It’s Him - Reviews

It’s Him
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Qin Li's section absolutely wrecked me in the most confusing way possible. Here's this woman who ran away from her ex-husband's kidnapping news because she was ONE TILE away from winning at mahjong. That opening image is BRILLIANT and terrible. She literally prioritizes a card game over her son's panic. And then — and THIS is what got me — she hangs up, finishes her hand, and ONLY THEN decides to go check on him. "Qin Li was picking up her tiles, and this hand was quite good. She was in no mood to go just yet." My stomach dropped. She's not a villain. The narration makes sure we know that. But she's a person who was broken by sleepless nights and a crying baby and a society that gave her zero support, and now her reflex is self-preservation over empathy. That's not evil. That's human damage. But then she changes her mind. She calls it in. She drives there. And when she sees her son sitting in the dark waiting for his father — "his head hanging, lost in worry" — she pats his head and feels something she hasn't felt in years. "Feeling for the first time how much her son needed her." Not the other way around. Not "she loved him." But "he needed her." That's the doorway back in for people like them. Love arrives through usefulness, not sentiment. And then she stays. Reschedules her life. Takes a day off. All because her son looked small in a room full of police officers. I sat with that image for a long time.
... Read More
You know what stuck with me? The Guan Gong statue. Right when they enter the house, there's this giant statue of the God of War, loyalty, righteousness—and Li Xun bows to it automatically, and Zhao Jingzheng copies her without understanding why. Guan Gong is supposed to represent justice and loyalty, but what's happening in this house is the complete opposite. The mother is taking justice into her own hands through kidnapping and torture. The son is searching for truth but being used as bait. And Li Xun—she's performing righteousness (helping investigate) while secretly orchestrating something far more sinister. The statue becomes this ironic reminder of what justice SHOULD look like versus what it actually looks like in this story. Zhao Laoshi's theory about 'emotional conservation' also hit me hard—the idea that people who are kind to outsiders vent their darkness on those closest to them. But Li Xun flips it: what if the darkness isn't kept at home but released onto strangers? The scar on the victim, the hidden basement, the A4 paper mask—all of these symbols point to a world where justice is obscured, where the truth is covered but never truly hidden, where the people who seem most righteous are standing nearest to the monster.
... Read More
Okay so I need to just sit with this for a second because my head is spinning. Everything up until this point in the story had me following Li Xun and Zhao Jingzheng on this investigation into the missing homeroom teacher. It felt like a standard mystery—searching for clues, checking cameras, looking into old cases. Totally in on board with that energy. But then BAM. Chapter 20 basically flips the entire table. Li Yugui—the sweet breakfast shop mom who seemed like background flavor the whole time—is NOT who we thought at all. She has scars from heart to navel. She keeps a phone that isn't hers scrolling through the social media of her CHILD'S KILLER. And the line that destroyed me: "But the killer's son was alive and thriving." Her child died 25 years ago. The murderer's son is studying for a master's degree. And now the actual killer is in her basement. I need to go back and re-read everything because I missed SO many signals. The scene where she sends Li Xun a text telling her to study while she's literally getting dressed in a black raincoat? That juxtaposition is chef's kiss terrifying. The author is playing with dramatic irony so smoothly here—we know what Li Xun doesn't, and it makes every sweet mother-daughter moment earlier suddenly have this dark undercurrent. Also the parallel between Li Xun searching for her teacher and Li Yugui harboring a killer in her basement? Both are mothers protecting/searching for their children in completely opposite ways. That structure is gorgeous.
... Read More
I need to talk about Zhao Laoshi because something SHIFTED in this batch. Up until now, he'd been putting on this act—playing the victim, acting confused, performing grief for his son. But here, with Li Xun sitting across from him eating dumplings, the mask completely drops. "Despite enduring physical harm, his spirit was still relishing it all. He was enjoying the fact that the victim's family had caught him but couldn't do anything." This line gave me literal chills. The man is not sorry. He is not repentant. He is sitting in a basement chained to a pillar and he is HAVING THE TIME OF HIS LIFE watching other people fall apart. And the dynamic with Li Xun? It's so sickeningly fascinating. He knows she values family. So he goes for her mother: "If your mother is arrested, your future will be ruined." Cold. Calculated. He reads her like a book. But then she flips it back on him instantly—"You gave me a chance back then, didn't you want to see me driven to suicide?" She connects the dots in real time and suddenly the whole chain of events he set in motion years ago comes into focus. Meanwhile Zhao Jingzheng is out there blindly protecting his father, taking photos of janitors, thinking he's the smart one in the room. The dramatic irony is KILLING ME. And Li Xun's loyalty to him—"Mainly because you're alone and in danger. If something happens, you won't have anyone to help"—shows that she genuinely cares even while she's trapped in this monstrous situation with her mother. These relationships are so layered and messed up and I can't look away.
... Read More
I have to give props where props are due because Zhao Jingzheng's voice in this batch is genuinely impressive. His text messages feel authentic—short, slightly formal when he's stressed ('I suspect this incident might be related to my dad's disappearance'), but then cracking open when he's alone with someone he's starting to trust. The moment where he talks about his childhood and his father 'never hit me, never scolded me'—that's not exposition. That's a person trying to convince himself as much as he's trying to convince Li Xun. The subtext is doing all the work. And Li Xun's responses are perfectly calibrated too. She's deflecting constantly—changing the subject when she sees the word 'disemboweled,' pretending to study her notebook when really she's terrified. Her dialogue is functional on the surface but hollow underneath, and that dissonance is where the writing shines. The substitute teacher's outburst in class is another highlight. 'They don't know your homeroom teacher and have no idea what kind of person he is. Yet they open their mouths and call him a murderer.' That line captures something real about how people perform righteousness online, and the teacher's voice feels distinct from everyone else's. Even Li Yugui's text to her daughter—'Remember to review your practice notebook. Don't forget about the college entrance exam'—is perfect in its banality. The horror is in what's NOT said. She could have written anything more emotionally honest, but instead she writes the most generic mom-text possible while preparing to do... whatever she's about to do. That contrast between form and content is what makes the dialogue work so well here.
... Read More
Let's talk about the central conflict here because it's more nuanced than 'good people catch bad guy.' These women spent fifteen to twenty years searching for a killer who vanished. They stopped contacting each other. They tried to live normal lives. And then—BAM—Li Yugui finds him by voice recognition triggered by hypnosis, and instead of calling the police, she calls Zhang Mingcai. Why? Because the system failed them. The text says 'there weren't many people who could help her, because her persuasion wasn't strong enough. Not many believed she could remember the murderer by his voice alone, and hypnosis was too unreliable.' So the law wasn't an option. The only option was vigilantism. But here's the thing that keeps me up at night: they didn't just capture the killer. They locked him in THE SAME BASEMENT he used for his crimes. That's not justice. That's poetic symmetry, and poetic symmetry is dangerous. Zhao keeps saying 'call the police for a blood test' and 'if this is really a murder scene there will be blood marks'—he's betting everything on the idea that they can't prove anything, that this is all circumstantial, that he can outlast them. And honestly? He might be right. The stakes here aren't just 'will they catch the killer'—they've already caught him. The stakes are 'what does doing this DO to them?' Li Yugui went from selling dumplings to running a kidnapping operation in one traumatic leap. Zhang Mingcai went from cautious investigator to 'the least rational' participant. The question hanging over all of this isn't whether Zhao is guilty. It's whether they'll survive being guilty themselves.
... Read More
Let me just say—this batch does NOT waste a single moment. Chapter 54-60 and I went from "wait, the father might be dead" to "OH MY GOD HE'S ALIVE BUT HE'S A MONSTER AND HE'S MANIPULATING EVERYONE" in what felt like five minutes of reading time. The structure is doing some really clever things. You've got Zhao Jingzheng's POV—staying up all night, rewinding footage, the slow dawning realization—and then it CUTS to Li Xun in the basement, which is simultaneously a relief (he's alive!) and a horror reveal (but look what he's become). The switch between these two parallel investigations creates this ticking clock effect where both threads are converging toward disaster. And then the Zhang Mingcai interlude? Brilliant pacing choice. Just when you're drowning in Zhao Laoshi's psychological warfare, you get this completely different emotional register—a woman's entire life destroyed, a child lost, a husband who couldn't survive the grief. It gives the story breathing room while simultaneously deepening the emotional stakes. "Her life had a huge void, and she had to fill it with countless tasks. Until Li Yugui called her." That final sentence is a hook that drags you into the next section like a riptide. The cliffhanger ending—"Someone ruined her life with"—and it cuts off mid-sentence? I am not okay. I need to know what happens next immediately.
... Read More
There's this one image that keeps coming back to me: the deskmate rubbing a stone smooth, comparing it to the gaokao. "This rough surface, imagine if we smooth it out like an ostrich egg—how satisfying would that be? It's way easier than the college entrance exams." A boy is literally trying to erase roughness from a rock because he cannot erase roughness from his future. That's not a side detail. That's the thesis statement of the whole high school experience in China right there. And Li Xun tries it too. She doesn't find relief. The stone doesn't help her. Which means the pressure inside her has a different texture than everyone else's. The baozi mother — Li Yugui — is also working on smoothing something. She's kneading dough at 2am, making soft, round, perfect things out of raw ingredients. Flour, water, filling. Transforming the rough into something that feeds people. That's the same impulse as the stone. Both are attempts to create order through repetition. The serial killer rumor is another form of roughness — the community trying to make sense of something senseless by giving it a face. Teacher Zhao's gentle face becomes the face of a monster because it's easier to believe a kind man is secretly cruel than to believe cruelty just happens. Three symbols. Stone. Baozi. Rumor. All about how humans process pressure by shaping, feeding, or blaming.
... Read More
I want to zero in on a few scenes because the atmosphere in this book is doing SO much heavy lifting. First: Li Yugui in the dim bedroom, changing clothes. The text is spare but every word lands. 'A black raincoat, which was waterproof.' Why does the author specify waterproof? Because she's preparing for something. Something that requires practical preparation, not impulsive action. This isn't a woman losing control—this is a woman who has been losing control for twenty-five years finally gaining direction. The raincoat detail alone tells me the author knows exactly what they're doing. Then there's the industrial area where the old murder happened. Late at night, workers finishing their shifts, a mother chased with a tricycle, left to bleed while nobody came. The specificity of 'workers finished their shifts' makes this feel real in a way that generic descriptions never could. You can hear the factory sirens, the echo of the tricycle wheels on pavement. And contrast that with Li Xun's world—the bright classroom, the substituting teacher losing composure, the pressure of the gaokao looming over everything like a storm cloud. These two worlds (the ordinary world of exams and teenage life, and the hidden world of basements and raincoats) keep intersecting and I'm genuinely unsettled every time they do. The settings aren't just backdrops. They're active participants in the story.
... Read More
The dialogue in this novel is deceptively simple, and that's what makes it work so well. Teacher Zhao's lines are conversational and warm—he says things like 'only when the children are full can they have the energy to study' and deflects blame to 'the school management' when students break rules. His voice is consistent: the kind of teacher who seems genuinely invested in his students' wellbeing. Which makes his one explosive line hit twice as hard. When Li Xun's classmate starts reading the horror story aloud and says 'That person started pouring something very smelly into my mouth,' the response isn't some measured 'put the book away, please.' It's 'Stop reading' delivered with enough force that the desk cracks. And then just 'Sit down. Continue with the morning reading.' That's not a teacher controlling a classroom—that's a man trying desperately to maintain composure while his world is cracking open. The subtext in those two sentences is enormous. The forum comments are also surprisingly well-voiced. Each netizen has a distinct personality—even through text, you can tell who's being cruel, who's being sympathetic, who's genuinely trying to help. The commenters debating whether this is attention-seeking versus genuine trauma feel like a real internet ecosystem. And Li Xun's own posts have this flat, almost clinical tone that contrasts sharply with the horrifying content—she's not dramatizing anything, just reporting: 'I dreamed of a woman calling my name. She was crying and kept asking me to come home.' The restraint in her voice is what makes it devastating. The author understands that horror lives in what's NOT said.
... Read More
Can we unpack the Snickers bar moment because this is honestly one of the most disturbingly human details I've read in a while? 'The sweet taste of chocolate on the Snickers bar, mixed with the scent of peanuts, soothed the irritation tearing through his body.' A kidnapped teacher is eating a candy bar offered by his captor — a high school student. And the narrative treats this like... a normal interaction? Like she's hosting him? The sweetness literally soothing his irritation? This is how the story establishes that neither of them is having a breakdown. They're just existing in this insane situation with the emotional range of people discussing homework. But below the surface, I think this scene is about power and how intimacy gets distorted when the people around you are broken. Li Xun isn't kidnapping people for fun. She's trapping her teacher in a basement because her own mother traumatized him years ago and now she's trying to fix her mother's mistakes with the only tools she has — negotiation, threats, snacks. There's also this recurring theme of food and care as currency. Guo Ying tells her about moxibustion for her mom's sleep issues — practical help between friends. Li Xun gives Zhao Jingzheng detailed instructions on how to approach the police — almost motherly in her thoroughness. But she also offers her imprisoned teacher chocolate. Who does that? Only someone whose idea of comfort and control got severely warped by circumstance. The whole thing made me think about how the novel keeps showing us characters trying to nurture and protect each other in deeply inappropriate ways. Li Xun protecting her mom by becoming a criminal. Zhao Jingzheng finding safety in a girl who can't even free herself. It's like everyone's trying to be a good person in a world that doesn't leave room for goodness to survive intact.
... Read More
The symbolism in this novel is doing SO much heavy lifting and I'm here for it. Let's start with the red balloon—a child holding it at a crossroads, crying, surrounded by people. This image is so loaded. The red balloon immediately evokes innocence, childhood, celebration. But in this context, it's clearly a marker of death. The crossroads represent a choice, a transition between worlds—past life and present life, literally. The child crying while holding the balloon is the ghost of the victim, unable to move on, unable to communicate. And seventeen years later, someone in a new body dreams the exact same scene. Then there's the dry grass. Teacher Zhao's gentle philosophy about feeding children properly, about rest and nourishment... and the victim's stomach literally STUFFED with dry grass. This image of forced consumption, of being filled with worthless straw instead of real food, is absolutely grotesque. It's not just a murder detail—it's a perversion of care. The killer doesn't just kill; he fills the victim with the opposite of nourishment. And the fact that the victim can't speak, can't cry out, can only endure—that's the ultimate silencing. But the most powerful symbol is probably Li Xun's MEMORY itself. In a world where nobody dreams the same dream twice, where her classmates are buried under exam pressure and can barely remember what they ate for lunch, SHE remembers a murder from seventeen years ago with photographic clarity. The sketch she produces—'a few strokes outlining the face of a middle-aged man'—is evidence that transcends normal human capability. Memory as proof. Memory as curse. Memory as the only thing that can bring justice. That theme of remembering versus forgetting feels like it's going to be the core philosophical question of the entire novel.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or