Sharing Cherry Pie - Reviews

Sharing Cherry Pie
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The pacing in this section is masterful because it starts so deliberately slow. Cherry wakes up confused, assesses her surroundings, notices the quality differences between the bed and the room—she's piecing things together methodically. The prose gives you time to breathe, to sit in that disorientation alongside her. Then the father enters and the exposition begins, and it flows like a conversation rather than an info dump. He reveals layer after layer: the witch ability, Blancheur's death, the memory potion, and through it all Cherry is just... processing. Absorbing. But then—CRASH. The knight gets blown through that iron door and everything accelerates. In three paragraphs we go from philosophical discussion about destiny and magic to physical violence to body inspection to romantic revelations. The pacing shift is so abrupt it's almost jarring, which is exactly what you want after a long information-heavy scene. The author understands that exposition needs a pressure valve. They could have kept the father talking for another twenty pages, but instead they interrupt with action right when Cherry is about to make a crucial decision about the potion. The interruption saves the scene from becoming a monologue and transforms it into active conflict. This is textbook but executed perfectly.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is sparse but each line lands hard. Ludwig's 'It's too burdensome to keep it confined. Suck it' is such a dominanter-type line—clinical, almost bored, which makes it hotter somehow. He's not even trying to be romantic about it. And then his later line 'At first it was curiosity. But you exceed my imagination'—that's the first time he shows something approaching genuine fascination, not just physical desire. That's character development through dialogue alone, right there. Ufkhan barely says anything the entire scene. His presence is communicated through actions and sounds mostly. When he does speak it's just her name repeated—'Cherry. Cherry.'—and that's somehow more intimate than any long confession. The author trusts silence and breath to carry emotion. Then later when Cherry is alone in her head she has this internal monologue that's so distinctly HER—'I don't know about it, I don't know! It seemed like a verbal promise anyway, so such things wouldn't have legal effect.' She's literally talking herself out of emotional engagement using logic. That's her voice. She's not a passive protagonist here even when she gets kidnapped—she's analyzing, rationalizing, planning escape routes in her head. The narrator's voice stays close to her perspective throughout, which makes the kidnapping hit harder because we're trapped in her head along with her.
... Read More
Okay, can we just talk about Cherry's absolute masterclass in social maneuvering here? She walks into a room full of sharks, wearing a mask she specifically chose to hide her identity because of those ridiculous newspaper rumors, and she doesn't just blend in—she goes straight for the throat. The way she ignores Ludwig's 'vampire' partner is chef's kiss. The lady throws a physical fit, fan trembling, trying to play the role of the jealous girlfriend, and Cherry just looks through her like she's furniture. I love that energy. It's not arrogance; it's strategic. Cherry knows exactly what game she's playing. And Ludwig? Oh, he sees it. He doesn't dismiss her outright. He examines her jewel, he reads her certificate, and he calls her 'interesting.' That's a win for her. Their dynamic is all about this power play—she's the unknown variable in his meticulously controlled world. Meanwhile, the dad subplot is such a subtle burn. He locks her up, yes, but he also sends her boxes of gold to compensate. She thinks it's absurd and keeps that thought buried. That's a whole complicated father-daughter relationship right there—control disguised as affection, and rebellion paid for with jewelry. She's playing a double life, outsmarting her chaperones and now outsmarting the most desirable man in the room. I'm just waiting for the moment she realizes that in this city, you can't just swap identities like swapping gloves. The game is already afoot.
... Read More
The symbolism in this chapter is dense and I keep finding new layers. The witch's fragrance isn't just a plot device—it's a metaphor for seduction, for the power that comes from beauty and presence, and most tragically, for how that power destroys the very people it attracts. Blancheur couldn't control what happened to her. Men became obsessed, jealous, violent. Her fragrance was both her gift and her curse, and now Cherry inherits the same thing without understanding it. The flower imprints on Ludwig and Ufkhan are deeply symbolic too. They're literally marked by Cherry's unconscious power, permanent reminders of whatever intimacy they shared. The fact that Ludwig's mark is more solid than Ufkhan's suggests something about the nature of their connections—whether it was deliberate or accidental, whether one bond is stronger than the other. Cherry traces these marks with her eyes but doesn't understand what they mean yet, which makes the reader feel ahead of the protagonist in that delicious way. The white orange flower on the Count's wrist from his wife—this is probably the most emotionally loaded symbol. It's a mark of servitude, yes, but it's also proof that Blancheur chose him. She agreed to his terms, stayed by his side, and he carries her mark like a wedding ring. When he shows Cherry the medicine to erase her memories, he's essentially asking her to delete the very thing that made his wife who she was. That contradiction is the thematic heart of the entire arc.
... Read More
There's a detail in the opening scene that I keep coming back to because it's too perfect to be accidental. Cherry is caught between two men, overwhelmed, losing herself in sensation — and the book she's been desperately clutching falls to the floor. The red hardcover lands face-up showing the title: "The Lady's Escapades, Volume 3." The unfinished volume. The one she doesn't have yet. That image — the physical book separating from her hands at the exact moment her fantasy becomes real — is the entire theme of this story compressed into one gesture. She's been consuming stories about ladies having escapades, and now she's having one, and she can't read ahead to see how it ends because the story is LIVING. She's become the protagonist of her own narrative. The cage metaphor is everywhere. Cherry is literally confined to her room, surrounded by all-female staff, unable to leave without a guardian. But the real cage is the genre itself — the expectations of what a noble lady's story should look like. The male leads in romance novels are "generous" — they share, they don't fight, the harem ends happily. But Ludwig and Ufkhan explicitly say they're NOT like those book heroes. Their version of love is possessive and competitive and dangerous. The father's obsession with protection versus imprisonment is the central moral question. He replaced all the staff, removed all the men, kept her in silk and surveillance — is this love or control? And Cherry's answer, silently, is to escape in a box. The silverware gifts she embroiders (badly, nobody has told her) are another symbol — she's performing obedience while planning rebellion. Every stitched flower is a lie. Every package sent to her father is a mask. This is a story about a woman who learned desire through fiction and is now risking everything to make it real.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or