No hope - Reviews

No hope
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about the Chinese class scene because this is where I realized the author is a absolute monster of misdirection. Shen Tingyu is doing reading comprehension questions, getting them wrong apparently, and Huo Ye leans over to critique his methodology. Shen Tingyu gets defensive and argues his case. And Huo Ye's motivation for pointing out the errors? "Because this is a way to get you to speak to me as fast as possible." LET ME REPEAT THAT. Shen Tingyu is giving him the silent treatment after the underwear incident—desks separated by books and elbows that feel like a taxi ride apart—and Huo Ye's solution is to intentionally disagree with him so he'll engage. This is not manipulation in a villainous sense. This is a socially calibrated person using academic disagreement as social glue. And the beautiful part? Shen Tingyu falls for it EVERY TIME. The text literally says: "If he refused to explain the problem, Huo Ye would push him, saying things like 'Are you unable to do it? With your intelligence, you should solve it in a few minutes,' which would inevitably prompt Shen Tingyu to snatch the notebook and start explaining." The provocation-as-attention-seeking is SO transparent and Shen Tingyu is SO vulnerable to it. Meanwhile Huo Ye is watching him lick his lips after explaining long passages and mentally comparing him to a ragdoll cat drinking water. The cat metaphor! I'm not laughing, I'm trembling. This power dynamic—Huo Ye provoking, Shen Tingyu reacting, both of them pretending this is normal—is the engine of their entire relationship. One is the spark, the other is the fuel, and together they're running somewhere neither expected.
... Read More
"Cats are good, but people are bad, especially my dad. My dad is the worst person in the world." — Huo Ye, age unknown, holding a stray cat on a park bench. This line echoes through every chapter like a mantra. It's not just backstory; it's the thesis statement for the entire book. Everything here is about who gets to be seen and who gets labeled. Bald Zhang refuses to call any student "rotten wood." The thermos is proof—ten years of loyalty to someone the world wrote off. Huo Ye himself is described by his sister as someone who loves to be vain, who performs his emotions, who asks simple questions hoping for honest answers. And then there's Wang Duoyu with his OCD-clean bedroom and luxury watches and a mother who calls him "little grandson" while keeping his room staged like a museum exhibit. Both boys are performing versions of themselves that no one asked for. The broken cup scene—Huo Ye stopping the old lady from bending down to pick up glass because her wrists are like "half-broken twigs"—that's the book telling you everything about how fragile people are when you finally pay attention. Nobody in this story is just themselves. They're all waiting for someone to look past the label.
... Read More
Okay so this one image has been stuck in my head since I finished reading. A paper crane. Just one. Tossed between classmates during an exam review session, flying out the window in a parabolic arc, landing outside the school gate at the exact moment the group photo is taken and Huo Ye and Wen Shiyi come to life below. It's almost poetic, isn't it? Like fate threading things together without anyone noticing. The scene outside the school gate is so vividly rendered—it's golden hour lighting, the shade of a tree, former classmates reuniting after what feels like forever. The contrast between Class 18's "plague gods" wandering leisurely and the top-class students rushing to avoid being late is such a sharp worldbuilding detail. You can feel the social hierarchy physically in the space. And Huo Ye walking through Classes D, C, and B on his way to Class A—everyone watching him like a magnet. The teacher in Class D slamming the podium, red-faced and hoarse, giving this whole speech about fairness and evidence and how the students' indignation is just narrow-mindedness. "The fairness you seek, others are entitled to as well." That line hit me so hard. It's the moral center of the entire chapter, really. The round-faced girl in Class D who nearly collides with Huo Ye and then flees like he's contagious—that scene is painfully observed. "Seemingly afraid of attracting trouble, the girl peeked at him while covering her bangs, then twisting her body like the weasel that stole the melon in Lu Xun's 'Old Home,' she disappeared in an instant." The author compares her to a Lu Xun reference and I SCREAMED. This level of literary texture in a web novel?? And Huo Ye's internal state while walking alone toward Class A—"When Huo Ye was by himself, he actually didn't like to smile. He was accustomed to approaching others with slightly curved eyebrows, trying to soften his tone, hoping that people wouldn't judge him too harshly by appearances; he actually thought he was quite nice." That paragraph broke me. A person who performs kindness as a defense mechanism because the world has only ever met his scary face.
... Read More
So Huo Ye sits down next to Shen Tingyu and what does our ice prince do? Glare at him silently for thirty full seconds before muttering something about being completely fine without a desk partner since middle school. Bro was clearly lying to himself AND to Huo Ye simultaneously. And Huo Ye notices EVERYTHING. He literally describes Shen Tingyu as an "aloof and feisty beautiful ragdoll cat" and I AM HERE FOR IT. The way he teases him—making him sit down, pointing out the only other options are the class pet or the trash can, watching him grind out a response that sounds suspiciously like a curse word—I've never felt this delighted to watch someone get flustered in my entire life. But here's what actually broke me: when Shen Tingyu's in the car saying "We're almost there" in that flat cold voice. There's a whole world behind those words and we haven't seen it yet. Meanwhile Huo Ye's asking his sister "Will you come back?" and that one question—how many times has someone asked it and gotten a different answer? The distance between these two boys is already collapsing without either of them realizing it.
... Read More
"At dusk, it feels particularly eerie here; the small woods next to the piano practice rooms often carry strange sounds, whispering secrets back and forth along with the music from the piano." And then the immediate whiplash: "—What? Oh, of course, it's not haunted. At such times, the disciplinary director comes looking for people with a flashlight, and they behave themselves." I need to talk about this scene description because it is *chef's kiss*. The author doesn't just build a setting—they build a mood, and then they puncture it with humor before you can get too sentimental. This is the tone of the entire book right here: gothic atmosphere undercut by the brutal realism of Chinese high school discipline. Lanjing Private High School #2 is described as being on the outskirts, in a 'serene and secluded environment,' with garden-style architecture and wide cypress paths. It sounds almost utopian at first—greenery enclosing the teaching and living areas, shade from blazing sun, students seeking relief. But then you realize this paradise is stratified. Classes A-D on the fourth floor of the western wing, parallel classes below, freshmen underneath. It's a literal social pyramid carved into architecture. The vertical hierarchy of the building mirrors the horizontal hierarchy of the student body. And then there's the Wuling Hongguang. Oh god, the Wuling Hongguang. Shen Tingyu's horror at discovering there's no back seat—just five removed seats replaced by rotting vegetable leaves and frozen meat blood smells—is one of the most vividly comedic scenes I've read. The contrast between his Maybach-expectations and the reality of sitting in a delivery van that smells like a summer kitchen is devastating. Huo Ye's complete desensitization to the stench while Shen Tingyu looks like 'a lost princess who stumbled into an old witch's wooden cabin'—I was howling. The September heat in Lanjing is described as making people 'irritable, even causing discomfort in the chest, with a feeling as if wisps of white smoke are rising from the top of one's head.' This isn't just weather description; it's atmospheric pressure for the entire narrative. Everyone is simmering. Shen Tingyu is simmering. Huo Ye is simmering. The Class 18 kids are simmering. The stage is set for an explosion.
... Read More
So Huo Ye transfers from Class 18 to Class A. On paper, this is a straightforward plot point—a underdog rising, a bully becoming a top student, the classic trope. But the author keeps undermining every easy reading. The cheating rumor follows him like a shadow. The girl who flinches when he touches her arm. The boy who moves his desk two steps away. Nobody gives him the benefit of the doubt, not even the kids in the top class who should know better. And yet—he passes through all of it almost silently. "Taking a deep breath, the teacher leaned against the podium" — wait, that's Bald Zhang's entrance. Huo Ye just... walks in. Confidently. Like he belongs. Which is either incredible self-assurance or profound naivete about what's coming. The subplot of the friend group is where the real emotional plot lives. Xiong Ying's guilt over "leading him astray" is the chapter's moral backbone. He's carrying blame for Huo Ye's entire trajectory in Class 18, and the fact that Huo Ye doesn't react when Xiong Ying says it out loud—does that mean he agrees? Does he forgive? Or is he too exhausted to care? All of these readings feel valid. Wen Shiyi's role is also interesting—quiet, observant, the one who corrects the poem, the one who takes the photo without remorse. He's the anchor of the group, the calm center. And Shen Tingyu—introduced in exactly three lines of dialogue and one glance—feels like the plot's biggest unknown variable. Whatever history he shares with Huo Ye, it's going to reshape everything. The plot here isn't moving fast, but it's moving DEEP. Every interaction is loaded with subtext. Every silence means something. I'm hooked.
... Read More
Let me tell you about the water cup scene because I CANNOT stop thinking about it. "Do you want some water? I've got it ready; it's not hot." Huo Ye pushes the cup toward Shen Tingyu. Shen Tingyu pauses—actually PAUSES—and asks, "Wait, you haven't drunk from this, right?" And Huo Ye says, "No, it's very clean." Shen Tingyu drinks anyway. Gulps too fast. Drops spill onto his chin. His adam's apple bobs. And Huo Ye just stares. Doesn't blink. When Shen Tingyu finally catches him looking and snaps "What are you looking at me for?" Huo Ye delivers: "How would you know what I'm looking at if you don't look at me?" I am SCREAMING. This is peak tension-building through almost-dialogue. They're talking about water. WATER. But they're not talking about water. Every beat in that scene is loaded—the deliberate preparation of water, the hesitation before drinking, the spill, the bobbing throat, the prolonged stare, the challenge at the end. It's like watching a slow-motion car crash where both drivers are simultaneously trying to avoid each other and also definitely want to crash. And Huo Ye is the worst. He orchestrated this entire exchange. He deliberately made Shen Tingyu talk until he was parched, prepared the water, timed the stare-down. This is a man who plays 4D chess while pretending to be a gnat spinning a pen in class. The fact that Shen Tingyu walks right into it every single time makes it even more delicious—he's annoyed, flustered, defeated, and yet he keeps engaging. The water cup is now my most analyzed object in recent literary history.
... Read More
Honestly, this stretch is where the plot stops being a smooth track and starts being a maze with hidden tripwires. The sports meet is the obvious centerpiece—the 100-meter dash, Huo Ye's dominant win, Zhao Jiayan's comic relief—but it's what bubbles underneath that actually hooks me. There's this slow-burn tension about the equipment room incident that I swear is going to blow up later. Shen Tingyu brings it up out of nowhere when he's pressed against Huo Ye's back, voice all cold and edged: “What exactly happened that day in the equipment room?” And Huo Ye just… deflects. He doesn't deny it, doesn't explain. He just asks Xiong Ying to dig up Gao Xiaoyuan's class info. That's a plot needle shoved into the ground, and I am waiting for it to sprout. Meanwhile, the Liao Zheng thread is dangling there too—Huo Ye notices he registered but isn't competing, which feels like narrative fat that'll either be trimmed or paid off. My only gripe? The pacing wavers. The morning commute and breakfast stuff is lush but drags just enough that I skimmed once. Still, the way the author stitches together public spectacle (the race, the cheering crowd) with private suspense (the whispers from the adjacent restroom) keeps you turning pages. What's your take—do you think the equipment room secret is going to fracture their whole dynamic, or is it something they'll smooth over together?
... Read More
Let's talk about the physical choreography of this passage because the author clearly understands that bodies tell stories that dialogue cannot. We have: dishwashing (proximity, shared task, Huo Ye's methodical efficiency vs Shen Tingyu's clumsy fury), the shower reveal (Shen Tingyu bare-chested, wet hair, muscles described with architectural precision—collarbones like blades, a dip that could hold water), the hairdryer hunt (domestic navigation, vulnerability), the wall-pin (physical dominance/submission swap), the water cup (shared vessel, the bobbing adam's apple, the stare), the cafeteria walk (parallel movement, shared rhythm). Each scene escalates physical closeness while emotional closeness remains stubbornly denied. The pen-spinning motif is doing heavy lifting too—Huo Ye spinning that black gel pen like it's alive, a controlled display of nonchalance that contrasts with Shen Tingyu's violent ink-soaking of paper. Even the classroom disruption (Zhang Li's flying pen, the ink splatter) serves as comic relief that underscores how Huo Ye and Shen Tingyu's tension operates on a completely different frequency. What strikes me most is how the author uses silence as a narrative tool. The three-second silence after the underwear revelation. The silent commute to the cafeteria. The silence at lunch where neither rushes to leave. These aren't empty moments—they're pressurized chambers. The author doesn't need to fill every gap with dialogue; the silences between characters who are physically close but emotionally circling is where the real story lives. It's almost cinematic in how it frames proximity—the composition of bodies in shared space tells you everything about power, desire, and the unspoken negotiation happening between them.
... Read More
The back-and-forth between Huo Ye and Shen Tingyu is honestly chef's kiss. Every line they exchange has this sharp edge to it—like they're always one step ahead of each other, ready to throw something back. The scene where Huo Ye shows off his abs and Shen Tingyu immediately yanks his shirt down? Perfect. You can feel the flush in Shen Tingyu's voice even though the text never says he's blushing. And then the basketball banter hits: "Do you know how to play golf?" "Did you score 19 points in math?" I literally screamed. This is the kind of dialogue that makes me reread paragraphs just to absorb the energy. Huo Ye's got this effortless, slippery charm—he knows exactly how to rattle Shen Tingyu and he does it constantly. But Shen Tingyu isn't some pushover either. He fires right back with this cold stare and a question about golf, and then later calls Huo Ye a rabbit when signing up for sports events. The rabbit thing still haunts me. What does that even mean? Is Huo Ye fast? Is he jittery? Or is Shen Tingyu just being annoying? The supporting cast has voices too—Wu Zhen yelling about the shot put, Zhao Jiayan saluting like a drama queen, Liao Zheng sneering from across the court. They don't all sound identical, which is rare in school fiction. Huo Ye especially carries this lazy confidence in his speech—"Our family member is also from Class A"—said so casually while basically claiming Shen Tingyu in front of everyone. Who even talks like that? Someone who knows exactly what he's doing.
... Read More
So. The underwear incident. I am not okay. I have not been okay since reading that. Shen Tingyu cornering Huo Ye against the wall—wait, let me back up. First they're washing dishes together (domestic fluff disguised as chore scene), then Huo Ye has been mopping, hanging clothes, doing literally everything in the house, and Shen Tingyu comes out of the shower like some Greek statue and demands a hairdryer. Everything seems fine. Chillingly fine, almost. And then—BAM. "Did you wash my—my innerwear?" He can't even say the word properly. And Huo Ye's response? "I handwashed it; I've already hung it up." The absolute GALL. The casual pride in his voice. Shen Tingyu loses his mind and pins him to the wall. This single scene contains more plot escalation than most entire arcs. It's domestic intimacy weaponized. The dishwashing establishes proximity, the shower scene establishes vulnerability (bare chest, wet hair—come on), and then the underwear discovery explodes everything into physical confrontation. This is how you build from awkward cohabitation to actual conflict. The author understands that tension isn't created by big events—it's created by the tiny, almost trivial things that feel monumental in the right context. And then Huo Ye just... touches his neck afterward and thinks "feels like I've been stamped by a cat's paw" and shrugs. That's not a reaction to a crisis, that's a reaction to someone who finds this entire situation mildly amusing. Who is this man and what has he done with my nervous wreck of a character?
... Read More
This book keeps offering me ice and calling it water. Look at the title—‘No Hope'—and yet every page is saturated with this desperate, humming want. The sports meet isn't just an event; it's a public arena where Huo Ye's dominance is announced, but also where Shen Tingyu's controlled world starts to sweat. That bottle of mineral water? Spilled, shared, claimed. The wall slam isn't violence—it's proximity disguised as aggression. Even the temperature shifts mirror the emotional climate: surface chill, underneath all that heat. And Gao Xiaoyuan… she's this ghost haunting the periphery. Her name isn't spoken aloud, but her absence (or presence?) in the equipment room incident hangs over everything like a question mark. When Shen Tingyu asks Huo Ye about it, he's not really asking for facts—he's asking for a piece of the puzzle he feels excluded from. The recurring motif of ears turning red, of throats going dry, of voices dropping to whispers—it all points to desire that can't quite name itself. This isn't a story about hope or despair; it's about the electric, awkward, terrifying space between ‘desk mates' and whatever comes next. The author knows that sometimes the most powerful symbolism is a half-drunk bottle of water and a heartbeat pressed against your spine.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or