It’s Him - Reviews

It’s Him
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so Zhao Jingzheng literally stays up all night rewatching surveillance footage and the breakthrough comes from a GARBAGE BIN. Like, I cannot stress enough how brilliant this is. All this time the police were probably looking for elaborate kidnapping scenarios or hidden rooms or something dramatic, and the killer's actually just pushing a wheeled bin down a slope like it's trash day. "One of the cleaners was pushing a garbage bin out, and when going up a slope, it seemed to be very heavy. The garbage bin had wheels, and the cleaner wasn't weak, so there had to be something inside the bin." And Zhao Jingzheng just... stares at it. His heart skips a beat. The simplicity of it is what makes it so terrifying—you'd literally pass it every day and never think twice. Then Li Xun's reasoning about not calling the police immediately? Chef's kiss. She's like, wait, if we alert the janitor now, they might panic and kill your dad. This is such a smart narrative choice because it forces them to operate outside the system, which means everything that goes wrong from here is on THEM, not the authorities. It raises the stakes massively. And then Zhao Laoshi's manipulation scheme—trying to get Li Xun to murder someone so they're both complicit? That is WILD. He's basically saying, "Let's all be criminals together so we can't be caught." The plot has been tightening like a noose this entire batch and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
The kidnapping scene has stakes that escalate without a single explosion. Teacher Zhao is bound. Gagged. Eyes forced open with tape. And the captor — we slowly realize — is Li Yugui, his ex-student's mother. She promised not to kill him. But she's holding an iron rod. She couldn't help herself. The line "She shouldn't have tortured the person. That was something they had agreed upon from the beginning" — AGREED UPON. This wasn't a spontaneous crime. This was planned. Someone hurt a student, and the family decided to take matters into their own hands. Teacher Zhao knew this was coming. He saw the rumor sketch in class and that very night was kidnapped. Meanwhile, upstairs, Li Xun has NO IDEA. She's asking about a catering job. She's worried her mother is curing bacon illegally. The dramatic irony is suffocating. And the external stakes — the police are searching. Cyber police are tracing the rumor poster. If Teacher Zhao doesn't show up within 48 hours, the case opens. Every hour matters. The chapter ends on the basement door creaking, footsteps above, and Li Xun calling "Mom" like nothing is wrong. The reader is screaming. That gap between what the character knows and what we know IS the tension. It doesn't need gunshots. It just needs a daughter walking toward a kitchen while her mother descends into darkness below.
... Read More
The stakes in this book just keep escalating and I can't breathe. Let me list what everyone has to lose: Zhao Laoshi—he's tied up in a basement, possibly facing death if he doesn't cooperate, and if he DOES cooperate, he might be signing his own death warrant if he's actually innocent. Li Xun—her mother is a kidnapper, possibly a murderer, and Li Xun is the only thing standing between her mom and life in prison. But if she exposes her mom, she loses the only family she has. If she protects her mom, she becomes complicit. Zhao Jingzheng—his father is missing, he's been used as a pawn in someone else's investigation, and he has no idea how deep this goes. And Li Yugui—she's lost her child to a serial killer, the law hasn't helped her, so she's created her own version of justice. Every character is cornered. Every character is making impossible choices. The tension isn't just about 'who is the killer'—it's about whether any of these people can get out alive, morally intact, or with their families still together. When Li Xun says 'we're in a difficult position. Someone has to take a step back,' she's understating it the way only a seventeen-year-old who's already compromised everything can.
... Read More
The stakes in this novel escalate in the most masterful way. We start with an internet forum post—'maybe I had this dream because I was murdered in a past life'—and within seven chapters, we've got a body exhumed from a construction site, a killer sketch that looks like a beloved teacher, and a high school student who is now carrying the entire weight of a seventeen-year-old cold case on her shoulders. What makes the tension so unbearable is the isolation factor. Li Xun can't check the news Monday through Friday. She's in a boarding school environment where information is controlled. So she posts these fragments of her dream and has to WAIT days to see if anyone responds. Meanwhile, the police are apparently already at her door. Meanwhile, her homeroom teacher—THE man who took her in when no one else would, who defends her every day—might be the most dangerous person in the city. The scene where Teacher Zhao's hand trembles while holding the newspaper is the turning point where everything shifts from mystery to personal danger. Before that, it was just a weird internet story. After that, Li Xun knows (and the reader knows) that the teacher is connected to this case. But she has to keep sitting in his class, keep listening to his gentle advice about eating and resting, keep pretending nothing is wrong. The dramatic irony is suffocating. And the ending of Chapter 7—'Homeroom teacher?'—that single question mark after the title is doing more work than an entire chapter of exposition. The sketch is complete. The face is known. And now the girl has to figure out what to do with a truth that could get her killed. The stakes have never been higher, and I am absolutely not ready for what happens next.
... Read More
I need to talk about Li Xun and her mother because this relationship killed me. We're talking about a daughter who hasn't seen her mother since she was SIX, and then suddenly her mom just shows up at the school gates every day with a tricycle full of baozi. And these two sit across from each other at dinner like… strangers. Not even awkward like stepmom-stepdaughter awkward. More like they're genuinely practicing a script they both forgot half of. "Playing the roles of a loving mother and obedient daughter" — THAT LINE hit so hard. Who talks like that in real life? That's not a relationship, that's a performance review. But then the tiny moments show up. Li Xun tells her mom EVERYTHING about school. Every detail. The class teacher taking the paper, his hands trembling — and her mother going silent for a long time. What was she thinking in that silence? I keep coming back to that quiet. And the mother — Li Yugui — she's selling baozi at 2am to keep her daughter in school. That's not obligation, that's love spoken in flour and steam. She chose this life of exhaustion without anyone asking her to. The whole dynamic reminds me of Chinese family novels where love is expressed through labor, not words. They don't hug. They don't say "I love you." They wake up at 2am and make bread. I also need to mention Teacher Zhao and Qin Li's backstory. A woman who felt she was losing her mind from postpartum isolation, married to a man so gentle she could yell at his colleagues and he'd just… absorb it. She called herself a tigress. He called her nothing. That silence was either incredible patience or incredible erasure. Both are possible at once.
... Read More
The opening dream sequence in Chapter 1 is genuinely unsettling in a way that stuck with me for hours. The author doesn't give us a traditional horror setup—no jump scares, no monsters. Instead we get this slow, methodical degradation of a girl's body in darkness. Can't keep eyes closed. Can't speak. Someone slapping her. Pinching her neck. Twisting her ear. Then the stomach incident—cut open, stuffed with dry grass, buried in stinky mud. It's clinical in its brutality, which somehow makes it worse. You can almost SMELL that mud through the screen. But then the novel pivots to this warm morning light hitting a fenced-off basketball court construction site, and Li Xun sleepwalking three kilometers from her house to stand exactly where a body is buried. That contrast between the dark nightmare world and the bright, ordinary-looking construction site is gorgeous writing. She posted a photo showing 'early morning sunlight shining warmly'—and underneath that warmth was death. The visual of her standing there feeling this overwhelming urge to just lie down, to merge with wherever her past-life body rests, is haunting. The school itself is such a vividly rendered world. Pingcheng High School under that level of academic pressure, where even entertainment gossip is contraband, where students are so starved for distraction that a four-yuan self-printed newspaper becomes an underground economy. Li Xun's operation—printing horror stories and school news under the guise of study materials—is such a brilliant detail. It shows exactly how suffocating this environment is while simultaneously giving us a protagonist who's resourceful and sharp. The world feels ALIVE, not just as backdrop but as something that actively shapes every character's choices.
... Read More
I need to talk about Li Yugui's backstory because honestly it hit me like a truck. The section about her childhood—no one caring when she had a fever, brain not functioning as well as others, bullied, disliked by teachers, patriarchal family, forced marriage—it's brutal. But what got me wasn't the suffering itself, it was what she did AFTER. She found one pure thing: her daughter. And that love basically rewired her. The text says 'her twisted soul was stretched for the first time' and I literally got chills. This is a woman who spent her whole life seeking love from people who couldn't give it, and the one person who loved her unconditionally was a child who couldn't even speak yet. Then the killer happened. The part where she says 'She didn't want to forget that day. In fact, she was afraid of forgetting it'—that's not trauma, that's identity. The killer became the most significant event of her life, and without it, who is she? So when she hears that voice at the school and her body remembers before her mind catches up—the vomiting, the smell of osmanthus and blood, the phantom pain in her healed wound—this isn't just PTSD, this is a person whose entire emotional architecture collapsed and had to be rebuilt around vengeance. And Zhang Mingcai? She's not just a friend here. She's someone who saw Li Yugui at her most broken and chose to stand beside her instead of running. That's the kind of bond that doesn't come from friendship forums or group chats. It comes from shared absence—the absence of children who should have grown up.
... Read More
The dialogue in this batch is deceptively casual. Everyone sounds like someone I've actually sat across from at a breakfast counter. Sister Zhang: "The price is negotiable, and the dishes are simple." — She's haggling over a family dinner like it's a bulk order. That's how Chinese aunties negotiate. Not with emotion, with logistics. The elderly neighbor: "If anyone should cure bacon, it's me. At my age, if they want to arrest me, let them." — This woman is IMMUNE to consequences. She's seventy-plus and proud. You can hear her smirk between the lines. Li Xun to her grandmother-figure: "Grandma, bacon isn't healthy. You shouldn't eat it anymore. It's bad for digestion. Please stop." — The "please stop" at the end. That's not negotiation. That's a daughter who has learned that polite persistence works better than arguing. And the quietest dialogue of all: Teacher Zhao, bound and gagged, saying nothing. Not a word. The narration tells us this is strategic — "Anything he said would be useless until she calmed down." But it's also character. A man who never raised his voice in marriage, who absorbed his wife's rage for years — of course he stays silent now. Silence is his language. The narrative voice itself has this dry, almost detached quality that lets the horror seep in sideways. It describes a kidnapped man with the same calm tone it uses to describe a baozi recipe. That tonal consistency is what makes the horror work. The author never raises its voice. The horror raises it for you.
... Read More
Let me just say this: that scene where Li Xun pulls out the burned piece of paper from her pocket? CHILLS. Absolute chills. She found it after Teacher Zhao was burning something late at night, and of course she didn't throw it away—she kept it. And then she searched the names on it, found Li Hao at the top, her own name at the bottom, and connected the dots that no one else had managed to connect. "One time I came home late and saw the homeroom teacher burning something from a distance. After he left, I picked this up." That's it. That's the whole mechanism of how she became dangerous. She wasn't taught to investigate—she's a janitor now, hiding in plain sight. But she has this relentless curiosity, this refusal to let things go. And the way the author structures this reveal is masterful. We already know from earlier chapters that Teacher Zhao is involved in student deaths. But we don't know THAT SHE KNEW ALL ALONG and was sitting on it, gathering evidence like a spider waiting in its web. Then there's the flashback structure—cutting from the present-day alliance-building to the past, to Sun Ning's first week teaching, to the students' rebellion, to that moment on the rooftop with Li Hao holding that suicide note like a weapon. The narrative doesn't just tell us Teacher Zhao is manipulative; it SHOWS us the machinery of his control, one layer at a time. He played both the students AND the teacher against each other, positioning himself as the gentle intermediary while undermining her authority at every turn. The parallel between the two women—Li Xun, the survivor hiding among janitors, and Sun Ning, the teacher who thought she was helping but was actually being weaponized—is the kind of structural symmetry that makes a thriller feel inevitable in hindsight. Both were used. Both are waking up now. And the fact that Li Xun approached Sun Ning with that fragile, almost childlike act—red eyes, weak voice, pretending to be a scared student—while internally she's running a cold, calculating operation? That contrast is what makes the plot sing.
... Read More
The basement scenes are giving me serious psychological thriller vibes and I am here for it. Let me paint the picture for you: there's this old teacher tied up, no light, just the faint glow of a phone screen, the smell of the basement still hanging in the air. Li Xun calmly takes away the only light and everything goes dark. Not dramatic. Not shaky. Just... off the switch. Like she's turning off a classroom lamp after the last student leaves. Then contrast that with the moxibustion clinic scene. Qin Li running her shop, chatting with regular customers about their aching shoulders, completely normal middle-class atmosphere. The smell of moxa, the warmth, the mundane social rituals of a small business. And Zhao Jingzheng sitting in the corner like a ghost of his own family, resentful and ignored. This woman who gave him life treats him like furniture while she boasts about his graduate school achievements to strangers. The most chilling image though is Li Xun going upstairs after whatever happened down there, lying in bed, looking at the ceiling turning 'cold white under the streetlight outside,' then picking up her phone to search for sentencing guidelines on body disposal. She exhaled like she'd released something trapped inside her, then immediately went to the internet. That transition from darkness to a bedroom lit by streetlight to cold blue phone glow — it's like she's physically moving between two worlds and never once questioning which one is real. I also love how the novel uses these tight confined spaces. The basement is claustrophobic. The clinic is suffocatingly ordinary. Li Xun's bedroom is this liminal space between the two. Every location feels like a character itself.
... Read More
There's this one moment where Zhang Mingcai first enters the house and notices something wrong—not visually, but audibly. Some floorboards make different sounds when stepped on. She goes to investigate while the agent is distracted and finds a secret door. That detail alone—her music background making her sensitive to acoustics—tells you so much about how this world works. The house almost gave itself away. The basement was never meant to be hidden from someone paying attention, which makes me think about all the other basements out there in this city, all the rental houses where nobody asked about the creaky floorboard. And then there's the actual description of the basement door itself: the thick rectangular bolt, the patterns on the door making inspection time-consuming, the way they have to check it 'inch by inch' in the dark. This isn't a cinematic dungeon. It's a mundane basement in a rented house that happens to sit next to a school. The mundanity is what makes it terrifying. Later, Zhao's explanation of the hidden panel—near the bolt, inconspicuous, requiring you to press the metal bolt and slide it inch by inch in total darkness—turns the whole space into a trap designed by someone who understood fear. The architect of this basement wasn't just hiding something. They were building a cage for people who are afraid of confinement, knowing full well that fear makes you stupid. And the osmanthus scent that haunts Li Yugui? That's not just sensory detail. That's the house breathing memory into her. Every corner of that basement is saturated with twenty years of unresolved grief.
... Read More
The basement scene in this chapter is one of those moments that just sits in your chest for hours. Li Xun walks in and this overwhelming chemical smell hits her—"a strong chemical smell hit her nose. Her mind immediately conjured up images of a murder, dismemberment, and the use of chemicals to dispose of the body." Every instinct screams WORST POSSIBLE SCENARIO. And then—cough. From the corner. He's alive. But the imagery of it all... Zhao Laoshi chained to a cement pillar with a one-meter chain. "It was actually more humiliating than being completely bound, as it made him feel like a dog." That single comparison says everything about the power dynamic in that room. He's physically restrained but psychologically dominating the entire conversation. The basement itself feels like a character—cramped, chemical-stained, claustrophobic, a place where truths come out that would never surface in daylight. Then you cut to the school—bright, normal, surveillance cameras everywhere but most broken, teachers and students flowing through gates like nothing is wrong. The contrast between the mundane school environment and the monstrous secret buried in that basement is exquisite. And the scene with Zhang Mingcai, the janitor, receiving a phone call about a student asking questions? Her hand going to her phone, the immediate alertness, the quick text exchange—it's so grounded and realistic. You can feel the panic beneath the calm surface. The world of this story feels incredibly tangible, like it could exist on your street.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or