No hope - Reviews

No hope
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is really slick and I want to talk about how the author moves us from one emotional register to another without ever making it feel jarring. We open with an almost domestic scene—Huo Ye and Shen Tingyu at the cafeteria, casual conversation about food, some flirty teasing about abs. It's slow, intimate, almost boring if you weren't paying attention. Then BAM—girls taking photos, gossip, the whole school noticing them together. The energy shifts upward but it's still light, almost comedic. Then PE class. The badminton scene slows us back down again, almost meditative—two guys playing without intense smashes, maintaining a leisurely pace while around them the basketball game simmers. The author lets us breathe before ramping it up. And when the basketball crisis hits—players injured, Class A about to lose, the dirty tactics laid bare—the pacing accelerates hard. Short sentences. Quick dialogue. The confrontation with Liao Zheng comes fast and sharp. Then Huo Ye steps onto the court and the action sequences fly. Dribbling, feints, passes, the dunk—each beat lands quickly, propelling us forward. After the victory, there's a cooling-down period. The class laughs, Wu Zhen complains about shot put, Zhao Jiayan does his silly salute. Then we get the time jump—two months pass, exams happen, rankings shift. The pacing stretches out, giving us space to process what just changed between these two. And then the sports meeting sign-up scene returns us to the bickering tone of the opening, bookending everything nicely. The structure here is essentially a wave—quiet, rising, crashing, receding, quiet again. But each return to calm has shifted the baseline slightly. Shen Tingyu and Huo Ye aren't in the same place they were at the start.
... Read More
There's a passage early on that stops being just description and becomes the thesis of the whole novel: 'Birds of prey are highly alert animals; they can sense danger and threats in an instant because they know the other possesses sharp claws and are evidently unmanageable. This was a big reason why Shen Tingyu found Huo Ye displeasing.' Both of them are predators. That's why they can't stand each other. But it's also why they're drawn together — nobody else in this story has claws like they do. The Shen family curse is everywhere once you start looking for it. They're wealthy, educated, powerful, and emotionally illiterate. Marriage is transactional. Love is 'an abstract influence on rationality.' Shen Tingyu was born as a 'necessary product' for continuing the lineage — not a child, a function. And yet the grandmother, the only warm person, reinforces the same pragmatic worldview: 'there are many things that money can't buy, like love. Someone will teach you in the future.' She knows the family is broken. She knows love is missing. And she's still sending her grandson into it blind. The apron is the perfect symbol for all of this. Shen Tingyu, the heir to generations of wealth, can't wash a dish. Huo Ye, a servant, cooks like a professional and runs the household. The apron should signify subservience — but Huo Ye wears it like armor, and Shen Tingyu refuses to wear the pink one because it diminishes his dignity. Pride vs. survival. Class vs. competence. Who really serves whom in that house? Nobody's clean, including the Shen family legacy.
... Read More
The isolation subplot is BRILLIANT and I want to shout about it from the rooftops. Class A second year—"good students" with inherent pride—reject newcomers. Huo Ye (tail-end from Class 18) and Shen Tingyu (transfer student) are tablemates and therefore doubly targeted. But here's the twist that made me actually appreciate the worldbuilding: other students feel RELIEF because these two are drawing fire. "With these two drawing the fire and attention, they might appear less like newcomers themselves." This is social dynamics at its most ruthless and honest. You don't need a dramatic antagonist when the antagonist is just... the natural hierarchy of a classroom. And the author handles Shen Tingyu's response to this with such perfect characterization. While everyone else is worried about being isolated, Shen Tingyu is "focused on his practice book, scribbling away" through a Chinese lesson he doesn't need. Huo Ye observes: "He didn't care whether others isolated him because he could single-handedly isolate everyone else. This was the pinnacle of pride—self-sufficient in his majesty." I AM DEAD. Self-sufficient in his majesty. The man doesn't just ignore social exclusion—he radiates so much arrogant competence that exclusion becomes irrelevant. And yet Huo Ye is the one worried. Huo Ye, who is good at socializing, recognizes that Shen Tingyu's approach works but might not be sustainable. This creates a beautiful narrative tension: one character is immune to social pressure through sheer force of personality, the other is acutely aware of it and trying to navigate both their own social survival AND Shen Tingyu's. Two newcomers, one doesn't care, one cares too much, and they're stuck at the same desk. The thematic resonance here—pride as both armor and isolation—is layered without being heavy-handed.
... Read More
Okay, let's talk about the water bottle scene because I have SCREAMED into my pillow about it. Huo Ye drinks from Shen Tingyu's bottle, and Shen Tingyu's entire persona cracks for a literal half-second. He goes from ‘I don't know those girls' to ‘THAT'S MINE, YOU CAN'T JUST—' and then Huo Ye leans into it with this ridiculous, devastating logic about cross-contamination and brushing teeth eight hundred times a day. I'm dead. But the real gut-punch is right after. Shen Tingyu shoves him against the wall, pins his wrists, and suddenly their bodies are pressed together—heartbeats drumming, foreheads bumping, and Huo Ye's internal monologue is just this calm, observant wreck noting how young boys have warm bodies even when they've got cold faces. The line ‘like a peasant fighting a landlord' had me wheezing, but it's also painfully accurate. They're both so careful. Then Shen Tingyu whispers, almost breathless, ‘Did I trigger your reflex?' and Huo Ye just… chuckles. No flustered panic, just this low, indulgent sound. That's the moment I knew they were already ruined for each other. Every other interaction since the opening ceremony feels like it's building toward that kind of raw, unguarded proximity. The group chat banter is sweet background noise, but THIS—the restrained hands, the wet shirt clinging, the ear-red denial—is the main course. I'm not crying, you're crying.
... Read More
People will read this and think it's just a fun school story with some sports and some banter. But the stakes are running underneath everything and they're genuinely tense. On the surface level, the basketball match has real consequences—Class A is getting their asses kicked by Class B's dirty tactics. Kids are getting injured. Elbows to kidneys, swollen ankles, people actually hurt. This isn't some harmless PE class; it's competitive and violent in a way that matters to these kids. When Liao Zheng threatens to "find someone" to take down Huo Ye after losing, and his friends have to cover his mouth and drag him away while muttering about "that last incident" and Director Liao being a powerful official—what the hell does that mean? Something happened before this chapter. Something serious. And it's hanging over the whole thing like a sword. But the deeper stakes are relational. Shen Tingyu is new. He has no social capital here. He's observable, targetable. The fact that Huo Ye starts defending him, claiming him, bringing him into their orbit—that changes everything about his position in this school ecosystem. If Huo Ye falls, Shen Tingyu falls with him. And we know from that throwaway reference to "that last incident" that Huo Ye is not immune to falling. Then there's the academic pressure—the monthly exams, the rumors about Huo Ye being a "problem student," the way everyone expects him to fail and now he's proven them wrong. The stakes keep escalating from social survival to academic reputation to whatever that dark history with Director Liao is. And through all of it, Shen Tingyu stays mostly silent, watching, taking it in. He's not passive—he's calculating. You can feel it.
... Read More
Okay, so let me just start by saying—this plot twist hit me like a freight train. Huo Ye? The guy who barely passed, who showed up to class half the time, who did multiple choice and guessed the rest? Top of Class A? I literally read that paragraph three times because my brain refused to accept it. And the best part? The author doesn't just hand him this achievement—we get glimpses of the effort behind it. He was never actually falling behind; he was holding back. That single realization recontextualizes everything. The pacing here is absolutely masterful. We start with what seems like a comedic setup—the wealthy rich kid被迫 getting stuck in a delivery van—and then slowly, almost imperceptibly, we learn that Huo Ye is playing a completely different game than everyone thinks. Meanwhile, the subplot with Zhao Yue... ugh. That silent standoff when Huo Ye tries to talk to him? My heart actually ached. Zhao Yue's forced smile, his inability to process that his best friend had outgrown their shared world without leaving it behind—'Congratulations'/'We will meet again'—this exchange ruined me in the best possible way. The narrative structure also does something really clever with the class placement system. The 3+1+2 exam model, the voting on combinations—if enough people want it, it forms, if not, it dies. It's a ruthless meritocracy disguised as student choice, and it mirrors the larger social hierarchy of the school. Class A vs. Class 18 isn't just academic tracking; it's an entire ecosystem of social stratification. And Huo Ye just cracked through it. But here's what I can't stop thinking about: where does the story go from here? Shen Tingyu is clearly not going to accept this new reality easily, and Huo Ye has essentially declared war on every assumption anyone made about him. How long until the tension between them snaps? And what about Zhao Yue—will that friendship survive the chasm that's opening between them?
... Read More
I have never related to a school uniform nameplate reveal so hard in my entire life. Shen Tingyu sliding into the passenger seat of Huo Ye's Wuling Hongguang with the energy of someone who just realized they've been riding in a garbage truck, and then Huo Ye casually unzipping his jacket to reveal — same class, same school, everything he thought he knew about this boy flipped upside down? The way Shen Tingyu's gaze moves from the embroidered nameplate UP to Huo Ye's face, his attitude shifting from arrogance to confusion? That silence between them? That was dialogue without words. But the actual spoken dialogue is where this author earns their keep. Let's talk about Zhao Yue's line: 'Nothing, huh, just feeling a bit reluctant. You're going to Class A, with us in different directions; it'll be hard to see each other from now on, haha…' The 'haha' at the end. The way the smile 'gradually faded, and he eventually couldn't smile anymore.' This is dialogue that does SO much emotional work. Zhao Yue is trying to perform casual acceptance but every word betrays him. The author doesn't need internal monologue here—the dialogue itself carries the weight of a friendship fracturing in real time. And Huo Ye's reply: 'We will meet again.' Simple. Firm. Not an explanation, not a comfort, just a declaration. He doesn't say 'in the library' or 'after school' because he genuinely doesn't know. The ambiguity makes it more powerful. Then there's the classroom gossip after Huo Ye leaves—'Is that a tumor on your neck?' 'I reckon he benefited from not having scores assigned to this exam'—this dialogue is brutal in its casual cruelty. These are kids who can't conceive of someone improving without cheating, without connections, without some illicit advantage. Their dialogue reveals everything about their limitations, not Huo Ye's. The group chat section is also a masterclass in digital voice. Zhao Yue's 'I'm gonna bite you all, I'm chomp chomp chomp' versus the deadpan efficiency of 'Just woke up, will head over soon. Please help me grab the textbooks.' These aren't just messages; they're character sketches in miniature. Huo Ye reading through them and smiling—'visions of his past classmates filling his mind, as if everyone hadn't changed at all'—this is where the dialogue becomes nostalgic.
... Read More
Okay, Chapter 10's opening is pure cinema. I swear to you, I could see this in my head frame by frame. Dark sky, sun setting 'unusually quickly' — that detail matters, it sets the mood before the scene even starts. Shen Tingyu unlocking the door, calling out 'Grandma,' getting a low voice back instead. The tension builds for three seconds before the camera pans to reveal Huo Ye in that apron, sweat glistening on his collarbone, holding a spatula like a weapon. The description of Huo Ye is ridiculous in the best way. The author took their time here — the rolled-up sleeves, the veins on his arms, the chest groove, the Adam's apple. This isn't just a handsome man cooking; this is a full sensory experience. And then the apron is 'a bit short, barely covering his upper thighs, with a pair of long legs peeking out from underneath.' I am not okay. The domestic setting contrasted with his physical presence is genuinely hilarious and hot at the same time. The house itself tells its own story. Spotless floors, rich food scents, the butler's anxious sweating over a staffing mistake — this is a wealthy household running on precision and fear. Everyone is walking on eggshells around the Shen family's expectations. The old lady's joy at seeing her grandson is genuine but fragile, almost desperate, like she knows this warmth won't last. Every room in that house feels heavy with unspoken history and emotional starvation.
... Read More
Guangdong in November, apparently, is a thermal rollercoaster that only high schoolers and insomniacs could endure. I love how the author paints the world before anything even happens—you get the temperature swing, the ‘steamed cake on top, cold jelly below' outfit joke, the way boys run hot while exposed calves shiver. It's not just decoration; it sets the rhythm. Then you drop them into the sports meet, and the sensory details go wild: the blinding sun turning Shen Tingyu's skin to porcelain, the roar of the crowd blurring into a hum, the specific chaos of phones coming out because, excuse me, this is the one day teachers can't legally confiscate them for ‘taking photos.' The classroom post-race feels lived-in—group chats lighting up, trivial shares that somehow build a whole community in three bubbles. But the scene that stuck with me is the restroom hallway. Two boys talking low, a girl's muffled sob bleeding from a nearby stall, and Huo Ye immediately connecting it to Gao Xiaoyuan's voice from that earlier incident. The author never over-describes the corridor; it's all sound and implication, which makes it way more unsettling. Even the Sanjin Soup Bun shop gets a cameo before Huo Ye parks—that's the kind of grounded, local texture that makes the setting feel breathed-in. I keep expecting some rainy confrontation or a night drive to unfold here, and the world is clearly ready for it.
... Read More
You know what's actually wild when I think about it? Neither of them wants to eat at the same time as the rabid horde. Huo Ye deliberately waits until 12:30 so they can have seats. Shen Tingyu doesn't remember how to get to the cafeteria because he's too proud to ask for directions. They arrive when everyone else is mostly done eating. They walk at a leisurely pace while everyone else rushes. This is courtship behavior and I will die on this hill. But here's what really got me—when Shen Tingyu sees Huo Ye not looking at the big chicken leg, he MODERATES HIS ORDER from three meat dishes plus two chicken legs to just one chicken leg. Because apparently eating more than your reluctant dining companion is a moral failing. "Shen Tingyu felt inexplicably that he was eating more than Huo Ye, making him feel like a foolish glutton." And then the narrator drops: "But in all fairness, Huo Ye had never thought like that." THE IRONY. Huo Ye didn't care about the chicken leg situation at all. Shen Tingyu modified his entire meal based on a assumption that Huo Ye was making a sacrifice. Meanwhile Huo Ye was just... not hungry for chicken legs. This is the funniest tragicomic beat in the entire passage. Shen Tingyu is out here managing his protein intake to avoid seeming like a glutton next to someone who literally ate less because he doesn't like chicken, and Huo Ye has zero awareness of this emotional calculus. Their emotional wavelengths are so far apart it's almost impressive. And yet—Huo Ye grabs Shen Tingyu's wrist when he tries to leave without him. "Eat, let's eat together. I'll accompany you to the cafeteria." He tugs his wrist and shakes it "like comforting a child." The physicality! The condescension! The care disguised as annoyance! Shen Tingyu is a carnivore who orders three meat dishes and gets self-conscious about it. Huo Ye is a pen-spinner who orchestrates thirst traps and pretends to be annoying. These two are going to be the death of me.
... Read More
"Young Master, even your ears are red."—I need this line framed. Huo Ye's voice in this book is a weapon wrapped in velvet. He says shit like “Did you do it on purpose?” or “Would you have hygiene issues if you brush your teeth eight hundred times a day?” with this slow, enunciated drawl that's equal parts tease and threat. The narrative actually notes his voice is “quite suitable for ASMR-type sleep audio,” which is both hilarious and terrifying when he's pinning Shen Tingyu against a wall. Shen Tingyu's replies are all clipped and defensive (“Get lost, it's hot, I'm irritated”) which makes Huo Ye's longer, meandering sentences feel like deliberate unwinding. Their dialogue is pure ping-pong—Huo Ye serves soft, Shen Tingyu returns sharp, and they keep resetting the table. But the group chat scenes are where the author really shows off. Xiong Ying's manic energy (“Boss, you weren't hacked, right?”), Xia Zhiyao's random skin-care complaints, the absurd #007_Huo Ye handle—it all sounds like actual teenager mess. What's clever is how the chat voice contrasts with the prose. The narration is tight, observant, almost literary, but the dialogue drops you straight into the noise. It never feels staged. Even the silence speaks: Shen Tingyu's “…” after Huo Ye's ridiculous vomit threat says more than any shout could.
... Read More
The scene at the fish ball shop is one of those moments where everything just clicks into place and suddenly you're standing in that exact spot breathing the same air. Huo Ye in his black jacket covering his school uniform, towering over this tiny market stall while the aunt next door sells fish and tries to figure out what kind of boy this quiet handsome kid is. "Almost twenty"—he likes saying that because he feels mentally older, and that's the most honest thing about him. Then the grandmother's house. Oh god the grandmother's house. The bedroom they've kept ready for Wang Duoyu with fresh sheets changed monthly, the black-and-white color scheme, the display cabinets full of Patek Philippe watches instead of childhood figurines. That room is a character in itself. It screams abandonment dressed up as cleanliness. "A place to sleep, not a home to live in." And Huo Ye notices all of this. He always notices. The thermos with its peeling paint sitting on Bald Zhang's desk, the old boss giving him car keys because "it'll just gather dust otherwise"—every setting detail is loaded with meaning. This book doesn't just describe places, it makes them ache.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or