 is basically one long delicious warm bath. You've got Ye Xing waking up hungover, getting fed chicken soup by a literal whole family, texting his crush, bringing Zhou Tian breakfast every day, riding bikes home — the pacing is so lazy and comfortable, like the author is just sitting there sipping tea watching us enjoy ourselves. And then chapter 10. THE STRANGER. At the school gate. In the middle of a peaceful afternoon bike ride. I literally sat up. The transition is so smooth too — the stranger doesn't even look threatening at first. Short-sleeved shirt, casual pants, young. "Excuse me, do you know Qi Guang?" sounds almost polite. But the moment Ye Xing pivots the bike and tries to leave, the reader's pulse goes UP. The author doesn't need to do anything dramatic — the tension is entirely in what Ye Xing does. He steps in front. He blocks. He acts. Then the scene shifts to the bar under renovation and suddenly we're in completely different territory. The pacing here slows down intentionally — long dialogue, cigarette smoke, silence. It's a contrast movement. After the chaos of Chapter 9's morning routine, this is quiet and heavy. The exposition about Brother Xu is woven so naturally into their banter. You learn about his unemployment, his KTV, his uncle's death, the rumors about Chen Town — all while they're verbally sparring like old friends. That's masterclass pacing. Eight years of separation compressed into a conversation that feels like five minutes. The chapter ends on a comedic note (Qi Guang's stomach rumbling during an emotional moment) which is such a smart structural choice. Keeps you from getting too heavy, but also — honestly — makes it more human. Even in serious moments, life goes on.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is absolutely perfect and I need everyone to understand how rare it is to find two characters whose banter feels this natural. Let me just quote this exchange because it's pure gold: "Your last name is Ye, but I don't see any green on you." That is such a Qi Guang line. So dry, so petty, so perfectly aimed at getting under Ye Xing's skin. And Ye Xing's response? He just rolls with it immediately. These two have a rhythm that's completely developed and it's beautiful to watch. Then there's the whole apology scene where Ye Xing goes into this elaborate self-critical speech and Qi Guang just absolutely loses it laughing. The narration says Qi Guang was "laughing so hard he couldn't stand up straight" and Ye Xing just... follows along. That's not just funny dialogue, that's two people who genuinely enjoy each other's company even when they're being idiots together. But what really makes this chapter sing is how the author uses dialogue to reveal power dynamics. Qi Guang is always the one throwing barbs—the "young master" jokes, the speed comments, teasing Ye Xing about the phonograph. But every time he provokes Ye Xing, Ye Xing just matches him or counters it. The frog comparison is my favorite moment: "Qi Guang looked at how Ye Xing would jump at the slightest provocation, like a frog." That's such a specific, visual metaphor that tells us everything about how Qi Guang sees Ye Xing now. And the humor keeps landing because neither character takes themselves seriously. Even when they're dealing with something as uncomfortable as the pervert incident, they pivot to gossip and sarcasm within seconds. That's real human behavior. That's how people actually cop.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is genuinely sharp. Qi Guang has this incredible ability to say something devastating and immediately undercut it with humor. After revealing he's alone in the world, the next beat is basically flirting with Ye Xing to come back to his place. The tonal whiplash is intentional and it WORKS. Then there's the bill scene — Ye Xing's internal monologue is pure comedy gold: "You don't have much money either, so I'll pay. Then he would have the lowest EQ compared to even Zhou Tian." This is such a specific, human thought pattern. And Qi Guang's lines? "Barbecue without cold beer has no soul!" followed by immediately drinking five more beers anyway. The guy lives in contradiction. The exchange about smoking is another highlight — Ye Xing's line "smoking affects kissing" delivered with such misplaced confidence, and Qi Guang's immediate response "looks like you've experienced quite a lot" makes me laugh every time I re-read it. Even the casual banter between them has weight. When Qi Guang says "Your brother can do many things" — is that teasing? Is it something more? The dialogue leaves just enough room for interpretation.
... Read More
Let's talk about the sun, because this book keeps coming back to it. Ye Xing's WeChat name changed from a star to the sun after his classmates made fun of him. He's never changed it back. A star — something distant, twinkling, maybe a little girly in his peers' eyes. The sun — something bigger, brighter, impossible to ignore but also impossible to look directly at. His name in the chapter title is "The Sun is but a Morning Star" — and this guy literally can't even keep his original star emoji without embarrassment. That's such a loaded detail for a character who's already shown us he doesn't belong where he is. Then there's the actual sun imagery in the text. Auntie Shen calling him her guest. The roadside meals. The chicken soup that makes him feel connected to something he's never had — home. In a city where he knows nobody, Zhou Tian's family becomes this accidental anchor. And Brother Xu. Oh god, Brother Xu. He grew up alone, inherited nothing, built something from nothing. He found Qi Guang — this kid who was "particularly pleasing to the eye" — and protected him from the worst of it. Didn't let him smoke or drink. Didn't corrupt him. And now eight years later, he tracks him down and says "tell me if you need money" without actually saying "I care about you." That's the whole novel in one sentence, isn't it? These guys who want to help but can't figure out how to say it without it sounding like charity or weakness. The bar being under renovation — that's Qi Guang's life right now. Half-built. Not ready to open. But Brother Xu sees potential in it and in him. Also: "what you heard is the truth" — Qi Guang says this about his father killing his mother with zero drama. Just... here it is. The unspoken things weigh more than the spoken ones.
... Read More
I need to talk about the barbecue scene because WOW. Six empty beer bottles and suddenly Qi Guang is pouring his entire life story into Ye Xing's lap. The way he talks about being raised by his grandparents, only meeting his parents once a year, not even remembering their faces — this is the kind of thing that should make you cry but instead makes you just sit there quietly processing. And Ye Xing? He just LISTENS. No performative sympathy, no interrupting with his own problems. Just silent attention while Qi Guang connects the dots between skipping school and having an epiphany and becoming top of his class. Then the pivot: "I'm the only one left in my family." Done. Next topic. But you can SEE Ye Xing unraveling internally. The alcohol-induced warmth evaporates instantly. And later when he's trying to pay the bill and fails spectacularly — the humor masks something real. He wants to help. He wants to DO something. But he doesn't know how, so he does the most Ye Xing thing possible: overthinks it until it becomes a disaster. Their dynamic is built on these tiny moments of genuine care disguised as annoyance. "You're so fussy," Qi Guang says while clearly enjoying having someone around.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or