It’s Him - Reviews

It’s Him
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about that one detail because I can't stop thinking about it. The text describes Li Yugui's scar: "from her heart to her navel." Do you understand what that means? That's not just an injury. That is a C-section scar. She gave birth. She survived childbirth. And yet her child died. Twenty-five years she dreamed of killing someone. Twenty-five years of carrying this wound—literally and figuratively. And now the person she wants dead is sitting in her basement, and she CAN'T kill him because she needs information about where her child is buried. The stakes here are so layered. She's a victim who became a potential victimizer, someone whose grief is so vast it's warping her moral compass. And then there's the other mother figure in this scene—the one from the old serial killing case. The single mother selling dumplings, stabbed almost to death trying to protect her child. "Disemboweled," the text says. The word keeps appearing and it connects both women across time. One lost her child and survived with a scar on her belly. The other was ripped open in an industrial area at night and may or may not have died. These aren't coincidental details. The novel seems obsessed with maternal grief as a force that can either create or destroy. Li Xun's mother is choosing vengeance; the dumpling seller chose sacrifice. Both are shaped by the same kind of love that runs deeper than reason. What do you think? Is the book saying grief makes monsters, or does it reveal who we already are?
... Read More
Okay so can we talk about how Li Xun becomes this suddenly competent guardian figure to Zhao Jingzheng while also being this terrifyingly pragmatic daughter to her own mom?? Like the contrast is wild. She's sitting in a basement threatening to kill someone's a teacher, but then she's also Googling legal consequences for disposing of bodies like it's a normal Tuesday question. And Zhao Jingzheng — I felt so bad for him honestly. His dad goes missing and who does he turn to? His mom? Nope. He goes to his mom's moxibustion clinic and she's just like 'here's some gossip about a regular customer, also your grad school achievement makes me proud.' She's completely emotionally absent. Meanwhile Li Xun is the one organizing investigation strategies, negotiating with entrepreneurs, assigning tasks. She literally says 'we're not afraid to talk' and he feels this wave of relief because she's become the parent figure his actual parent refuses to be. There's this one line where Zhao Jingzheng thinks about how his first instinct was his mom, but she 'hadn't been able to take over the responsibility.' Then Li Xun 'picked up the baton' and his anxiety vanished. That hit hard. It's not romantic — at least I don't think it's meant to be read that way — it's more like she's the capable one in a world where the adults have completely failed. The mother-daughter dynamic is even more messed up. Li Xun kidnaps a teacher to protect her mom, feeds him Snickers bars while interrogating him, and says 'I only want to protect my mom. I won't believe that you won't call the police once you get out.' She's simultaneously a victim of her mother's chaos and an accomplice to it. Does she even realize how unhinged that sounds, or has she normalized it to the point where she genuinely thinks she's the reasonable one here?
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this: the reveal about the hidden panel near the bolt absolutely floored me. The narrator had been shaking that door from the inside thinking it was locked, and it turns out there's this mechanism that would let someone open it—except it's 'nearly impossible for an ordinary person to do this.' In the dark. By touch. Inch by inch. Which means either someone very clever was in there all along, or the whole setup of them trapping Zhao was built on a foundation of wishful thinking. And then Zhao himself says 'I guessed it could open. I touched it, and it opened.' Wait, WHAT. So he KNEW? He knew the door could be opened from the inside and still went along with being locked in there? That's not the behavior of an innocent man. That's either a deeply calculated performance or something way more complicated. And the timeline stuff—they locked him in early because of what exploded online, abandoning their original plan to wait until after the college entrance exam? The plot just keeps pivoting on these desperate decisions and I'm here for it. Also, the fact that Zhang Mingcai originally wanted to be careful and rational but then admits 'she was the least rational' right when it matters most—that's such a classic thriller move where the people chasing justice become the thing they're hunting.
... Read More
The dialogue in this batch is absolutely vicious and I love it. Zhao Laoshi and Li Xun's exchanges read like two people playing chess where the pieces are other people's lives. Watch how he probes: "If your mother is arrested, your future will be ruined." Not a threat—a statement of fact, delivered with the calm tone of someone discussing the weather. And her response? "I won't let that happen." Two words. No elaboration. She doesn't explain how, doesn't negotiate, just... declares war. But the real masterpiece is Zhao Laoshi's proposal: "All you need to do is help me kill someone." Think about how insane that is. A man who murdered children is casually offering a hostage's daughter a partnership in murder. And the way he phrases it—"We'll both be on the same boat, so things will be easier to discuss"—he's making it sound almost reasonable. That's the voice of someone who has never once faced consequences and has built an entire personality around操纵他人. Meanwhile Zhao Jingzheng's dialogue with the janitor is this perfect contrast—stilted, nervous, clearly fake. "Auntie, who is usually in charge of cleaning the trash bins at night?" He's terrible at this, adorable and desperate, and it makes you want to scream at the page. The author gives every character a distinctly different verbal rhythm, which makes conversations feel like actual people talking rather than plot devices mouthings lines.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—this entire batch is a masterclass in layering. You start with what seems like a straightforward missing person investigation, Zhao Jingzheng and Li Xun visiting victims' families, trying to track down the truth. Then BAM. The basement scene. Zhao Laoshi tied up, Li Xun with an A4 paper mask, flashlight in hand. The twist isn't just that her mom kidnapped the teacher—it's that Li Xun already KNEW her mother was involved and still went there anyway. That line where she quietly tells Uncle (who she suspects might be the killer) 'I actually suspect that his father is the murderer' right in front of Zhao Jingzheng?? CHILLING. She's playing both sides, gathering info, protecting her secret while making it look like she's helping. And then the whole negotiation scene—Zhao Laoshi realizing he's trapped between Li Xun's vengeful mother and his own possible guilt. The plot doesn't stop there either. The whole setup about the sketch appearing hours after the disappearance, Li Xun's deduction that it couldn't have been a victim's family member because the timing doesn't work—it's all woven together so tightly. Every clue connects. The story builds this pressure cooker and then cracks it open in the most unexpected way.
... Read More
I keep coming back to Li Xun. She's mentioned in barely a paragraph but she's doing SO MUCH emotional work in this text. On the surface she's just 'the smart daughter who got into trouble at school and might get expelled,' right? But read between the lines and she's the moral compass of the entire story. She told Teacher Zhao she didn't care whether he was the murderer or not—but the text immediately undercuts that by saying 'through her observations, Li Xun was certain that Teacher Zhao had blood on his hands.' This is a teenager who has been forced to grow up in the shadow of her mother's trauma, who watches her mother hunt a killer, who knows her mother is now part of a criminal plot, and who is still trying to solve both cases 'so she could figure out a way to get her mother out of this mess.' Who does that? What kind of child volunteers to be the rescue plan for a parent who has become an avenger? And then there's Zhao Jingzheng—Zhao's son—getting text messages about incidents at school, growing up in the teacher dormitory, supposedly unaware of anything. But the text ends with 'none of them involve' and cuts off, and I am SCREAMING. What don't they involve? Violence? Death? CONNECTIONS to his father? The entire second generation in this book is carrying burdens they never asked for, and the emotional weight of that is just… I can't. The parent-child dynamics here are everything. Every love story in this book is fundamentally about parents and children, and every single one of them is broken in a different direction.
... Read More
I have to stop and just appreciate how the author constructs Teacher Zhao as a villain who literally cannot be threatened by conventional means. Li Xun tries everything in her head—hunger, pain, isolation, freedom—and none of it works. The text says it outright: "In her view, Teacher Zhao was a fully developed pervert with no weaknesses. He didn't care about his son; if the son died, he'd probably breathe a sigh of relief, cry dramatically in front of others, and pretend to be a pitiful father." Think about that. The man who orchestrated a student's suicide can FUND the act of grief while feeling nothing. He performs pain so perfectly that even his own son becomes a prop in his theater of suffering. That's not just evil—that's a psychological architecture so refined it's almost beautiful, which makes it infinitely more horrifying. And Li Xun, who has never hit a wall in her life, who has always been clever enough to solve every problem before it solves her—this is the FIRST TIME she's faced something she can't outsmart. The stakes shift from "can she catch him" to "is there even a way to catch him?" "This was the first time she encountered such a big setback. She spent the whole night with her eyes wide open, staring at the ceiling, mentally simulating the childhood, youth, and present of this person." That sentence. JUST that sentence. A woman who has spent her whole life one step ahead of disaster, lying awake at 5 AM, trying to reverse-engineer a predator's psychology. The suspense isn't in action scenes—it's in this quiet, desperate mental gymnastics. Every hypothesis she generates (the noisy children, the irritable parents) is a thread she's pulling, hoping something will unravel. Meanwhile, the structural stakes keep escalating. Li Xun now has Sun Ning involved. Sun Ning has the original suicide note. They're building a case, but they're also putting her in danger—because Teacher Zhao is still out there, and he's someone who turns grief into ammunition. The question isn't just whether they'll succeed. It's whether the pursuit of justice will cost Sun Ning the same thing it cost Li Xun.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this one part because it wrecked me and I can't stop thinking about it. Li Xun, this woman who has lost everything—her father-in-law dead by his own hand, her ex-husband remarried and moved on, everyone who went through that horror with her except her—she ends up among these older rural women cleaning school floors. And instead of being miserable about it, she LISTENS to them. She learns their lives. She knits sweaters secretly during shifts and teaches them phone apps. "She had a good relationship with the other janitors, and they all worked the same dirty, tiring job." But the line that got me—really got me—was: "What Zhang Mingcai didn't know was that these people considered her one of their own. When one of their own has a small problem like this, of course, they would help." ONE OF HER OWN. She spent years building something real among people who had nothing but each other, and when she needed them most, they showed up. Zhao Jingzheng thought he was getting information from suspicious locals, but really he was being fed a cover story by women who decided Li Xun was family. That is such a tender, devastating kind of love—it's not dramatic or loud, it's the kind that shows up because you've earned the right to be protected. And then Li Xun's interaction with Sun Ning—she performs vulnerability like an actress. The watery eyes, the soft voice, the trembling hands around that hot water cup. But the narration keeps reminding us: she's calculating. She knows exactly what she's doing. There's grief in her performance, yes, but it's also armor. She can't afford to show Sun Ning the real monster inside her because that might scare her away. So she gives her a wounded girl instead. It's heartbreaking that the most honest emotional moment in the whole chapter is the one that's entirely fabricated. Meanwhile Sun Ning, sitting in her study surrounded by artifacts of her old pain—the first letters from students, the handmade crafts, the suicide note—she's still carrying Teacher Zhao's words like shrapnel in her chest. That's the emotional through-line: two women, both weaponized by the same man, slowly finding each other in the dark.
... Read More
I need to talk about Teacher Zhao because this guy is everything. Like, on one hand he's literally the sweetest teacher ever—slashing five minutes off class so kids can eat lunch earlier, covering for students who break minor rules, accepting kids rejected by every other homeroom teacher. And on the other hand... he's the monster in the sketch? The girl's own homeroom teacher, the man who told her 'only when the children are full can they have the energy to study,' and he's apparently the Red Balloon Killer? That cognitive dissonance is wrecking me. The scene where he reads the horror excerpt from Li Xun's newspaper is the kind of moment that lives in your head forever. One second he's chuckling, asking if they're all reading horror novels again—completely relaxed, the way he always is. Then she starts reading about the victim's stomach being cut open and stuffed with dry grass, and suddenly he SLAMS the desk. Not a tap, not a sigh, but a full violent smack that made every student in that classroom freeze. His face went from soft and middle-aged and approachable to sharp 'like the edges of a knife.' And Li Xun noticed his HAND trembling while holding those papers. That trembling hand is what gets me. Because it's not just shock at reading a horror story in class—it's recognition. He knew exactly what that story was about. And the fact that Li Xun, of all people, gets to sit across from this man every single day while slowly uncovering the truth? That's the kind of dramatic irony that makes my chest hurt. The trust is already there, established over months, and now it's being systematically destroyed. I can't wait to see how this plays out.
... Read More
This part had me genuinely stressed. Li Xun sitting there negotiating with Teacher Zhao and the math she lays out is terrifying: 'I really want to let you go. My mom is old. I don't want her to go to prison. In a way, we're in this together.' She's calculating exactly what leverage she needs. A teacher's secret has to be big enough to guarantee silence. Bigger than illegal imprisonment and assault. The stakes keep climbing with every page — if her mom gets caught, she goes to jail. If Teacher Zhao talks, more people go to jail. If Li Xun slips up, everyone loses. And the worst part? She's right to be anxious. The longer her mom keeps Zhao imprisoned, the more the crime escalates. 'Her mom's crime might escalate to the point of causing someone's death through illegal detention.' She KNOWS this. She's watching the clock. Every hour he's down there, the noose tightens. Then there's the parallel conflict with Zhao Jingzheng's dad's disappearance. Two mysteries, two families, both falling apart. The entrepreneur who agrees to help only wants confirmation his son's killer isn't Zhao Laoshi. Everyone wants the truth but nobody can afford it. Li Xun negotiates all of this while also being a high school student who needs to do a paper. What keeps me hooked is that the author never lets the tension drop. Even in the quiet moments — like when Li Xun is just sitting in the dark basement with a hungry teacher — you can feel the countdown ticking. Her mom could come home any second. The police could show up. The entrepreneur could back out. And Li Xun just keeps talking, keeping people engaged, refusing to let the silence win. I kept reading past midnight just to see if anyone actually gets out of that basement alive.
... Read More
I have to address Zhao's dialogue because it's genuinely masterful. Listen to this: 'How could it be such a coincidence that you rent a house, find a basement to lock me up, and it just happens to be the same basement the murderer used back then?' That's not the rambling of a panicked man. That's the measured, almost academic delivery of someone who has calculated every possible objection and is addressing them one by one. And then—here's the genius part—the text notes that if Li Xun were there, she would have noticed 'Teacher Zhao had changed his focus.' He's no longer arguing his innocence. He's questioning WHY they suspect him. He's deflecting onto their logic instead of his guilt. That shift is so subtle and so devastating. Compare that to Li Yugui's voice—which comes through mostly in narration and physical reaction rather than dialogue. She doesn't argue. She vomits. Her body speaks for her. And Zhang Mingcai? Her dialogue is almost entirely absent too, which makes her actions louder. The three of them reopening the door to inspect it inch by inch—that's their conversation. The silence after they find the hidden panel—that's their argument. The text itself has this incredible restraint where the most important information is conveyed through what characters DON'T say. Like when it says 'The three of them fell silent. The information among them flowed freely.' No words needed. They all understand exactly what they've found. That's writing that trusts its readers, and honestly it's refreshing in a genre that often over-explains everything.
... Read More
The basement scene is the kind of writing that makes you physically uncomfortable, and I mean that as the highest compliment. "A pungent smell of rotten vegetable leaves mixed with food waste." That's the FIRST sensory detail we get. Not visual. SMELL. The author understands that trauma lives in the nose before it reaches the eyes. And then — "His eyes were forcefully held open with tape." I actually had to pause. Not because it's graphic in a gore way, but because it's so specific. The tape pins the eyelids. He can't close them. Every time he tries, it hurts more. This is torture designed around one body part. The footsteps. The flashlight behind the metal rod. The screeching sound. All of it builds like a horror film score but with zero music — just concrete details stacking on each other. Then the CUT to upstairs. A lively voice: "Mom! I'm home! What's for dinner?" Li Xun, normal, alive, asking about dinner, while three flights down (or however far) her mother is holding an iron rod that was originally a rolling pin. The juxtaposition is surgical. Same building. Same family. Two completely different worlds existing simultaneously. One daughter worries about her mother's pale face. The mother worries about nothing because she's in the dark with a bound man. And the bacon conversation on top of all of it — neighbors discussing cured meat like it's weather. That domestic banter layered over a kidnapping is the kind of contrast that makes literary fiction feel like a thriller.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or