The Curse Was Not Broken - Reviews

The Curse Was Not Broken
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let's talk about how Valentin speaks, because this man is a LANGUAGE. He barely says anything and every word hits like a hammer. "Your mind is truly contemptible." Just that. Said to Anton after breaking him. Not even shouting. Just stating a fact like the weather. "Every last Mivela is contemptible. And you, among them, are foolish on top of it." He doesn't just insult Anton, he INScribes him. Reduces an entire family line to a single adjective and then adds foolish as a complimentary detail. The efficiency of this dialogue is insane. "Do you truly believe that someone like you being careful could ever replace Iela?" This line does triple duty—it dismisses Anton, asserts ownership over Iela, and reminds everyone in the room exactly who holds the power. Three birds, one stone, zero wasted words. And then the switch. The moment Anton is on his knees and Valentin turns to Iela—his language changes entirely. He doesn't say anything nice. He just EXPECTS something. The narrative tells us he's hoping to be praised, and that's more powerful than any compliment he could have spoken. Iela's dialogue voice is equally distinct. She's sharp, dismissive, and economically violent with her words. "I hear the flower garden here is quite something." Mayer is trying SO HARD to be pleasant and she just cuts through it like a knife. "Would you like to see it?" she says about the blue roses and the man is flustered and she ignores his hand and just gestures with her chin. The way she speaks to Mayer—"For someone who had been a mercenary, he seemed to have picked up unnecessary formalities"—this is narration bleedi ng into her internal dialogue, and it's so distinctly HER. The maids' voices are underwritten but perfect. Mary's gentle concern, Anna's practical bluntness, the way they all unite behind Mary to ask if she's alright—it feels so real, like eavesdropping on actual people who care about each other but don't know how to express it without money changing hands first. And Iela's response to the maids? "Do you want to go home?" said like she's asking about the weather, followed by four GOLD coins that shut everyone up instantly. The dialogue between employer and employee here is SO honest about what it actually is.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Phillip Lorid because WOW. This man is a whole phenomenon. Let me just say this: I have never met a character so aggressively mediocre who is also so utterly convinced of his own grandeur. The scene where he twirls a mustache he "had no doubt convinced himself was quite distinguished" made me physically laugh out loud. Like, buddy. You're a merchant who got caught stealing from a nobleman's annex. You broke into a building and barely managed to pluck "a single rose." And you think the mustache is the problem? The problem is you just sold your daughter for a stolen flower and you're acting like it's a business acquisition. And that call bell! The text specifically mentions he had a custom-made one because "the cost of making it exceeded the wages he paid the maid." Iela literally pointed out: "Thanks to Iela getting ahead of him, he ended up ringing the bell on his daughter's behalf." That is such a perfect moment. He spent more on a brass button than on the person who serves him, but here he is, ringing it for HER. Iela's interaction with him is delicious. She doesn't fight him head-on—she just lets him hang himself every time he opens his mouth. The way she yawns, spills tea deliberately, and then tosses water back at him when he tries to threaten her? Chef's kiss. But honestly? Diana scares me a little. She's sick, bedridden, still trying to protect Iela even as her father dumps a bucket of water on both of them. When she says "Comfort, laced with apology" and wraps her arms around Iela—that's a whole lot of love from someone who can barely stay awake. The sister dynamic feels real. Not the perfect princess and the ugly duckling. More like the one who's surviving and the one who's bleeding quietly."
... Read More
I need to talk about Diana and Iela because this is the emotional core I wasn't expecting. On the surface, these two seem completely different. Diana is the beautiful, flawless eldest sister who got sick and is now bedridden. Iela is the sharp-tongued, untamable younger one who mocks her father to his face. But the text keeps showing us that Iela's sharpness is armor, and Diana's gentleness is a choice—not weakness. The scene where Diana, half-asleep from medicine, presses herself against the wall and pulls back the covers for Iela? "You've been walking around barefoot again. Come in here and warm up." Even sick, even drugged, she's still mothering her sister. And Iela's response—flat refusal, then later sitting at the vanity while Diana tries to gather strength to ask about the marriage—is so painfully real. These are sisters who love each other but don't know how to be soft. Then Diana wraps her arms around Iela's shoulders. "Comfort, laced with apology." And Iela twists free and says: "So it has nothing to do with you, Sister." But it DOES have everything to do with Diana. Because if Iela disappears into this marriage, Diana is the only family left, and she's trapped in this house with a madman of a father who just sold one daughter and is already circling the other. The ending hits hard: "Even if the young wife he acquired in his old age whispers requests that are not entirely proper, surely he would be inclined to grant them, wou—" The sentence cuts off mid-thought. Not because the author is lazy. Because Iela can't finish imagining what happens to her. And Diana hears it. We can tell she hears it. This story isn't just about survival. It's about two sisters trying not to destroy each other while the world tries to destroy them.
... Read More
Okay so I just finished these chapters and I'm sitting here like what actually happened? Iela demanded to move to the annex, Anton agreed to play along, Valentin completely dismantled Anton like it was nothing and then—here's the part that got me—turned that razor edge off the second he looked at Iela, like he was literally waiting for a reward. And she thought it was EXCITING. Like, what is wrong with us. But the real plot twist nobody's talking about is the blue roses. Iela walks into this godforsaken annex, sees these absurdly rare blue roses growing right there in the ground, and suddenly everything clicks into place. Philip Lorid wanted a cutting. Anton offered her as a substitute. One rose for one woman. The fact that she immediately realized her value had been calculated and negotiated like some commodity by three different men made me so angry I almost threw my phone. And then she immediately started thinking about how to drive the price up. Of course she did. The narrative arc here is doing something really clever—Iela insisted on leaving because she needed space to observe Valentin and test her theory about the curse. Send a knight back who never reaches the inner castle. See if he notices. That's such a brilliant investigative move, and I love that she doesn't trust anyone, not even herself. She keeps the master-servant both-mad-together possibility open in her head. She's not buying anything at face value. Also the journalist catching a ghost detail? Anton suggested it. Valentin used it. Iela is now living in what is essentially a haunted house set designed to lure in a supernatural reporter. The whole annex arrangement is a performance, and everyone knows it except maybe the maids, who are just over there trying to survive while dropping truth bombs about how their lord doesn't seem ordinary.
... Read More
Okay, so let me just say—this chapter is absolutely brilliant in how it takes what could have been a straightforward "catch the bad guy" scene and turns it into something genuinely hilarious while still moving the plot forward. The setup: Peter Carpenter has hired mercenaries to cause trouble at the castle, and instead of just letting the knights handle it normally, Iela completely hijacks Anton's plan. She takes her subordinate—a man who had the audacity to hit on her and was already being insufferable about her—and makes him dress in a woman's gown to act as bait. The image of this former mercenary-type fellow trudging out in a ghost costume is something I will never get over. What I love about the execution is that it's not just a funny set piece—it solves the actual problem. Carpenter was looking for something supernatural, and by making it look like a thief stole a dress AND the "ghost" turns out to be a man in a dress, she completely wrecks his investigation while simultaneously making the knight order look incompetent. The layers! She has Mayer bribed into silence (with copper coins, no less—genius), and the knights are running around chasing each other in circles while Iela sits in a plush chair sipping jasmine tea watching the whole thing unfold. And the ending—when she goes out to receive the kneeling, dress-torn man outside the annex, with Mayer trailing behind her like she's some kind of crime boss... Anton's observation that she looked "less like a lady and more like the head of a back-alley gang" is the perfect capstone. The plot here is tight, the cause-and-effect is clear, and every character is playing their part while Iela is three moves ahead of everyone. Also the line about Carpenter realizing he's been chasing a "cross-dressing pervert" instead of a ghost is just Chef's kiss.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in controlled escalation, and I want to break down why it works so well. It opens with what feels almost like a prelude—Iela dismantling Mayer's subordinate verbally with brutal efficiency. This establishes her dominance and sets the tone before we even get to the main plot. The transition into the actual scheme happens when Anton bursts in, and suddenly we're in motion. The pacing here is snappy, dialogue-driven, with each exchange escalating the absurdity slightly more than the last. Then the chapter does something clever—it cuts away to Valentin. This isn't filler; it's a pressure valve. After the high-energy scene in the annex, we drop into near-silence with Valentin, and the shift in tempo makes both sections feel more powerful. The quiet of his chamber makes the noise of the annex feel even louder by contrast. When we return to Iela, the chase is already underway, and the pacing accelerates again. She's no longer just planning—she's executing in real time, improvising the dress theft accusation, bribing Mayer on the spot, and directing the entire operation while sitting down drinking tea. The climax comes when the man is captured, dressed in tatters, and Iela emerges like a queen receiving tribute. The resolution is almost too quick—which is perfect, because the chapter ends on a visual punchline rather than dragging out the aftermath. If there's any critique, it's that the transition between Valentin's POV and Iela's felt slightly abrupt, but honestly, that jolt mirrors the tonal shift perfectly. The chapter moves like a well-choreographed farce—every beat lands, nothing lingers too long, and the final image of Iela walking out as the self-appointed head of something that absolutely is not a respectable lady's entourage is the perfect button.
... Read More
Let me just... process what happened here. Phillip Lorid, a merchant-class man, breaks into the lord's castle. Not the main castle—he's smart enough to know that would be worse. He goes to the ANNEX. Which turns out to be "no better than a rubbish heap." He gets caught. He steals almost nothing—a rose, apparently. And the lord's response is: give me your younger daughter, and I'll let you walk. This is either the most twisted marriage proposal in fictional history or the most pragmatic hostage situation ever disguised as romance. Iela puts it best: "The esteemed lord proposed an exchange, the rose for a woman." The plot has me hooked because Iela herself is completely unimpressed. She doesn't panic. She doesn't cry. She sits there and mentally calculates how to bruise her father's ego while simultaneously figuring out what kind of man would make this deal. Her internal monologue after the conversation with Phillip: "As he had said, marriage was something that would happen sooner or later. Whether it was to a man who had not shown his face in over a hundred years, or to some ordinary old man of around eighty, it made little difference to Iela." That line. That line is everything. She's already made peace with the worst-case scenario, which means she's already planning around it. And the fact that the lord has "never shown his face" for over a hundred years? That's not a detail the author dropped by accident. Something is going on there. Is he old? Is he a ghost? Is he literally just hidden away? I need to know.
... Read More
The atmosphere in these first seven chapters is genuinely chilling—in more ways than one. "Valita was a region known for its brutal weather, with snow falling throughout the year. It was not uncommon for outsiders who came to challenge the cold to end up returning as frozen corpses." That's not worldbuilding with a whisper. That's the author grabbing you by the collar and saying: this place will kill you, and also your father might sell you to a recluse who hasn't left his castle in a century. The study scene is so vivid I could feel the temperature drop when Phillip opened the window. "A biting wind rushed in and sent a neatly stacked pile of documents flying to the floor." The tea that "had barely enough left to wet his lips." The pale, watery tea trickling across the table. Every sensory detail works. It's cold, cramped, miserly—and Phillip Lorid is the human equivalent of that barely-steeped tea. I also love how the world keeps intruding. The weather outside mirrors the emotional temperature inside. When Iela leaves, "The gradually brightening sky was suddenly swallowed by clouds that appeared from nowhere. It was not a good omen." Diana's room—water pouch on her forehead, the heavy medicine haze, the unmade bed where Iela sits at the vanity. These aren't decorative descriptions. They're setting the mood for a story where warmth is scarce and people are transactional. And that last line about the lord's deputy coming personally? "Even if you're not feeling well, you ought to show your face as a matter of courtesy." The fact that the AUTHORITY figure in this household is sending a DEPUTY to escort a kidnapped bride says everything about Valita's power structure.
... Read More
Okay so Iela has officially married the most confusing man alive and I am HERE for it. Let's talk about Valentin because this guy is a masterpiece of contradictions. On the surface, he's acting completely out of his mind - blushing at being touched, saying things like 'thank you for falling for me at first sight,' calling her his wife like it's the most precious thing in the world. But here's the thing that got me: Iela keeps convincing herself he's dim-witted, then realizes he's actually mad, and BOTH options are equally hopeless. The man has layers. Like actual onion layers of unhinged energy. And Iela? She's not one to back down. She's a predator by nature - she's the one who usually treats people as prey. But Valentin flips the script entirely. He gives her this look described as 'the rapture of admiring a breathtaking work of art, the emotion of someone who had witnessed a miracle they had longed for all their life, and at the same time the proud exhaustion of looking upon prey captured at the end of a life-or-death struggle.' THAT'S the moment I knew something was different about this dynamic. She's never been looked at like that before. Never been the prey. Never had someone fight this hard to capture her. Their banter is everything though. The back-and-forth about who's the loser in love, the argument about whether she called him charming or stated a fact - these two are locked in a battle of wits and neither will yield. Iela even internally admits she's never found herself on the defensive like this. Twenty-three years of living by her principles and Valentin just walks in and unravels her composure. The fact that she withdraws first from the argument only irritates her more - she HATES losing, even when she technically 'won.' This marriage is going to be so much trouble in the best way possible.
... Read More
"Iela, reverence! Don't forget. Not aggression, reverence!" This is the single most important line in the entire chapter and I'm still thinking about it three times through. Iela is a force of nature, sure. She threatens her own father into collapsing, she flips off a contract like it personally offended her, she insults a painting and walks away from it. But Diana — sweet exhausted Diana — sees the trap her sister is walking into and she needs her to understand the difference between aggression and reverence before it's too late. Because Iela doesn't know how to navigate a world that expects her to be something she's not. She's a "common woman of no standing" being thrust into a noble marriage, surrounded by people who see her as prey or a threat. The way the maid watches Iela before answering Diana is chef's kiss — one-sided loyalty, but also survival instinct. And Philip Lorid himself? He sends his daughter away like cargo while gasping about his health, and Iela's first thought is literally "What a pity he hadn't split his skull." That's not a daughter. That's a survivor who's been cursed at her whole life and learned to weaponize her silence. I'm also obsessed with how little we know about Valentin. A portrait of a beautiful man with blue hair, a name that rolls off the tongue, and Anton can't even answer whether the man can walk. What kind of creature is waiting for her in that castle?
... Read More
The pacing in this section is absolutely masterful. Let me walk through why this works so well. It starts intimate - chapel, just the two of them, wedding vows fresh. The conversation flows naturally from awkward silence to banter to deeper revelations about their natures. You get this beautiful rhythm where Valentin says something seemingly unhinged, Iela responds with sharp logic, and then the dynamic shifts again. The author doesn't rush any of these moments. Each exchange builds on the last, revealing character through dialogue rather than exposition. Then - BAM - intruders appear. The shift is seamless. One moment they're discussing whether to call each other by name, the next there's labored breathing and rattling door handles. The tension doesn't drop; it multiplies. You've got the romantic tension between the leads AND the physical danger outside. It's like the story is saying 'you thought THIS was the most intense part?' What really sold me was how the author uses the intruders' scene to deepen the main relationship rather than distract from it. Valentin takes her hand. He asks her to stay. He says he'll wake from this dream if he leaves. The external threat becomes a mirror for their internal emotional stakes. And then it ends on that perfect note - 'It is only natural for a husband and wife to share a bedchamber' - leaving you desperate to turn the page. The chapter structure here moves from quiet intimacy to chaotic external threat back to intimate confrontation, and it never feels rushed or dragged. Every beat lands.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are layered like an onion and I'm already crying. On the surface, Iela's marrying into a dangerous situation — a possibly immortal, possibly cursed lord in a crumbling castle, surrounded by people who think she's either a victim or a threat. But the real stakes are underneath. She's being sent away because her father needs to get rid of her, and the prenup makes it clear: she gets nothing unless he dies, which means everyone expects her to either submit or perish. "Not merely in the sense of a fierce predator. Is it not said that humans are social animals? If so, could a human who has cast aside all notion of sociality simply be called an animal outright?" Anton thinks this about her. And he's not wrong — Iela has literally stripped herself of every social convention and she's walking into that castle like a wolf entering a den of sheep. But here's what keeps me up at night: the castle itself is a character in this conflict. Felled trees because of "intruders." Journalists coming for occult stories. An elderly man named Grandfather George who won't shut up about curses and immortality. Someone — or something — lives in there, and the whole world is waiting for a spectacle. The stakes aren't just whether Iela survives the marriage. They're whether she can survive becoming part of a story she never asked to be in.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or