Simulated Crime, This Criminal Doesn’t Seem to Be Acting - Reviews

Simulated Crime, This Criminal Doesn’t Seem to Be Acting
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so I just finished reading this section and my mind is racing. This isn't your typical self-defense case, is it? The whole setup with Ye Sangsang getting thrown into this holographic game where she has to RELIVE the crime is genuinely brilliant plotting. You've got this habitual criminal Wang Shun sitting behind her, knowing exactly what he is, and she has to play along while secretly planning to replicate his murder with perfect precision. What really gets me is how the author sets up this twisted mirror situation. In the original case, the taxi driver Sun Bin killed Wang Shun in self-defense. But now Ye Sangsang has to become that driver and figure out HOW to kill him without getting caught. The case details she's reviewing—coroner photos, the hammer, the cleaning of the scene—it's all information she needs to succeed. That's dark. The plot twist when Wang Shun actually confesses to killing someone is gold. He thinks he's gained an accomplice, but really he's walking right into the trap. Ye Sangsang playing along, pretending she wants to join his crew while secretly preparing to end him—that's such a satisfying reversal. The comments from other viewers keep underestimating her, thinking she's a coward or a damsel, which makes her actual competence even more satisfying. I love how the rain keeps getting heavier as they approach Tianjia Dam. It's not just atmosphere; it's narrative pressure. The setting itself is building toward the climax. And that moment when Wang Shun says "I've killed people" and the entire mood in the car shifts instantly—that's classic thriller plotting. You feel the danger spike. The author is playing with perspective brilliantly too. We're watching this through a livestream where other people are commenting in real-time, which adds this layer of irony because the audience thinks they know what's happening but they have no idea. Ye Sangsang is way ahead of everyone, including the viewer. I'm also curious about how she'll actually execute the murder. The original driver used a hammer and destroyed the head to the point of unrecognizability. Can she pull that off? And will she succeed in making it look like self-defense, or will something go wrong? The tension between her mission parameters and the reality of actually killing someone feels very real. This is solid procedural plotting wrapped in a suspense thriller. The self-defense angle gives it moral complexity too—is she justified? Is Wang Shun getting what he deserves? The author isn't giving easy answers, which makes it much more interesting. And that ending when she transforms into this terrifying figure, that twisted smile on her face... chills. Actual chills. She's become something darker than the criminal she's hunting, and I'm fascinated to see where that goes.
... Read More
The temple. The thinnest part of the skull. The spot where a bottle could kill you. The author hammers on this - literally, with a hammer - and keeps coming back to it like a motif. Three blows. 'Ye Sangsang was certain that even if she hadn't hit the exact weak point where the skull is thinnest, three such blows would be enough to kill.' And the thing is, it's not just a fight choreography detail. The temple as symbol is about the gap between the outside of a person and the inside. The skull is this dense, protective architecture and the temple is where it's thin, where the bone gives out. Ye Sangsang has to get RIGHT at that spot. She has to close the distance past the knife, past the safety buffer, into the exact millimeter where protection fails. That's the whole thematic engine here: you can only reach the truth of a person by getting dangerously close and accepting that the proximity will hurt you. The knife in the stomach isn't a plot obstacle, it's the cost of the truth. And the rain-soaked coat as a 'weapon' is doing similar work - it's a soft, domestic, almost maternal object (coats protect, coats are warm, coats are given by people who care about you in the rain) that she deliberately makes into a trap. The fleece lining that clings when wet. The sleeves tied like a child's onesie. And she throws it over his head. I keep thinking about identity in this stretch too. 'I'm Sun Bin.' Not 'I am Ye Sangsang.' She shows up with one name and leaves with another, and Wang Shun has to figure out which one is the person he actually knew. The game's structure - 'it was still a firsthand experience. She knew her fragile psyche couldn't handle the trauma of being tortured to death' - means she's choosing a fictional death to avoid a real psychological one. The line between the game and the person is thinner than the temple. Thinner than the skull. And the live chat treating it all as content, 'I wonder if there'll be more chances later' referring to a beauty getting killed, makes me want to throw my phone into a river. The violence is spectacle. The hammer is spectacle. The only thing that isn't spectacle is the sound of the padlock clicking open in the rain, which is so small and mechanical and normal that it becomes the most human moment in the whole sequence. I keep coming back to that click.
... Read More
This is the section where every single nerve ending in my body got activated. The stakes go from 'will she get caught?' to 'she is literally sitting across from a police officer right now' and I cannot breathe. Let's break down the tension architecture here. First layer: the immediate physical danger. She's cleaning a car full of blood while a livestream records her every move. The viewers aren't suspicious—they find it soothing—but the fact that ANY recording exists is a ticking time bomb. Second layer: the forensic reality. She did a good job, but 'something that was too clean would only raise suspicion.' Even her perfect crime has a flaw baked into it. Third layer: the institutional weight of the police. They found Wang Shun, they know he took a taxi, and they're systematically narrowing the net. And the officer! 'A stern-looking police officer with a hint of a rogue demeanor'—he's not just doing paperwork, he's *performing intimidation*. The cigarette sniff, the pen tap, the direct threat about jail. This is someone who knows how to press. Meanwhile Ye Sangsang is 'fidgeting with her hands' which is either genuine nervousness or the best acting of her life. The text refuses to tell us, and that uncertainty is TORTURE. What's killing me is that we're positioned so close to her perspective that we're rooting for her to succeed, but we also know she killed someone. The moral discomfort of being on the wrong side of a murder investigation is exactly what makes this unputdownable. And I'm pretty sure this interrogation hasn't even reached its peak yet.
... Read More
There's something deeply unsettling about the theme of *performance* running through this entire section. Ye Sangsang isn't just cleaning evidence—she's becoming someone else. The text literally says she's 'gradually immersing herself in the perspective of the taxi driver' and 'getting into character.' But is she really the taxi driver, or is she playing one? The whole concept of identity in this book feels porous, constructed, something you can step into and out of. The burning of the clothes at the paper offering site is such a loaded image. Qingming Festival is approaching—this is literally a time when people burn paper offerings for the dead. She's choosing a place where burning things is *normal*, where the community expects to see flames. The disguise isn't just in what she does but in WHERE she does it. Ritual masking as cover. Then there's the water imagery. The body in the ditch, floating, half-submerged. Water as both a purifier and a preserver of evidence. And the cleaning solution she uses—it's literally designed to make blood disappear from detection. Water washing away traces. The whole section feels haunted by this motif of purification that never actually purifies anything. She's trying to clean the world of evidence, but the stains remain in every other sense. The woven bag is another detail that sticks with me. She finds a dusty one, puts the ashes in it, and now there's 'something that was too clean would only raise suspicion.' Imperfection as armor. Authenticity through dirt. That's a philosophy that goes way beyond this scene.
... Read More
"Everyone had assumed that in a horror game like this, Ye Sangsang would be the vulnerable one. They had prepared to watch her break down in tears." Bro. THAT line. That was me at the start of this arc. I was literally bracing for her to cry in the rain, shake the hammer, maybe call for help. And instead she just... hits him. Again. And again. Until he's dead. And then she rubs her sore arm and thinks 'holy shit that's physically exhausting.' The gap between what the audience expects and what she actually does is so sharp it's almost funny. And the relationship dynamic between her and the viewers is the real story here. They're watching this terrified, typing things like 'I could never be that composed' and 'this is so terrifying,' and she's just... in the zone. She speaks once, to herself, looking at the body sinking: 'I think this is how he did it.' And the chat goes silent. She's not performing for them. She's not even aware of them in that moment. That's what makes her feel so separate, so cold, so unbotherable. And then there's Wang Shun himself, who only exists as a body and a set of tools by this point, but the fact that she uses his own disposal method, his own habits, to finish the job makes this a weirdly intimate relationship. She's finishing his sentence. She's becoming the last part of his routine. I don't know, it's unsettling in a good way. The power dynamic between viewer and watched character is the actual relationship I keep thinking about. They want her to be a victim. She refuses to be anything but competent. And that refusal is the entire personality of the character in three sentences.
... Read More
So the pacing here is... structured tension, I guess. Let me explain. We get the setup: device arrives, she reads the rules, signs the card. That's functional exposition but it moves fast, two paragraphs of 'here's how the game works, here's what you have to do.' The author isn't dwelling. Then she's in the game. Two seconds of darkness. Logo. 'Criminal Files.' Stats. Ninety-nine guidelines she skims. Scenario selection. She clicks start. Weightlessness. Rain. And then the knock. 'Knock, knock, knock.' That's it. Three syllables. And the whole chapter structure shifts from 'system tutorial' to 'now you're in it.' The pacing trick is that the tutorial section is all procedural - click this, confirm that, read the rules - which is actually boring in a productive way. It makes you skim. And then the rain hits and suddenly you're IN the scene and your reading speed drops because the prose is doing something different. Shorter sentences. Sensory details. 'The streetlights cast a hazy glow through the rainy night.' You slow down because the environment is asking you to look around. And then the knock interrupts that settling-in moment. You haven't even oriented yourself in the car yet and the threat is already at the window. The livestream comments are layered on top of this like a second rhythm. The main narration is steady, almost calm - rain, glass, the man's face. The comments are chaotic, fast, mocking. 'I give her ten minutes before she's slit throat.' And they keep going. And she can't close them. The live view is permanent. So the pacing has this dual channel: her experience in the car is slow-burn, sensory, quiet. The audience's experience is loud, impatient, cruel. And they're racing each other. She's carefully reading his lips through the glass while they're already betting on her death. The cliffhanger at the end of this batch - him opening the back door, removing his raincoat, settling in - is structured so that the last thing you see is him in the seat and the first thing the next chapter will probably be is the knife. Or the negotiation. Or her saying something that changes everything. I'm keeping the book open and not putting it down. The author knows exactly how long to let the silence sit. The ten-minute countdown in the comments is both a reader countdown and a narrative countdown. You're reading and thinking 'she's got like... a few pages before this gets bad' and that keeps you turning them faster. Smart structural manipulation. A little ruthless. I respect it.
... Read More
Okay listen, I need to talk about how the Wang Shun disposal scene is structured because I genuinely sat down re-reading it twice just to follow the logic, and it holds up. Like most crime thrillers, they rush from kill to cleanup, right? But this one actually maps the whole thing like a forensic reversal. First she kills him. Then she bands her own wound to prevent blood as evidence. Then she takes his raincoat off his body to wear. Then she drags him to the trunk. Then she goes to his house for his disposal tools. Then she wipes the scene clean on her hands and knees. Then she drives to the dumping site. Then she washes his clothes of fingerprints. Then she swaps his shoes for Sun Bin's. Then she ties the bag with nylon rope. Then she secures it with a tree in the ditch. That's like nine distinct phases and each one has a specific tactical reason. The shoe swap is my favorite because it means the original killer anticipated that the criminal profile would use shoe size to estimate height and weight, and built a misdirection into the evidence chain. So the plot isn't just 'kill the guy, dump the body, leave.' It's a layered puzzle where every step feeds the next. And what sold me completely is that she doesn't have Sun Bin's memories. She's working off instincts and the mission's success criteria. So the author is basically saying: watch this character solve a multi-step procedural puzzle without a walkthrough. The live chat comments about the gloves being in the car and the body description contradiction actually make the plot feel more alive because the 'audience within the story' are confused while she's not, which keeps the narrative tension going even in the quiet parts. Does anyone else think the author is deliberately making the reader feel like a detective who can only see half the board? Because that was exhausting in the best way.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this: the way this story opens is genuinely clever. You've got this girl in a psychiatric hospital who apparently can't leave, right? Pale, beautiful, wheelchair-bound. And then BAM — she gets an invitation to a holographic game. And what's the game about? Criminal investigation. I'm already wondering if her condition is connected to the game somehow, because that would be too on-the-nose but also honestly kind of perfect. The biggest plot twist in these opening chapters isn't even a twist — it's the reveal about her brother. She pretends to decline the beta slot knowing full well he wants it. That line — "I declined." — was so cold and precise. She literally weaponized his desperation. I love it. It immediately reframes her from a passive patient into someone with agency and teeth. I'm also intrigued by how the nurses keep talking about her beauty and wondering why someone so beautiful would be sick. There's something unsettling about that. Like, the narrative is almost whispering: is she really sick? Or is the system labeling her sick because she doesn't fit in? The hospital itself feels like a character — the high walls, the drizzle, the smell of decay mixed with rain. It's a world both confined and strangely alive. And now she's getting pulled out of it into something else entirely. I need to know what Criminal Files actually is and why she specifically was chosen. Five stars for setup so far.
... Read More
I need to talk about the absolute desperation of this situation because WOW. Ye Sangsang committed murder. We KNOW this because the narrator literally says 'if I hadn't seen Ye Sangsang commit the murder with my own eyes.' So we the readers are in this uniquely terrible position—we know she's guilty but we're rooting for her anyway because if she gets caught, the story is over and we've invested dozens of chapters in watching her play this character. The conflict here operates on at least three levels simultaneously. First: Ye Sangsang vs. Wei Qingzheng, the cat-and-mouse game of interrogation. Second: Ye Sangsang vs. the system—the police force, the surveillance, the forensic science that could expose her at any moment. Third, and this one got me: she's trapped in her OWN car, driving Wei Qingzheng around, unable to speed up, slow down, or change course without seeming suspicious. What she stands to lose is everything. Not just freedom—identity, survival, the entire carefully constructed life she's built. The narrator even acknowledges: 'She wasn't far from the truth now.' That means ONE more clue, ONE more witness, ONE more unlucky break and it's all over. And Wei Qingzheng?? This guy is sharp. 'My instinct told me something was off. And more often than not, their instincts were spot on.' He's the kind of antagonist who doesn't need dramatic threats—he just needs time and patience. The fact that he volunteered for a ride in HER car shows confidence bordering on arrogance, which makes him even more dangerous. The stakes have never felt higher. Every word she speaks, every hesitation, every glance in the rearview mirror could be the difference between walking away and ending up behind bars—or worse.
... Read More
I'm going to ramble a little here because the physical texture of this chapter's scenes got under my skin and I can't just summarize it neatly. Start with the crime scene itself. We never get a full visual sweep of the road, the wilderness, the body. We get fragments. The angle of the victim's body in photos. The bloodstained gloves in her hand. The hammer 'within easy reach.' And I think that's intentional. The scene is reconstructed from forensic evidence, not observed. She's not standing at the blood spatter. She's reading a case file with a body diagram and a dead woman's gloves. The worldbuilding of the crime is done through absence and inference, and somehow that makes the car interior more vivid than any 'the red sedan sat in the rain, its windows fogged' description could. You build the car in your head because you have to. The hammer's position matters. The medicine in the cup holder matters. The little bump under the seat that she only feels because she shifted. That one physical sensation, 'a small bump against her back,' is doing more worldbuilding than a paragraph of environmental description. You can feel the vinyl, the narrow space, the way you have to squint to see what's under the passenger seat. Then the newspaper. 'The paper was yellowed and slightly wrinkled from frequent handling.' That one phrase. Yellowed. Not crisp. Not a fresh printout from a database. A physical artifact that someone carried, creased, smoothed, re-read. It's a 2004 clipping in a holographic game set in the near future, and the anachronism of that worn paper against the sleek smart-cameras and system notifications is doing something I can't quite articulate. It grounds the horror of the case in something tactile. You can almost smell the old ink. And the live stream. The 'smart camera angles' that let viewers see what she's reading. The pauses she builds in so the audience can catch up. The chapter gives us the sensation of a broadcast space, not a private investigation. There are screens everywhere, there's a comment feed scrolling, there are thousands of eyes. The world of the game is a studio, a theater, and the crime scene is a set. Even her own body is framed by the camera. She 'paused for a minute to let the audience catch up before putting the paper away.' She's performing her deduction. The physical act of solving is also a physical act of showing, and that layer of mediation changes how you experience every scene. The gloves aren't just evidence; they're a prop she holds up for the lens. Then the care facility. No description. No lighting. No hum of machines. Just a bed, a caregiver's watch, the flat 'seven oh three in the evening.' The sensory palette strips away completely. From the colorful, noisy, camera-lit game to this beige, silent, unnamed room. The contrast is so stark it almost makes the game feel like a fever dream by comparison. I don't know yet what this place is. I don't want the author to tell me. I want to sit in that beige and feel how much information has been pulled out of the environment on purpose. The less the room gives you, the more you focus on her face, her 'impatient' expression, the way she sits up. The scene IS the silence.
... Read More
Okay so here's the thing that made me actually pause mid-scroll and just stare at the ceiling for like two minutes. The whole arc from 'is there even a hidden clue?' to 'wait, the briefing I was given was LIES' is structured like a nested box. Layer one: you think the murder was random violence between criminals. Layer two: Ye Sangsang re-examines the body position, the hammer angle, the gloves and medicine, and flips it to premeditation. Layer two-and-a-half: the live stream audience is actively telling her she's being fanciful, 'There's nothing else to uncover. Is Ye Sangsang's imagination running wild?' And then BAM, the little bump under the seat, the two pieces of paper, the system notification for Sun Bin's info. That's layer three. And layer four is the newspaper clipping that retroactively makes the original 'case summary' look like a deliberately incomplete dossier. What kills me is how the author uses the audience's own doubt as narrative fuel. The chat comments aren't just flavor text or filler. They're there to make YOU feel the resistance, so when the clipping drops and suddenly 'the once puzzling details now formed a coherent narrative,' the payoff hits ten times harder. I was in the chat section going 'oh yeah sure she's just making stuff up' and then the smart camera pans to her reading and I was like NO. The way the author weaponizes the viewers' skepticism against them? Chef's kiss. That's not just plot, that's meta-fictional plotting baked into the game structure. And the four names at the end. Wang Shun, Zhou Qiang, Jiang Jiansheng, Wang Zhi. She just holds the crumpled paper and says essentially 'these people are connected.' No explanation. No hand-holding. Just a list of names and addresses and the reader is supposed to FEEL the weight of it. The author trusts us to sit with the discomfort of not understanding yet. I respect that. The tension isn't 'will she figure it out' anymore, it's 'what is the shape of the thing we can't see yet?' 'So, the previous mission briefing was just a smokescreen from the system.' That line landed like a physical kick in the stomach because it reframes everything she's done so far. Every step, every deduction, was built on a foundation that was intentionally misleading. And she's been inside the game this whole time, watching the audience gasp, performing for cameras, and she had to catch a hidden clue hiding under a car seat while four continents watched her live. The stakes of getting it wrong aren't just 'game over,' they're 'you've been dancing on a rigged stage and nobody told you the music was playing you.' Also the transition at the very end to the caregiver, the 'beep-beep' breaking the fourth wall of the game layer, dropping us back into the 'real' room where she's a patient receiving treatment. The plot architecture is literally nested holographic layers inside physical layers and the author just... switches registers mid-sentence. No transition. No breath. One line of game UI and then 'Miss Ye, were you just asleep?' in flat, cold, clinical prose. The tonal whiplash IS the plot point. I need to know what 'my condition' actually is before I can sleep.
... Read More
Okay so the thing that got me is how offhand Ye Sangsang refers to Ye Zhe. 'Ye Zhe, that annoying person, had finally done something good for once.' Just... casually tossed in there like they've been exchanging this energy for years. We don't get their backstory, we don't get why he's sending her this thing, whether it's charity or a bet or some weird sibling dynamic or whatever. And I'm FIXATED on it. She's in a wheelchair, clearly has a whole caregiving setup with nurses coming in for medication, and this dude just... ships her a VR criminal simulation headset like it's nothing. 'You're going to be livestreamed.' Cool. Thanks, bro. And she just... takes a pen from the nurse and signs. No hesitation. No 'wait, what are the implications of strangers watching me play a murder game while I'm in a wheelchair.' She just signs. Which tells me so much about her - she's either incredibly composed or she's been so reduced by her situation that public humiliation stopped mattering a few chapters ago. And then there's Wang Shun. We barely meet him but the author drops this line - 'a notorious bandit who would even consider killing a stray dog for a meal.' He's not a sympathetic villain. He's not even an interesting villain. He's just... force. And she's been dropped into his narrative as the prey. Physical strength 3 out of 10. The system literally says 'Killing a chicken would be a challenging task for you.' So the whole dynamic is set up as this impossible mismatch - this fragile, brilliant, mentally sharp woman in a body that can barely handle basic physical tasks, now sitting in a taxi in the rain with a knife-happy man in the back seat. And the audience? The livestream comments are already calling her a noob, saying women aren't cut out for this, betting on when she'll scream. I want to know if she watches those comments. I want to know if she's building a case file in her head while her hands shake. The relationship between her and her own limitations is the real tension here, not even the bandit yet. She's in a wheelchair IRL. In-game her body has a 3. She's been told repeatedly she's not enough. And she's about to walk - well, sit - into a crime scenario and make it work with what she's got. That's the character hook that's getting me. The Ye Zhe thing is secondary but I need the full context or I'll be re-reading batch 1 by tonight.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or