In the clouds - Reviews

In the clouds
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—this section right here? The part where Wen Ruqing shows up to deliver the USB drive and gets lectured about being two minutes late? I actually slammed my phone down. Like physically slammed it. Because WHAT does Lawyer Bai think he's doing coming off as such a cold jerk? But then—I couldn't stop replaying what happened BEFORE that. The scooter ride. The way Wen tightened his grip around Bai's waist when the road got bumpy. That was SO specific and intimate but written like it was totally casual, like it was just... natural. He didn't even realize he was smiling until later. That's the kind of detail that gets me. That quiet, unconscious physical closeness. And then the part where Wen stands in the doorway watching Bai work. Just watching. Five full minutes he wastes standing there, and he doesn't even notice. His arms are rolled up, he's focused on his keyboard, and Wen is just... transfixed. The text says something about a 'slight stir of warmth in his heart, a gentle wave of emotion so subtle he didn't even notice it.' Subtle enough that even HE doesn't notice it. And I noticed. I absolutely noticed. Then BAM—five minutes later he's standing at the door and gets scolded like a child. The fingers-to-face gesture, the cold voice, the 'you should be more aware of time.' He's treating Wen like his subordinate. But Wen ISN'T his subordinate. And the worst part? Wen doesn't even defend himself properly. He just mumbles an excuse and never mentions that those five minutes were spent just WATCHING him work. The fact that he keeps that secret—that vulnerability—tucked away while Bai treats him like an errand boy? My heart.
... Read More
Let me break down the conflict layers in this chapter because there are SO many and they're all working together brilliantly. First, the external conflict: Grandpa Chen vs. his two sons over an apartment. This is clear, tangible, and emotionally resonant. An old man getting old, his house being demolished, being offered a new one that's unfinished and can't move into. His sons both want the apartment but neither wants him. That's brutal. And now he's being dragged into legal proceedings he didn't ask for, and he doesn't trust the 'lawyer' showing up. The stakes are his home, his independence, his dignity. But the internal conflict - and this is where it gets interesting - is Wen Ruqing. The text drops hints everywhere: 'he was smiling, but it seemed like he didn't really want to smile,' then that scar, then his panic about whether Bai Xizhou noticed, whether he should explain, whether telling his aunt would change things. What is Wen Ruqing hiding? Is it a medical condition? A past trauma? The text won't tell us, and that uncertainty is deliberate. Then there's the interpersonal tension between Bai Xizhou and Wen Ruqing. Bai Xizhou notices the scar but doesn't confront him about it. He tells him to put the wristband back on, avoids touching the wounded area, watches him with 'a complex expression.' Is this curiosity? Concern? Something more? And Wen Ruqing is over there spiraling about whether he's been discovered, whether to talk to Bai Xizhou about it, whether it'll be 'walking right into his own trap.' The stakes here aren't about winning or losing a case. They're about trust, about vulnerability, about whether two people who barely know each other can see past their surfaces. And honestly? That's way more compelling than any courtroom drama.
... Read More
Okay so the whole Fujiang No.1 High School setup was actually super vivid. Like, you could literally feel the warm sunlight, see the students marching onto the field in neat rows, the whole atmosphere of a typical Chinese school event. And then there's Wen Ruqing standing under that tree—watching his sister in the front row, the girls pulling her closer to gossip. The author painted this picture of 'blooming sunflowers' which honestly made me visualize it so clearly. It's one of those scenes where everything feels alive. The contrast between the quiet campus during class hours and the energy once everyone's gathered is perfect. I love how the lecture venue on the field becomes this shared space where past and present collide for Wen Ruqing, since he went to that same school and his dad taught there too. And then later, the inn setting at night—that dimly lit room with Bai Xizhou stumbling through the door, the phone ringing under his arm, the strong smell of alcohol. The author doesn't over-describe but the sensory details land every time. The shift from bright afternoon sunlight to that heavy, confused nighttime scene creates such a mood swing. It's like the story itself gets darker as the chapter progresses, and the setting mirrors that perfectly.
... Read More
I need to talk about the atmosphere in these chapters because WOW. The author doesn't just describe a setting—they make you feel like you're standing right there in Yunduan Town. Not some generic small town, but ONE with specific texture. Remember that early summer night? The moist air, the evening breeze, the smell of earth after rain? That's not just set dressing. That sensory detail right at the beginning of the scooter scene grounds the whole emotional beat. You can SMELL that moment. It makes the apology scene feel so much more intimate too—like they're alone on this dark road with only the wind and each other. And Bai Xizhou's room! Let me just say: the desk organized from largest to smallest books, pens lined up beside stationery, the bed looking untouched even though it's been a month. This isn't just 'he's neat.' This is OCD-level precision that tells you everything about who this man is without a single personality adjective. His room is basically a visual argument for his professional competence and his emotional walls. The aid center office has this quiet energy too—just the sound of his keyboard tapping, his jacket draped over the chair, the way natural light falls across his desk. It's domestic in a way that makes Wen's five-minute stare feel earned. You're in a space designed for work but accidentally becoming a space for something else entirely. I also love how the inn itself functions. The landline that barely rings, the aunt popping in with food containers, the way Wen carries both a USB drive and food boxes at once—this world is lived-in and cluttered in the right places. It contrasts beautifully with Bai's sterile, staged-looking room. Two worlds colliding in one town.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is actually really good. Bai Xizhou has this dry, almost sarcastic way of speaking that's distinctive. When he says 'Look at you acting like it's a crisis' about the school lecture invitation—that's classic deflection with a side of warmth. And then 'Thanks, by the way. The coffee is really good' while completely dismissing the whole assistant-duty topic? Perfect character moment. He's grateful but won't show it directly. The mysterious phone caller is another voice that pops off—aggressive, protective, switching from cursing to serious to cryptic warning in seconds. 'You're the idiot, aren't you?' versus 'Stay away from drunk Bai Xizhou.' That tonal whiplash tells us everything about this person's relationship to Bai Xizhou. Wen Ruqing's dialogue is more hesitant, more questioning—which contrasts nicely. And that ending line 'Why did you use my phone?'—so casual, so Bai Xizhou, even after getting drunk. The author gives each character a distinct speech pattern without making it overbearing. Even the minor characters like Xie Yuzhu have voice: 'Brother, when did you buy this watch?' is innocent curiosity that drives the plot forward naturally.
... Read More
"The electric scooter sped down the road. Wen Ruqing drove steadily, but faster than during the day, making Bai Xizhou feel the need to hold onto his waist. He didn't want to be thrown off." I just— I reread this passage five times. FIVE TIMES. Do you understand what's happening here? Wen Ruqing is driving faster intentionally. He's creating a reason for Bai Xizhou to touch him, and he's doing it so casually that if you blinked you'd miss it. And Bai Xizhou? He holds on. Not because he's scared of falling, the text tells us explicitly. Because he wants to. This is the most dangerous kind of romance writing. Not the dramatic confessions or the rain-soaked kisses. This is the quiet, almost accidental intimacy of two guys who are completely unaware of what they're doing to each other. Wen Ruqing putting a coat over Bai Xizhou while he slept. Bai Xizhou staying by the door the entire afternoon because he couldn't bring himself to leave. These people are so bad at hiding their feelings and yet so terrible at admitting them to themselves. And then there's the dream sequence—Wen Ruqing hearing voices in his sleep, arguments he can't escape, and the one clear thing cutting through all that chaos is Bai Xizhou's voice. "Steady and powerful, providing a sense of security." Security. That's the word. After everything Wen Ruqing's been through, the one sound that makes him safe is another man's voice. I'm not okay with this. I'm genuinely not okay.
... Read More
Okay so the dream sequence. At first I thought it was just flavor text, you know, giving us some context on Bai Xizhou's past. But honestly? It reframed the entire chapter. Think about it: he applied to a school in Germany the day AFTER dinner with his best friends, left without telling anyone, cut up his parents' bank card out of spite and moved completely on his own terms. That's not just a flashback—that's a pattern. The man runs. He isolates himself. He makes dramatic unilateral decisions and then acts like nothing happened. And NOW Wen Ruqing is asking him personal questions, probing at things he hasn't told anyone, and Bai Xizhou is having flashes of that same defensive mechanism kicking in. The dream ended with him waking up feeling like the shattered bank card was still on the table. THAT is authorial intention right there—the past isn't past, it's sitting right in front of him. The narrative is basically saying: every time Wen Ruqing gets close, Bai Xizhou's whole survival system goes into overdrive. The fact that the story gave us this dream right after their argument wasn't accidental. It was the plot itself reminding us what's at stake if this relationship actually goes anywhere.
... Read More
The stakes are escalating and I need to know what happens next. On the surface, nothing catastrophic—it's just a school lecture and a drunk lawyer coming home. But the UNDERCURRENTS are where the conflict lives. Wen Ruqing's internal conflict: he wants to understand Bai Xizhou, to be useful, to maybe... more? But he's also cautious, asking 'Are you sure you don't need me here?' repeatedly. The external conflict is building too—that mysterious caller represents some past relationship or complication that could disrupt the fragile dynamic forming between our two leads. The warning 'You'll regret it if you don't' suggests danger, not necessarily physical, but emotional. What happens when Bai Xizhou isn't the composed lawyer anymore? What version of him emerges when sober? The tension of that final scene—Wen Ruqing attending to a drunk Bai Xizhou, the phone call interrupting, Bai Xizhou waking up and immediately questioning him—is charged with something unspoken. Every character here is standing at a threshold. Wen Ruqing is gaining access to Bai Xizhou's private world, and the stakes feel real because we sense there are layers beneath the surface that haven't been explored yet.
... Read More
I've been thinking about this USB drive all day. It's such a small thing—literally fits in your palm—and yet it carries so much weight in this narrative. On the surface, it's just a forgotten piece of technology. But look at what it does: it gives Wen an excuse to enter Bai's space. To see his room. To watch him work. To feel that warmth that 'he didn't even notice.' The USB drive is the key that unlocks the door to Bai's world, and Wen walks through it carrying something else entirely—curiosity, fascination, maybe something warmer. And the warmth itself! The text literally says the USB was warming in Wen's palm. Is that the USB drive? Or is it his hand? The ambiguity is intentional. The object he's carrying becomes heated by his own emotions. There's also the contrast between Wen's room at the inn and Bai's room at the aid center. Wen's world is warm, cluttered, familial (his aunt with food containers, the loud laughter, the everyday mess). Bai's world is pristine, ordered, almost sterile—books stacked by size, pens perfectly aligned, a bed that hasn't been slept in. One man lives; the other exists. And the USB drive is the bridge between these two ways of being. The old watch on Bai's wrist is another detail that won't leave me. An old watch, not a new one. Something inherited or kept deliberately. In a man who controls everything else about his environment, one thing remains unchanged. Is that sentimentality? Nostalgia? Or just practicality? The text doesn't tell us, and that's the point. The symbols don't explain themselves. They just sit there, waiting to be felt.
... Read More
"Sorry." Just one word. One word from Wen Ruqing and everything shifts. Let me just talk about how the dialogue works in this section because it's doing SO MUCH heavy lifting without ever feeling heavy. The entire scooter ride conversation is basically two people circling each other, saying things that aren't really about what they're saying. 'Do you like being a lawyer?' 'Have you never gotten tired of it?' These aren't casual questions—they're someone testing the waters, trying to understand a person they haven't quite figured out yet. And Bai's answers are so blunt and clean. 'Of course.' 'No.' Two words, no elaboration. He's not the type to wax poetic. But the narration tells us he felt something behind Wen's words, and that gap between what's spoken and what's felt? That's where the whole scene lives. Then the apology. Wen says sorry for putting Bai in an awkward position, and Bai's internal response is fascinating. He appreciates the apology. Not because he's easy-going (though he claims he is), but because it signals social awareness. Someone who knows boundaries is someone he can relax around. This is a man who reads people through their manners. But then the delivery scene? Completely different energy. Bai's voice turns cold. 'You're two minutes late.' 'You should be more aware of time.' That's not how you talk to someone who just ran an errand for you. That's how you talk to someone below you. And the dialogue captures this power dynamic perfectly—short sentences, imperative tone, no pleasantries. The contrast between his earlier warmth and this coldness is devastating because it's ALL in the way he speaks.
... Read More
This chapter has such a deliberate pacing structure. It starts slow and warm—the coffee routine, the easy job acceptance, the pleasant afternoon at the school. The author takes time here, letting us settle into the scene. The lecture sequence is efficient but not rushed; we get the Q&A, the students' reactions, Xie Yuzhu's interruption—all while maintaining that bright, comfortable tone. Then comes the shift. Bai Xizhou leaves for a social event, time passes (we're told it's past 10pm), and suddenly we're in a completely different mood. The transition from the sunlit field to the dark inn hallway is jarring in the best way. The drunk arrival scene moves faster—Bai Xizhou stumbling, the phone ringing, the caller's aggressive dialogue all happens in quick succession. By the time Bai Xizhou speaks that final line, the chapter has built enough tension that the ending hits hard. The structure mirrors emotional movement: comfort → stability → disruption → mystery. It's a textbook example of how to control reader engagement through pacing, and honestly, it works. I wanted to keep reading to see what happens next because the author earned that curiosity.
... Read More
So the plot threads are weaving together nicely. We've got Wen Ruqing getting the assistant job at the center, which obviously ties him closer to Bai Xizhou—but is it coincidence or strategy? He thought being nearby would help him understand Bai Xizhou's temperament, which tells us there's history here we haven't fully seen yet. The watch detail is crucial—Bai Xizhou gave him a broken watch that was 'a gift from a friend,' and now Wen Ruqing can't stop touching it. The doctor's voice in his head saying unconscious actions reflect inner thoughts is basically the author whispering 'pay attention to this.' Then the lecture goes smoothly, but that's just the calm before the storm. Bai Xizhou getting drunk and stumbling home at 10pm? That's a huge character reveal—we've only seen him professional and controlled. And THEN the phone call. This mystery person who answers calling him an idiot, then hearing faint voices calling 'Gege,' then the warning: 'stay away from drunk Bai Xizhou. You'll regret it if you don't.' What does that even mean? Is there someone in Bai Xizhou's past? A lover? A rival? The chapter ends with 'Why did you use my phone?' and Bai Xizhou's voice behind him—absolute cliffhanger energy. The plot is definitely cooking something.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or