Is It So Wrong that I Like Seeing the Villain Suffer? - Reviews

Is It So Wrong that I Like Seeing the Villain Suffer?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about Arkle for a moment because THIS MAN. Here's someone described as 'the empty man who possessed the strongest power in the world but was interested in nothing,' and yet he gets genuinely stuck trying to write a social invitation. His attempt at small talk about the weather — 'It's as gloomy as the sky over Moril territory' — made me laugh out loud. This is a person who can probably level cities with magic but cannot compose a polite letter. And then he looks at Lize with what the narration describes as 'found a ray of light' energy when she offers to write it for him. The vulnerability here is so understated it almost slips past you. He says 'May I ask you to?' — Arkle Cayenne, strongest being in the world, asking for help with a letter. Their dynamic is shifting in real time. He kidnaps her, yes, but he also asks 'Are you experiencing any discomfort?' in that flat, indifferent tone that somehow reads as almost considerate. And then at the end when she leaves, he watches her the whole way down the corridor. 'I enjoyed it,' he says, but his eyes show nothing. I keep wondering what Arkle actually feels versus what he shows. The pinky promise scene is iconic — two people linking fingers like children sealing a secret pact, and somehow it carries more weight than any dramatic confession scene ever could.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is absolutely masterful and I want to break it down because the author really knows how to string emotions together. We start at the banquet, which is almost comedic — everyone is worshipping Lize as this angelic saintess, she's internally rolling her eyes ('What nonsense is this now?'), and then there's this genuinely touching moment with the servants who say 'Thinking it's not extraordinary is what's extraordinary.' That line actually made me feel something. The chapter goes from lighthearted comedy to heartfelt warmth in about three paragraphs. Then it WHIP-SNAPS to the Arkle scene, which is a completely different genre entirely. It's comedic (her trying to teach him to beg), then suddenly romantic tension (the desk breaks, she falls into his arms, his breath on her ear), then it deflates when she realizes his begging is terrible, and then it DESTROYS her hopes when Juan walks in. That's like four tonal shifts in one continuous scene and I barely noticed because the writing pulls you along so well. And then — right when you think you've had enough emotional whiplash — you get Naran appearing at her door, acting like a cute cat, then the moment she mentions Arkle's name and he INSTANTLY transforms into something cold and threatening. 'Arkle Cayenne is much more ruthless than you think, Lize.' The transition from warm sibling affection to razor-sharp warning is so fast it makes you sit up straight. By the end of all this, I'd read probably 30 pages and experienced a full emotional rollercoaster. The author never lets you settle.
... Read More
"With that feeling, please beg. Ask me to touch you." I had to stop reading for a second because THIS IS SO GOOD. Like, what a emotionally complicated moment. Lize isn't forcing herself to heal him—she's making HIM need to want it badly enough to beg. And Arkle, who believes in absolutely nothing, who sees himself as an empty person who desires nothing... he literally becomes hollow enough to ask for mercy. The chemistry here is absolutely feral. Not in a romantic way yet, but in the way two incredibly sharp people recognize something dangerous in each other. Arkle grabs her wrist and says "No. Just a little longer." After the pain is gone and he's composed himself again, he still doesn't want to let go. That single moment tells you everything about how starved he is for relief, for connection, for anything that makes the pain stop. And Lize's inner voice—oh my god. She's completely transparent about her own warped enjoyment of this. "The vulnerable face of a good-looking man is always thrilling." She knows she's not a saint. She knows the title is ridiculous. But she also knows exactly what she's doing to him and she's not apologizing for it. The fact that she keeps touching his face after the healing is done, that she feels his grip on her wrists and just... accepts it, says "I guess I have no choice" with a smile—that's so loaded with meaning. What hit me hardest was the parallel between their situations. Lize has been trapped in this body and this role. Arkle has been trapped in his own body and his own suffering. Neither of them asked for any of this. And the one moment where they truly connect is through pain and desperation, not through kindness or shared understanding. That's the kind of emotional realism that makes you want to scream.
... Read More
Okay so let me just sit with this chapter for a second because the plot mechanics here are genuinely clever. We have Lize making a deal with Arkle — she helps him write an invitation to Gillian Moril, and in return he grants her one favor. But here's the thing: she KNOWS that in the original story, Gillian accepts the dinner party invitation only to spy on the Cayennes and discover Lize is being held there. Lize could just let history play out, but instead she chooses to actively intervene and make the deal succeed. Why? Because she wants to see Arkle struggle. She literally thinks 'Arkle Cayenne, I will make you cry' and the sheer perversion of that goal drives everything she does. The irony is absolutely delicious — she's playing both sides of the board, manipulating events while pretending to be this innocent helper. And then there's the dinner party subplot simmering in the background, the Cayenne family's interest in the Moril magic stone mines, and Gillian Moril walking right into a trap that Lize might either preserve or sabotage. What I love is how the author doesn't tell us Lize's full plan — we only get glimpses. 'I can't tell you what it is now. If you knew, you'd absolutely refuse to do it.' That single line is a hook so sharp it cuts. The plot feels alive, not predetermined. Lize isn't just following the story — she's weaponizing her knowledge of it.
... Read More
The transition from the farm to Arkle's bedroom is one of the most unsettling spatial shifts I've read in a while. You start in this open, almost agricultural space—servants kneeling, dust and dirt and the threat of violence happening in broad daylight. Then Arkle literally just grabs Lize's hand and walks her somewhere without explanation. No context, no warning. And when the door opens and you see THE BED, it hits differently because the author never once prepared you for THAT turn. The sensory details are doing a lot of heavy lifting here. Arkle's face is "flushed red," he's drenched in cold sweat, his breathing is ragged. But what really makes the scene work is how the space itself changes. This isn't some grand throne room or sacred temple where holy power is supposed to work. It's a bedroom. Intimate, private, vulnerable. The fact that his "master" persona completely drops in this space—and that Lize witnesses it—makes everything feel more real than any epic fantasy setting could. And the farm itself! The door sound—"as if it would fall off"—the servants turning "pale blue," that collective holding of breath when Arkle walks in. The author builds atmosphere through sound and color more than through descriptive passage. It's almost cinematic in how it works. Every shift in lighting and posture tells you more than a paragraph of worldbuilding would. I also love how the world feels lived-in without being over-explained. The Allenheim family name carries weight. The title of "saintess" has history and reputation behind it. But you learn all of this through the characters' reactions, not through exposition dumps. The world exists in the spaces between what's said.
... Read More
The dialogue writing in this passage is genuinely excellent, and Arkle's voice is what carries it. The man speaks in fragments and monotone deliveries that somehow say so much. 'Yes.' When asked if he's trying to get rid of her quickly. Not defensive, not apologetic — just a flat acknowledgment that would be terrifying from anyone else but lands perfectly from him. 'The weather... It's as gloomy as the sky over Moril territory.' The attempt at pleasantries from someone who has clearly never spoken pleasantries before is character building in three words. And his reaction to Lize's letter — just 'Oh...' — a single syllable loaded with so many meanings. Recognition, surprise, maybe even the faintest trace of gratitude that he'd never verbalize otherwise. Lize's voice contrasts beautifully: she's performative, switching between angelic smiles and internally screaming, using humor as armor ('I just hope you stay healthy' while literally thinking obscene thoughts). The exchange between her and Juan about the staff's workload is also standout dialogue — Juan's professional courtesy slowly dissolving into visible exhaustion, and Lize's internal 'I started to feel sorry for him' showing us that beneath all her weird obsessions, she's actually empathetic. The narrator's voice has this delicious unreliable quality — Lize describes herself with such dramatic self-awareness ('my expression probably looks quite perverted right now') that you can't help but trust her even when she's lying.
... Read More
Up until Naran shows up, I was mostly enjoying this as a fluffy rom-com with some meta humor. Then he drops this bomb and suddenly the stakes feel VERY different. Naran — who earlier was literally rubbing his head against Lize's hand like a cat — suddenly becomes ice cold the moment Arkle's name is mentioned. 'Have you been with him all this time?' His voice carries tension. 'It's best to stay away from that wretched guy.' Not 'be careful' or 'he's complicated.' He's saying RUN. And then the smile. That's the scariest part honestly. One second he's warning her with cold seriousness, and the next he's grinning and saying 'I can be more helpful to you than Arkle can.' That switch is NOT reassuring. It reads like someone who has history with Arkle, has seen something bad happen, and is now actively positioning himself as an alternative. This recontextualizes everything we've seen. The 'heartless monster' thing, the way everyone seems to fear or respect Arkle from a distance, Naran's genuine concern that goes beyond typical sibling worry. There's clearly something dark in their shared past that the original novel never explored but the text hints at with lines like 'the original story never really delved into the past of the Cayenne family.' Meanwhile, Lize is still over here treating Arkle like her weird deal-making project, completely unaware that apparently everyone else sees him as genuinely dangerous. That dramatic irony is TENSION. I can't wait to see what happens when she learns what Naran knows.
... Read More
Oh my god, can we just talk about Juan for a second? This scene was such a gut punch and I'm still fuming. Lize had been trying SO HARD to recruit Juan, to build some kind of friendship with someone who actually sees her for who she is — remember earlier when she thought 'people of the same kind recognize each other'? She was genuinely excited. And then immediately after, everything falls apart in the worst way possible. She was in Arkle's office, all flustered and embarrassed, trying to teach him how to beg properly because apparently this is some weird holy power manifestation exercise (lol sure), and she yells at him 'Just think of yourself as a dog—do as I say! You're my pet now. Got it?' And then the door opens and Juan is standing there. I literally screamed reading this. And his reaction?! '...What did you just say...?' He doesn't even let her explain. He just backs out and says 'Please don't mind me and continue your business. Then.' That final 'Then' hits so hard. He heard exactly what he thought he heard, and he's already written her off in his head. Lize is left there devastated, thinking 'I wanted to make him one of my people, but it feels like the opportunity keeps slipping away.' This is the kind of miscommunication that could drive an entire plot and I am HERE for it. Also, the fact that Juan was the FIRST person who saw through her fake saintess persona and she was SO grateful for that, only for this moment to potentially destroy everything... that's just cruel writing in the best way.
... Read More
I started reading this batch and within the first page I was already committed. The pacing is relentless in the best way possible. It goes from: servants threatening Lize → Sylvia losing it → Arkle's entrance → the entire magical healing subplot → Lize's bedroom realization → back to composure. All in what feels like twenty minutes of reading time. What I really appreciate is how the author controls the tension curve. The first confrontation with Sylvia is fast and chaotic—lots of dialogue, shouting, physical struggle. Then Arkle enters and everything instantly shuts down. Silence. Everyone freezing. That contrast alone is a masterclass in pacing. The author knows exactly when to speed up and when to make you slow down and absorb what's happening. But the middle section—the bedroom scene—is where the pacing really earns its keep. It starts slow, almost hesitant. Arkle breathing heavily, struggling to speak, reaching out... and then Lize touches his face and there's this moment of stillness. Just two people in a room. And then the conversation about reverence and sincerity unfolds at a deliberate, almost uncomfortable pace. You can feel every second stretching. And then—just when you think the scene is over—he grabs her wrist. "Just a little longer." And suddenly everything speeds up again because your heart is racing. The ending where he leaves to call his aide and puts his mask back on is perfectly timed too. It gives you breathing room while also making you want MORE. This is how you write chapters that are impossible to put down.
... Read More
"Why would anyone like someone like me?" "What would anyone want with trash like me?" These lines keep echoing in my head because they're not just Naran being dramatic—they're the core of everything this chapter is trying to say about self-worth and isolation. Naran's workshop is basically his entire personality manifested in physical form. It's dark, it's obsessive, it's something he keeps hidden because he knows people will judge him for it. But it's also the one place where he has control, where his particular interests aren't mocked or dismissed. He cleans it himself every morning like it's sacred ground. And Lize—this person who literally does NOT belong in this world, who has no right to be kind to him—sees that workshop and doesn't flinch. She looks at all those instruments and says, calmly, genuinely, that she likes it. Not out of manipulation. Not out of fear. Because she actually relates to the thrill of dark things. The trash/nuclear waste exchange is the thesis statement of the whole chapter. Naran calls himself trash because his family treats him like garbage. Lize calls herself nuclear waste because she's a transmigrated soul who doesn't fit anywhere. They're both outsiders in different ways, and somehow that's what brings them together. "She doesn't know anything about him"—but maybe that's the point. Maybe being seen without fully knowing someone is exactly what Naran needs.
... Read More
Can we talk about how distinct every character sounds? Because I can tell them apart without name tags, which is the highest compliment for dialogue writing. Lize's internal voice is this sharp, self-aware, almost vicious narrator. She calls people "pitiful" to their faces. She admits to enjoying being strangled. She thinks about how thrilling it is to see a handsome man vulnerable. And yet she's also the one offering mercy. That contradiction makes her dialogue feel alive in a way that's rarely achieved. Arkle is the opposite—short sentences, clipped responses, but when he breaks, the words come out raw. "Hurry up." Then later, after she tells him to beg with sincerity: "...I got it." and then "...Please... touch me." That progression from formal to informal speech is everything. It's not just dialogue; it's character development happening in real time through syntax alone. Even the servants have a voice. Their desperate kneeling, the way they stutter and plead—"We're sorry! Please, p-please forgive us just this once!"—you can hear them. You can hear Juan's weary authority. You can hear Sylvia's hysteria. And the narrative voice itself—Lize's POV is so distinctive. She references the original novel, she knows she's in a story, she compares her situation to the male lead's struggles. This meta-awareness could easily become annoying, but the author writes it so naturally that it just becomes part of who she is. It's not a gimmick; it's her personality. The dialogue also does incredible thematic work. When Arkle says "Wasn't holy power supposed to help people unconditionally?" and Lize replies "You don't believe in such things anyway"—that single exchange captures the entire philosophical conflict of the book. No exposition needed.
... Read More
Okay, can we talk about how Lize's smile works in this scene? On the surface it's all angelic warmth while holding that contract, but her internal narration screams something completely different. 'I felt proud' - proud of what? Outsmarting her abuser? Making Gillian sign away his family's mine while he sobs? That's not pride, that's trauma response dressed up as victory. And then there's the Juan interaction. When he says she looked 'vile' and immediately tries to take it back, his panic is so palpable I almost felt sorry for him. But Lize? She *likes* it. 'For the first time since coming here... someone saw me for who I am.' That moment when she accepts the lunatic label instead of defending her saintess image? Chilling. Beautiful. Terrifying. The way she describes Arkle's smile as 'indescribably beautiful' while simultaneously plotting to send Gillian's corpse in a carriage - that dissonance is where the real story lives. She's not healing. She's weaponizing whatever's left. And yet... when she twists her wrist free from Gillian and calls his behavior 'creepy,' there's a flicker of the girl who just wants to be left alone. Buried under all that ice, but there.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or