I need to talk about this scene because I am STILL not over it.
David traces his thumb between Catherine's knuckles, exploring the hollow space between her middle and ring fingers, and lets his nail slide down her ring finger. He's marking territory without saying a word. He's testing whether she feels it too. And Catherine—oh God, Catherine freezes completely. She doesn't pull away. She doesn't slap him. She just... stops breathing.
What makes this moment so devastating is the contrast with what we know about their relationship. Earlier, the servant girl asks Catherine whether David has feelings for her, and Catherine's immediate reaction is to laugh it off. She remembers his "cold gaze" and shakes her head. She doesn't want to see it. But the text makes it crystal clear: she's lying to herself. David has been sitting beside Saul's deathbed for days, not eating, not resting, and when Catherine touches his shoulder, he startles like a man caught doing something sacred.
And then there's Saul. "This was the hand Catherine should be holding." Even as she says this to herself, the prose itself is asking the question: SHOULD it be? Saul is "thin and gaunt," his wound unhealed, barely breathing. David is alive, blue-eyed, devoted. The novel is constructing this unbearable triangle where love isn't the problem—loyalty is.
I also want to highlight the servant girl as a character. She's barely in the text but she's the one who names the thing everyone else is pretending not to see. She asks about David's feelings, she notices the servants' gossip, and when Catherine dismisses her, the girl's shoulders droop in this heartbreaking little moment of disappointment. She WANTS Catherine to see it. She wants the story to go differently.
The butler is interesting too—he shuttles between Catherine and David, reading the room with "slightly narrowed eyes," sensing something he can't quite name. He's the chorus character, the one who reflects back the tension without understanding it.