I need to talk about Valentin because this chapter gave us one of the most unsettling yet fascinating portraits of him yet, and honestly the way his scenes contrast with Iela's is *everything*.
Valentin is up in the main castle, in his forbidden bedchamber, watching the chaos in the annex through the window. He's alone with his pipe, surrounded by thick curtains he drew himself, and the text makes it painfully clear how isolated he is. His ability to read minds isn't portrayed as a superpower—it's described as torture, a "resonant prison" where voices bombard him constantly. That detail changed how I see his entire character. He's not some cold, collected lord lurking in shadows because he's sinister. He's actually suffering from sensory overload and the only thing that brings him quiet is... well, Iela.
And that's where it gets complicated. The text says he "shamelessly wanted all of Iela's heart" and then immediately undercuts it with: "Without a moment's thought for what she might go through because of it, or how she might change, he simply demanded that she hand over his remedy." That is such a specific kind of selfishness. He loves her, but his love comes wrapped around his own needs like a vise.
Meanwhile, Iela and Valentin's relationship operates on this bizarre frequency where she actively enjoys his absence. The line "The mere absence of Valentin, who always wanted to be looking at her, was remarkably comfortable" is both hilarious and sad. She's found space to breathe, and part of her is savoring it while watching Carpenter's mercenaries run around in the distance.
Then there's Anton, who exists entirely to be the exasperated straight man to Iela's chaos. Their banter is genuinely sharp—he calls her plans worse, she calls him stubborn, but he follows her anyway. And Mayer, quietly being used as both enforcer and patsy, collecting those copper coins with a grin he'll regret later. The relationship dynamics here are so layered.