Miserere Mei: Have Mercy Upon Me - Reviews

Miserere Mei: Have Mercy Upon Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
"I fell in love the moment I first saw you in the chapel." His voice was clear and forceful, yet somehow it sounded like David was trying to deceive even himself. THIS SCENE. I cannot breathe. Catherine just sits there frozen, watching David's blue eyes fill with light again after that momentary blink—"like an ivory maiden coming to life under the Creator's kiss." I swear the author wrote that specifically to make me clutch my chest. Let me walk through why this destroys me. Catherine has spent months being politely neglected by Saul. Saul who touched her hand with pity, like someone feeling sorry for an innocent child. Saul who said "Don't... love me" as if suppressing something enormous inside him. And David—David is the brother who shows up holding her arm, blocking her path, saying things that are inappropriate and impossible to ignore. But here's the thing: David's confession isn't clean. It's messy and ugly and comes at the worst moment. He's sitting there with his elbows on the table, face buried in his interlaced hands, and he blurts it out like something he can no longer contain. And then he says the most cruel and tender thing simultaneously: "Your unhappiness won't come from Saul not loving you. It will come because I love you." Catherine doesn't move. She could take one step and leave. But she's captivated. The author writes: "even knowing it was false." False how? Is David lying? Or is Catherine wrong to think it's false? Because David sounds more honest right now than Saul ever did. The marigold in Catherine's teacup keeps coming back to me. It slides along the tilted surface, taps against her lips, and drifts away. A flower that blooms unseasonably—out of time, out of place. That's exactly what this conversation feels like. And then David says "So, leave" in a solemn voice. After confessing his love, he tells her to leave? The push and pull here is absolutely suffocating. I need the next chapter immediately. I need to know what Catherine does next. My heart is literally racing.
... Read More
"You... loved him," he said softly. Not that she had loved him—she still loved him. Yet Catherine deliberately chose not to correct his words. This is where the stakes become unbearable. Let me break down what everyone is risking here. Catherine is risking everything she's built. Her position at Cavendish. Her marriage to Saul. Her own heart. She knows David loves her. She knows Saul doesn't love her. She knows she still loves Saul despite everything. Three truths that cannot coexist, and she's standing in the middle of them with no escape hatch. David is risking the only thing he has that matters. His confession is simultaneously an act of courage and self-destruction. He's telling Catherine he loves her at the worst possible moment—while she's tending to his dying (now revived) brother. He's using Saul's indifference as ammunition against his own brother. And he's saying that Catherine's unhappiness will come from HIS love, not Saul's lack of it. He's making himself the villain in his own love story, all while being the most honest person in the room. Saul is the absent presence. He didn't show up in this chapter physically, but his shadow covers everything. He made a promise to bear one child. He placed a ring on Catherine's finger. He whispered "don't love me" during their wedding. He has returned from death's door, and now David is telling Catherine to leave because Saul doesn't love her. What does Saul know? What does he not know? The author has built this entire conflict around a man who isn't even in the room. The external conflict is clear: David vs. Saul, two brothers competing for the same woman, one honest and one concealed. But the internal conflict is where this story lives or dies. Catherine's choice isn't between two men—it's between two versions of herself. The woman who made one promise and kept it, or the woman who finally lets herself want something she's never been allowed to want. Every word spoken in this teacup scene raises the stakes further. Leave or stay. Love or duty. Truth or protection. There is no safe option. That's what makes this chapter so tense—you feel like holding your breath the entire time, waiting for something to break.
... Read More
The atmosphere in these chapters is THICK. Like, you could cut it with a knife. And the way the author builds tension through environment rather than action is masterful. Let me just quote this passage because it's doing SO much work: "The crimson glow spread across the floor like crushed pomegranates and clung to their bodies. The faintly warm light stuck to their exposed skin like syrup." SYRUP. CRUSHED POMEGRANATES. This isn't just description—it's visceral, almost claustrophobic. The red light permeates everything, coating Catherine and the maid as they walk through the corridor. It's beautiful and wrong, and it perfectly mirrors the emotional state of the story: something alive and nourishing has been violently broken open. And then Catherine hears those voices from the stairwell. The servants gossiping about her and David. She freezes for a half-second, but pushes forward. The pacing here is deliberate—she moves from the bedroom (intimate, quiet) into the corridor (exposed, watched) toward the servants' quarters (dark, hidden). Each location shift increases the sense of vulnerability. The chapter structure works on two levels: the immediate tension of Saul's condition and David's disappearance, and the slower, creeping dread of the estate itself turning against Catherine. The author doesn't rush either. Samuel examines Saul, the doctor is puzzled, Catherine waits. David vanishes. Catherine searches. She finds nothing. Then the whispers. Then the gamekeeper. Then—cut to black almost. The pacing is agonizing in the best possible way. Every scene ends with more questions than answers, and the emotional weight accumulates rather than spikes. By the time Catherine sees that shadow near the chapel and thinks she spots Samuel, I was on the edge of my seat. What isn't shown is often scarier than what is.
... Read More
Let me trace the plot architecture of this entire sequence because wow. The scene opens with David insisting Catherine leave Saul's side. Catherine goes reluctantly, pushed and pulled by David's contradictory behavior—first courteous, then invasive, then withdrawn. The reader thinks we're heading toward a confrontation about Saul. Instead, David pivots hard: "Leave this place." "Anywhere that isn't Cavendish." "Because Saul is deceiving you." "Saul... doesn't love you." Each line lands like a hammer. Catherine responds calmly because she already knows this. She's lived with Saul for three months. She noticed. The fact that David is saying what she already suspected creates this beautiful dramatic irony—we know something the speaker doesn't realize the listener already understands. Then David reveals his own secret. Not about Saul. About himself. "Catherine, I love you." The entire power dynamic shifts in one sentence. Up to this point, David has been the challenger, the one with information, the protective brother. Now he's vulnerable. Exposed. He's been sitting there with his face buried in his hands, and suddenly he looks up and confesses something that changes everything. The plot structure here is surgical. Every beat escalates tension without raising its voice. The author doesn't need shouting or physical conflict—the words do all the work. David says he loves Catherine, then immediately undermines it by saying her unhappiness will come from HIS love, not Saul's indifference. He's both the cause and the solution, and he knows it. "So, leave" is the most devastating line in the entire passage. After confessing love, after laying his heart bare, David tells Catherine to go. He's pushing her away precisely because he can't bear to keep her. The contradiction IS the conflict. And Catherine's response—silent, frozen, unable to blink or tear her gaze away—suggests she's standing at the edge of a decision that will redefine every relationship in this story. The plot has arrived at its turning point. I can feel it. The ground is shifting under everyone's feet, and nothing will be the same after this room.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter aren't life-or-death on the surface but they feel enormous because they're about TRUST. Catherine already doesn't trust David, and she has every reason not to—he whispered false love, he threatened her. But then he does this genuinely considerate thing with the coat, and she has to navigate: is he sincere now or is this another performance? The powder adds a physical danger element—Samuel says it 'shouldn't be harmful' but his hesitation says otherwise. And then there's the deeper stake: Catherine is investigating her late husband's brother while possibly developing actual feelings for him. That's a trap waiting to happen. The David POV section where he calls himself morally failed and admits he wanted to 'prevent tragedy' but ended up causing it anyway—that's him acknowledging the stakes are real. He genuinely fears he's the villain in her story, and that self-awareness makes everything more tense because you can't tell if he's right or if he's manipulating even his own guilt.
... Read More
There's a specific quality to the atmosphere in these chapters that I can't quite put my finger on, but it's haunting me. The manor is described as "extremely noisy" with servants whispering and bickering in the corridors, but when Catherine reaches the third-floor landing, the noise falls away into something much heavier. The bedroom where Saul lies is quiet—too quiet. It's the silence of a place where death has recently been waiting and then been persuaded to leave. David is described against this stillness, his golden hair cascading over his white nape, his forehead pressed to his interlaced fingers. The visual is so cinematic: candlelight (I assume, though not explicitly stated), the pale shape of Saul in the bed, David's bowed posture beside him like a knight keeping vigil. The contrast between the noisy downstairs world and the hushed upstairs world is doing a lot of work here. Downstairs, the servants are scheming, gossiping, calculating who will benefit from Saul's possible death. Upstairs, there's only prayer and silence and Catherine's heartbeat. The author uses this vertical architecture—the manor itself—to map the social and emotional hierarchy of the story. I also want to note the sensory details that make this world feel lived-in: the lukewarm water Catherine drinks, the bottle of warmed goat's milk on the servants' tray, the cold skin of Saul's hand, the sound of footsteps fading down the stairs. None of this is decorative—it's all functional. The goat's milk tells us something about the household's resources and priorities. The lukewarm water tells us Catherine hasn't been properly attended to. Every small detail grounds us in a physical reality. The priest's departure is another atmospheric beat that works on multiple levels. They leave "in obvious haste," their bodies "on fire" to spread the news of Saul's revival. This isn't just plot convenience—it tells us that Saul's death and resurrection matter beyond this household. The church is watching. The world is watching. And the manor, with its whispered conversations and sideways glances, is a pressure vessel about to explode.
... Read More
David carrying his unconscious brother back from wherever he collapsed. That's the image that won't leave me. Everything we knew about their relationship — the close bond, the shared childhood, the hunting dog that obeyed them both — gets reframed by this single moment. Who brought him in? The second young master. Not the servants. Not the doctors. David. This changes everything about how I read their current dynamic. Saul is the sick, fragile one. David is... well, we don't actually know where David is or what he's doing, do we? The fact that the brothers were close and then something happened around the time of the collapse is the kind of detail that always signals betrayal, abandonment, or grief so profound it broke something irreparable. And the text doesn't confirm which one it is, which is torture. The maid character is interesting too. She's the first servant who's ever主动 offered to help Catherine beyond her duties, and she does it by reaching out to her aunt who used to work at the castle. There's something almost childlike about her enthusiasm — "May I go send a letter right away?" — like she's thrilled to be included in something important. It reminds me that Catherine has spent her whole life being managed by other people's agendas (her guardian, the Cavendish household staff) and here is someone genuinely choosing to help her. That moment of trust between them felt really significant, especially considering how guarded Catherine has been about her investigations. But what about Catherine herself? Her reaction to the gamekeeper's stories is fascinating. She can barely imagine the brothers being close. She's so conditioned to seeing Saul as just... ill, just... present, that the idea of him as a healthy child is almost incomprehensible. What has this marriage done to her perception of her own husband? And what has the collapse done to David, if he was the one who found him?
... Read More
The atmosphere in this chapter is SO specific. The broom shrubs lining the winding path, the leafless skeletal branches, the winter air—that's not just background, that's almost a character. And the lighting! Catherine holding the vial up toward the light leaking from inside the house, examining the powder like some kind of occult relic. The author writes with such tactile sensory detail: the sharp nauseating scent, the cold ground David sat on, the warmth of the coat, the rough tap of Samuel's hand on the chair armrest. Every scene has this muted, wintry palette that makes everything feel suspended and fragile. Even the colonnade casting shade is significant—Catherine stays in the open while David disappears into shadow inside the building. It's like the setting itself is reflecting their relationship: cold on the surface, something hidden underneath, and neither of them willing to step into the light about it.
... Read More
I need a minute. The opening passage about Catherine's backstory absolutely wrecked me and I wasn't prepared for it. Let me just... she never had anyone. Her mother died when she was basically a baby, and then this 'kind but foolish man'—the executioner—takes her in out of pity. She grows up begging for warmth from a man who killed people for a living, and when she's barely ten, he dies. Killed by hunting dogs released by HIS master. She literally steps over his red blood to become 'Blue-blooded Catherine.' That imagery is so violently beautiful it makes my chest hurt. And then she meets Saul. This sickly, fragile-seeming man who proposes with his 'utterly dry manner' and says he wants to 'purchase your death.' Catherine thinks he's just another powerful person who will take what he wants, same as everyone who ruined her life. But there's this moment—I can't stop thinking about it—where she says he might have been right that she was living a 'living life,' and she uses the price of her sold death to 'transform a dead man's life.' She throws herself into saving him even while knowing he might die. And then he DOES die, and comes BACK, and she's there holding his cold hand feeling those fingers weakly grip hers back, and she presses her forehead against their clasped hands. I literally had to put the book down and breathe.
... Read More
The structure of these chapters is a masterclass in controlled escalation and I need to talk about it. We open with what reads like a climax — David's quasi-confession, the door-blocking, the threatening undertones. It's intense. It's confrontational. And then the author deliberately deflates it. Catherine walks away. David lets her. He even opens the door for her like a gentleman. The tension snaps but doesn't resolve — it just... hangs there. Then we CUT to three days later. Not a single scene of aftermath, not a single line about how Catherine processed that conversation. Just: three days have passed, David hasn't left, Saul hasn't woken. This compression is brutal. It tells us that whatever happened between them, it didn't matter as much as the coma does. The personal drama is secondary to the life-and-death stakes. That's a deliberate choice that says a lot about what the story values. The middle section — the caregiving routine — is almost meditative. Wiping, shaving, warm water, cool water. Repetitive, domestic, quiet. This is where the chapter breathes. And it's here that David's character shifts from threat to something more complicated. He's helpful. Attentive. Almost sweet in his clumsiness with the windowsill height adjustment. The author is making us LIKE him a little, which makes everything that follows more troubling. Then the shaving turns into the waist-grabbing moment. The pacing SHIFTS again — from domestic calm to physical closeness to... wait, what's happening now? And just as we're leaning into that romantic tension: Saul's eyes open. In one beat. One sentence. The entire chapter pivots from slow-burn romantic drama to emergency. The structure doesn't give us any transition time — we're dropped into the panic alongside Catherine and David. No breathing room. Just: red eyes. Saul. Awake. The chapter ends mid-sentence — "Just as Saul, who had be" — and honestly I think that's the author being a bit cruel. We don't even get the full sentence. David rushes out. Catherine is already moving. The cliffhanger isn't just "what happens next?" it's "we didn't even finish the thought." The pacing here is essentially: confrontation → deflation → routine → escalation → catastrophe → cliffhanger. Five movements in what feels like a single sitting. I stayed up way too late reading this.
... Read More
I need to sit with the candle scene for a minute. Catherine lighting that cheap animal-fat candle and being immediately transported back to her childhood — that was brutal. The author doesn't even need dramatic language. Just: "a foolish but kind-hearted man who had taken in Catherine," getting ready by candlelight to execute someone. The tenderness of it. He didn't want to wake her. He embraced her with "sorrowful tenderness" when she cried. He was angry at her for following him but then couldn't stay mad. "Looking back, he was truly a foolish man. Though he could hardly be called a good guardian... he had been faithful to the young Catherine." Faithful. That's the word that destroys me. Not loving. Not perfect. Faithful. There's such profound loneliness in that sentence. A girl raised by a man who did the state's dirty work, who tried his best with imperfect tools, who gave her love in the only way he knew how. And then — immediately after this tender memory — Catherine walks into her nightmare. The clapping. The dogs. The hunting dog lunging at her. The text moves from the most gentle childhood memory to the most violent childhood fear with zero buffer. That's not accidental. The executioner's world and the hunting dogs are the same world: controlled violence, duty above comfort, love expressed through protection from horrors the child isn't meant to see. Catherine running after the clapping sound, forgetting she's an adult, forgetting everything except the need to stop it — that's a trauma response written with real understanding. She's not running FROM the sound. She's running TOWARD it. To stop the man from doing whatever it is he's about to do. The same compulsion that made her follow the executioner as a child. The same need to be there when death happens. Has she run from this her whole life or toward it?
... Read More
I need to talk about this scene because I am STILL not over it. David traces his thumb between Catherine's knuckles, exploring the hollow space between her middle and ring fingers, and lets his nail slide down her ring finger. He's marking territory without saying a word. He's testing whether she feels it too. And Catherine—oh God, Catherine freezes completely. She doesn't pull away. She doesn't slap him. She just... stops breathing. What makes this moment so devastating is the contrast with what we know about their relationship. Earlier, the servant girl asks Catherine whether David has feelings for her, and Catherine's immediate reaction is to laugh it off. She remembers his "cold gaze" and shakes her head. She doesn't want to see it. But the text makes it crystal clear: she's lying to herself. David has been sitting beside Saul's deathbed for days, not eating, not resting, and when Catherine touches his shoulder, he startles like a man caught doing something sacred. And then there's Saul. "This was the hand Catherine should be holding." Even as she says this to herself, the prose itself is asking the question: SHOULD it be? Saul is "thin and gaunt," his wound unhealed, barely breathing. David is alive, blue-eyed, devoted. The novel is constructing this unbearable triangle where love isn't the problem—loyalty is. I also want to highlight the servant girl as a character. She's barely in the text but she's the one who names the thing everyone else is pretending not to see. She asks about David's feelings, she notices the servants' gossip, and when Catherine dismisses her, the girl's shoulders droop in this heartbreaking little moment of disappointment. She WANTS Catherine to see it. She wants the story to go differently. The butler is interesting too—he shuttles between Catherine and David, reading the room with "slightly narrowed eyes," sensing something he can't quite name. He's the chorus character, the one who reflects back the tension without understanding it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or