No hope - Reviews

No hope
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about how this chapter handles the cheating rumor because it's woven through EVERYTHING like a ghost. It opens with Zhao Yue hearing classmates whisper about whether Huo Ye actually cheated—and he doesn't even turn around. He just sits there, motionless. That's such a powerful structural choice. The entire chapter is haunted by that one question. Then later, Teacher Zhang Zhiming literally confronts the Class D students about their suspicion, demanding evidence, calling out their narrow-mindedness. The author mirrors the private gossip with public confrontation, and it works so well. The rumor isn't resolved—it's acknowledged, defended, and then... still lingering underneath everything. Even at the end, when Huo Ye sits down in Class A and the boy in front scrapes his desk two steps away, you can feel the institutional bias still operating on a micro level. The pacing between the group chat scene and the physical reunion is also masterful. We get the digital moment first—the photo, the comments, the collective 'so cool'—and THEN the physical gathering outside. The photo acts as a prolepsis, a glimpse of the bond between Huo Ye and Wen Shiyi that we then see in full color moments later. Time collapses beautifully. And that ending—"What are you doing here?" / "What are you doing here again?" It's a perfect cliffhanger. Not dramatic, not explosive, just deeply intriguing. Who is Shen Tingyu? Why did he say 'again'? What happened before? The chapter doesn't answer any of these questions and I am OBSESSED. The transition from the emotional weight of the farewell scene to the comedic relief of Bald Zhang's introduction is also well-timed. You need that breath after Bai Feiyu's puppy-like clinging. The author knows exactly when to let you exhale.
... Read More
I need to talk about the fish balls. Not the romance, not the tension — the fish balls. Because that tiny detail wrecked me more than any dramatic confession could have. The grandmother says, 'You loved these when you were little.' And Shen Tingyu, this boy who came home after two years abroad with his pride intact and his credit cards frozen, just... ate them. All of them. He didn't argue. He didn't say he was too old for childish things. He ate every single one because, as the narration tells us, 'apart from his grandmother, no one ever treated Shen Tingyu as a child.' His parents see a product. A lineage continuation. Huo Ye sees a young master to serve. But Grandma? She sees the little boy who likes fish balls and that's it. Meanwhile, Huo Ye is sitting there, being served by the old lady, nodding along, and Shen Tingyu can only look at him with this mixture of resentment and something else. Something he probably can't name yet. The scrambled eggs? He poked them into mush. A tiny act of rebellion against the one person who wasn't even trying to control him. That's the kind of emotional detail that makes a reader sit with their phone for twenty minutes after closing the chapter. And the way Huo Ye watches him do it — 'It was hilarious. He didn't know who this was being done for' — this man is reading Shen Tingyu like a book and finding him endlessly entertaining. I'm telling you, this CP is going to be devastating.
... Read More
Okay so on the surface this is just a school sports match, right? Two classes playing basketball, some dirty players, whatever. But the way this scene unfolds is actually doing a LOT of narrative work and I'm not even being dramatic. Before the game, Shen Tingyu is this new transfer student floating alone—no friends, no connection to anyone in Class A. He's standing by himself playing badminton with Huo Ye while everyone else clusters in groups. There's this quiet ache to his isolation that the text doesn't spell out but you feel it. Then the shuttlecock hits him and suddenly Huo Ye is there, offering to play, and it becomes this moment of selection—Huo Ye chooses to include him. The basketball game is the catalyst. Huo Ye steps in and basically takes over, not just as a player but as a protector. When Liao Zheng tries to probe about Shen Tingyu's origins, Huo Ye deflects with this territorial "our family member" line and then physically steps between Shen Tingyu and the question. That's not just teamwork—that's possession, is what it is. He's marking territory in front of the entire school. And the result? They win. Class A wins. But more importantly, Shen Tingyu goes from invisible transfer student to someone who now has a reputation by association. The whispers around Huo Ye start dying down because suddenly there's a dark horse narrative emerging. Plot-wise, this is the moment the two of them become a unit in the eyes of everyone else. The diary entry at the end sealing this as remembered history is such a clever structural choice—it frames everything we've just read as already legendary, like we're looking back at the origin story of something huge.
... Read More
I have to talk about Shen Tingyu and Huo Ye because this is EVERYTHING. You get absolutely ZERO backstory about them in this chapter, just one shared moment—"What are you doing here?"—and my brain is already writing fanfiction about their entire history. And that follow-up, "What are doing here AGAIN?" CHILLS. Actual chills. Then inside the classroom when Bald Zhang asks if they know each other and they BOTH say "Don't know each other" in unison, and Shen Tingyu tries to interject with "We shared a ride once" but Huo Ye literally shuts him down with a glare so sharp it made me laugh out loud—"promptly closed his legs." BRO. You cannot deny it. That little look in his eyes was indeed quite fierce. I am DEAD. The dynamic between Shen Tingyu and Huo Ye is fascinating because it's built entirely on tension and avoidance. Shen Tingyu is cold, stiff, almost hostile, yet there's this undercurrent of... something. Recognition? Annoyance? Jealousy? And Huo Ye, who is used to being feared and misunderstood, actually seems to meet Shen Tingyu on some wavelength that nobody else gets. When Bald Zhang misunderstands their exchange and says "maybe I recognized the wrong person," Shen Tingyu just goes silent. That tells me SO MUCH. And then there's the whole friend group. Xiong Ying accidentally nearly spilling about Huo Ye's past grades—"his grades were excellent! If it weren't for—" and then immediately cutting himself off is such a raw, painful moment. You can feel the guilt radiating off the page. He blames himself for leading Huo Ye astray, and the fact that Huo Ye shows no reaction but clearly hears it... that silence speaks volumes. Bai Feiyu crying like a puppy clinging to Huo Ye, begging him not to go, saying "your world will have no me, but that's alright, you need to be happy on your own"—I'm not crying, you're crying. That friendship is so genuine and it hurts because we KNOW this is a turning point. Class 18 is broken up. The top class is looking down on Huo Ye like he doesn't belong. And Shen Tingyu? Still unreadable.
... Read More
Let me just say: the moment Shen Tingyu asked for Huo Ye's apron instead of wearing the pink cat-paw one? Chef's kiss. That entire exchange was a power struggle dressed up as a silly domestic moment, and I love it. He basically said 'you will give me your apron' like it was a command, not a request, and Huo Ye just... agreed. 'Alright, young master.' The way those two negotiate power in every single interaction is insane. One is a rich heir with no autonomy, the other is technically a servant who runs this entire household. Who's really in charge here? And the grandmother situation — oh my god. The way Shen Tingyu's voice literally changed when he said 'Grandma,' going from icy to soft and warm, is devastating. His mother cut off his cards, his father doesn't exist in any meaningful sense, but this old woman treats him like a child and feeds him fish balls he hasn't eaten since he was six. She's the only person in that entire family who seems to understand what he actually needs. The rest are just managing assets and bloodlines. The mother-son dynamic in Chapter 34 is also something else. 'Aren't you arrogant?' Shen Tingyu fires back, and honestly? Fair point. The whole Shen family is toxic — they reproduce like corporations and love like calculators. But Li Luoyin isn't wrong about the independence thing either. She just... can't say it gently. Can anyone in that family even do that? Nobody knows how to be warm. Not even the grandma, I think, if you really dig into it. She dotes on him, sure, but she's also the one enforcing these domestic lessons like he needs to learn to wash dishes before marriage. Progressives she is not.
... Read More
The Cheng Rongrong story that opens this section is not incidental. It's a thematic key, and I'm convinced the author placed it there deliberately. Cheng Rongrong is described as having 'a brilliant beauty like a luxurious flower, with a round and plump face and an hourglass figure'—but also 'a terrible personality. She was often quick to anger and spoke very harshly.' Yet one boy persisted, endured her slaps, and won her heart. The narrator's conclusion: 'Perhaps the world is strange that way; some people love your beautifully crafted face, while others love your dark eye circles. Some admire Cheng Rongrong's glamorous appearance, while others are fascinated by the underlying sharpness that could wound at any moment.' This is the thesis of the entire novel compressed into one anecdote. And Huo Ye is Cheng Rongrong—not in appearance, but in the dynamic of being misunderstood, underestimated, and only truly seen by someone who recognizes that the rough exterior IS the person. Shen Tingyu doesn't just tolerate Huo Ye's roughness; he's fascinated by it. The slap-boy didn't leave because Cheng Rongrong was cruel—he stayed BECAUSE her cruelty was authentic. The symbol that repeats is the car. The Wuling Hongguang isn't just a vehicle—it's the physical manifestation of Huo Ye's chosen identity. It's loud, smelly, unrefined, practical. It has no back seat. It's the anti-Maybach. And yet Shen Tingyu, someone who could never have imagined sitting in it, ends up buckled into the passenger seat anyway. The car becomes a space where social hierarchies are suspended, however uncomfortably. There's also the motif of the classroom as a battlefield. The placement exam results aren't just academic outcomes—they're territorial conquests. Class A vs. Class 18, the western wing's fourth floor versus the basement-level parallel classes. Huo Ye moving his books out of Class 18 and into Class A is a literal migration across social strata, and Zhao Yue watching him leave is the tragedy of someone whose entire identity was built around sharing the same mud. The 'fair play from the universe' line circles back to this: the universe opened one door (Huo Ye's academic rise) and closed another (his bond with Zhao Yue, his place among the 'bad kids'). Some gain beauty, others gain darkness. Some gain Class A, others lose their best friend. The story seems to be asking whether any of this trade can truly be fair.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is deceptively calm. You'd think going from a hostile phone call to a domestic dishwashing scene would lose momentum, but no — every moment compresses tension tighter. The mother's call opens with procedural coldness (the frozen card reveal hits like a gut punch), then the car ride home is almost meditative, and then BAM — Huo Ye appears in the kitchen like a plot bomb detonating. What I love is how the author uses silence as a pacing tool. That half-minute of phone silence between mother and son after all the barbed exchanges — you can feel both of them wanting to say something they can't. Then the abrupt hang-up. No resolution, just... distance maintained. The dinner scene operates on a completely different frequency. It's surface-level warm (grandma smiling, food on the table, 'Xiao Qi's cooking is so delicious') while underneath, every line carries double meaning. Shen Tingyu glaring at Huo Ye. The scrambled eggs being sabotaged. The grandmother innocently comparing them. And then the final transition to the kitchen sink, where two enemies are left alone with a mountain of dishes. That's not a downbeat — that's a setup for everything coming next. The chapter ends not with a cliffhanger but with an invitation: tell me what happens when these two are alone in a kitchen.
... Read More
Let me just say this upfront: the dialogue in this book is genuinely funny and I cannot stop laughing. Like, I read the scene where Xiong Ying and Xia Zhiyao are butting heads over a poem and I literally yelled at my phone. Xia Zhiyao: "I remember a line from a poem, what was it? The golden fish surely is not a mere pool creature, uh, pool creature—" Xiong Ying: "How could it be tied to day and night?" Xia Zhiyao: "Oh, oh, how could it be…" [realizes the error] "Go away!" [hits him] This is not even the punchline. The punchline is Wen Shiyi deadpanning the correct answer: "The golden scales are certainly not mere pool creatures; once encountering the wind and clouds, they transform into dragons." And then Xia Zhiyao immediately pivots to roasting him for scoring 130 in Chinese but only 15 in math. Wen Shiyi's silence afterwards is a CHARACTER MOMENT. But the real gem is Bald Zhang. The man is a COMEDIC INSTRUMENT. His name alone—"Bald Zhang"—and then the nickname evolving to "Guangguang" because of his shiny head? The author gave him this whole backstory: Northeastern lumberjack family, migrated to Guangdong, taught in Cantonese-speaking areas for decades, can't shake the accent, occasionally slips into non-standard Cantonese during physics lectures and the kids lose their minds. This man is beloved. I can already tell. The group chat scenes are also peak fiction. Everyone has such distinct voices. Xiong Ying is loud and eager ("I have it, I have it!! No one better fight me for it; I'll light it for the boss!"). Bai Feiyu is dramatic and poetic in his grief. Xia Zhiyao is sharp-tongued and quick to violence. Wen Shiyi is cold and precise. And Huo Ye? Huo Ye barely says anything in the group chat. He just exists. Perfect. And the unison dialogue—"What are you doing here?" / "Don't know each other." That parallel structure between two characters who clearly know each other VERY well is chef's kiss.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this thermos because honestly it hit me harder than any plot twist in these chapters. Bald Zhang carries this battered old thing with peeling paint for TEN YEARS and nobody knows why until he finally drops the story about the athlete student who used to give him headaches and went on to become a top scorer and get into Beijing Sports University. That twist! I literally gasped. It mirrors everything happening right now with Huo Ye—same restless energy, same "unmanageable" reputation, same potential everyone else is too blind to see. The teacher-student thread running through the whole narrative is what holds this book together honestly. And then Wang Duoyu's subplot gets dropped in like a grenade—this spoiled rich kid sent to live with his grandma to "learn hardship," which is already comedic gold given that his bedroom looks like a hotel model room. The author is layering futures here. Every character is either hiding something or becoming someone. I kept waiting for these threads to connect and they absolutely will. Just a matter of time.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is sharp enough to cut glass and I need to discuss it immediately. 'Aren't you arrogant?' / 'Isn't my dad arrogant? Besides Grandma, is there anyone in the Shen family who isn't arrogant?' — This back-and-forth between Shen Tingyu and his mother is perfect. It's not just snappy; it's precise. Each line reveals character. His mother can't be caught off guard. She doesn't defend herself, she just goes colder: 'Shen Tingyu, are you talking back to me?' The full-name punishment. Instant silence. We don't need a single line of narration to understand the power dynamic. And Huo Ye's voice is its own thing entirely. 'Oh, so you are my young master.' Said with a smile. Not hostile, not submissive — amused. He's been waiting for this moment. Throughout the dinner, his dialogue is minimal but loaded: 'What are you laughing at?' Shen Tingyu demands, and Huo Ye just says 'I truly didn't prepare anything else. Young master, can you please make do this time?' The respect is performative, the amusement is real, and Shen Tingyu can't figure out which one to be mad at. The grandmother's voice is the warmth in the cold house: 'Yao Yao, you're back, you're back.' Repetition as love language. And then pivoting immediately to practicalities — 'wash the dishes together and learn.' That's the Shen family in one breath: sentiment and pragmatism welded together with no emotional transition. The author's command of voice across three distinctly different speakers is genuinely impressive.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or