Is It So Wrong that I Like Seeing the Villain Suffer? - Reviews

Is It So Wrong that I Like Seeing the Villain Suffer?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just lay this out plainly because my hands are still shaking a little: In the original story, Naran dies. He's executed by his own sister after being framed. It's a brutal, heartbreaking scene where he loses his composure and screams about how it's not his fault he's not as good as them. Martha beheads him personally. Now Lize is standing in his body, alive, and she's looking at a boy who hasn't yet been destroyed by the world. The stakes here are INSANE on every level. External stakes: Lize is a hostage in a hostile mansion. If she screws this up, she could die. Internal stakes: She's watching a future murder victim in real time, knowing exactly how his story ends, and she can't just walk away because she needs to survive. But the most interesting conflict is the one between what Naran expects and what Lize actually gives him. He's been conditioned his entire life to expect rejection, contempt, exploitation. So when Lize offers genuine kindness, his brain literally can't process it. He assumes there's a motive. He assumes she's lying. He says things like "You want something from me, right?" And then she says "If you're trash, then I'm nuclear waste" and somehow that's enough to make him start Humming as he cleans his torture devices again. The shift from "I'll use her for her healing abilities" to genuinely worrying about whether she can survive in this mansion—that's the moment everything changes. Not with a bang, but with a quiet, uncomfortable realization that someone actually sees him.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this chapter moves because the pacing is absolutely relentless and I didn't see any of it coming. It starts in TERROR. No sunlight. Torture devices everywhere. Naran asking if she likes them. My heart rate was already elevated. Then it pivots to COMEDY. Lize says she likes it. Naran's entire worldview cracks. The nuclear waste line. I was wheezing. Then it hits you with the FLASHBACK to his execution. Just one paragraph but it completely reframes everything that just happened. You go from laughing to grief in approximately three seconds. And then back to the present, where Lize is being weirdly kind and Naran is confused but secretly softening, and he starts humming again like nothing happened. The structure is: dread → shock → humor → devastation → hope → quiet warmth. That's a WHOLE emotional arc packed into what should be a single chapter, and the author makes it flow so naturally you don't even notice the transitions until you're already feeling something completely different. The kitchen scene acts as a palate cleanser between the workshop horror and the emotional climax. Getting food, the head maid's resentment, Naran threatening the staff—all of it grounds the scene in mundane reality before diving back into the heavy stuff. And ending on Naran deciding to protect Lize while telling himself it's just strategic? Perfect. It's hopeful but not saccharine, warm but still tangled up in his defenses. The chapter doesn't tie things up neatly—it leaves you exactly where you need to be to turn the page.
... Read More
Listen to how Lize's dialogue shifts between registers. With Gillian, she's all sugary menace: 'I hope you enjoy the dessert,' 'How about signing here and finishing the deal?' Perfect polite vocabulary wrapped around threats of mutilation or death. But internally? 'That word doesn't suit Lize Allenheim at all.' The dissonance between her performed identity and true self creates this delicious tension in every line. Arkle's voice is all flat statements and chilling questions - 'What do you mean by that?' delivered while walking toward someone like a predator closing in. His few jokes ('He can make jokes too') land because they're so rare. Gillian's dialogue is performative arrogance that cracks with each attempt - the way he escalates from 'I'll reveal everything' to desperate bargaining shows a man who's lost control of his own narrative. And Juan! His attempts at diplomatic language ('You looked vile' followed by immediate panic) reveal someone who's trying desperately to navigate this dangerous household while maintaining professional decorum. The servants' chorus-like declarations ('Miss Lize should only see cute and lovely things') give them collective voice while individualizing them through action. Even the unspoken dialogue matters - Gillian's interrupted threats, Lize's trailing sentences, all speak volumes about power dynamics.
... Read More
Reading this passage, I'm struck by how Lize and Arkle's relationship operates on two simultaneous frequencies: the public performance of business negotiation and the private current of something dangerously close to trust. Watch how Lize watches *him* while pretending to watch the contract - she's counting the seconds until he smiles, memorizing the micro-expression. That's not gratitude; that's hunger. And Arkle? He plays along perfectly. The delayed 'My office is on the third floor' isn't just setting up the next scene; it's a test. Does she remember their bargain? Does she *want* him to deliver? His barely-there smile when he calls her distracted is the first honest thing he's done all chapter. Meanwhile, Gillian represents everything Lize is running from - the brother who collects her hair like trophies, who thinks ownership equals love. But here's what got me: when Sylvia throws that knife, Lize doesn't flinch. She's already decided these servants are hers. She's building her own family, brick by bloody brick. And Juan's line about me looking like a lunatic? Finally someone sees the real her. The saintess costume is just another weapon now.
... Read More
"You like it?" "Yes. It's hard to believe, but I really do." "......" Naran turned his gaze away and slowly opened his mouth. "......Never mind." "What?" "It's become boring." I CANNOT stop laughing at this exchange. Lize: "I like your torture devices" Naran: *internally short-circuits* "...boring." The way Naran keeps trying to read Lize's motives and failing miserably is comedy gold. He's so convinced she's lying, so convinced nobody could genuinely like something like his workshop, that he can't even process the possibility that she might literally just... like it? And then the nuclear waste line?? "If you're trash, Naran, then I'm nuclear waste." I died. I actually died. That is the most random, unhinged, absolutely perfect thing either character has ever said and I need to frame it. Naran's dialogue throughout is just this perfect mix of condescending, defensive, and genuinely confused. He tries to be scary and intimidating but Lize keeps derailing him with her cheerful weirdness. "Stop, stop—! Don't lie. You want something, don't you?" He's so bad at calling out liars when the lie is actually the truth. The author's voice is also doing a lot of work here—Lize's internal monologue is so casually self-deprecating and modern, which creates this hilarious contrast with the gothic mansion setting.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about this entire sequence because honestly it gave me whiplash in the best way. You have this whole setup where Sylvia orchestrates this elaborate trap—fake injured maid, dark farm, hostages situation—and the reader is just sitting there sweating because, obviously, this is where things go wrong for Lize. The tension ramps up so naturally too. Sylvia starts with that sob story at the door, the whole 'please help me Saintess' act, and you can feel Lize walking right into it because she's being her usual naive self. But then the moment they get to the farm and it clicks—straw doll, fake blood, the lock clicking shut—I thought we were done. The narrative was leaning hard into the danger angle. And then Lize just... finds the secret brick? Because she's read the book and knows the layout? That was such a satisfying subversion. Most would-be-hostages would be panicking in that cage, but our girl is over here going 'oh wow this is the steamy scene location.' The plot had me convinced this was a turning point where Lize actually gets vulnerable, and then it flips it completely. The fact that she uses self-defense as a weapon afterward, forcing Sylvia to literally grab her own hand and put it around her neck—that's not just clever plotting, that's psychological warfare disguised as a conversation. And the servants standing around freezing because they genuinely can't touch her? That detail alone tells you everything about the power dynamics in this house. Beautifully constructed chapter arc.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is doing some serious gymnastics and I'm here for it. We open with Lize's dark, almost creepy fixation on Arkle — the perverted thoughts, the desire to see him broken. Very intense, very heavy atmosphere. Then it pivots to this almost domestic scene where she's helping him write a letter, and there's genuine warmth bleeding through despite the kidnapping context. The conversation flows naturally, the tension diffuses, and then BAM — she proposes a deal with that hooked-pinky moment. Just when you think the scene is settling into something almost sweet, Juan arrives and the whole energy shifts again. The walk back to her room gives us world-building about the staff, hints about the larger plot with House Moril, and develops Lize's relationship with Juan as a potential ally. Then the chapter ends with the most comedic tonal whiplash possible — she opens the door and finds her room has been transformed into a Disney princess fantasy. The author controls reader engagement masterfully here by never letting us rest in one emotional register for too long. The chapter moves from psychological darkness to awkward humor to genuine tenderness to outright comedy, and each transition feels earned rather than jarring. The only complaint I have — and it's minor — is that the ending cuts off mid-sentence ('Actually, from the moment Arkle acce...'). Classic cliffhanger technique, but also slightly frustrating in a batch read like this.
... Read More
I need to highlight one specific moment that had actual cinematic quality to it. After the desk incident, when Lize gets up and positions herself against the wall, the text says: 'The sunlight streaming through the window bathed my whole body warmly. Right now, I must look like the most holy saintess. But a smile full of mischief appeared on my lips.' This is such a deliberate visual composition. Warm light, her positioned almost iconographically against a wall, the saintess aesthetic playing into her whole public persona — and then that smirk that undercuts everything. It's literally a painting come to life. I could see this in an anime adaptation and it would be gorgeous. There's also the contrast with the office scene itself — the desk leg breaking, the sudden physical closeness, his voice whispering right by her ear. The spatial choreography is really well done. She goes from sitting on the desk, to leaning against the wall, to kneeling on the floor (trying to demonstrate), to being pulled up — and Arkle never moves from his spot. He's almost like a fixed point in the scene, unmoving and impassive, while she's the one orbiting around him, getting more and more frustrated. And then the final image of the chapter — Arkle alone in his office, hand on his chest, heart pounding, saying 'This is serious... one curse is enough.' The lighting, the silence, the solitude. It's such a strong visual to end on. Very much a 'lonely powerful figure discovering emotion for the first time' trope and it WORKS.
... Read More
The stakes in this section are deceptively simple on the surface—you have a girl who might get killed by her own servants, and a man who might die from magical backlash. But the real conflict is far more interesting: can someone who believes in nothing still be saved? Arkle is established as an "empty person who believed in nothing in this world." Not evil, not villainous, just completely hollow. And the one power that could heal him requires something he can't give—sincerity, reverence, genuine emotional investment. The author sets up an impossible condition that feels almost cruel. How do you heal someone who can't want to be healed? But then Lize figures it out. Desperation IS a form of reverence. When you're in enough pain, the line between worship and survival blurs. And that's when the real tension kicks in—not whether Arkle will survive, but what this exchange will do to BOTH of them. Lize, who has been playing a role this whole time, finds herself genuinely Enjoying the power she holds. Arkle, who has nothing left, finds himself grasping for something—anything. The physical stakes are real but secondary. What I couldn't stop thinking about was the emotional consequence. If Arkle's healing depends on begging someone who doesn't even believe in her own title, what does that say about the nature of salvation in this world? Is it real, or is it just another transaction? And then there's the detail about the original male lead Jean Allenheim—"He infiltrated the Duke's family and had no peace, mentally or physically." The author is layering conflicts across multiple characters and timelines, and each one raises the stakes higher. You're not just worried about whether Arkle survives this chapter. You're worried about what this pattern of suffering means for everyone involved.
... Read More
This is the funniest emotional comedy of misunderstandings I've read in ages. Let me paint the picture: Lize is internally absolute filth — she's watching Arkle's back with burning desire, thinking about making him cry, considering herself a 'depraved, lustful demon.' Meanwhile, the entire Cayenne household has collectively decided she is the purest, most delicate angel to ever grace their walls. Sylvia calls her 'a fragile angel' and wants to protect her. The maids redecorate her entire room in pink frills and lace because apparently saints like puppy pictures and fluttery curtains. And when Lize finally says 'I actually liked the original room,' they interpret this as the MOST SELFLESS ACT OF HUMILITY EVER. 'She's being considerate of us who have lived in House Cayenne, worried we might feel embarrassed!' NO. I just like gloom. I like the aesthetic. But no — to them, she's beyond comprehension in her purity. The emotional whiplash of reading Lize's internal monologue while watching everyone else project whatever fantasy onto her is absolutely hysterical. There's a tender moment too — Juan telling her that the staff owes her gratitude because she stood up for them at the farm, and that Sylvia begged to stay and repay her debt. These people are genuinely attaching themselves to her, and Lize, for all her perversions, seems to feel actual warmth toward them in return. That contrast between how she sees herself and how they see her? Chef's kiss.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or