Is It So Wrong that I Like Seeing the Villain Suffer? - Reviews

Is It So Wrong that I Like Seeing the Villain Suffer?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The pacing here is absolutely ruthless. We open with exposition about magical stone explosions, then immediately drop into dialogue that feels like sparring - quick, sharp, layered with subtext. Gillian's threats escalate by syllables: first he mentions the article, then Lize's hair, then the magical tool. Each revelation should give him advantage, but each time Lize or Arkle neutralizes it before he can press the button. That's structural mastery. The servant intervention comes at perfect comic relief timing - just when Gillian thinks he's won, Sylvia's knife flies. Then the aftermath: Juan handling payments, Gillian fleeing, and that final beat with Arkle promising to grant her request. The chapter ends on a question mark that isn't really a question - 'Does that mean he'll do anything?' - but it's the kind of beat that makes you immediately want to turn the page. What I love most is how the author refuses to let us breathe. Every dialogue exchange contains either a threat, a counter-threat, or a revelation that shifts the power balance. By the time Gillian leaves crying, we're already bracing for whatever comes next in that third-floor office.
... Read More
What keeps me up at night is how many layers of threat exist in this single scene. On the surface: House Cayenne vs. House Moril over a mine. But peel it back and there's Lize's safety (Gillian has her hair, evidence of her presence), her reputation (the saintess image vs. the woman who smiles while threatening torture), and her future (that third-floor office promise that could be salvation or doom). Gillian thinks he has leverage with the Allenheim family's devotion to their daughter, but he's forgotten that devotion can become weaponized against him. The magical tool that would summon knights gets shattered before he can use it - a perfect metaphor for how all his planned escapes will fail. But the deepest conflict is internal: Lize wants justice for Jean's fate, but each victory brings her closer to becoming like the monsters she fights. When she says 'I felt proud' after getting the contract, is that satisfaction or the seduction of power? The stakes keep escalating because every solution creates new problems. Gillian leaves trembling but alive. Arkle's promise hangs in the air like a blade. And somewhere, an Allenheim holy knight could be gathering forces based on that hair evidence. Nothing is settled. Nothing is safe. That's what makes this conflict so viscerally engaging - we know every advantage is temporary, every alliance has teeth, and every smile might hide a knife.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this first—this chapter is absolutely WILD and I have so many thoughts. So Lize wakes up inside the villain's body, right? And instead of panicking and trying to escape immediately, what does she do? She goes looking for the KITCHEN. Like, first priority is food. I respect this woman. But then Naran drags her to his torture workshop and everything CHANGES. In the original novel, Jean Allenheim tricks Naran into thinking he's being loyal to his siblings, and Martha ends up executing him. But now Lize is in his body, and her whole dynamic with him is completely different. Instead of fear or hatred, she Genuinely says she likes his collection. Of torture devices. Because she used to watch GORE MOVIES as a kid. Like. What. The plot twist here isn't even a twist—it's an earthquake. Naran completely fails to process her reaction. He expects disgust, he expects fear, he expects the usual garbage everyone in that family throws at him. But Lize just smiles and says 'I like it.' And that single moment rewrites EVERYTHING. Also the flashback to Naran's execution scene hit me SO hard. I remembered reading that part and thinking 'man, that's intense,' but now knowing she's standing where he stood and actually talking to him as a living person? I'm not okay.
... Read More
"The farm was pitch black without a single light. Only when Sylvia lit the lantern she brought could they somewhat see ahead." This line and the scene around it are some of the most atmospheric writing I've read in this book. Let me paint it for you: midnight, a woman leading a glowing lantern through complete darkness, down to a farm that shouldn't even exist. And then inside, the revelation—not livestock, but a human cage with shackles on the floor, chains connecting them, the whole setup screaming 'people go missing here.' The sensory details pile up in this slow, dreadful way. You're walking alongside Lize, lantern light flickering, and each step reveals something worse than the last. But then the tone does this incredible flip. Instead of horror, we get Lize's internal monologue going 'oh my god this is where the male and female leads had their first steamy scene.' The contrast between the gothic dread of the setting and Lize's completely unhinged appreciation of it as fan service is either the funniest or the most disturbed thing I've encountered in this genre. Maybe both. And the worldbuilding details are dropping like bombs in this passage. 'The Cayenne family's human cage.' 'In those shackles. For months, sometimes even years.' One sentence and you realize this mansion isn't just a fancy house with mean servants—it's a place where people are imprisoned for disobedience, and the 'useful' hostages get treated better than the staff quarters. The slum-born servants who 'resorted to crime' adding another layer of moral complexity to who lives here and why. This place feels real, lived-in, and genuinely dangerous. Not fairy-tale dangerous, but 'your neighbor might be chained in a barn' dangerous. I'm obsessed.
... Read More
"There not a single ray of sunlight entered. The spacious room was filled with all kinds of torture devices. Whips and iron skewers of various sizes hung on the walls, and devices I had only seen in movies were displayed everywhere." I need to sit down. This description gave me literal chills. The author doesn't just tell us it's a torture room—they make you SEE it. No sunlight. Spacious. Meticulously collected. The fact that Naran refers to it as his workshop and cleans it himself every morning adds this layer of domestic normalcy to something utterly horrifying, and that contrast is chef's kiss. And the corridor leading to it? "Deliberately designed to be difficult to navigate." Of course it is. This is a mansion built by a family where the eldest daughter is a political genius, the second son is the strongest being in the world, and the youngest son collects pain instruments like some people collect stamps. I also love how the kitchen scene plays out right after. Naran, this terrifying guy with a room full of iron skewers, suddenly acts like a proper host and makes sure Lize gets fed. Calls over the head maid, threatens her life if anything happens to his hostage. The tonal whiplash between 'I could torture you' and 'please enjoy your breakfast' is so Naran. The red-haired head maid's resentful glance at Lize? Little details like that make this world feel so real.
... Read More
Let me just say this chapter structure is a masterclass in misdirection. Act One: domestic comedy. Lize getting served breakfast by a hostile maid, bickering about dessert like it's a sitcom. You're smiling, you're relaxed, you're thinking 'this is a cute fluff moment.' Then Act Two hits like a truck. Sylvia's fake emergency, the journey through the dark, the cage locking behind them—the entire tone inverts and suddenly we're in full thriller territory. The pacing here is ruthless. There's no breathing room between 'this is fine' and 'I'm going to be imprisoned forever.' But then the third act—the escape—is where the author really earns their keep. Lize doesn't have a dramatic fight scene or a sudden power reveal. She just... walks out. Because she read the book. The resolution comes from meta-knowledge, not combat or magic or anything traditional. It's elegant and quick and almost anticlimactic, which somehow makes it more satisfying because the entire chapter has been building toward a climax that deflates in the best possible way. And the chapter ends mid-confrontation, with Lize holding Sylvia's hand to her own neck and the servants frozen in indecision. No cliffhanger tag, no 'to be continued.' Just... she said 'try to kill me' and now everyone is staring at her. The pacing gives you exactly what you need and no more. Every beat lands. I read this in one sitting and immediately opened the next chapter before I even processed what happened.
... Read More
There are so many layers to unpack in this chapter and I barely have the energy. But the central image—the human cage—is impossible to ignore. A cage meant for livestock, used to imprison people. 'We lock up humans who don't listen or make mistakes.' The Cayenne family doesn't just hold Lize as a hostage; the entire power structure of this estate runs on the threat of dehumanization. Servants become animals. Disobedient people become caged things. And Lize, the 'noble saintess,' is supposed to occupy the top of this hierarchy—fed, housed, protected—while everyone below her suffers. But here's where it gets interesting. Lize knows she's a character in a story. She knows the script. And that knowledge becomes her cage key—literally, because she knows about the secret brick that opens the cage from the inside. The meta-awareness isn't just comedic relief; it's a form of power. In a world where everyone is trapped by their roles (hostage, servant, master), Lize's awareness of the narrative gives her an escape route the other characters don't have. She's not just surviving the plot—she's using the plot against itself. And then there's the scene location itself. The very place where the original protagonists had their most intimate encounter is now a dungeon of cruelty. The romance of the source material is built on top of abuse and captivity. Lize standing in that same space, not as a romantic participant but as a prisoner who recognizes the architecture of her own story—it's almost like the novel is commenting on how dark romance genre conventions can be when you actually examine the setting. The 'steam' in 'steam scene' takes on a completely different meaning when you're locked in a cold cage. Chilling. Absolutely brilliant.
... Read More
"I'm saying this because I'm worried. Worried about you." — said the woman who was about to commit murder, with a straight face. I still cannot get over Sylvia. Like, anyone else in this book might be forgivable but the level of theatrical menace this woman brings is something else entirely. She went from sneering at Lize over breakfast to orchestrating an elaborate kidnapping trap in one afternoon. That's not petty, that's professional. But what's fascinating is how the text keeps revealing layers. On the surface she's just a resentful servant who hates the 'noble being' eating free meals, right? Classic class resentment angle. But then you see her kneeling and crying on Lize's doorstep, and suddenly it's clear this woman has been performing emotion since she could walk. The narration literally says so—'an act she had perfected since she first learned to walk in order to survive.' She didn't choose bitterness, she learned it as a survival mechanism. That makes her a thousand times more interesting than a cartoon villain. And the dynamic with Lize? It's so asymmetrical and yet it keeps shifting. Sylvia thinks she's the predator in this relationship, but every time she makes a move, Lize recontextualizes it. First she diffuses the breakfast confrontation by asking for dessert. Then she walks into the trap and escapes it because she knows the source material. Then she reverses the power dynamic entirely by grabbing Sylvia's hand. Lize isn't being brave—she's being casually, almost carelessly brilliant. And I think that's what makes their relationship so electric. Sylvia is playing chess and Lize is apparently reading the rulebook.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this confrontation sequence is actually genius level storytelling. You have Sylvia trying to murder Lize in front of everyone, then Juan and Arkle show up like the cavalry. But here's the thing that really got me—when Lize actually FORGESIVES Sylvia? That's not saint behavior, that's survival instinct mixed with some dark curiosity. She literally admits "Actually, well, I kind of enjoyed it a bit" right after getting strangled. That is not someone who should be called a saintess and the book KNOWS it. But the real plot twist here isn't the violence—it's the magical system reveal. Holy power requires reverence from the recipient. Not just any belief, not just any respect. SINCERE reverence. And the whole second half of this chapter is basically Lize figuring out how to game that system. She's not some naive isekai protagonist pretending to be holy. She's calculating, self-aware, and she uses her knowledge of the original novel to her advantage. When she tells Arkle to beg with sincerity, she's not being cruel for no reason—she's engineering the exact emotional state that will activate her power. The structure of these chapters also does something I really appreciate. It starts with external conflict (the servants threatening Lize), moves to character introduction (Arkle's entrance), then pivots into this deeply intimate scene where the real stakes are revealed. By the time we learn about the magical resonance and the conditions for healing, we're already emotionally invested. And that line from Jean Allenheim about "holy power would work on you bastards who have no love for humanity anyway"—that's foreshadowing so good it hurts. The author is building a theme here about what sincerity actually means, and Lize is going to be the one to prove that desperation counts too.
... Read More
Okay, I need to dedicate an entire note to the aftermath of the desk scene because IT WAS EVERYTHING. So Lize is kneeling in front of Arkle, trying to demonstrate what 'begging' looks like because apparently he's too emotionally stunted to understand the concept. She's doing her best pitiful voice, looking up at him with teary eyes, and what does Arkle do? Absolutely nothing. Not a flicker of emotion. Just stares at her like a wooden statue. And then the narrator goes: 'Even though I looked at him so pitifully, Arkle's face remained expressionless, without a hint of emotion.' My heart broke a little for her honestly. She was putting in effort and getting zero return. BUT THEN — and this is the part that actually made me sit up — we get Arkle's POV after she leaves. He's standing there alone, replaying what she said: 'We're both strange people.' 'Heartless.' He puts his hand on his chest and feels his heart pounding. 'Despite being called heartless, his heart was pounding quite fiercely now.' 'The tin man's heart began to beat again.' I am not okay. This man has felt nothing his entire life, and the mere thought of THIS woman makes his heart race faster than any battle ever did. He thinks it's a curse, he's genuinely concerned it might be some kind of magical backlash, but it's obviously NOT that at all. The fact that he's calling it 'serious... one curse is enough' while his face turns red and his heart won't stop racing — this is peak slow-burn romance writing and I am invested.
... Read More
This entire scene takes place in what I can only describe as a gilded cage wearing a mansion's disguise. The Morris Mine explosions that opened the chapter echo through every interaction - these magical stones aren't just plot devices, they're the literal foundation of House Cayenne's rise and Gillian's corporate crimes. Notice how the setting mirrors the power dynamics: Arkle sits casually drinking while Gillian stands trembling, the newspaper article becomes a weapon, then the contract. The servants emerge like ghosts from the walls - Sylvia first, then others appearing one by one, creating that delicious sense of a hidden army finally revealed. And the magical tool! That little spherical device Gillian pulls out thinking it'll save him, only for a kitchen knife to shatter it mid-gesture - that's worldbuilding in motion. This is a society where magic and mundane violence coexist seamlessly. The contrast between the polite banquet hall setting and the brutal negotiation happening within it says everything about this world's social codes. Everyone's performing civility while holding knives. Even the hair Gillian collected - such a petty, intimate detail in a story about mines and contracts. It makes the world feel lived-in, dangerous, real.
... Read More
The stakes here operate on so many levels simultaneously it's almost dizzying. On the surface: Lize is a hostage in a dangerous mansion run by the notoriously reclusive and rumored-evil Cayenne family. That's real danger — we're told she was previously living 'like a breathing corpse before the possession,' and the farm incident shows the staff almost crossed a line with her. But layer on top of that the meta-conflict: Lize knows the original story's plot, and Gillian Moril is about to walk into a trap that will expose everything. The original narrative has Gillian discovering Lize's captivity and informing Jean, which presumably triggers the rescue arc. But Lize is now interfering — she made a deal with Arkle to ensure the dinner party succeeds, which means the original timeline is breaking apart. What happens when the script changes? Who does Jean rescue if Gillian never exposes the Cayennes? And what's the favor Lize wants from Arkle that he 'would absolutely refuse' if he knew about it? Those last two lines hit like a hammer. Whatever she's planning, it's tied to seeing Arkle break emotionally, and the fact that she's willing to alter the entire plot structure to achieve it tells us this conflict is deeply personal, not just about survival. The external threat (Cayenne reputation, magical politics with House Moril) and the internal obsession (her desire to make Arkle cry) are converging into something that could go spectacularly wrong.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or