Sharing Cherry Pie - Reviews

Sharing Cherry Pie
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay, I need to just sit with this scene for a second. Cherry gets locked up for TEN DAYS after one encounter with Ufkhan and she's literally just eating scones on her bed like 'this is life' — and then BOOM, Father shows up with Ufkhan at his side like they're sharing a secret alliance. The Count looks guilty as hell, refusing to meet Cherry's eyes, while Ufkhan is strutting around like he owns the place. And then the line drops: 'You and I promised to marry when we were young.' Cherry immediately chokes on tea. I CHOKED ON TEA reading this. But here's what gets me — Ufkhan doesn't just reveal the promise, he ties it directly to their sexual encounter: 'Why do you think I gave you my virginity that day?!' He's treating their intimacy like a transaction, like the marriage promise validates it. That's deeply unsettling and the author absolutely knew it. And Cherry's response? 'Aren't you talking too recklessly knowing I can't remember my childhood?' She's NOT wrong, but also — how is she supposed to remember? The text literally says the kidnapping incident wiped her memories. So she's being held accountable for a promise she has no recollection of making. That's not romantic, folks, that's coercion wrapped in pretty packaging. Then she bolts to Ludwig's place like 'I'm not into monogamy!' which is both hilarious and heartbreaking because she has every right to say that and doesn't need anyone's permission.
... Read More
Let's talk about the energy in that bedroom at the end because it was ABSOLUTELY electric and I have so many thoughts. First, the dynamic between Ufkhan and Ludwig is chef's kiss perfection. These two men who clearly both want Cherry but have completely different approaches — Ufkhan is all aggression and possession while Ludwig is measured, almost gentle — they stand off like rivals in Cherry's favorite novel. And here's the kicker: Cherry notices this herself and feels her heart race. She says she hates obsession, but there's something about two powerful men competing for her attention that she finds exciting. That's a flaw she's aware of but can't quite shake, which makes her SO much more interesting as a protagonist. Then Ludwig's line when Ufkhan shows up: 'I suppose you can't ignore physical compatibility after all.' He's not even hiding it — he's PROVOKING Ufkhan on purpose. This man knew exactly what would happen by inviting Ufkhan over. He called him. He orchestrated this. And Cherry, caught between them, is just... vibrating. The fragrance hits again before either man reacts — and the text specifically says 'A fragrance Cherry didn't perceive spread thickly throughout the bedroom.' She's becoming increasingly disconnected from these supernatural elements even as they surround her. Meanwhile Ufkhan just... picks her up and tosses her onto the bed while Ludwig pulls her the other way. The imagery of her being physically contested between two men is wild, and I am HERE for the chaos but also concerned for her agency in all of this.
... Read More
Can we talk about how the world of this book makes you FEEL the suffocation from page one? The opening scene is this blazing hot afternoon in a mansion steeped in history, where even the servants find moments to hide and read erotic novels together. That detail alone tells you everything about the atmosphere — this is a place where desire is forbidden, repressed, pushed into corners and shadows. The maids huddling with their heads close, voices lowered, terrified of being caught — it mirrors Cherry's own secret life exactly. And the servants' conversation! When they're gossiping about Cherry as "the lady in the cage" while holding Volume 2 of her favorite book... the irony is brutal. They pity her but also mock her. "She'll probably never hold a man's hand in her entire life." The author is building this entire world where everyone knows Cherry's story except Cherry herself. The description of the mansion itself is sparse but loaded — old trading family, Count Vallinoa away on business to the Eastern Continent, all-female staff because the father replaced everyone after the kidnapping. That single detail explains the entire power structure. No men allowed near his daughter. Not even the stable keeper is a woman. The suffocation is architectural. But then the nighttime carriage scene — forest path, lamplight, whispered voices — the atmosphere shifts completely. Dark, dangerous, conspiratorial. Cherry emerging from a luggage box dressed in a ruby-accented silver dress is such a cinematic moment. The contrast between the stifling mansion and this stolen night of freedom is everything. The author doesn't need to describe palaces or markets or armies. One hallway scene with gossiping maids and one carriage ride through a forest and I understood this entire world. That's skilled writing.
... Read More
I need to talk about the Count for a second because wow. 'How could you have avoided the accident?' Cherry asks, and the father's response is so quiet, so broken—he just says accidents happen unexpectedly, even for a witch. You could feel the guilt radiating off the page. This man loved his wife so much that he proposed to her specifically because of her fragrance power, and then lost her to one of the men she'd bewitched. And now he's looking at his daughter and seeing the same danger, the same curse, and he can't stop himself from trying to control it. But here's what killed me: when Ufkhan shows up and breaks through that iron door, Cherry's first thought is basically 'a hero coming to rescue a princess in crisis, how novel!' She's so used to having no agency that the idea of someone else taking charge feels almost comforting. Meanwhile Ufkhan and Ludwig are just there, marks on their chests, bound to her somehow, and the whole situation is this tangled mess of romantic tension and accidental dominance. TheCP dynamics are deliciously complicated. Ludwig seems more... gentle about it? Actually concerned about propriety even while half-undressed. Ufkhan is all sharp edges and menace, calling the father 'father-in-law' like it's a threat. Two different types of devotion, both triggered by something Cherry didn't even consent to.
... Read More
This batch is a MASTERCLASS in pacing and I'm still recovering. It opens with Cherry in what feels like a false calm — ten days of homebody bliss, blueberry scones, rolling around on bed crumbs laughing. The prose is light, almost comedic. 'This is life.' And then Father arrives. The moment the Count walks through the door, the temperature of the entire narrative drops ten degrees. The作者doesn't waste a single beat — awkward greeting, Ufkhan lurking behind him with crossed arms, the Count looking guilty, the heavy silence in the reception room. All of this builds in about five paragraphs before Ufkhan drops the 'childhood friend' revelation. Then Cherry spits tea on Ufkhan. COMEDY GOLD. But it immediately pivots back to tension when he shouts about giving her his virginity. The emotional whiplash is intentional and effective. Cherry fleeing to Ludwig's mansion is the breath of fresh air — lighter dialogue, the absurdity of her saying 'I won't devour you today' at dinner. Then BAM, the manuscript reveal. 'The Lady's Escapades.' The meta twist that Ludwig is the AUTHOR and Cherry resembles the heroine Botana Loren is genuinely shocking. I literally gasped. It reframes everything we know about the story — is Cherry aware she's in a novel? Is that why she has these escapades? The philosophical implications are enormous. And the batch ends with... three people in a bedroom, the scent returning, both men closing in. The cliffhanger is not subtle but it is EFFECTIVE. I need the next chapter immediately.
... Read More
I'm obsessed with how Cherry's inner voice sounds versus how she speaks out loud. The text has this brilliant pattern where she's constantly comparing reality to novels—this is THE moment, this is how it starts in books, love is something you seize—and then the actual dialogue reveals she's completely unfiltered when drunk. Her line about wanting intense romances with handsome men plural is the single funniest moment in these chapters. The fact that she says men plural while looking at exactly one man—Ufkhan—who is clearly not taking this well. And his response of just ...Men plural?... is perfect. He's trying to process what she just said and all he can manage is confusion. The servant interactions are also doing so much work. When Ufkhan grabs the servant by the collar asking about the drink, the servant's cautious Pardon? Yes... shows this instant recognition that defying this man is not an option. And later when he demands an empty room, the servant immediately covers both ears and leads the way like he's already been threatened with ear removal. It's dark humor at its finest. Cherry's dialogue evolves throughout the scene too. She starts tentative—Um, thank you. with that small hand gesture—but by the time she's drunk she's whining freely and shouting catch me if you can! The text marks this shift perfectly, and it's genuinely funny watching this carefully constrained woman completely lose her filters while Ufkhan loses his patience. The narrator's voice is also doing incredible work here. There's this wry observation quality—like when it notes Cherry's realization about parties having subdued lighting, or when it describes Ufkhan as someone whose temperament couldn't tolerate even the slightest inconvenience. The narration knows exactly what's happening even when Cherry doesn't.
... Read More
Ufkhan is supposed to be the stoic, controlled war hero type — the classic cold duke archetype who never loses his composure. But watch what happens in this scene. Cherry, drunk and mischievous, climbs all over him like he's playground equipment. And instead of pushing her away (as any properly written cold male lead should), he just... grapples with his own reactions. That silver bottle moment? Chef's kiss. He downs hard liquor to clear his head while she's giggling beside him, mistaking it for a canteen. The contrast between her chaotic energy and his desperate attempt at self-control tells you everything about who these people actually are underneath the noble personas. But here's what really got me — when he says 'You're mine now' and immediately backtracks with that premarital chastity speech, he's actively constructing a moral framework to justify what he's about to do. Classic manipulation, but delivered with such genuine internal conflict that it doesn't even feel manipulative. The text literally says 'His lack of immediate response made her mischievous' — she knows exactly what buttons to push because she's been reading this story before. She's playing the role of the bold heroine while Ufkhan is genuinely drowning in uncharacteristic heat. That gap between performance and reality is where their whole relationship dynamic lives now.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about the morning after because WOW. Cherry wakes up and her first instinct isn't panic or regret — it's stretching like a cat and thinking about room service. That line 'Ah, it really was good' while she's rolling around in bed? I literally gasped. The author just completely subverted every romance novel trope I've ever read where the heroine wakes up next to a powerful man and immediately regrets everything. But then — THEN — Ufkhan shows up and the whole emotional temperature shifts. This guy who she 'devoured and abandoned' comes barging in like 'I was your first!' and Cherry's response is just... genuinely confused? She's over here like 'wait, did he want more and I ran away? I felt sorry for hurting him since he even prepared lemonade.' THE LEmonade detail hit me so hard. She remembered he made her lemonade after their first time and now she's feeling guilty about leaving? Meanwhile Ufkhan is losing his absolute mind and she's just sitting there in a sheet thinking about whether the carriage scene could've been hot. And Ludwig? He's just casually sitting there like 'congratulations on receiving your title, Marquis' while everyone else is having an existential crisis. The way both men just stared at her dumbfounded when she said 'so was I' about being someone's first? That moment between all three of them was pure electric chaos. I love how Cherry isn't playing victim or heroine here — she's just a girl who genuinely enjoyed herself and doesn't understand why everyone else is treating this like a tragedy.
... Read More
On the surface this reads like a romantic comedy and honestly it is, but there's this undercurrent of genuine danger that makes it work on multiple levels. Cherry isn't just having fun at a party—she's escaped her mansion without permission. The text keeps reminding us that if discovered, her father would throw a fit and she'd lose her only friend. That's not nothing. She's gambled everything on this impulse and has to keep it secret. The conflict escalates in these beautiful waves. First there's the external threat of the ugly brigade closing in on her—Robron grabbing her, other men swarming, her realizing there's no escape route. Then there's the physical danger of being drunk and vulnerable in a crowded room full of men with transparent intentions. The text specifically calls out that she should've called a guard but couldn't because she was surrounded. That's genuine tension. But the deeper conflict is internal. Cherry has this idealized notion of romance straight from novels, and the party systematically dismantles it. She sees the ugly brigade, she processes that male protagonists in books aren't real, she has to recalibrate her entire expectation of what love looks like. And then Ufkhan shows up and his roughness is both terrifying and exactly what she wanted—but also complicated by the fact that she's drunk and can't properly assess the situation. What I love is how the stakes keep rising even in comedic moments. She's running around a party getting increasingly intoxicated, he's carrying her over his shoulder like a kidnapping, and somewhere in there there's this moment where she might throw up. The physical discomfort, the social scandal waiting to happen, the fact that she's alone without her friend Rena—all of it creates this pressure cooker that makes the eventual intimacy between them feel earned despite how chaotic it is.
... Read More
The tension in this section is OFF THE CHARTS and I need to unpack why it works so well. On the surface you've got a love triangle but it's so much more layered than that. Ufkhan shows up claiming ownership — 'You dare sleep with me and then run off?' — but the real stakes here aren't about romance, they're about power and consequence. Cherry escaped one dangerous situation only to walk into another. Ludwig is a powerful man with 'murky' intentions. Ufkhan just got his title thrust upon him and is clearly unstable. Every exit from this scene leads somewhere dangerous. But the author is masterful about layering internal conflict on top of external. Cherry's biggest conflict isn't between the two men — it's inside her own head. She's discovering parts of herself she didn't know existed ('I might have unexpected tastes?') and that self-discovery is terrifying AND exhilarating. She thinks 'I should try lots of play' and the reader is like — cherry, you just survived something intense, take a breath. The carriage ride is where the stakes peak for me. Ufkhan goes completely silent, Cherry stays quiet, and the reader is dying waiting for the explosion. When he finally asks 'Do you remember or not?' and she says 'Sex?' and he SCREAMS — that release of tension was so satisfying. The author built that silence like a pressure cooker and then just let it blow. And the ending? 'Cherry succeeded in secretly entering the mansion again' but then Ebony is acting weird and the chapter cuts on suspicion. The stakes just shifted AGAIN. She physically escaped but she's not free. The real conflict is just beginning.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about the pacing shift in this section because WOW. We go from one of the most intense erotic scenes I've read this arc straight into Cherry getting kidnapped and it was such a jarring transition. The first half is pure, unapologetic hedonism—two men, one woman, no holding back. But then she decides to leave, steps outside, flags a carriage, and bam—hands over her mouth, chloroform rag, blindfold, next thing she knows she's waking up on a cot in some moldy room. What hit me was how quickly the power dynamic flips. Earlier in the scene she had agency, she was experiencing pleasure on her own terms, figuring out her fragrance ability, feeling confident enough to wander off. One moment she's walking through the night air thinking about her future, the next she's gagged and dragged into a carriage. That moment when she realizes 'this is exactly like being kidnapped or...' and then cuts off? Chef's kiss. The author doesn't let up. And I'm already wondering—who the hell kidnapped her and why? Was it random or was someone watching her?
... Read More
Let me just quote two lines and explain why they destroyed me. First: "Cunning Cherry." Ludwig says this while whispering in her ear after blocking her mouth with his own. Two words. That's it. In two words he's acknowledging exactly what she's done — she seduced them, she orchestrated this, and now she has to deal with the consequences. It's threatening and tender and absolutely delicious all at once. Second: "If you seduced us, you have to take responsibility, yeah?" Ufkhan says this with a fierce smile while pulling her arm around his neck. The casual confidence, the ownership, the absolute certainty that she's his responsibility now — this man doesn't ask. He states. And the author's narrative voice? It's restless. It moves between Cherry's internal monologue, the maids' gossip, the omniscient observer — sometimes in the same paragraph. The prose doesn't sit still, which matches Cherry's own inability to stay contained. The meta-dialogue is my favorite part though. When Ludwig says "What should we do, Cherry? It seems neither I nor the hero have hearts as generous as the male leads in books" — the author is winking at the reader while also establishing that these characters are aware they're living in a different kind of story. The genre consciousness is sharp. Rena's lines are simpler, more grounded, which works perfectly. She's the straight man to Cherry's chaos — half bewildered, half anxious, agreeing reluctantly. "Really? Just this once." Classic reluctant friend energy. The dialogue never feels stiff even during the most intense scenes because every character has a distinct rhythm. Ludwig is elegant threat. Ufkhan is brutal simplicity. Cherry is chaotic desperation. Rena is bewildered compliance. Four completely different voices in one scene and I could tell them apart blind.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or