Simulated Crime, This Criminal Doesn’t Seem to Be Acting - Reviews

Simulated Crime, This Criminal Doesn’t Seem to Be Acting
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
'This gentleness and refinement stemmed from their upbringing and education. People like this rarely showed extreme emotions.' This observation, spoken almost clinically by Ye Sangsang, is the emotional core of the entire passage. The author isn't asking us to feel sorry for victims or even to fear the killers—they're asking us to be profoundly confused about the nature of evil itself. How do gentle, educated, well-adjusted people become capable of such systematic cruelty? What strikes me most is Ye Sangsang's lack of moral confusion. She notes her own antisocial personality diagnosis ('she knew because she had been diagnosed as such') and then applies that framework to understand Sun Bin and others like him. But unlike herself, they weren't born broken—they were made broken by something. The question 'what kind of event could have driven these two to such ruthlessness?' is asked with genuine curiosity, not judgment. It's the question of a scientist observing a specimen, and that detachment is somehow more chilling than any emotional reaction could be. There's also a strange intimacy in the way Ye Sangsang studies Zhou Qiang's murder photos. She's not disgusted; she's analyzing. 'It wasn't that she felt sympathy for Zhou Qiang, but such methods were far from ordinary revenge.' This clinical observation reveals the depth of her emotional landscape—or rather, the notable absence of conventional emotion within it. She feels excitement ('a glint of excitement flashed in Ye Sangsang's eyes'), curiosity, professional interest... but not grief, not compassion, not even fear. The live stream comments provide an emotional counterpoint, though. When viewers react with horror to the mission details—'Holy cow, it's actually about slitting wrists and flaying alive'—they're performing the emotional response that Ye Sangsang cannot. Their outrage becomes her emotional proxy, and in that substitution, there's a kind of tragic loneliness to her character that the author never explicitly states but makes palpable through absence.
... Read More
I need to talk about the device description for a second because it's doing so much quiet worldbuilding work. She expected a 'bulky, head-covering helmet-like device.' She was thinking about where to hide it from nurses. And then it arrives and it's 'a sleek black neckband' that 'could easily be mistaken for a piece of jewelry.' Do you feel how that one reframe changes everything? The technology is so advanced it's invisible. It's not a gadget you hide under a blanket, it's a collar you just... wear. Like it's always been there. The worldbuilding implication is that this Star Ring tech has been normalized to the point of being domestic. It's not the future, it's Tuesday. And the card - 'a sword, rose, and scale, its edges tinged with a vivid red hue' - tiny detail but it gives the company this almost heraldic, official, institutional weight. Like a government-issued ID card but corporate. Very slick. Very 'we own you now, sign here.' Then the game drops and we're in the taxi. 'The sound of rain pattering against the ground and windows.' Not 'driving on a rainy road.' The rain hitting the ground AND the windows simultaneously. She's perceiving it in layers. 'The streetlights cast a hazy glow through the rainy night.' Hazy. Everything is slightly blurred, slightly wet, slightly uncertain. You can't see clearly. The face at the window - 'a middle-aged man with a stubbly chin, dark skin, and an honest demeanor' - 'honest demeanor' is doing SO much work there. He looks normal. He looks like a guy who needs a ride. The world is constructing him as non-threatening before the narrative tells you he's the worst kind of predator. The physical texture of the scene is all wet surfaces, reflections, the metallic softness of the neckband, the hazy light. It's very tactile. I closed my eyes and I was in the passenger seat feeling the rain drum on the roof. The author doesn't describe the city's name for us beyond 'Hai City' - we get no skyline, no landmarks. Just the car, the rain, the window. Which is actually the smartest choice because the worldbuilding isn't the city. The worldbuilding IS the car. Four walls, one back seat, one rain-soaked night, and a man who's about to pull a knife. The environment is claustrophobic by design. And the weightlessness before she appears - 'A strange sense of weightlessness washed over her' - that transition from the sterile wheelchair room with its nurses and medication schedules to this drenched, anonymous street in someone else's life. Two completely different sensory worlds smashed together in one page. I'm still thinking about the neckband. The fact that this life-altering tech looks like a choker. There's something quietly terrifying about that.
... Read More
"Such a beautiful person... how could she be sick?" — this line haunted me after reading. The way the author paints this hospital scene is so specific and layered. Anding Hospital in Hai City, Zhongzhou Country — they don't just tell us it's a mental institution, they SHOW us. The caretaker who is "silent as ever" but has been heard speaking before. The patients greeting each other warmly while the nurses walk around Ye Sangsang like she's something fragile or dangerous. The chamomile flowers placed by the window like ritual objects. The rain stopping and leaving that post-rain scent mixed with decay. These are the details that make you believe this place exists. The contrast between the hospital world and the game world is brilliant. On one side you have concrete walls, medication schedules, wheelchairs, institutional lighting. On the other, Star Ring Company promises "a second world that truly exists" — tactile, auditory, olfactory, visual immersion. The hospital is suffocatingly real; the game is hyped to be MORE real than reality. That inversion is genius. The website description alone gave me chills — swords, roses, and scales as decorative motifs. Three symbols that probably map onto justice, passion, and balance or judgment. The author is building a mythology here without even starting the actual game. I also love the small visual details: the silver fork reflecting the white ceiling light for exactly three seconds before she puts it down. That's the kind of thing that makes a scene feel lived-in rather than described.
... Read More
'Pull over there. Stay the night at my place, and I'll agree to take you under my wing.' And I just... laughed out loud at my phone at 2am because that line is so aggressively functional. No pleasantry, no 'hey sorry about the car situation,' just a transactional sentence that doubles as a power play. His voice is all clipped, strategic, every word a chess move. 'Drive away now, and we'll leave each other alone' - same energy. He speaks like a guy who's spent twenty years negotiating with cops and the words are pre-loaded, no spontaneity, no vulnerability leaking through. Contrast that with Ye Sangsang's actual spoken lines in this stretch: 'Brother, wait! I've got a flashlight. I'm just holding a flashlight!' Which is PERFECT because it's a lie delivered in the most mundane, slightly embarrassed register possible, like a kid catching their teacher red-handed. And then the killer line: 'I'm Sun Bin. Do you remember you?' Wait, 'Do you remember me?' In the rain, barely audible, said to a man she just punched twice with a hammer while he's clutching a knife and bleeding from the head. The absurdity of the register - she's essentially asking for a date, emotionally. 'Remember me? I'm the one who mattered.' While she's got a blade in her gut and he's on the floor. The dissonance is the whole point and the author writes it so flat, so understated, that it hits harder than if she'd screamed it. The live chat voices are also fun - they shift from playful ('I'm waiting to see her get killed instead') to genuine horror ('A criminal!!! Lock her up') without the characters themselves acknowledging the tonal whiplash. It's a nice device. Honestly though, I'm curious if Wang Shun gets another line after this chapter because right now he's basically a prop who says 'uhh, you're tough, I'll let you go' and then gets hit again. I need him to be more than a wall for her to throw hammers at. I need him to say something that reveals he KNEW Sun Bin. I need him to crack. The dialogue's not going to save the scene - the physicality will - but I need one more sentence from him that isn't tactical. One sentence that's human. Give me that and I'm buying the next volume.
... Read More
So the whole time I was watching her crawl on the ground, drag the body, stand, walk, hit someone with a hammer, I kept thinking about one line: 'Having been in a wheelchair for so long, she even enjoyed this moment of being fully capable.' And that one line cracked the entire section open for me. The physicality of the crime scene isn't just plot mechanics. It's her reclaiming a body that, in real life, she can't fully use. She's in a wheelchair. In this game, she's on her hands and knees in the mud, dragging a fifty-kilo man into a ditch, swinging a forty-centimeter hammer until her arm aches. And she likes it. Not the killing. The doing. The physical agency of it. The theme here is so quietly buried under all the procedural detail that I almost missed it until that one sentence popped up like a needle popping a balloon. And then the shoe swap becomes symbolic too. She's literally wearing someone else's size, someone else's dimensions, fitting herself into a body that isn't hers. Sun Bin's body, Sun Bin's wheelchair life, but Ye Sangsang's mind and hands. The red herring of the shoe size is also a metaphor for identity: the evidence says one person, the reality is another. And the rain washing her face clean after the blood? That's not just practical. That's erasure. That's the world saying 'you didn't do that, the rain did it.' She's always the invisible agent. The one who exists in the margins of other people's stories. In the game, for the first time, she's the one on the ground, moving, doing, and the narrative gives her that permission. I keep thinking about whether the author realizes how much that physicality is the actual theme or if it's just... good scene construction that accidentally becomes philosophy. Probably both. Probably that's why it hits.
... Read More
Random thought: the pacing trick here is that the killing is fast but the cleanup is slow, and that contrast is the whole engine of the section. The hammer scene? Three sentences. Done. She's dead, he's dead, move on. But the body disposal and scene cleaning stretches out over like five or six hundred words of her crouching, wiping, dragging, driving in circles. And I loved that. Because the tension isn't 'will she kill him.' We already know. The tension is 'will she miss something? Will a print survive? Will the rain not wash enough?' It's a ticking clock made of meticulousness instead of explosions. The author keeps inserting the live chat as a metronome, which also controls the pace. When the chat goes silent during the killing, time slows. When it floods back with 'shouldn't she clean the car first?!' the urgency spikes and we're pulled out of her POV into the audience's anxious head. That back-and-forth between her silence and their panic is the rhythm. Also the driving-in-circles bit before she stops is such a small detail but it mimics real behavior and stretches the timeline just enough to make me feel the minutes passing. I was skimming the middle of the cleanup until that comment about the gloves showed up, and then I had to reread. Good hook. The whole section reads like a heist movie where the heist is just... not getting caught by a virtual police system. Slightly ridiculous but completely effective.
... Read More
Can we talk about how the pacing in this section is absolutely calculated? It starts SLOW—the car cleaning scene goes on for what feels like forever, and I mean that in the best way possible. Three hours of scrubbing, scraping, emptying buckets into sewers. Every detail of the process. The reader is forced to sit with this slow, almost meditative violence, and then suddenly—BAM—'piercing terrified scream' and the body is found. The transition is brutal. One moment she's wiping door crevices, the next there's a corpse in a ditch and police tape everywhere. That whiplash is intentional, and it works. The author basically makes YOU the one who's nervously waiting, right? And then the time skip! 'Time flew by like a fleeting shadow'—just one line, and we're three days later at the police station. Efficient without feeling rushed. The structure here is: meticulous preparation (the cleaning), chaos (the discovery), cold procedure (the investigation), and then the trap snaps shut (the interrogation). The pacing of the interrogation scene itself is also masterful. It starts with this quiet tension—the officer lighting a cigarette, the long pause—before he even asks the first question. The author doesn't dump all the police info at once; they drip it out. First we learn Wang Shun was a familiar criminal, then they review surveillance footage, then they narrow it down to taxis, and THEN Ye Sangsang gets summoned. Each beat raises the stakes incrementally instead of hitting us with everything at once. I stayed up way too late reading this.
... Read More
I need to talk about the narrative voice here because it's doing something really interesting. Ye Sangsang's internal monologue during the cleaning scenes is almost clinical—"Cleaning up the bloodstains was the most critical task"—like she's reading from a manual. But then there are these moments where the narrator just drops in these wildly subjective, visceral descriptions and it's so jarring in the best way. The body floating in the ditch with 'shattered skull fragments and red-and-white flesh'—that's not clinical, that's straight horror, and it completely breaks from the measured tone we had before. The dialogue is sparse but every line lands. The police officer's opening: "Where were you between 6 PM and 10 PM on the 19th? Answer our questions seriously. Lying to the police will land you in jail." There's no flourish, no drama—it's just blunt authority. And Ye Sangsang's response is so perfectly performed: timid, fidgeting, saying 'it was raining heavily that day.' She's acting, and the fact that the narration doesn't explicitly tell us she's performing makes it even more chilling. The live stream comments are such a bold choice too. '[Her movements are so methodical]' '[Same here. It's a blessing for my OCD]'—these aren't traditional dialogue but they give us a chorus of witnesses who are completely missing the horror happening in front of them. It's dark comedy gold. The author's prose has this particular texture—terse when it needs to be, almost lyrical when describing violence. Not flowery, but precise. Like a camera panning across a crime scene.
... Read More
First of all, the English was good. Based on the first chapter I can say that it was well-defined, but if I wasn't mistaken there were some quotation marks that weren't inserted right in the dialogue. I hope it will improve. Keep writing!?
... Read More
Disapointig translated novel. Mc with low IQ high ego and 0 good points goes 10 years back in time 2008y but into illogical parallel world that has all that our world has but all big wigs are matial artists. I think beside being arrogant dick and stealing from his little sister mc has nothing going for him. Translation is so so too as it does not bother to translate all words like for example university exam...To wn development team: This has lot of fake reviews here with no content or with same copy paste from different acounts. Is it normal now to let this crap be as reviews?
... Read More
I really like this novel. And all the other series and manga but unfortunately I don’t know how to read Chinese. This review is for the translator or who is in charge of the story here. Do u know when tang Jiao San will star/source out the translation of DD4 as a novel. I hope u see this whoever is in charge
... Read More
The woman which was sitting in front of me, with eyes of void, and hair of snow, clapped her hands, and looked at me, annoyed.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or