Simulated Crime, This Criminal Doesn’t Seem to Be Acting - Reviews

Simulated Crime, This Criminal Doesn’t Seem to Be Acting
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
'Yeah, it's not a bad thing.' He paused, then added, 'But what if the killer is someone just as bad as Wang Shun?' This exchange between Ye Sangsang and Wei Qingzheng is a masterclass in conversational misdirection. On paper, it reads like two people making small talk about a dead criminal. In practice, it's a tactical spar where every sentence is a feint. Wei Qingzheng sounds casual, almost chatty—the live stream comments even joke that he's 'too talkative'—but each question is carefully designed to probe her moral alignment. And Ye Sangsang? She sees right through it. 'She thought this officer was talking way too much.' That internal sigh is so human, so relatable, that I almost laughed out loud. Ye Sangsang's dialogue is deliberately plain, almost bland. 'This isn't something for us ordinary folks to worry about. I trust you all will catch the culprit soon.' It's the verbal equivalent of wearing neutral colors—designed to blend in, to disappear. But the voice underneath is sharp and calculating. The gap between her spoken words and her inner monologue creates a rich double-voice that's incredibly satisfying to read. The live stream commentary interspersed throughout is another brilliant dialogue layer. Lines like '[I think even Ye Sangsang is getting annoyed with him]' and '[Is this probing even effective? Or am I missing something?]' provide comedic relief while also functioning as Greek chorus—commenting on the action, revealing what casual viewers can see but the characters cannot. The author's narrative voice itself is remarkably controlled. It doesn't oversell emotions or telegraph themes. It observes, describes, and lets the reader connect the dots. There's a particular restraint in passages like 'Hesitation? That didn't exist in her mind'—three words that say everything about a character who may be fundamentally broken in ways she doesn't even recognize as broken.
... Read More
'From the map, Ye Sangsang could clearly see that the small courtyard Sun Bin rented was very close to Zhou Qiang's location. Only five kilometers away, a taxi ride would take about ten minutes.' That line hit me like a cold splash of water. Five kilometers. In real detective terms, that's nothing—practically next door. The author uses this geographic proximity as an invisible noose, tightening around the reader without anyone in the story quite noticing yet. The description of Zhou Qiang's neighborhood is one of those passages that feels almost documentary in its specificity: 'The gray exterior walls were crisscrossed with wires, and all the buildings were seven stories high. Outside the neighborhood was a lively commercial street.' It's unglamorous, mundane, deeply Chinese suburban realism—and that's precisely what makes it unsettling. Evil doesn't live in gothic mansions here; it lives in seven-story walk-ups with tangled electrical wires. But the scene that truly lodged in my brain is the cigarette moment. Ye Sangsang buying 'a pack of Hongtashan cigarettes' and leaning against her car door, 'her peripheral gaze fixed on the neighborhood's entrance.' She's been waiting three hours. Three hours of patience from a woman who doesn't feel hesitation. The banality of her posture—the ordinary act of smoking outside a mediocre apartment complex—contrasts violently with what she's preparing to do. It's Hitchcockian tension built from stillness rather than action. The virtual mission screen described as 'glowing faintly blue' adds a subtle sci-fi texture to an otherwise grounded urban setting. It's a nice touch—a thin layer of unreality sitting on top of concrete reality, like a ghost overlaid on a photograph. The world feels lived-in, specific, and deeply ominous.
... Read More
Let me just say upfront: the fumbling with the padlock is the single best pacing device in these chapters and I will die on this hill. You think the tension comes from the hammer or the knife, right? No. The tension comes from Wang Shun trying three times to find the keyhole in the dark while she stands there, close enough to touch, holding a flashlight she will 'just' produce when he reaches for his blade. The author stretches that moment across the page with 'He tried three times but still couldn't find the keyhole. He shifted his body and bent down' and you are stuck in his POV, slightly claustrophobic, while the reader (and the live chat, god bless those commenters) knows full well what's in her pockets. The live chat lines are doing actual structural work here too - they function as beat markers. After the coat throw: '【Ahhhh, she really did it!】【So sneaky!!!】' BAM, new phase. After the hammer strike: '【This is so terrifying! I'm holding myself tight, crying!】' And the chat FREEZES for a moment before exploding, which is the author saying 'hold your breath here, the next thing is the real payoff.' So the pacing isn't just prose rhythm, it's literally using the stream's audience as a metronome that speeds up and slows down the diegetic time. The cliffhanger structure is clean: we get the setup (she's preparing in the car, slipping the hammer in, soaking the coat), we get the midpoint reversal (he notices her hand, pulls the knife, she 'is discovered' per the chat), and then the final beat where she chooses the knife-in-stomach trade. The problem - and this is minor - is that the explanation paragraph after the action ('Her strength had been described as barely enough to lift a chicken...') slightly undercuts the rush. You're mid-adrenaline and suddenly you're in a strategy memo. I get WHY it's there, I NEED to understand why she could pull it off, but it lands a beat too late. If that math had been whispered during the approach, while she was closing the distance, instead of after the body hit the ground, the action would have hit harder. Still, I was reading at 1am and kept thinking 'okay one more paragraph' and then it was 1:40am and I hadn't slept because of this goddamn padlock fumble. The author knows exactly how to make me feel like I'm the one bent over in the rain trying to find the keyhole.
... Read More
The red-brick house barely visible through the rain. That's how we find Wang Shun's place and honestly it's such a perfect detail because it tells you everything about this area - it's not a mansion, it's not hidden in a forest, it's just a red-brick house that you'd miss if you weren't looking for it, on a road so empty in the rain that a single car pulling over feels like a cinematic wide shot. The author keeps the world narrow and wet and dim. Car headlights as the only practical light source. The padlock so rusty you can't find the keyhole in the dark. Three failed attempts to open it. And that's not just set dressing, that's the entire tension engine running. Because while Wang Shun is bent over fumbling with the lock, Ye Sangsang is closing the distance. Half a meter. And the whole scene breathes with that rain, this early-spring rain that soaks the fleece lining of the coat so it clings to his body and she can tie the sleeves and trap him. The environment IS the weapon system. The cold makes the soaked cloth adhere. The darkness makes him rely on his eyes instead of spatial awareness. The desolation means no witnesses, no cars passing, just the sound of water on asphalt and the metallic click of a padlock. And then the physical space collapses further - he's on the ground, his back in the rain, 'the fall left his entire body aching,' and she's standing over him with the flashlight clamped in her teeth. I kept seeing this as one unbroken camera angle, the kind where the director doesn't cut, just lets the rain keep falling while everything changes. The visual of the wet coat thrown over his head, sleeves yanked tight, is almost Rube Goldberg in its mechanical precision but also deeply unsettling because it looks like someone suffocating a dog. Cinematic. Genuinely. The whole chapter is basically one shot in the rain with two people and a hammer and a knife and the reader's job is to just watch the geometry of it. No montage. No time skip. Just the slow, wet, terrible choreography.
... Read More
Okay so this whole arc is just *chef's kiss* tense. You've got Ye Sangsang meticulously cleaning her car like some kind of serial crime scene procedural, right? And then—bam—the body is found, police show up, and within THREE DAYS she's sitting across from an interrogating officer. The speed at which the plot moves from cover-up to almost-getting-caught is insane. What really got me was how the author sets up this weird duality: on one hand, Ye Sangsang is methodically wiping every trace, thinking she's brilliant. On the other hand, the police are already circling because Wang Shun was a known criminal with multiple cases. That's the kind of plot irony that makes you want to scream at the book. And the live stream detail?! I lost it. While she's literally destroying evidence, there are COMMENTERS watching and saying things like 'so soothing to watch' and 'blessing for my OCD.' The author is basically trolling us, making us complicit in this whole situation. That moment where the body is described as 'almost alive' with driftwood anchoring his head—that's the kind of image that sticks with you. The plot isn't just about 'did she get away with it,' it's about the audience *watching* her do it. The ending of this section with the interrogation room... the officer lighting up a cigarette and threatening her? That's not even the climax yet, is it? I have so many questions and I need to know what happens next.
... Read More
What a deliciously layered plotting here. On the surface, it's a police procedural—Wei Qingzheng interrogating a taxi driver—but the entire scene is actually a reverse cat-and-mouse game where the hunter doesn't realize he's being hunted. The author plays with dramatic irony so smoothly that you can't help but be hooked. The most impressive structural choice is how the POV switches between Ye Sangsang's calculated exterior and her private internal calculations. When she tells Wei Qingzheng 'I trust you all will catch the culprit soon,' she's performing sincerity while her heart races. Meanwhile, Wei Qingzheng's parting line—'Contact Lin City and dig up information on Sun Bin and his wife'—lands like a hammer. The audience thinks the coast is clear; only Ye Sangsang knows the net is closing. Then comes the masterstroke: Ye Sangsang's decision to trigger a second mission by deliberately approaching Zhou Qiang. This isn't just reckless—it's tactical experimentation. She's testing whether proximity activates the game system, whether Wei Qingzheng can trace her. 'Racing against someone like him made her blood boil with excitement.' This single line transforms the entire narrative from survival thriller into something far more interesting: a predator who genuinely loves the chase. The plot also raises an intriguing mystery thread—why did Sun Bin, described as 'refined' and 'mild-mannered,' commit such brutally disproportionate revenge? The gap between his domestic gentleness and his murderous methods is a plot hole the story seems consciously building toward. It's the kind of question that makes you want to keep reading just to understand the psychological mechanism. My only minor complaint is that some transitions feel slightly rushed—the jump from the taxi confrontation to Zhou Qiang's neighborhood happens in a few paragraphs. But honestly, the momentum carries you through so I barely noticed.
... Read More
'No, something feels off. He doesn't carry himself like a taxi driver.' Wei Qingzheng's line is the single most important sentence in this entire passage. Everything after it rides on that instinct—that unquantifiable police intuition that has solved more cases than any forensic technology ever could. The stakes just went from 'she might get caught' to 'a sharp detective is already circling her.' What makes the conflict so gripping is the asymmetry. Ye Sangsang believes she's the hunter, but the narrative keeps revealing that she's simultaneously the hunted. Wei Qingzheng's colleague suggests they 'head back and wrap things up,' treating the interview as routine. But Wei Qingzheng lingers, watching the car disappear, already formulating the order to contact another city. The reader holds both perspectives at once—the false security of the protagonist and the real danger she's in—and that dramatic irony is pure tension fuel. On a deeper level, the internal conflict is what haunts me. For the first time, 'Ye Sangsang hesitated.' Not about whether to kill Zhou Qiang, but about the psychological puzzle: what event could transform a refined, mild-mannered person into someone who flays victims alive? Her professional curiosity—her need to understand the mechanism of the revenge—conflicts with her role as participant-observer in the murder game. She's both student and potential next killer, and that duality is psychologically rich. The stakes also escalate through the mission description itself. Slitting wrists and flaying alive—'his body looked like a fish, with arc-shaped wounds resembling scales covering his skin.' This isn't just gore for shock value; it's evidence that the emotional temperature of this world has been building toward something monstrous, and we're only seeing the tip of the iceberg.
... Read More
There's something deeply symbolic about this entire sequence, and I've been sitting with it for a while trying to figure out what it is. The rain first. It's not just weather. It's cleansing and destruction at once—washing away evidence while also creating danger, making roads treacherous, obscuring vision. The harder it rains, the more the boundary between the civilized world and this dark act blurs. Tianjia Dam itself sounds like a place of danger and water, and I can't help but think that's intentional. Water as metaphor for death, for washing clean, for the subconscious rising up. Then there's the mirror. She's looking through the rearview mirror, literally seeing him reflected, seeing the criminal in his true form while pretending to be someone else. The taxi interior becomes this liminal space where identities are fluid—she's not herself, she's the driver, and she's becoming the killer. The mirror shows us the duality, the two versions of reality coexisting in the same moment. The cigarette exchange is symbolism too. He offers it as a gesture of friendship, of trust, and she accepts it while reaching for the hammer. The very act of acceptance is deception. She takes his gift while already holding his death. That's such a clean metaphor for the entire situation—what looks like connection is actually preparation for violence. And her voice, that "nostalgic tone" with "twisted longing"—she's channeling the memory of the original killer, Sun Bin. She's not just playing a role; she's channeling his essence, his technique, his willingness to destroy. The theme here is about transformation, about how far you're willing to go to become what you need to be. Is she becoming a monster to defeat a monster? Or is that distinction even meaningful anymore? The livestream comments represent society watching violence as entertainment. These people are treating this life-and-death situation as content, analyzing her every move, placing bets on her survival. There's something deeply uncomfortable about that, and I think the author wants us to feel uncomfortable. We're complicit too—we're reading this, watching her danger unfold, benefiting from the entertainment while she risks everything. And that ending transformation, where she becomes something scary—"that twisted smile on her face that sent shivers down anyone's spine." What does that mean? Is she finally accepting her role? Has she crossed a line that can't be uncrossed? The theme of violence corrupting the viewer, of the hunter becoming the hunted becoming the monster—that's classical stuff, but the author makes it feel fresh by grounding it in this specific, immediate moment. The whole novel seems to be asking: what does it take to kill a killer? And more importantly, what happens to YOU when you do it? That's the deeper current running through every scene, every raindrop, every whispered conversation in that taxi.
... Read More
I wasn't looking for an emotional gut-punch in a crime-deduction chapter. I genuinely was not. I was busy tracking the clue logic and the audience's reaction, totally in my head-nodding 'yep the hammer angle checks out' mode, and then the last two lines just... hit me in the soft spot I didn't realize was still open. 'Miss Ye, were you just asleep?' 'What time is it?' 'Seven oh three in the evening.' And then she stares at the caregiver and says 'This treatment is very effective for my condition. I hope you won't interfere.' I'm reading that and I feel this cold, hard, performative politeness and I'm not even sure if it's directed at the caregiver or at the version of herself that's still in the game. The way she sits up. The way she 'frowned at her, her expression impatient.' She's not scared. She's not vulnerable. She's already back in the armor, already the one who's three moves ahead, already the player, not the patient. And the caregiver just stands there with her hand frozen mid-air, doing this flat administrative check-in, and the gap between those two women is so huge it's almost funny in a sad way. What gets me is that we don't know the caregiver's name. We don't get her face. She's 'the caregiver.' A function. A door that opens and closes on Ye Sangsang's world. And Ye Sangsang treats her the same way. Transactional. You verify I'm awake, I verify I'm fine, we go back to our separate orbits. There's no warmth in that exchange and I think that's the point. The whole holographic game is this spectacular, noisy, five-continental event with thousands of viewers screaming in the chat, and the actual human moment is a woman in a beige room being asked 'were you just asleep?' by someone who will walk out and probably type a note into a file. The emotional thread here isn't romance. It's isolation. It's the loneliness of being the smartest person in the room and also the most locked-up. In the game, the audience is her mirror, her cheer section, her echo chamber. Out of the game, she's alone with a timer on the wall and a stranger who monitors her breathing. The contrast between the chaos of the live stream and the silence of that room is doing more emotional work than I expected from this section. I keep thinking about whether the game is the escape or the cage. Because in the game she's Ye Sangsang-the-detective, solving, theorizing, holding the bloodstained gloves up like a trophy. Out of it she's the girl who gets beeped at and told it's seven-oh-three. And she chooses the cage. 'I hope you won't interfere.' As if interference would drag her back into the beige. As if the game, for all its traps and smokescreens, is the only place where she gets to be a person instead of a patient.
... Read More
Okay so. 'I think this is how he did it.' Four words. Delivered after the entire killing and disposal sequence where she hadn't spoken once. And I need to talk about why that specific moment undid me. It's not the violence. I'm desensitized to the hammer stuff at this point, it's processed, it's over, it's a checkbox. What got me was the quietness of that line. She's standing in a ditch in the rain, flashlight in one hand, looking at the bag sinking beneath the water, and she says it like she's confirming a hypothesis. Like she's a scientist verifying a result. 'I think this is how he did it.' Not 'I killed him.' Not 'it's done.' She's thinking about HIM. About Wang Shun. About what he would have done if he were the one in her position. And that's when the live chat went silent. Because for one second, she wasn't the player, wasn't Sun Bin, wasn't the streamer. She was just a person standing over a body, trying to understand the logic of what happened to her. And then she wiped the knife, threw it in the ditch, watched it sink with a 'plop,' and felt 'a strange sense of satisfaction.' That word is doing so much work. Satisfaction, not relief, not triumph, not guilt. Just satisfaction. Like she finished a task she was good at. And I kept thinking about the emotional whiplash of the whole arc: from her being the most vulnerable person in the game to the most terrifyingly competent, and the one soft moment is her looking at water and remembering a dead man's routine. Is she grieving? Probably not yet. Grief comes later. Right now she's just... processing. And that 'plop' of the knife hitting the water is the sound of the section closing. Clean. Final. A little sad. I re-read that paragraph four times. Don't ask me why.
... Read More
Let me tell you about pacing, because this author clearly understands it on an instinctive level. The opening of this chapter is deceptively calm. We're getting case files, background info, system instructions. It feels like setup, right? But then you realize that's the ENTIRE POINT. The reader is being fed information the same way Ye Sangsang is—processing case details, understanding the mission parameters, and we're all quietly bracing for impact. Here's what I love about the structure: the author uses conversation as a countdown timer. Every time Wang Shun offers her a cigarette, every small talk exchange about the rain, every moment of false rapport—it's all building toward something inevitable. The reader knows what's coming, which makes those mundane details TENSE. She's reaching for the lighter, tilting her head, taking a drag—all normal actions, but we're sweating because we KNOW what's in her hand. The rain is doing double duty here, you know? It's not just atmosphere. The increasing storm mirrors the escalating danger. When the author writes "the rain grew heavier, as if a hole had been torn open in the sky," that's pacing through imagery. The world itself is speeding up, pressing in, and there's no escape. And the chapter break! I love how the author leaves us right at that moment—"I've killed people"—and then cuts to Chapter 3 where suddenly they're thirty minutes away, still talking, still building toward the same explosive endpoint. It's like the author keeps extending the rope before finally letting it snap. The live stream comments are used brilliantly for pacing too. They function as a Greek chorus, but one that's completely wrong about what's happening. Their panic and impatience create dramatic irony—we know she's planning something they can't comprehend. Their commentary actually ACCELERATES our reading because we want to prove them wrong. The transition from casual chat to the confession scene is MASTERFUL. One moment they're talking about cigarettes and familiar faces, the next the atmosphere has shifted so violently you can feel it. The author doesn't explain the shift; they just show us through body language—his hand moving toward his jacket, his gaze going cold—and that's so much more effective than any internal monologue could be. I also appreciate how the author paces the information reveal. We don't get all of Sun Bin's backstory at once. First it's the case overview, then details about the driver's appearance, then the murder method, then the coroner photos. Each piece of information lands at the right moment to raise the stakes just enough. The chapter ends on this note about Ye Sangsang transforming, becoming something scary, and it's the perfect structural beat. After all that tension-building, the author finally lets us see what she's becoming. Not a victim, not a hero, but something complicated and dangerous. And honestly? That's the most satisfying kind of ending to a chapter.
... Read More
Okay. Okay. Let me process what I just read. The brother. THE BROTHER. He used her identity to try and get a beta slot. When she declines it, he threatens to tell their father that her condition has worsened and she's trying to escape the hospital to kill him. This man is not just selfish — he's calculating, cruel, and has complete access to her medical records and family dynamics. He knows exactly which buttons to press. But here's what genuinely made my blood boil: Ye Sangsang's response. She doesn't scream. She doesn't cry. She says "I declined" and then follows up with the most devastating line in these chapters: "I didn't know. If you had told me earlier, I might have saved it for you." That's not a reconciliation. That's a scalpel. The stakes are already insane. She's confined to a hospital. Her brother is actively working against her. And now she's entering a game where 500 million people wanted in and only 8,000 got selected. Whatever happens in that game, it's clear it's going to matter deeply to her real life too. I'm worried about her. Not because she seems weak — she seems sharper than everyone around her — but because the world outside the hospital walls is clearly stacked against her. The brother has power. The hospital has power. The game probably has power too. What does she have? Everything makes sense now. She declined the slot on purpose. She let him think he'd won. And now he's going to find out the equipment never came to him.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or