In the clouds - Reviews

In the clouds
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Can we just appreciate the atmospheric writing in this chapter though? The opening with the unpaved road, the rain from yesterday making everything wet and muddy - it immediately puts you somewhere. You can feel the bumpiness of that scooter ride, you can smell the damp earth, you can see these two men navigating these small paths through fields. It's not some glamorous city setting; it's raw, real, and it grounds the whole story. And then there's Grandpa Chen's vegetable field. The text mentions Wen Ruqing 'carrying a hoe back' and having 'a light sheen of sweat on his forehead, and his face was slightly flushed from the heat.' I love that detail. It shows us this is someone who actually works with his hands, who's out in the elements. And then Bai Xizhou handing him water, watching him drink - there's this whole visual of the countryside kitchen, the tool shed, the water faucet where they wash up together. The most vivid scene for me is definitely that washing-up moment. The soap bubbles, the running water, Wen Ruqing taking off his wristband because he doesn't want it to get uncomfortable wearing it wet. And then Bai Xizhou seeing this scar in such a casual, domestic setting. It's not some dramatic reveal in a dark alley or anything - it's right there at the faucet while they're getting ready for lunch. The contrast between the ordinary activity and this discovery of something hidden is perfect worldbuilding. It makes the rural setting feel alive and lived-in, not just a backdrop.
... Read More
Let me be honest—the first half of these chapters moved like a sigh. And that's exactly what made the second half hit so much harder. The author spends time on quiet moments: the ride back, the nod at the front desk, the aunt bringing food. None of this is plot-critical. None of it moves the story forward in a traditional sense. But it builds something. It builds a rhythm. A normalcy. You start to feel like this is just... life. Two people coexisting, finding their equilibrium. And then—the USB drive request changes everything. Suddenly the pacing tightens. Wen is dispatched. There's urgency in Bai's voice (even if it's just a forgotten USB). The landline call adds a touch of drama to what could have been another filler chapter. And then we get those five minutes of pure, unbroken stillness—Wen watching Bai work—before the collision happens. The structure here is genius. You go from slow, atmospheric drifting to a tight scene with real emotional friction, and you don't even see it coming. The author lulls you into thinking this is just a quiet slice-of-life moment, then WHAM. Two minutes late and suddenly the dynamic shifts. The pacing itself mirrors what's happening between these characters—they're close, they're comfortable, and then ONE WORD from Bai changes everything. That ending though. 'Did he really need to make such a big deal?'—the sentence cuts off mid-thought. No resolution. No softening. Just abruptness. That structural choice? That's the author doing exactly what Bai does: leaving you hanging.
... Read More
I need to process what this chapter is really about on a deeper level, because there's clearly something bigger going on here than just a legal case or a chance encounter. The central symbol - and I'm not even being subtle about this - is that scar on Wen Ruqing's wrist. It's pinker than the surrounding skin, doesn't look fully healed. And he wears a wristband to cover it. Bai Xizhou notices it immediately, deliberately avoids touching that spot, and then tells him to put the band back on. But he never says WHAT he saw. He never asks. He just... lets it go. What does this represent? I think it's about hidden pain, about the things we carry but don't show. Wen Ruqing presents this cheerful, smiling facade - the text literally says 'he was smiling, but it seemed like he didn't really want to smile.' And Bai Xizhou sees through it. He sees the scar and understands there's a story there without needing words. There's also the Grandpa Chen storyline as parallel symbolism. An old man whose sons want his apartment but not him - that's about being discarded, about family ties that are transactional rather than genuine. And the unfinished apartment, the one he can't move into yet - it's like his future is incomplete, just like Wen Ruqing's hidden pain. The scooter itself feels symbolic too. Two people, one vehicle, navigating muddy roads together. One driving, one holding on. The physical closeness forced by circumstance, the trust required. It's intimacy without romance, connection without confession.
... Read More
Let's talk about what's at stake, because on the surface this is just a lawyer checking into a hotel and meeting a weird guy. But underneath? There's a LOT of conflict simmering. Bai Xizhou has this strong feeling of discomfort around Wen Ruqing—'for some reason, perhaps because he had met so many people over the years'—which means his instincts are firing but his brain can't explain why. That's the kind of internal conflict that usually precedes a major revelation. Then there's the external setup: he's in Yunduan Town for a reason, he's seeing Old Mr. Chen about something important (Liu Li is sending him files), and this entire town operates like a fishbowl where 'there were no secrets.' So the question becomes: what is Bai Xizhou running from or running toward? And what does Wen Ruqing know that makes Bai Xizhou's lawyer instincts scream? The stakes aren't life-or-death yet, but they're building. The auntie's matchmaking isn't just comedic relief—it's active interference that raises the tension every time she pushes them together. And that ending? 'A loud honk snapped him out of his morning reverie'—we cut right as the car arrives. The suspense is real. I need to know what's waiting at Old Mr. Chen's house, and I need to know why these two can't stop colliding.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about how this chapter just… sneaks up on you. It starts with such a mundane moment—Bai Xizhou dragging his suitcase into this tiny hotel—and you'd think nothing's going on. But then the author keeps layering these little beats like: the water heater breaks, he goes downstairs, encounters Wen Ruqing again, doesn't sleep well, comes down the next morning, gets roped into a task. It's not a plot explosion, it's a plot ripple. And honestly? I was into it. The pacing is deliberate, almost uncomfortably slow in places, but there's this underlying current that tells me something's building. Like, why does Bai Xizhou feel discomfort around Wen Ruqing for no reason? Why is the receptionist auntie so invested in pairing them together? These are loose threads, but they're vibrating. The only thing I'll say is—I wanted more from the Old Mr. Chen visit. The chapter cuts off right as the car arrives, which feels like a cliffhanger the author built almost accidentally. But the setup is solid. Little town, two strangers, an overbearing auntie, unexplained tension. What more do you want from a Chapter 4 opener?
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this - the way this chapter starts with them on that electric scooter is literally perfect. First of all, you have this whole setup where Wen Ruqing is like 'trust me I'm a great driver' and Bai Xizhou is clearly having zero of that energy. The scooter sliding on the wet mud road? Classic tension building right there. And then Bai Xizhou grabs Wen Ruqing's waist instinctively? Ugh, I love it. But what really got me is how the plot moves from this seemingly random encounter to the whole Grandpa Chen situation. You've got this elderly man whose two sons want his apartment but don't want him living with them - that's such a real, grounded conflict. And Bai Xizhou is from the Legal Aid Center, not one of the sons' lawyers. The misdirection with Grandpa Chen thinking he's being sued is brilliant storytelling. You could practically see his face drop when someone mentioned 'lawyer.' The pacing here is everything. They meet Uncle Chen, there's all this tension about Grandpa Chen's situation, and then by lunchtime you're left with this moment where Bai Xizhou notices something on Wen Ruqing's wrist. I swear I was like wait what? Because the way it's written, you know this is going to matter later. The scar, the wristband, the way Wen Ruqing immediately puts it back on like he's hiding something... I need answers. Chapter's done and I'm already checking if there's a volume two.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this upfront: the way the author handles the plot in these chapters is actually genius because on the surface it looks like a simple legal case story, but underneath you've got this whole web of hidden wounds and unspoken things. Bai Xizhou notices Wen Ruqing's scar on his wrist and immediately starts theorizing—does he have problems he can't solve? Does he need to hurt himself? That single observation sets off a chain reaction. The whole plot isn't just about resolving Old Chen's case anymore. It's about two broken people circling each other, and the legal work is basically the excuse they use to stay in the same room. What really got me was the transition from the lunch scene to the afternoon nap. One minute they're awkwardly eating together, the next Wen Ruqing is asleep against the doorframe and Bai Xizhou is quietly covering him with a coat. That shift—from tension to something almost tender—happened so naturally you don't even notice it happening until it's already done. And then the scooter scene at the end? Perfect. The author doesn't spell out what's happening between them. Bai Xizhou holds onto Wen Ruqing's waist because he's afraid of falling off, right? Or is there more to it? The plot doesn't force anything. It just lets these moments breathe. I keep coming back to how the case itself works as a plot device. Old Chen's situation brings them together, but the real story is in what's NOT said. Bai Xizhou pretending not to care about the scar while obsessing over it. Wen Ruqing teases him about eggplant but then regrets his own childishness and watches him work in silence. This is plotting at its most confident—letting the audience do the work.
... Read More
So the pacing in these chapters is wild. You've got this big chunk of courtroom/legal stuff happening in the background, right? Old Chen's case, paperwork, the whole deal. But the author refuses to let that dominate. Instead, you get these little pockets of time that just... expand. The lunch scene takes up a ridiculous amount of attention for something as simple as eating rice. The afternoon nap—Wen Ruqing falls asleep and the next thing you know it's dark and Bai Xizhou has been sitting there the whole time. No transition, no warning. Just BAM, five hours have passed and something has shifted. It's almost frustrating how casually the author moves time forward. You're so focused on the legal details that you don't realize the emotional timeline is doing the real work. By the time the scooter scene hits, you're like wait, since when are we doing nighttime scooter rides together? Since the nap, apparently. Since the coat. Since the eggplant incident. None of it feels forced because the author never tries to force it. The pacing trusts you to feel the accumulation. The only moment that slightly dragged for me was the middle section where Bai Xizhou is just organizing case notes. It's necessary for the plot but emotionally stagnant. But honestly? That might be intentional. Sometimes you need the quiet moments to make the charged moments hit harder. The author knows exactly when to speed up and when to let things breathe.
... Read More
'He must have some experience with book repair.' This one line from Bai Xizhou's POV tells me everything I need to know about how observant this guy is. And then Wen Ruqing—this guy sits there mending torn paper with a brush and water, completely absorbed, not even noticing someone walking past him. That's a character who exists in his own world. Then the next morning, their eyes meet and the playfulness just… vanishes. Gone. Cold. Neutral. What was he like before? The auntie calls him out constantly—'glued to those books,' 'ruin your eyesight,' 'skin and bones'—and there's this weird protectiveness underneath the scolding. Meanwhile Bai Xizhou catches himself thinking Wen Ruqing 'ought to eat more.' Bro. You just met this man and you're already worrying about his health? The dynamic between them is doing SO MUCH work without saying anything. One's a city lawyer who notices everything but pretends he doesn't. The other's a book restorer who can't keep his guard up for more than three seconds. And the auntie is clearly orchestrating something. I need to know what happened between these two before Chapter 1.
... Read More
I keep thinking about the recurring image of Wen Ruqing touching his wrist. Not once, not twice, but three separate times across these chapters. Each time he does it, the context is different. First it's Bai Xizhou noticing the scar and wondering about its origin. Then it's Wen Ruqing himself subconsciously rubbing it during idle moments. And it becomes this visual motif for everything he can't say out loud—the self-harm, the insomnia, the memories he can't escape. The coat is another symbol that hit me hard. Bai Xizhou drapes it over a sleeping Wen Ruqing without being asked, without any fanfare. It's an act of care so small it's almost invisible, but it represents the entire emotional arc of their relationship. You don't need grand gestures. You need someone to notice you're cold and do something about it while you can't even thank them. And the scooter ride at the end—night, stars, the wind, the darkness collapsing the space between them. The steel jungle Bai Xizhou has spent half his life navigating is replaced by this rural road where nothing is controlled and everything is uncertain. He likes the scent of grass. He relaxes. For the first time, his nerves aren't tight. Is this about the setting or about the person driving? I think it's about both, and that's the beauty of it. The recurring question throughout these chapters is: who is Wen Ruqing when nobody's watching? And Bai Xizhou is the first person to see him without a performance. The scar, the insomnia, the dreams—it's all part of a story that hasn't been told yet. But the book is finally ready to tell it.
... Read More
I need to talk about this relationship for a minute because honestly it's one of the most quietly devastating portrayals of two people who want to connect but don't know how I've ever read. Let's start with Wen Ruqing. He's this person who literally cannot rest—not even in his familiar hometown, not even surrounded by people who care about him. His insomnia isn't just a symptom, it's a metaphor for something much deeper. He's haunted by conversations he can't quite hear in his dreams, arguments he can't escape. And Bai Xizhou's voice is the only thing that cuts through the noise. That detail alone tells you everything about where this relationship is headed. But here's what I love: neither of them is performing. Wen Ruqing regrets his teasing after he says it—he recognizes it was childish, pointed, unnecessary. And Bai Xizhou? He doesn't push back. He just sits there, works, and when Wen Ruqing wakes up, he's still there, covering him with a coat. Who does that? A guy who's already decided he cares, even if he hasn't admitted it to himself yet. The physical distance between them is hilarious too. They sit 'like they were separated by a galaxy' on bamboo stools, but then suddenly they're sharing a scooter at night, Bai Xizhou holding onto Wen Ruqing's waist. The galaxy collapses into centimeters without either of them noticing. That's how real relationships work—they don't have announcements. They just... happen. And the author captures that perfectly. Every moment between these two feels like it was earned, not manufactured.
... Read More
I have to appreciate how the author structured these chapters because the flow is genuinely masterful. You open with the aftermath of a ruined night—tension already peaked, no resolution in sight—and then instead of letting that hang, we drop straight into Bai Xizhou's dream. The dream itself moves quickly through key beats: watching a movie three times, dinner with friends, the impulsive application, the silent departure. It's almost breathless, which mirrors how fragmented his memories feel. Then he wakes up and the pacing slows considerably—you can practically hear the narrative exhale. Steam in the bathroom, making coffee, getting dressed. These quiet moments do double duty: they give the reader breathing room AND they build anticipation for Wen Ruqing's arrival. When the knock finally comes, it lands with real impact because we've earned it through that slower middle section. And then the chapter ends on such a perfect note of interrupted thought—Bai Xizhou about to speak, the sentence dying mid-air. Not a full cliffhanger, just... a pause. A breath held. I literally sat there for a second wanting to turn the page immediately.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or