In the clouds - Reviews

In the clouds
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just start by saying: the dialogue in these chapters is deceptively simple. On the surface it's just people talking about food and the weather and whether someone's tired. But underneath every conversation is this whole other layer of meaning that only becomes visible in retrospect. Take the eggplant exchange. Wen Ruqing: "Why aren't you eating the vegetables?" Bai Xizhou: "I don't really like eggplant." Wen Ruqing: "Such a waste. You're not disgusted by it, are you?" And then he doubles down: "Not just that he doesn't like eggplant, he can't stand our countryside food. Such a young master attitude." This is pure Wen Ruqing. He sees an opening and he takes it, not out of cruelty but out of this need to provoke a reaction, to make the interaction matter. And Bai Xizhou's response? He just forces a smile and eats his rice. He doesn't rise to the bait. He marks Wen Ruqing with a cross in his mind and moves on. The power dynamic here is fascinating—who's actually in control? The one who speaks or the one who chooses not to respond? Old Chen's dialogue is always a relief. "Lawyer Bai doesn't like eggplant?" he says, completely missing the tension. His lines are warm, natural, unhurried. He exists in a completely different emotional register from the younger two. The contrast makes their tension even sharper. And Wen Ruqing's whisper to Bai Xizhou—"Are you awake? I'm worried you're still asleep and might drive the scooter into a ditch"—such a perfect example of saying the exact opposite of what you mean. Of course he's worried about Wen Ruqing's safety. That's how you know he cares.
... Read More
I need to process what just happened and I'm not sure I can. So Wen Ruqing spends FIVE MINUTES just watching Bai Xizhou work. Five minutes of absolute peace. His boss is focused, the office is quiet, there's this gentle warmth building in his chest that he can't name. He's happy. He's content. He's having a moment. And then Bai looks up, counts his fingers like he's keeping track of delayed seconds, and says: 'You're two minutes late.' Not 'Thanks for bringing this.' Not even 'I appreciate the help.' Two. Minutes. Late. As if Wen has a schedule to keep. As if he works for this man. As if he isn't the INNKEEPER who hosts him. The stakes here are SO low and SO high at the same time. Low because it's two minutes over a USB drive. High because in that moment, something fundamental shifted between them. Bai re-established a boundary. He made it clear: I am your client, you are my helper, do not mistake courtesy for closeness. But Wen doesn't push back. He just... accepts it. Offers a weak excuse, apologizes, and swallows the sting. The conflict isn't dramatic. There's no shouting match, no betrayal, no revelation. It's quieter than that. It's the conflict of someone realizing they cared more about this interaction than the other person did. And the ending just cuts off. Mid-sentence. Like the moment itself. No resolution, no comfort, no promise that things will get better. Just... hanging. And I'm still hanging.
... Read More
Okay so the plot in these first four chapters is basically a masterclass in controlled setup. Bai Xizhou arrives in Yunduan Town—already late, already stressed, already mentally fraying—and the author doesn't pull any punches with the obstacles. Delayed train, no driver waiting, a chatty taxi driver who refuses to take no for an answer, and then his thoughts getting hijacked by his father. Every single thing that happens to him is a tiny brick in the wall of his irritability. And you know what? It makes total sense. The plot isn't throwing crazy twists at us yet—that's not the point. The point is: who is this man, what is he running from, and why does this sleepy, rain-soaked town feel like the only place he can breathe? The handover at the legal aid center is almost bureaucratic in its mundanity, which somehow makes it more interesting. And that ending beat—Wen Ruqing, that thin person who can't even look at him—everything about this setup is humming with future explosions. Just the right amount of "I need to know what happens next."
... Read More
Okay so can we talk about how brilliantly this chapter reveals their dynamic? Wen Ruqing pretending to be angry — and Bai Xizhou completely walking right into it. The author note literally calls Bai Xizhou "Little Liar" and Wen Ruqing "Hehe" which is SO accurate. Wen Ruqing is clearly the manipulative one here, but in a fond way, not a malicious way. He engineered an entire fake conflict just to get dinner with Bai Xizhou. And Bai Xizhou, this apparently sharp lawyer who probably tears apart witnesses for fun, gets completely played by someone younger than him. The line "you're really easy to fool" delivered with that helpless smile — chef's kiss. But what I love most is that beneath the teasing, there's genuine care. Wen Ruqing noticed Bai Xizhou crossed out the garlic eggplant without even being asked. That's the kind of small, quiet attention that says more than any grand gesture ever could. Their whole dance — the manufactured anger, the apology, the roadside stall date disguised as compensation — it's all wrapped in this layer of unspoken warmth. Bai Xizhou might be the 'easy fool' in this moment, but he's also the one who would ride a windy electric bike to a greasy street stall for someone. Who's really winning here, honestly?
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is actually doing SO much heavy lifting and I need to talk about it. First, let's address the obvious: Wen Ruqing's voice is 'floating through the air' when he introduces himself. That's such a specific, almost poetic choice for the narrator. It's not just dialogue; it's atmosphere woven into conversation. But what really sold me is how each character sounds distinct. Grandpa Chen's lines are all loud and angry - 'Is this because of that little brat!' and 'I haven't gone to sue them yet, but they've already hired a lawyer!' You can HEAR this old man's frustration. He's defensive, suspicious, and completely untrusting of the young man before him. And then there's Wen Ruqing's softer, almost childlike energy - 'Why are you in a daze, Lawyer Bai? I'm starving. Aren't you hungry?' with him 'tilting his head with a childlike innocence on his face.' The contrast is immediate and telling. Bai Xizhou's dialogue is all business mostly, but when he says 'Put your wristband back on,' that's it. That's the entire emotional weight of the scene compressed into three words. And then Wen Ruqing's internal panic - 'Should he explain something, or just let the atmosphere continue?' - this is the narrator getting inside his head, showing us the gap between what's said and what's felt. The best line though has to be Wen Ruqing muttering 'How annoying!' under his breath. It's petty, it's human, and it's absolutely perfect. Because sometimes the most honest moments are the ones where someone just admits they're irritated without explaining why.
... Read More
The pacing here is absolutely masterful, and I want to break down why it works so well. The chapter opens at TENSION PEAK — an argument already in progress. Two minutes late, criticized, Wen Ruqing turning cold. We're thrown right into the conflict with zero preamble. Then instead of resolving it quickly, the author makes us sit in the awkward aftermath: Liu Li leaving, the office emptying out, Bai Xizhou actually following up with a sincere apology. The meal setup acts as a pressure valve — we exhale, but then the real question hangs over everything: what does Wen Ruqing actually want to talk about? Every beat of crawfish-peeling silence stretches that tension thinner. And between the conflict and the revelation, we get this gorgeous sunset interlude that functions as a narrative breath. The author is playing with our expectations like a cat with a string — teasing us with dramatic conflict, then deflating it into something softer, then building a different kind of suspense (the unsaid thing) on top of the romance. By the time we hit the end of this excerpt, I am DESPERATE to know what Wen Ruqing was saving up the courage to say. And the chapter doesn't give me easy answers. It lets the moment breathe.
... Read More
I need to talk about the birthday cake moment because I am NOT okay. So these two just had a full-blown argument the night before, right? Things are tense, Bai Xizhou is all closed off, and then Wen Ruqing literally shows up at his door with a slightly smashed piece of fruit cake because he saved him a slice and didn't want it to go bad. This man crossed a finish line in awkwardness and kept running. And Bai Xizhou's reaction—his mind immediately goes to this memory of a shy girl in high school who nervously handed him a love letter. He literally says they're not similar AT ALL but the scene brought the memory to mind anyway. I SCREAMED. The fact that Wen Ruqing is basically handing him something sweet while standing awkwardly with his hands clasped behind his back—it's so earnest and tender and Bai Xizhou doesn't even know how to process it. He opens his mouth to make an excuse about not liking overly sweet cream and what comes out is just... "Why?" Like he genuinely can't understand why someone would go out of their way for him after everything. That line hit me so hard. These two are walking on eggshells around each other and I'm just sitting here losing my mind.
... Read More
There's this one detail that's been looping in my head since I finished these chapters—the scars on Wen Ruqing's hands. They're mentioned almost in passing early on, something that makes Bai Xizhou worry Wen might harm himself again. But I think they're doing way more heavy lifting than that. Scars are evidence of something that happened, yes, but they're also proof of healing. Of survival. And then there's Bai Xizhou's shattered bank card from his dream—that broken plastic sitting on the table when he wakes up. Both are fragments of things that were once whole. The card represented his rupture from family, from expected paths, from a life that didn't feel like his own. The scars represent whatever Wen Ruqing has survived that Bai Xizhou doesn't fully understand yet. And the space between these two men—literally the doorway, the hallway, the distance they keep maintaining—keeps becoming a symbol too. Every time Wen Ruqing reaches across that gap with something small (a piece of cake, a sincere apology, a question he won't let go of), Bai Xizhou wavers. The themes here are about how people carry their damage and how proximity forces you to either hide it or let someone see it. Neither of them knows how to do either one well yet.
... Read More
I need to talk about Bai Xizhou and Wen Ruqing because WOW. From the moment they're on that scooter together, there's this whole unspoken thing happening. The text literally says 'Bai Xizhou didn't care, saying it was fine, but in the next moment, the scooter suddenly slid, causing Bai Xizhou to tip to one side. He instinctively grabbed Wen Ruqing's waist to steady himself.' AND THEN 'Holding onto his waist was actually a little uncomfortable, but to avoid being thrown off, Bai Xizhou didn't let go.' That last part? That's the part that got me. He wasn't letting go because he needed to hold on - he was letting go because... well, actually he wasn't letting go. He was just trying to stay upright but you can feel the tension there. And then when Wen Ruqing asks his name after all that physical contact? Chef's kiss. But the emotional peak for me is definitely that scene at the water faucet. Bai Xizhou sees this scar on Wen Ruqing's wrist, this pink-ish mark that doesn't look healed yet. And then he deliberately shifts his position to avoid touching that spot when he holds Wen Ruqing's wrist. That's such a subtle, caring gesture. And then he tells Wen Ruqing to put his wristband back on? I was screaming inside. Because you KNOW he saw it. You KNOW he knows something is going on. And Wen Ruqing is over there panicking like 'did he find out? Should I explain?' while Bai Xizhou is just... being weirdly gentle about it. The line 'You could practically see his face drop' - no, that's not what I meant, but Wen Ruqing's entire body went stiff and then he pulled his hand behind his back like a kid caught doing something wrong. And Bai Xizhou just said 'let's go eat' and walked away? I'm dead. This is the good stuff. This is the kind of moment that makes you reread pages three times.
... Read More
The symbolism in this chapter is NOT subtle and I'm here for it. That watch. It's broken. It doesn't tell time anymore. Stripped of function, it's just a useless item. And yet—Bai Xizhou kept it. Why give away something you hold onto? Maybe it represents something he can't let go of but also can't use. The watch was 'from a friend' according to him, but the person on the phone clearly knows him intimately, calls him 'Gege,' and seems angry about something. Is the watch connected to THIS person? Time not working properly could mirror how Bai Xizhou's emotional life is stuck or broken. And Wen Ruqing—touching the watch unconsciously, his fingers brushing over it constantly. The doctor's voice says it reflects 'inner thoughts' about someone he values. Is he projecting? Is he becoming attached to Bai Xizhou through this object? The coffee too—he made it because Bai Xizhou drinks it, it's 'the same type he drank back in Xincheng.' Nostalgia and connection through everyday objects. Even the school field, where students look like 'blooming sunflowers,' contrasts with Wen Ruqing's memory of his own high school where 'even smiles were rare.' Growth, healing, different paths—these aren't random details, they're deliberate thematic choices.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the word 'boundaries' because it's literally the central conflict of these chapters. Last night Wen Ruqing crossed some line, Bai Xizhou got upset, and today Wen Ruqing is standing at his door apologizing for it. But here's the thing that made me genuinely anxious—Bai Xizhou's internal monologue right after the argument. He's not just dealing with Wen Ruqing's questions. He's wrestling with the fact that his unconscious confession during their all-night conversation revealed things he'd never intended to share. The stakes here aren't dramatic in a traditional sense—nobody's life is in danger—but emotionally? It's everything. Bai Xizhou built his entire adult life on self-reliance and emotional containment. Wen Ruqing barged into that. And every scene in these chapters is a negotiation: how close is too close? How much truth is safe to share? When Wen Ruqing says 'I can't give you the answers you're looking for,' Bai Xizhou's expression darkens and his internal question cuts off mid-sentence. That trailing thought—what he was about to say about boundaries—felt like a cliffhanger more intense than anything in an action novel. What WAS he about to say? And more importantly, what is Wen Ruqing willing to risk to find out?
... Read More
I need to talk about the atmospheric shift in this chapter because it's intentional and beautiful. We start in Bai Xizhou's office — controlled, professional, air-conditioned, the space where he holds all the power. Then Wen Ruqing drags him onto a windblown electric bike to a roadside stall where Bai Xizhou's actual comfort zone shatters. The contrast isn't just visual, it's emotional. That scene where Bai Xizhou pulls out napkins for the greasy table? Perfect character detail through environment. His mysophobia against the oily plastic chairs and makeshift canopies — you can feel his discomfort, but also his willingness to endure it for Wen Ruqing. And the town itself becomes a character: the orange-red sunset, the oilcloth partitions between tables, electric bikes parked "neatly yet somewhat haphazardly," the sound of ordering and laughing blending into the night. "If not for seeking Wen Ruqing's forgiveness, Bai Xizhou might never have set foot in such a place." This is a man who lives in a world of consultation rooms and contracts finding himself under a makeshift canopy eating crawfish with his arm resting on three layers of paper napkins. The world-building doesn't need dragons or magic systems — just one carefully observed street at twilight, and suddenly you're living inside it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or