If I Could See You Once More - Reviews

If I Could See You Once More
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The phrase "vessel is still alive" stuck in my brain like a burr. I can't stop thinking about it. There's this whole vocabulary of possession, frequency matching, vessels, solvents—language that treats human beings like containers. Like Judith isn't a person at all but a HUSK waiting to be filled. "The method to empty the vessel." Empty. As if her consciousness, her memories, her very self—is just something to be poured out and replaced. And Erika. Who is Erika? She's not Judith. She's some OTHER woman whose frequency "matches" with Judith's, and Lorenz and his associates scoured the ENTIRE CONTINENT to find her. They found Erika first, used her as a test subject for half a year, and now they need to kill Judith because... the possession came undone? Because Judith survived? The text is deliberately vague here, which I think is the POINT. Judith doesn't fully understand what's happening to her, and neither do we. That's intentional design. But here's what really gets me: Altmere. The hometown. The place from a vision Judith never lived. The city that was devastated by scarlet fever over ten years ago. There's this recurring idea that Judith's past and someone else's past are BLENDING together. Was she there? Did Erika die there? Was Erika someone who survived the fever and now carries something inside her that Judith's body is also carrying? The scarlet fever survivors—"those, on occasion, who had reached the very threshold of death and emerged from it whole, as though by miracle." Miracle. The word feels loaded. Too loaded to be accidental. Is Judith actually ALREADY possessed? Is she Erika? Or is something far more complicated happening between their identities? The text keeps asking the same question from different angles without ever answering it, and that's what makes it haunting. "Whose past, exactly, was it." This line alone is the thesis statement of the entire novel.
... Read More
Let's talk about this townhouse for a second because THE ATMOSPHERE is UNREAL. "Given how things stand, I can't trust Rita." Judith walks alone down the third-floor corridor in the fading evening light. The text says: "Evening light crept through the windows and drained the corridor of its color. It would be dark soon." That's it. That's the whole sentence and I am SUFFOCATING. The light is dying. The colors are draining. And Judith is literally walking toward the moment her world cracks open. The author doesn't even need dramatic music or thunder—just fading light and a corridor that goes on forever. And House Belheim! Even this townhouse, "meant only for brief stays," is nearly the scale of a full manor. Because of course it is. These people have money and secrets and the architecture itself feels oppressive. The study scene—oh my god. The teapot still warm. The two cups, nearly empty but cold. Judith pieces together that a guest was JUST there, maybe minutes ago, and yet NO ONE is inside. How did they leave? Where did they go? The immaculate ordering of the room, not a single gap where a grown man could hide, the window that's too high to escape from—every detail screams impossibility. "The window. Judith crossed to the large window behind the desk and threw it open... But there was no ledge wide enough to cling to, and the ground beneath was stone, not grass — even from the second floor, the drop would be enough to injure anyone." Someone was in that room. They spoke. And then they were GONE. No exit. No hiding spot. Just... gone. I keep coming back to the image of Judith gripping the window ledge, head falling forward, wondering if she's losing her mind. That visual hits different. She's physically holding onto something solid while her entire reality is dissolving around her.
... Read More
Let me just say this outright: Judith is in far more danger than she realizes and the book is making us watch her walk into traps with her eyes open but her defenses down. The external stakes are clear — something happened in Altmere ten years ago involving an illness that causes possession-like symptoms, Lorenz is connected to it in ways he hasn't explained, and Judith herself has died and come back. The people acting like different persons? That's the illness. And now Judith is experiencing the same thing — memory gaps, personality shifts, wearing clothes she doesn't remember putting on. But the INTERNAL conflict is where it really hurts. Judith is ANGRY at herself. Not at Lorenz. At herself, for being careless, for trusting the herb because it matched one in her room, for letting her guard down. That's the tragedy — the person trying to save her is also the person breaking her, and she keeps folding instead of fighting. Rainer is the only one who sees what's actually happening. He notices the change in her at the banquet. He catches her scent at the plaza. He remembers her maiden name when everyone else has moved on. But he can't reach her — she's married to someone else, she's indifferent to him, and she has no memory of the week she spent alongside him. The stakes keep rising because Lorenz is always one step ahead. He orchestrates the tea. He controls Judith's environment — the herb in her room, the ceremony at the pavilion, the hat and veil she wakes up wearing. He has her surrounded by ordinary objects that are actually pieces of a puzzle he's assembling, and she doesn't even know she's playing the game. How long until she figures out that the woman she married isn't the husband she thinks she married?
... Read More
Okay so. Plot twist of the century and I am LITERALLY SHAKING. I've been reading this book for a while and I genuinely trusted Lorenz, you know? The whole setup made me feel safe. He's this caring husband, always gentle, always concerned. I literally thought this was going to be some political intrigue with a sweet romance at the core. BUT THEN. That moment. Oh my god. Judith hears her husband's voice from behind a door, talking calmly about KILLING HER. "We'll simply have to try killing Judith." She. Heard. Him. Say. That. And the worst part—the ABSOLUTE WORST part—is how the author made me experience this alongside Judith. She doesn't just find out; she's standing there, hand on the doorknob, trying to process whether this is real or another one of her hallucinations. Three times now. THREE TIMES she's seen things that weren't there. And the reader is right there with her, wondering: is she losing her mind, or is her husband actually a monster? Then Lorenz appears RIGHT BESIDE her like a ghost. Just—there. And he smiles. That same warm, tender smile she's fallen for. And says "This is my study. I hope that satisfies your curiosity." Like he didn't just discuss murder five feet away. The way the plot is structured here is genius because we're never quite sure what's real and what isn't. Norman comes in later and talks about "short-term memory loss" but Judith immediately notices the cause and effect don't line up. Lorenz told him something DIFFERENT from what actually happened. Deliberately. And then—Altmere scarlet fever. The illness from her childhood. The visions of a place she's never been. The woman named Erika whose frequency matches Judith's. What is ERIKA, exactly? I have so many questions and I need answers NOW.
... Read More
The stakes in these chapters keep escalating and I need everyone to understand what's actually on the line here. On the surface: Judith needs to find Clara Hoffmann to understand why she's having visions and hearing voices. Lorenz needs to keep her contained because she knows too much. Rainer is caught in between — protecting her while simultaneously being the one who brought her into this political nightmare. But underneath ALL of that: Judith is fighting for her own identity. If the scarlet fever can make people behave like entirely different persons, then what happens when it touches someone who already doesn't know who she is? The battlefield vision Rainer describes — caves, explosives, shrapnel, death — is literally the kind of thing that could have killed him. And someone saved him. The fact that Judith asks "what became of them?" is not just naive curiosity. It's the question of someone who just realized her visions might be real. If they're real, then the person who warned Rainer four years ago exists in her past, and she might be able to find them, verify the visions, and prove that her experiences are genuine. But here's what keeps me up at night: Rainer's reaction to that question. His voice goes flat. He snaps his documents down. "You have no reason to be this curious about my scars and my past." Why does that curiosity threaten him? Is he afraid she'll discover something he's deliberately buried? Or is he afraid she'll figure out that their connection runs deeper than either of them wants to admit? The train compartment scene is pure conflict — Judith wants answers, Rainer deflects, the physician tends to her wound while both of them pretend nothing happened. "He needn't have sat quite so far away." Every sentence between them is loaded. Every silence is a battleground. And theEmpress's warm smile at the end? That's not relief — that's the calm before another storm. Because the palace isn't safety. It's just a bigger cage with better lighting.
... Read More
The pavilion scene is visually STUPENDOUS and I need to talk about it. Rainer walking through a shadowed alley on a cloudless day, wondering "whether this was what it felt like to be one of those people who believed the world was at peace." That single sentence does SO much worldbuilding. It tells us the world is NOT at peace, it tells us there are people who think it is, and it puts us inside Rainer's head where he can't quite join them. Then he steps out and — salt air. Brass bands. Thousands of people. An iron pavilion built over the water. The Empress on a podium. Duke Lorenz smiling his unhurried, pleasant smile. And threading through ALL of that, Rainer catches a scent. The same bittersweet herbal scent that clung to Judith a week ago. He follows it like a bloodhound and finds... her. Wearing a wide-brimmed hat with a mesh veil, looking exactly like Judith but somehow NOT Judith. The contrast between the public spectacle — drums, trumpets, crowds chanting "Long live His Grace Duke Belheim!" — and the private devastation happening underneath it is devastating. Rainer reaches out. Catches her. She wakes up slumped in his arms after a week-long gap and has no idea how she got there. And then she takes off her hat and he asks if she needs it because she'd been wearing it the whole time, and she realizes she's been standing beside him the entire ceremony and has no memory of any of it. The imagery of that moment — the wind catching the veil, the military band still playing, Rainer's golden hair in the sunlight, Judith's confusion sharpening into fear — is absolutely cinematic. I swear to god I could see every frame.
... Read More
Let's talk about how this author builds dread without ever raising their voice. The structure of these chapters operates on two simultaneous tracks: Judith's surface-level return to the townhouse, and the slow, horrifying accumulation of evidence that something is deeply wrong with her memories. And the pacing is exquisite because it never rushes either track. Watch how it works. First, Judith and Lorenz are in the carriage. Quiet conversation. She says it's grown cold. He responds carefully. Nothing alarming yet. Then — the memory loss discussion drops in almost casually. "Quite a long stretch of memory is missing." Half a year? A year and a half? Said so matter-of-factly. But it lands like a bomb because we've already been seeded with the knowledge that she hasn't stayed in the capital since marriage. Then the static spark. The vision. Altmere. Summer. A happier version of herself. The scene cuts to Rainer — completely different tone, almost comedic with Wenzel — before returning to Judith arriving home. And THEN the real knife twist: the maid says "whenever you come to the capital." Not once. Repeatedly. Again and again. Judith has never stayed in the capital after marriage. But apparently she comes here regularly. What does that mean? What did she do here before? Each revelation comes at a different temperature. Some are quiet whispers. Some are full-on shocks. The Rainer interlude provides necessary breathing room — almost comic relief — before diving back into the懸念. And that ending? "With no way of knowing what she was about to see and hear" — classic cliffhanger that doesn't feel cheap because it's earned through genuine mystery. The pacing never drags because every scene does double duty: advancing plot AND deepening atmosphere. Even the short Rainer bits about feeling more at home on the battlefield than in his own palace add thematic weight about displacement and belonging.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this Altmere scarlet fever reveal because it genuinely stopped me mid-read. A thousand people died from something traced to contaminated seawater and this weird fish, and the survivors? They get memory lapses and start behaving like totally different people. I literally squeaked out loud. Because when Judith reads that clinical book and her finger lands on the author's name — Clara Hoffmann — and she says that line, "Would it be possible to meet this person?" I already knew exactly what that meant. This isn't just some medical mystery subplot. This is THE thread. The neurodamage from scarlet fever causing personality shifts, memory gaps, the whole thing — and then we find out Rainer saw it firsthand as a kid. "I once saw someone like that with my own eyes." Said so casually too, like he's commenting on the weather. Meanwhile Judith is sitting there going absolutely feral inside. And here's the part that has me pacing my room: she had VISIONS. Of Rainer on a battlefield carrying someone on his back. And then she accidentally asks about a scar from four years ago during the pirate campaign — the EXACT battle she witnessed. Rainer's reaction was chef's kiss levels of tension. "You have no reason to be this curious about my scars and my past." She couldn't tell him the truth because what would she even say? "Sorry, I hallucinated you getting shot five years ago"? The plot is stacking revelations on top of revelations like a goddamn Jenga tower and I am TERRIFIED it's gonna topple. Also Lorenz? The man who started this entire chapter with that smile that "chills you to the bone"? He's been reducing her to a wad of paper in a wastebasket this whole time. The fact that the newspaper called it "Belheim's Downfall" and the Grand Duke "rescued" her — but really just put a leash around her neck — this plot has layers and I cannot handle it.
... Read More
Okay so I just finished these first seven chapters and my brain is doing gymnastics. Let me just say — the way this story plays with Judith's lost time is genius. On the surface it looks like a standard transmigration/rebirth narrative where the protagonist wakes up in someone else's body, but the execution is so much more layered than that. Here's what's actually happening: Judith Griene, former Royal Guard officer, wife of Duke Lorentz Belheim, has been experiencing blackouts for about three months. Night after night, she sneaks out to train with a wooden sword because she can't let go of who she used to be. Then one evening while walking back with her husband, she collapses. And when she wakes up — she's in the Imperial Palace guest suite. Not her manor. NOT her bed. The same place she used to report for duty as a Palace Guard. But here's where it gets spicy. When she opens her eyes, Lorentz calls her "Eri" and "Erika." Her. Husband. The man she's been married to, the most devoted husband in the empire according to everyone, calls her a different name like it's the most natural thing in the world. And Judith herself — this version of her — reacts with visceral resistance to that name. Not confusion. Not embarrassment. Something deeper. The plot structure here is doing double duty. Every chapter peels back another layer: Chapter 1 establishes who Judith thinks she is (suffering wife training in secret). Chapter 2 gives us her backstory — orphaned, debt-ridden, worked her way through military academy. Chapter 3-4 start introducing the mystery elements. And then BAM — she wakes up somewhere she shouldn't be, being called by a name that doesn't belong to her. What's really clever is how the author plants clues without being obvious about it. The fact that Judith instinctively knows where she is when she wakes up in the guest suite — "a place she had yearned for so desperately" — hints that this version of her had a whole life BEFORE becoming Judith Griene. And Grand Duke Rainer's presence, the mention of "Erika" slipping out, the physical reactions — it's all pointing toward one conclusion: Judith didn't just wake up in a new body. Something far more complicated happened to her. I need to know what Erika's story is. And more importantly — why does Judith feel like an imposter in her own life?
... Read More
The stakes in this story just went through the roof and I am here for it. Let me break down what we're dealing with. On the surface level, Judith is experiencing blackouts — she loses time, sometimes hours, sometimes days, and nobody notices except her. That's a personal stakes situation. Her health is declining. Her marriage is already strained. She has no one to turn to. But then the Palace guest suite reveal hits and everything changes. She's not just losing time — she's apparently waking up SOMEWHERE ELSE. Somewhere she used to work. Somewhere connected to her past life as a Palace Guard. And Grand Duke Rainer — exiled, disgraced, returned from a front line — is there. With her. In a situation that has Lorentz absolutely furious. The external stakes just exploded. We've got political tension between Lorentz and Rainer that's palpable in every line. Lorentz threatening to hold Rainer accountable. Rainer's cutting responses about Conrad and imperial decrees. The implication that Rainer was being sent somewhere dangerous by someone in power — possibly someone connected to Lorentz. And the INTERNAL stakes? Even worse. This woman doesn't know who she is anymore. She has memories of a life as Judith Griene — orphaned, indebted, military-trained, married into the Belheim duchy. But she also has INSTINCTIVE knowledge of the Palace guest suite, like she belonged there. And the name "Erika" triggers something visceral — resistance, recognition, maybe even grief. The tension maintenance is absolutely brutal. Every chapter ends with a revelation that raises more questions than it answers. Chapter 4 ends with her collapsing. Chapter 5 ends with her waking up in a stranger's location. And the final lines — Lorentz holding her, calling her Erika, his voice breaking — that's the kind of cliffhanger that makes you immediately open the next chapter and not care that it's 2 AM. What I love most is how the author layers these conflicts. The personal mystery of identity. The political intrigue between Lorentz and Rainer. The implied danger from the Valurak front. And underneath it all, this ticking clock of lost time that could mean her consciousness is literally being overwritten. The stakes aren't just high — they're existential.
... Read More
I need everyone to understand what I just read because my hands are literally shaking. This scene where Lorenz brings Judith herbal tea and she drinks it and then... nothing. Just a black hole where seven days should be. Let me walk through this slowly because the horror is in the details. Lorenz says he wanted to be alone with her. He says herbs are best for putting one at ease. The tea is "translucent, pale and tinged with blue — something between violet and lilac." It reminded her of the color of his eyes. Think about that. He is literally matching himself to something she finds calming so she'll drink it. She WAS suspicious. She considered refusing. But then she remembered the herb plant in her room — the SAME one — and she let her guard down. That's the whole tragedy, isn't it? She trusted the familiar. She trusted the connection. And that's exactly what he used against her. The moment she passes out, Lorenz just... smiles. Soft. Unhurried. "Have a cup first. While it's warm." Meanwhile Judith is awake inside all of this. She's connecting the dots herself — the memory gaps, the people in Altmere who act like different persons, her own death and return, the words she overheard in his study about possession and vessel and frequency. She's putting it together and she knows, even before she reads it confirmed, that this is not an accident. "Was the herb the cause?" She's furious at herself. Not at him. At herself. For being careless. For trusting. And I just — how is a man this温柔的 (no wait, English only, sorry) how is a man this gentle-seeming actually the villain and I hate that I can see the trap closing around Judith and she still hasn't fully escaped it.
... Read More
Let me just say this one passage: "The sound of two sets of footsteps echoed alone across the cobblestones blanketed in early morning fog." I don't even know how to process this. The imagery in this book is not playing around. The Altmere Central Library scene is one of the most atmospherically charged sequences I've read in a while. The caretaker fumbling with the lock. Click. That single metallic sound ringing out sharp against the quiet square. Then entering — colder than outside, the grandfather clock ticking, this overwhelming hush that settles over everything the moment the door closes behind them. You can feel the temperature dropping through the prose. You can hear the silence. And then the train — "the great mechanical churning of the engine sent vibrations through her whole body" — she's riding back to the Capital, the city that shaped her, and there's this tingling at her fingertips like she's coming home. The description of the city through the carriage window: "rows of white buildings carried the mingled scent of freshly baked bread and the faint sharpness of oil." How does an author make you SMELL a place? I don't know but this author does it constantly. The Imperial Palace arrival is understated but devastating — "the noise of the city fell away all at once." Just like that, everything changes. The grand facade, Johanna Hohenlohe greeting them with warmth, the Empress's playful glance — it all paints this world so vividly that you forget it's fiction. Every location feels lived-in: the port city, the railway, the palace. This isn't backdrop. This is a world that breathes.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or