The Curse Was Not Broken - Reviews

The Curse Was Not Broken
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so Iela shows up at Valentin's castle and immediately I'm like—what are we doing here? This whole arrangement is so bizarre. They're married on paper but she's clearly trying to get out of it, and yet she's USING him as leverage against her own problems. Genius and absolutely deranged, honestly. The whole scene with the intruder was peak plot tension. She lied about killing three people who broke into the chapel, Valentin somehow believed her (or played along), and now she's casually referencing it while trying to negotiate terms. And Anton—poor Anton is just standing there witnessing this insane dance. The power dynamics are constantly shifting. Iela thinks she's in control because Valentin can't let go of her hand, but then Valentin drops 'Protect my wife' and suddenly the table flips. What got me was the Peter Carpenter reveal. So there's an outside threat coming, mercenaries specifically, and Anton is basically saying he can't handle it alone. Iela could potentially move to the annex for safety but Valentin literally won't let her go more than a few feet away. The plot is setting up this interesting contradiction—she needs protection that requires her to stay trapped with the very person she wants to divorce. And that ending?? 'If you will permit it, I will attend to you myself.' What does that even mean in context? Iela was complaining about her maids making mistakes because Valentin glares at them, and his response is to personally attend to her? Is this a threat or a offer? The narrative is deliberately leaving it ambiguous and I'm here for it.
... Read More
I need to talk about this ONE moment because it hit me like a truck. You know how Iela is - cold, calculating, never swayed by beauty even though she's used to it from growing up with Diana? Well, Valentin nearly breaks through her defenses with just a glance and a bitten lip. And then she remembers candy. Philip Lorid gave Diana a rare bright blue candy with some pretentious speech about how blue was difficult to achieve artificially and meant to be enjoyed with the eyes rather than the taste. Iela didn't get any candy. Diana shared hers. And Iela crunched through it without ceremony. That flashback wasn't random - it was the author slipping in this quiet, devastating detail about how Iela has ALWAYS been the one left out, the one who doesn't get the special treatment, the one who takes what's offered and destroys it quickly because waiting for affection hurts too much. But here's where it gets painful: Valentin sees her lick her lips and turns away because he thinks she's looking at him that way. Then he whispers 'Thank you for falling for me at first sight' and she genuinely asks if he's lost his mind. She's spent her whole life building walls, treating love as a trap that fools and careless people fall into - and here comes this man who's already fallen so hard he can't even form coherent sentences. She can't understand his delusion but she also can't deny the pull she feels. The most devastating line for me though? When Valentin says 'Even knowing that I will be all right as long as you are here, I am afraid that if I leave the chapel, I will wake from this dream.' He's terrified this is all temporary. She's planning her divorce exit strategy. He's terrified of waking up without her. Both of them protecting themselves in completely opposite ways and somehow that's more romantic than any sweet declaration ever could be.
... Read More
'The man's pale skin shimmered in the light. It was a sight captivating enough that Iela found herself staring without thinking.' I need to talk about how atmospherically rich this setting is. Valita is this remote, harsh territory at the very edge of the kingdom—conquered by the Bahar family when no one else could claim it, now essentially abandoned by the rest of the world. The castle is neglected, the knight order is made of former mercenaries who look nothing alike, and the locals treat Lord Bahar's name like a bad omen. This isn't some gleaming fantasy kingdom; it's a place that exists in the margins, and it perfectly mirrors Valentin himself. The visual of Valentin in that mahogany-lit office is so cinematic. Sunlight streaming through the window, his pale skin glowing, sprawled like a cat in Anton's armchair reaching at the air as if trying to catch light particles. There's something almost supernatural about him—like a beautiful creature that doesn't quite belong in this world. And Iela, sitting at HIS desk reading a letter from Diana, has completely reclaimed the space without even realizing it. The annex description is also fascinating. Former mercenaries turned knights, a order that values flexibility over uniformity, living quarters that are apparently louder than the main castle. It's a world where the traditional structures of knighthood and nobility have been completely subverted by circumstance. The geography itself tells a story—Valita conquered what others couldn't, now sits unused, and the people there survive through practicality rather than ceremony. Every setting detail reinforces the central theme: this is a world where appearances are stripped away and only raw necessity remains.
... Read More
I need to talk about Valentin and Iela because my brain is still recovering from Chapter 54 and I don't think I'll ever be the same. So Valentin does this incredible thing—he makes Anton kneel, destroys him verbally, reminds him that he is NOTHING without him, the castle would survive without Anton but the Mivela family would crumble, and then the SECOND Anton is fully broken, Valentin looks at Iela and his entire presence shifts. The ferocity vanishes. That cold smile softens into something expectant. He's waiting for praise. He literally just humiliated someone's husband in front of his wife and then looks at her like a dog who did a trick. And Iela's response? She trembled inwardly. She thought it was EXCITING. She covered her lips and thought 'this is exciting.' What is WRONG with me, I love this woman. But here's where it gets complicated because Iela is NOT having any of that romantic nonsense. She admits to herself that she was slightly disappointed that Valentin's obsession doesn't contain the same kind of affection Diana has. She wanted to feel wanted, not just desired. And yet here she is, captivated by a man who treats her like a prized possession and a curse-broken talisman all at once. The maids are out here literally crying for her welfare. Mary asks if she's truly all right. Anna says not every nobleman would want to listen to his wife bathing. These women are looking at her like she's walking into a fire and Iela just tips them more gold coins and sends them on errands like everything is fine. The loneliness in this is suffocating. And then she tears apart six pillows. Six. Because she realized Valentin placed her worth at exactly one blue rose. She couldn't even sit on that windowsill without plotting how to shatter the glass. That image of her violently dismantling pillows because she felt commodified—what a perfect expression of rage that can't be directed at anyone because the people who hurt her are all the people she needs.
... Read More
Iela's voice is absolutely phenomenal and I need to talk about it. The way she speaks is so distinctly hers—cool, observant, laced with this dark practicality that somehow never feels forced. When she tells the journalists "Starting today, a female ghost has come to live here too. She has a different agenda from the cursed man, so she has appeared like this to make an example of you"—this is her being theatrical and manipulative and absolutely loving every second of it. The lilting tone she uses while simultaneously committing what might be attempted murder? Iconic. Her internal narration is where the voice really shines though. "Success always comes with a little obstacle. A journalist with a broken arm who cannot write. An obstacle that would serve as the foundation for success." This is the kind of line that makes you laugh out loud because it's so ruthlessly pragmatic. She's not being cruel for cruelty's sake—she's running calculus in real-time about how taking out one intruder actually helps her divorce strategy. Valentin's dialogue is a masterpiece of restrained desperation. Watch how he speaks: fragmented, reactive, always reaching. "Are you two hundred years old?" — no, wait, that's Iela. But Valentin's lines like "I have no intention of…" trailing off mid-sentence, or "I imagined nothing" when he clearly imagined EVERYTHING—this is a man who has spent decades without speaking to anyone and now has someone in front of him and he doesn't know how to use his words. The narration itself has this razor-sharp quality. Lines like "He was exhausted and wanted to escape the deafening noise" and "the arrogance of believing that knowing you are falling in makes it all right" show an authorial voice that's both literary and deeply funny. Not pretentious—just observant in a way that makes you feel smart for catching every layer.
... Read More
The symbolism in this text is so rich I could write an essay. Let me just hit the main ones. The fairy tales. Iela finds children's books about witches being defeated by heroes scattered on the floor, and Valentin hides them ashamedly. These books represent the entire cultural framework that's been used to torment him his whole life—the witch hunts, the demon possession narrative, the desperate need to categorize the unknown as either sacred or evil. The third Mivela literally quotes from these same kinds of books: "Every legend, myth, and book of spells says the same thing. True love will be the answer." The stories that imprisoned Valentin are now being weaponized to try to free him. Ironic? Yes. Hopeful? Also yes. The castle itself is a massive symbol. It's in complete disrepair—cobwebs, spiders, furniture a hundred years out of date. This is a man who stopped living when he was locked away as a child, and everything around him reflects that. Iela commenting on the spiders and Valentin's embarrassment about it is such a small moment but it says everything about how he views himself: damaged, neglected, unworthy of proper care. The curse as fate. Valentin wasn't chosen—the Bahar family produces one heir per generation, and he's it. His entire existence is predetermined: born into isolation, destined to never age, surrounded by servants bound to him by some familial obligation stretching back generations. The Mivela family's son boasting that he's been preparing since before inheriting "the duty of caring for Valentin" shows how even the servants are trapped by this system. And then there's Iela herself—the woman who claims not to believe in curses at all, who calls them fairy tale nonsense, yet walks right into the cursed castle and voluntarily enters the cursed marriage. Is she defying fate or fulfilling it? The text leaves this beautifully ambiguous.
... Read More
Beneath the humor and the chase scenes, this chapter is quietly wrestling with some heavy questions about identity, freedom, and what it means to be truly seen by someone. The recurring symbol of dust keeps coming back. Iela tells the reluctant cross-dresser: "When you die, you all return to a handful of dust. So think of it as dressing up as a handful of dust and take it easy." This is framed as a joke, but it echoes something deeper about the novel's preoccupations. Valentin is literally haunted—by a curse, by the voices in his head, by the ghost of his ancestor whose face he wears. He's trapped in a body and a role that aren't fully his. The dust metaphor suggests that all identities, all names, all social positions eventually reduce to the same nothingness. Which is both liberating and terrifying. Then there's the curse itself as symbol. Anton argues that "true love resolves all problems," and the narrative seems to both support and complicate this. Yes, Iela is the only one immune to the curse—that's established. But Valentin's response to that knowledge isn't gratitude or gentleness. It's possession. He wants her heart completely, without regard for what that demand costs her. The curse becomes a metaphor for addiction—someone so dependent on another person's presence that they forget the other person has a life outside of soothing them. Iela's actions throughout the chapter are acts of reclaiming agency. She refuses to be bait without consent. She turns the plan into something entirely her own. She watches from a position of power rather than being watched. The final image of her walking out of the annex, coat swirling, followers trailing behind like a mafia don's entourage—that's not just funny. It's a woman claiming her space in a world that keeps trying to define her as something small.
... Read More
The stakes in these chapters operate on so many levels and the author never lets you forget any of them. On the surface: three journalists are trying to break into a supposedly cursed castle. Iela handles it by—well, by being absolutely ruthless. She assesses the height, calculates whether they'll survive, gives them a theatrical ghost performance, and pushes the ladder. The text deliberately leaves ambiguous whether the man actually dies or just gets caught on a tree branch. "By some stroke of luck"—Iela notes this, and it's fascinating because she doesn't seem to care either way. Either outcome serves her purpose. But the real stakes are personal. Iela's entire strategy depends on maintaining the appearance of a正常 marriage while quietly working toward a divorce. Bringing four maids from her family home was supposed to be deniable—"visiting a relative's house" is a socially acceptable excuse. But Valentin's sudden insistence on sending them away threatens to blow her cover. Every interaction with him is a tightrope walk. Valentin's stakes are even darker. He's been alone for over a century, imprisoned since infancy, surrounded by people who fear him or pities him but never truly sees him. When Iela appears—beautiful, sharp-tongued, unafraid—she represents the first real connection he's had since his father's suicide. The conflict here isn't just romantic tension; it's the tension between a man who has nothing to lose and a woman who's using him as a means to an end. The external pressure from the journalists ties into the larger supernatural stakes. The curse isn't just a backstory element—it's an active force. The third Mivela believes true love will break it. Iela suspects Valentin IS the witch. The journalists think there's a two-hundred-year curse. Everyone is projecting their own fears and desires onto this situation, and the actual truth seems to be something far more complicated than any of them realize.
... Read More
'But see, Lord Bahar will not let me go.' This line repeats like a mantra throughout the chapter and I think it operates on three completely different levels. On the surface, it's Iela's complaint about Valentin's physical grip on her wrist. But deeper, it's about how neither of them can release the other from whatever this twisted entanglement is. And then there's the thematic layer—Valentin won't let go because he's holding onto something neither of them fully understands yet. The pulse-taking motif is doing heavy symbolic work here. Iela counting his pulse like she's diagnosing him, and Valentin doing the same to her—it's intimate violence disguised as medical examination. Two people trying to prove they're alive, that they're real, that this thing between them has a measurable rhythm. But neither knows the 'normal' rate, which is the point. Their connection exists outside normal human parameters. Then there's the ghost imagery. The intruder called Valentin a ghost. Iela plays along with the ghost narrative. But who's actually haunting whom? Valentin haunts Iela's thoughts even when she's trying to escape him. She haunts his every movement—he follows her like a shadow precisely because he has no other anchor in this world. Diana's letter represents the old world, the normal sisterly love, the life Iela had before being bound to this cursed castle. Reading it at Anton's desk while Valentin watches sunlight instead of the letter—that's the perfect symbolic tableau: Iela reaching for normalcy while her reality refuses to let her look away from him. And the jewelry catalog that never materializes—Diana's offer of simple, uncomplicated desire versus Iela's current trapped existence. She wants to be spoiled but only by someone who won't actually let her go. The central irony of the entire chapter lives in that contradiction and I think the author knows exactly what they're doing.
... Read More
"I have just killed someone, Lord Bahar." "How many?" I am still processing this exchange. I literally cannot. This is the most unhinged romantic moment I have EVER read and I need to sit with it. Valentin doesn't recoil. He doesn't call the guards. He doesn't even flinch. He just—leans into her hand and asks how many people she's killed. Because apparently, watching Iela murder-scare some third-rate journalist is the most beautiful thing he's ever witnessed. This man has been alone in a decaying castle for a hundred and something years and the moment someone shows him even a glimpse of darkness that matches his own, he's emotionally compromised beyond repair. Iela notices this too. She thinks about how she came here to escape someone she couldn't reason with, but "thinking that married life with a mad witch might not be entirely unpleasant." That line hit me like a truck. She's not falling for him because he's charming or kind or any of that Disney nonsense. She's falling because he's BROKEN in a way that makes her feel safe enough to be her own broken self around. And then there's Valentin's POV chapter. Born screaming. Refused milk. Locked away. The clergyman telling his parents their child is possessed. His mother internally wishing he was dead but unable to kill her only heir. His father taking his own life. And Valentin just—endures it all until he's twenty-six and finally free and sets everything on fire. No wonder he's clingy. No wonder he can't let go. The guy has never had anyone choose to stay. The emotional chemistry between them isn't sweet. It's feral. And I am utterly consumed.
... Read More
Okay, let me just say this: the dynamic between Iela and Valentin is so goddamn good and I am not okay. Iela literally refers to Valentin as a witch who bewitches people with enchanting beauty and draws them into wickedness. And then she says she willingly steps into the trap. She KNOWS he's dangerous, she KNOWS this is a bad idea, and she steps in anyway with this arrogance of thinking that knowing you're falling makes it all right. I am HERE for it. But the real character work is Valentin. Read his history—locked in a stone chamber as a BABY because his parents thought he was demon-possessed. Twenty-six years of isolation. His mother couldn't handle carrying him and died. His father killed himself out of fear and grief. He burns down the castle when he finally gets free and the only person who shows up to serve him is this squire from the Mivela family who basically says 'I'm stuck with you forever.' And now over a hundred years later, Valentin hasn't aged a day while his servants grow old and die around him. The way he clings to Iela's hand—that desperate grip, the tears streaming down his face when he watches her push that man off the ladder—this isn't romantic, it's traumatized. He's so starved for human contact that ANY touch feels like salvation. And Iela, brilliant cold creature that she is, uses his desperation perfectly. She rubs his damp cheek like she's petting a wounded animal, which is both terrifying and kind of hot I guess??? Then the bedchamber scene—she casually mentions bringing four maids from her family home and his entire mood shifts. 'Send them away.' Like, sir, you just pulled me into YOUR bed and now you're upset about MAIDS? The contradictions are delicious.
... Read More
I need to talk about Valentin because this chapter gave us one of the most unsettling yet fascinating portraits of him yet, and honestly the way his scenes contrast with Iela's is *everything*. Valentin is up in the main castle, in his forbidden bedchamber, watching the chaos in the annex through the window. He's alone with his pipe, surrounded by thick curtains he drew himself, and the text makes it painfully clear how isolated he is. His ability to read minds isn't portrayed as a superpower—it's described as torture, a "resonant prison" where voices bombard him constantly. That detail changed how I see his entire character. He's not some cold, collected lord lurking in shadows because he's sinister. He's actually suffering from sensory overload and the only thing that brings him quiet is... well, Iela. And that's where it gets complicated. The text says he "shamelessly wanted all of Iela's heart" and then immediately undercuts it with: "Without a moment's thought for what she might go through because of it, or how she might change, he simply demanded that she hand over his remedy." That is such a specific kind of selfishness. He loves her, but his love comes wrapped around his own needs like a vise. Meanwhile, Iela and Valentin's relationship operates on this bizarre frequency where she actively enjoys his absence. The line "The mere absence of Valentin, who always wanted to be looking at her, was remarkably comfortable" is both hilarious and sad. She's found space to breathe, and part of her is savoring it while watching Carpenter's mercenaries run around in the distance. Then there's Anton, who exists entirely to be the exasperated straight man to Iela's chaos. Their banter is genuinely sharp—he calls her plans worse, she calls him stubborn, but he follows her anyway. And Mayer, quietly being used as both enforcer and patsy, collecting those copper coins with a grin he'll regret later. The relationship dynamics here are so layered.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or