Sharing Cherry Pie - Reviews

Sharing Cherry Pie
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The fragrance in this batch is doing SO much heavy lifting and I need to unpack it. First appearance: Cherry is happily lounging in her room after her encounter with Ufkhan, eating blueberry scone like a gremlin on a bed, and the text just casually mentions the fragrance spreading and paralyzing the entire area. She seems to enjoy it — 'the more her throbbing headache intensified, the more fragrance spread thickly, paralyzing this entire area.' It's almost euphoric for her. Second appearance: Ufkhan is trapped in the reception room after the marriage bombshell drops, and 'the thick fragrance spread everywhere was strangling his body. Even in a situation where he couldn't even make a sound, Ufkhan's gaze couldn't tear away from the door Cherry had left through.' This time it's NOT pleasurable — it's paralyzing, restrictive, like an invisible chain. Same scent, completely different experience depending on who's feeling it. Third appearance: The bedroom scene at Ludwig's. 'A fragrance Cherry didn't perceive spread thickly throughout the bedroom. The two men noticed that distant scent before she did.' SHE STILL CAN'T SMELL IT. She's becoming increasingly blind to whatever supernatural force is orchestrating all of this. Meanwhile both Ufkhan and Ludwig notice it and react to it — Ufkhan says 'Fine' like he's surrendering to fate, and then immediately makes his move. The contrast between how different characters experience this scent — euphoria for Cherry, paralysis for Ufkhan, anticipation for Ludwig — is masterful worldbuilding. It's clearly a plot device tied to Cherry's destiny or some magic system, but the author never explains it outright. We're meant to FEEL its presence more than understand it.
... Read More
Okay so let me just start by saying the love triangle situation in this book is absolutely bonkers and I cannot stop thinking about it. Cherry is basically the definition of a lady in a cage — her father lost his wife, kidnapped her daughter when she was twelve, and since then he's turned her entire life into a gilded prison. But then you have these TWO men who literally cannot share her and the dynamic between all three is so messy I love it. Ufkhan is the kingdom's war hero, tanned, muscular, and absolutely feral. His energy is pure animal — he's jealous watching Cherry kiss Ludwig and he makes that sound while thrusting and honestly? The contrast is everything. He's this untamed force who sees Cherry as prey almost. And then Ludwig — platinum hair, golden threads catching light, kisses her forehead like an angel. "I'm jealous," he says while simultaneously ravaging her mouth with his tongue. The man is a contradiction wrapped in silk. He's the calculated one, the strategist. When he calls her "Cunning Cherry" with that voice "as sly and sweet as a snake biting into fruit" — I about lost it. But what really got me is their willingness to SHARE her. Neither of them is playing the noble game of one woman. They explicitly say "neither I nor the hero have hearts as generous as the male leads in books" — which is such a meta acknowledgment that they're writing their OWN ending outside the genre conventions. That line hit me because it's basically the thesis of the entire story. And Cherry herself — she claims she's weak for handsome faces, pinning her whole surrender on that. But is it really just about looks? Or is she starving for ANY kind of agency, ANY kind of choice, after years of being controlled? She drops the book mid-climax and that detail... the book she can't finish because she doesn't know how it ends, and meanwhile she's living a scene she can only fantasize about. The meta layer is insane. I need to know what happens in Volume 3.
... Read More
I need to process something. Cherry's relationship with these novels IS her love story in a way, and I didn't expect to feel this attached to a character whose primary emotional journey so far has been reading books about other people having adventures. When she finishes Volume 2 and pounds the bed with her fists, screaming internally about how incredible it is — that's not just a reader's frustration. That's a person who has never experienced anything this intense in her own life, watching someone else live it through ink and paper. "Everything except this is completely boring" — said about her entire existence. The friendship with Rena is interesting too. Rena gets to go to parties, midnight ones, garden ones, masquerade balls — three times a week apparently. Cherry only gets one mandated debutante party and even that was cut short by her father. Their friendship is real but it's built on this massive inequality. Rena is the自由 bird; Cherry is the pet. But here's what wrecked me — Cherry crafting her escape plan. The forged documents, the silverware gift to cover her presence in the carriage, the ruby necklace she uses as payment. This girl who's never held a man's hand has just engineered the most elaborate getaway of her life. She's not waiting for a prince to rescue her. She's rescuing herself and she's bringing her friend along for the ride. The emotional arc from passive consumer of romance novels to active participant in her own escapade is already happening in these first chapters. I'm invested.
... Read More
Let me just quote this because it's perfect: "Father-in-law seems to know something. Let's hear it." Ufkhan saying that to Cherry's father while standing there with his back exposed, marks visible, having just shattered an iron door with his bare hands—this man is a walking personality disaster and he is absolutely perfect. The way his dialogue contrasts with Ludwig's is also noteworthy. Ludwig barely says anything in these chapters but when he does, it's practical, slightly awkward, concerned with propriety. Ufkhan's lines are all edge and implication, never saying what he means directly. Cherry's voice is the most interesting development though. She starts as this naive girl who barely questions anything, but by the end she's the one demanding answers, exposing bodies, refusing the potion. Her dialogue shifts from questions like 'what do you mean?' to statements like 'I never did that' with actual defiance. The father's voice is consistently sad and measured—he never raises his voice, never gets angry, just increasingly desperate. That consistency makes his final moment of offering the potion feel even more tragic because he's doing it out of love, not malice. The prose itself has a light, almost comedic tone during the inspection scene that undercuts the gravity of the witch revelation. That tonal whiplash is intentional and it works.
... Read More
I cannot stop quoting Ufkhan's lines from this section because they are PERFECTION. First you've got him storming in shouting 'How could you do that to me?' all dramatic and wounded, and Cherry just looks at him going 'What did I...?' in formal speech like she's trying to distance herself from the situation. Then the exchange that destroyed me: 'I was your first!' 'So was I!' 'How does it make sense to change men after just one time?' 'Why wouldn't it make sense?' I fell out of my chair. Cherry blinking innocently at two men while internally wondering if she should've stayed for round two is the funniest character writing I've read in forever. She's not being cruel — she genuinely doesn't understand the social script everyone else is following. Her logic is flawless and completely unhinged. And Ludwig's voice is SO distinct from Ufkhan's. Ludwig speaks in commands and low hums — 'Open your mouth,' 'You look just like a dog. Right? Why don't you bark.' But then in the morning he's laughing, genuinely amused by Cherry's honesty: 'Really... Cherry, you really love my body.' His dialogue has this warm undercurrent even when he's being dominant. Ufkhan is all fire and tension while Ludwig is amusement and possession. The line 'I'm not a horny bastard like you' from Ufkhan followed by Ludwig just shrugging 'Is that so? That's unfortunate' — the contrast between their voices is everything. Two completely different energy types colliding and Cherry is just sitting in the middle going 'do you want to touch my breasts?' which of course starts Ufkhan's entire meltdown.
... Read More
The dialogue here does a lot of heavy lifting for character voice. The maids' exchange at the beginning is perfect naturalism. 'I wasn't reading erotic novels, I was reading the newspaper.' It's funny, relatable, and instantly establishes their personalities—the dreamer and the skeptic. Then you have the noblewoman, Ludwig's partner. Her voice is distinct: haughty, entitled, and performative. 'Oh my, excuse me. Listening and listening, I just can't stand it anymore.' She speaks in complete, aggressive sentences, using her fan as a prop. It's very 'high society.' Cherry, on the other hand, is economical. She doesn't waste words. 'That jewel is fake.' 'Because I'm holding the real one.' Her dialogue is direct, bold, and cutting through the noise. It contrasts perfectly with Ludwig's silence. He barely speaks until the end. When he does, it's measured and authoritative: 'It's real.' His voice is described as 'low, slow,' which adds to his mystique. He doesn't need to shout; his authority is implicit. The viscount is all bluster—'What nonsense is this?!'—which makes him look weak compared to Ludwig's calm demeanor. The narrative voice itself is witty and slightly ironic, often aligning with Cherry's internal perspective. Phrases like 'octopus head—decorated with what little hair remained' show the narrator's sharp eye for detail and disdain for pretension. The banter, or lack thereof, creates a real sense of hierarchy and conflict. It's not just people talking; it's people posturing.
... Read More
I keep thinking about Ufkhan's face during that scene. Specifically one line: 'He looked both agonized and fulfilled at a glance. It was an emotion Cherry couldn't understand.' What does that even mean?? Agonized AND fulfilled simultaneously? Like he's hurting while being satisfied? That's such a specific, complicated emotion that doesn't come up often in romance novels. And then Cherry—she doesn't try to comfort him or figure him out. She just wraps her arms around his neck and kisses him instead. She accepts it without understanding. That tells you so much about their dynamic. Meanwhile Ludwig is completely different—he's all control and observation, commenting on her body like a connoisseur examining art ('Your breasts are beautiful no matter how many times I see them'). But Ufkhan feels more... feral? More animalistic? The wolf eyes comparison earlier in the text comes back to me here. There's something dangerous about him that Ludwig isn't. And what about that flower tattoo moment? Cherry thinks she saw a flower tattoo on one of them but can't remember who or if it was real. My guess is Ufkhan. That imagery of 'bitten nape of prey' makes me think he's the more predatory one emotionally, not just physically. And now she's been kidnapped—could this be connected? Is Ufkhan involved somehow? I genuinely don't know yet and it's driving me crazy.
... Read More
I need to talk about this one moment where Cherry sits on top of Ufkhan and starts 'tracing through memories from the book.' Like... she's aware she's in a novel? Or maybe she's just referencing some romance handbook? Either way, the text goes: 'What did the female protagonist do here?' and then she kisses him. Not a soft, romantic kiss — she gives herself a 'generous score for her first bird kiss' internally. She's treating this like a quest objective while Ufkhan is losing his goddamn mind. And Ufkhan's emotional arc in this scene is absolutely wild. He starts completely composed, walks her to the room, sits on the edge of the bed looking down at her with what the text calls a 'complicated expression.' Then she grabs his neck. Then she's climbing him like a mountain. Then she kisses him and he's just... frozen. The text says 'Far from murderous intent, the excessively soft presence toppled the large frame.' That line alone destroyed me. This man who could probably bench press a carriage just gets dismantled by a woman half his size who's too drunk to know what she's doing. The tension peaks when he whispers 'You came at me so confidently earlier. What were you planning to do?' and she can't even meet his eyes. That shift from her being bold and him being flustered to them both completely lost is what makes this CP feel real instead of manufactured.
... Read More
The writing in these chapters is doing so much heavy lifting with the atmosphere and I can't get over it. From the opening where the carriage ride feels like celebration to the party itself, every scene is loaded with sensory detail. The sparkling lights in the darkness making Cherry's heart race, the subdued lighting that she misremembers from her first debutante party, the ruby necklace Rena gives her—it all paints this world that feels lived-in. But the party description is where it really shines. The text captures this specific nobility atmosphere where everyone's performing. The wealthy mansions district, the splendid villa, the various age groups mingling with hidden agendas. There's something almost satirical about how Cherry observes everyone at the party—she notes that the young nobles are mostly there to hook unaccompanied ladies, and the whole ugly brigade converging on her feels like a commentary on how these characters actually see her versus how she wants to be seen. The visual contrast between Ufkhan and everyone else is striking. While the capital nobles are pale-faced and refined, he's in black from hair to clothing, shirt gone, vest showing off sun-tanned forearms. The text specifically calls out how elderly nobles would gasp at his attire but it suits him. That image of him with his crooked smile, the phosphorescent gleam in his eyes—it's almost animalistic compared to everyone else in the room. And the champagne scene! Round bubbles rising, the fizzing sound giving Cherry courage, that first taste being surprisingly sweet. You can feel the alcohol working through her and the whole world softening around the edges. The transition from the public party to the private empty room where he demands service feels like crossing a threshold into a different tonal space entirely.
... Read More
The emotional undercurrents in these chapters are actually giving me whiplash, and not in a good way. We start with the maids gossiping, right? They mention Cherry has 'red hair and blue eyes,' and then they immediately pivot to the newspaper rumors about the 'war hero and his anonymous lover.' Are we really supposed to believe Cherry isn't connected to this? The text screams subtext. The narrator even shows us her internal monologue: 'It was just a one-night stand, how did things turn out like this?' This girl is haunted by a rumor she can't control. That's not just backstory; that's current emotional baggage she's dragging into the ballroom. Then you contrast that with her attraction to Ludwig. She's physically captivated—'Wow, is that human?'—but her mind keeps drifting to 'Ufkhan.' Who is Ufkhan? The war hero? If so, the triangular tension is delicious. She's physically present with Ludwig, admiring his 'delicate beauty,' but emotionally she's still entangled with this wild, 'rough charm' of Ufkhan. The author paints them as 'heaven and earth' but in 'perfect harmony.' That's heavy romantic coding. Cherry is torn between two archetypes: the refined, dangerous nobleman and the feral war hero. And her motivation for being at the party isn't just adventure; it's a reaction against her father's suffocating control. She feels 'wronged for having stayed quiet.' There's a lot of suppressed frustration there. She's buying freedom with jewels and risking her reputation, all while hiding behind a mask because her face is already ' plastered across every newspaper's front page.' It's tragicomic. She's living the romance novel the maids read, but she has no idea if it's going to be a happy ending or a scandal.
... Read More
I need to talk about how Cherry operates because this woman is something else. She's completely unapologetic about wanting romance. Like she escaped her mansion specifically to find a partner, and when reality doesn't match her novel expectations, she doesn't crumble—she adapts. The text has her thinking she's found THE ONE when Ufkhan saves her, and honestly I was with her until I realized she's seeing him through this intoxication filter. But here's what got me: Ufkhan's reaction to her. When she says she has no friends and is alone, he doesn't swoon or whatever. His brow furrows and he looks away and clearly wants to leave. Then she grabs his arm and he... stays? The text says his arm tensed up twice already and he's reacting to her movements, which is classic novel behavior but also kind of interesting because he could've just left and didn't. What's fascinating is the power dynamic. He's this huge war hero, covered in scars from battlefields, and he's the one being managed by this tiny woman who's drunk on champagne and running around like a maniac. He calls her strange, he's suspicious, he's grinding his teeth—and yet he follows her. He gets her another glass. He lets her use his chest as support. He carries her over his shoulder like she weighs nothing. The scene where he thinks she might throw up hanging upside down—that's the kind of detail that shows he's paying attention even when he's clearly exasperated. And Cherry, meanwhile, is completely weaponized by liquid courage, saying exactly what she wants with zero filter. These two are built for each other in the most chaotic way possible.
... Read More
This chapter is structured like a perfect pressure cooker. The author knew exactly what they were doing. Act One: pure comedy. A woman drunk enough to climb a man like furniture while he drinks hard liquor beside her like a disappointed parent. The servant fleeing. The bottle mistaken for a canteen. These are laugh-out-loud moments that let your guard down completely. Then Act Two hits with a single sentence: 'What was done?' Cherry asks 'All done' and the text just... stops. That gap between what she thinks she accomplished and what actually happened is where the tension starts building. She recalls 'the next chapter' from some mental script, and suddenly the comedy evaporates. 'Wait, do you even know what you're doing right there?' Ufkhan's line isn't angry — it's genuinely bewildered. And that's scarier. Act Three is the explosion. The kiss. The vest ripping. The dress tearing. Each paragraph removes another layer of restraint — first words, then clothing, then control. The pacing accelerates with every beat: dialogue becomes shorter, descriptions become more fragmented, Cherry's internal monologue devolves from clever observations to single exclamation points. By the time she's whispering 'I don't know anything about that' about her own scent, the reader is breathless too. The final image — Ufkhan kissing her 'deer-like slender ankle' while she clamps her hand over her mouth — is the perfect button. The chase has inverted. She started as the aggressor, now she's trapped and watching. And the chapter ends mid-sentence with his 'stiffly erect member began to swell even more' — a cliffhanger that's equal parts thrilling and devastating. I immediately opened the next chapter.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or