If I Could See You Once More - Reviews

If I Could See You Once More
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me talk about this ONE scene because I cannot stop thinking about it. Judith is sitting in the guest suite, Lorenz is being weirdly emotional, Rainer is watching from the couch—and then it hits her. A smell. The text describes it as an "overwhelming stench of blood" saturating the air. But here's what makes it so visceral: she's the ONLY one reacting. Neither Lorenz nor Rainer shows any sign of noticing it. She covers her nose and mouth, holds her breath, and the smell only grows thicker. Her stomach turns. She's curling in on herself. And then—BOOM—the vision. The blood pool expands and the world transforms around her. A battlefield. "Across a rugged terrain of sheer cliffs and bare rock, bodies lay strewn here and there, their forms too mangled to identify." Ashen sky. Snow falling in ones and twos. And Rainer—covered in dirt, wounded in the left side, half-carrying someone on his back. This is some of the most cinematic writing I've encountered. The way the sensory detail pulls you from a quiet room into a warzone in one breath. And then it just... vanishes. "The thick stench of blood that had hung so heavily throughout the guest suite vanished — as though it had never been." Also, the carriage scene at the end with the plaza—fountain, bronze statue, pigeons, pale yellow buildings—gives such a vivid sense of place. It grounds the whole story in a tangible world even as the mystery thickens.
... Read More
I have been thinking about this handkerchief for hours. It shows up at the beginning — Sabine embroidering it with clumsy stitches and a small yellow flower in the corner — and then Judith finds it on the garden ground, and gives it back, and suddenly Sabine's entire romantic subtext is visible to the reader even though nobody says it out loud. Let me just say it: the yellow flower embroidery = unspoken feelings. The fact that Sabine was 'wondering if Lord Schmidt will like it' while dropping it in a garden where Judith happened to be standing with Rainer — who is apparently ALSO someone she should be thinking about but clearly isn't because she was making flowers for someone else — this is layers upon layers of dramatic irony that the author is堆ing on us like a sadist. And Rainer's line when he says 'You keep saying things like that. As though you never loved Belheim to begin with' — that's not just plot exposition, that's the THEMATIC QUESTION of the whole book. Is this a story about a woman who never loved her husband and therefore owes him nothing? Or is it about a woman who may have loved him once and now has to decide whether love matters when trust is gone? Because Judith herself answers that: 'This is not a matter of love — it is a matter of trust. One can sustain a marriage without love. But trust, once gone, cannot be done without.' That is the thesis statement of the entire narrative, folks. She's not divorcing him because she stopped loving him. She's divorcing him because someone is TRYING TO KILL HER and he's connected to it. That distinction changes everything. Also the Altmere scarlet fever keeps popping up like a ghost motif. Every time I think I understand what's happening, the author drags another thread out of the dark and I'm left with more questions than answers and I LOVE IT.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter are layered like an enemy in an onion—or maybe more accurately, like Judith's memory: fragmented, hidden, and dangerous to dig into. On the surface, the conflict is simple: Judith doesn't remember who she is or why she's here. But the deeper conflict is what that loss COSTS her. She's married to a man whose true nature she's beginning to glimpse, and every time she gets closer to the truth, he pulls the mask back on. The scene where his eyes go cold and then immediately warm again—that's the entire relationship in miniature. Trust vs. survival. Then there's Rainer. The battlefield vision suggests they share history—a real, visceral, blood-soaked history that predates her marriage. And Lorenz's reaction to Rainer (glaring at him "as though he meant to kill him") tells us everything we need to know about what's at stake. This isn't just romantic rivalry; it's something darker, something that involves violence and possibly death. The transactional nature of the marriage adds another layer of tension. Judith married Lorenz to clear her family's debts and secure her brother Theodore's education. But what happens when the arrangement starts consuming her? What does she stand to lose beyond her identity? The answer seems to be: everything. And yet—the most compelling conflict might be the one inside Judith's own mind. She's fighting to remember, and every碎片 of memory she recovers seems to make her current reality more unstable. The blood smell, the battlefield, Lorenz's true face—each revelation is both a victory and a threat. She's digging herself deeper into danger with every step.
... Read More
Okay so this whole garden scene with Rainer is doing SO MUCH work and I need to talk about it because the way Judith just drops 'I intend to divorce the Duke of Belheim' out of nowhere — no buildup, no softening — that is such a JUDITH move. She doesn't negotiate, she doesn't ask permission, she states her intention like it's already decided. And Rainer's reaction? The text says 'a flash of bewilderment crossed his eyes. It shifted into something harder to name.' That shift is EVERYTHING. He's been watching her from the sidelines this whole time, right? And now she's telling him she wants out of her marriage, and instead of judging her or trying to stop her, he says 'If you want a divorce — I'll help you.' But then the narration does this thing where it gives us Rainer's internal monologue: 'Something close to atonement. So the least I can do is grant what she wants — the one I hope finds happiness.' WAIT. What?? Is he saying this because he has feelings for her? Or because he feels guilty about something? And then he drops 'Belheim is far from a blameless man' like it's just a casual observation but clearly it's loaded with meaning. The way these two are positioned — she's his princess, he's apparently in love with her or owes her or something — and now she's asking him to help her escape another person's marriage... it's a triangle that's not even fully formed yet and it's already vibrating with tension. Also can we talk about the physicality? When he grabs her arm and her voices stop? That's a detail the author keeps coming back to and I am OBSESSED with the implication.
... Read More
I need to talk about how each character's dialogue feels genuinely distinct here, because that's surprisingly hard to pull off and this author nails it. Lorenz is the master of controlled silence. Listen to how he speaks — always careful, always measured. "Yes, my lady." "That's—" He opens his mouth then presses it shut. Swallows. Drops his gaze. When he says "Perhaps you're right, my lady… Perhaps that's truly all it is," there's this awful weight behind the compliance. He's not agreeing — he's retreating. His dialogue is full of things he doesn't say, pauses that scream louder than words. That violet eye reaction when she mentions Altmere? All the dialogue around it is minimal because the silence is doing the work. Rainer, on the other hand, bursts onto the page with pure energy. "Not here either." Hands in his own hair. The self-deprecating laugh about the battlefield being more like home than the Palace. And then the instant personality switch when Princess Dorothea is mentioned — "Thea is here?" One carrot dangled, one carrot consumed, and suddenly he's stretching and smiling like nothing happened. His voice is immediate, physical, almost childish in its honesty. He can't even pretend to be bored for more than thirty seconds. And Rita! Oh, Rita is perfect. Watch how she transitions from formal servant to someone who actually knows Judith. "My lady — has something happened? Something unpleasant?" Then the cascade: the formal speech, the calmness, the evening paper request, and finally the explosion of genuine concern. "My lady, don't tell me you've forgotten my name as well? What on earth has happened to you…" Her dialogue has warmth that cuts through the servant-master distance. When she takes Judith's hand, it's not performative — it's the voice of someone who has genuinely cared for her. The narrative voice itself deserves mention too. It's deep third-person, staying close to Judith's consciousness almost entirely, but slipping into Rainer's perspective for that one interlude. The prose quality is consistently strong — literary but never pretentious. Sentences like "A peace purchased at the cost of Judith's freedom" land with the weight of a verdict.
... Read More
I'm not okay. I am genuinely not okay right now. Let me tell you about the moment that destroyed me. Judith — this woman who spent years as a Royal Guard, who lost both parents, who clawed her way out of debt and misery only to land in a loveless marriage — sneaks out every night to practice swordwork. Just to feel ALIVE. The text says it directly: "Only then did she feel something close to alive." And then her husband finds her. Again. And he says, with this gentle, unhurried smile: "You need not love me in return. I only wish that you are not suffering." That line. That GODDAMN LINE. Because it's TRUE. She IS suffering. But not because she doesn't love him. Not because their marriage is loveless. But because SOMETHING ELSE is happening to her and she can't explain it. The emotional complexity here is staggering. Lorentz loves someone — maybe Erika, maybe this version of Judith, maybe both — and he doesn't even know it. He sees her flinch when he touches her. He notices she looks "far too fragile." He comes looking for her every single night despite being told not to. And she — this woman who should be grateful for such devotion — feels nothing. Not because she's cold. But because the person inside this body might literally BE someone else. And then the moment that made me sit in silence for twenty minutes: Lorentz pulling her into his arms, his voice breaking, saying "I was afraid something had happened to you, Eri." The hand trembling. The breath catching. The raw, unfiltered terror of a man who thought he'd lost the person he loved. But he's holding JUDITH. The woman who doesn't feel anything for him. And he's calling her by a name that belongs to someone else. That's not romance. That's a tragedy dressed up as devotion. What's killing me most is the isolation. This woman — whether she's Judith, Erika, or something in between — has no one to talk to about what's happening. The physician knows about the blackouts. Lorentz doesn't. And when she finally tries to tell him, when she starts describing the missing time, the pain behind her eyes — she collapses before she can finish. She's completely alone inside her own life. The emotional weight of that loneliness is suffocating. And I think that's exactly what the author is going for.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—I have SO MANY QUESTIONS and the author is loving this, I can tell. First off, the whole memory loss setup. Judith claims she doesn't remember recent events, but here's the thing: she remembers enough to lie about it strategically. When Lorenz asks if she remembers something and she says no, his eyes go wide—"trembling almost imperceptibly"—and she notices. She *notices*. That's not someone who's lost their mind; that's someone playing a very careful game. Then there's the Erika thing. Lorenz calling out some name that isn't Judith's, speaking with "perfect, effortless familiarity" to someone else. Judith's internal monologue here is devastating: "And that… was never meant for me to begin with. For Erika, in all likelihood." She's connecting dots in real time and it's heartbreaking. But the REAL plot bomb drops when Rainer appears. Judith looks into his crimson eyes and suddenly she's somewhere else entirely—a battlefield, snow falling, blood pooling. A man in a dirt-caked uniform carrying someone on his back. And she identifies him: "Grand Duke Rainer." She remembers this. The memory isn't gone; it's just buried under whatever happened. The structure of this chapter is masterful. We get the romantic tension with Lorenz, then cut to the violent sensory flash with Rainer, then return to Lorenz being... off. His eyes go cold for one split second before he smiles again. The author is layering revelations like an onion and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
I don't know if I've ever read a more cinematic conservatory scene. Let me just walk through it because the author here is basically directing a film in prose. The Empress offering tea, coffee, AND chocolate—three options laid out like a royal spread, and Judith's whole internal world collapsing at the word "tea." That's not just description, that's worldbuilding through sensory trigger. You feel the weight of everything she's left behind just from one word being offered. Then theEmpress's touch: "The Empress's touch carried the full warmth of a human hand." Have you ever noticed how authors include something like THAT? It's not necessary to the plot but it tells you everything about this woman—she's performing warmth deliberately, she's conscious of what her touch communicates. And the fact that Judith notices it at all means she's been touched by hands that didn't feel warm. Oof. Dorothea hiding behind the planter—this detail absolutely made me laugh out loud. The most powerful person in the room is being spied on by a ten-year-old who refuses to attend her political science lessons. The image of the Grand Duke dropping to the floor to flick her nose, completely unbothered by witnesses, while the Empress watches with a quiet smile—that's worldbuilding about POWER without a single line of exposition. We now understand: this family operates differently than the stiff court around them. But the garden scene at dusk? That's where the atmosphere went from good to haunting. "The early winter garden was full of bare, skeletal trees. The moonlight that filtered between their branches was cold." Combined with Rainer emerging from the pavilion's shadows, his face marked by deep fatigue—that's a composition so deliberate I'm convinced the author has a film background. The sound design alone: "Crunch, crunch / The sound of two pairs of feet treading dry fallen leaves dropped quietly into the stillness." You hear that. You hear it. And the Palace corridors—"as high and long as she remembered" after three years. That single detail does more temporal work than most authors manage in a paragraph. It tells us time has passed, that she's been away, that this place hasn't changed but SHE has. The world feels lived-in because every room and corridor carries the weight of her personal history in it. The imperial seal on the letter, the leather notebook, the silver tray, the white porcelain—all of it grounds us in a world with material reality. This isn't a generic fantasy court; it has specific textures.
... Read More
I need a minute. I genuinely, genuinely liked Lorenz. Like—before this chapter hit me like a truck, I was sitting here thinking "aww, finally a reasonable husband character" and now I want to throw my phone across the room. "You are all I have, Judith." THE MAN WHO JUST AGREED TO KILL HER SAYS THIS TO HER FACE. With that soft voice. With those violet eyes that looked at her with concern. My stomach just turned. But let me unpack WHY this hurts so much, because it's not just the shock value. It's the TRUST. Judith had this very specific, measured trust in Lorenz. The text literally says: "It was the kind of trust that came from stability — from the assurance that Lorenz's words and actions would never stray beyond the bounds of what she expected from him." SHE TRUSTED HIS CONSISTENCY. Not blind trust. Not naive trust. The kind you build over time when someone is ALWAYS there, ALWAYS reliable, ALWAYS the same. And that's what makes this betrayal cut so deep—it's not that he's some obviously suspicious villain from chapter one. He was PERFECT. Too perfect. And now we understand that his consistency WAS the trap. There's this heartbreaking moment where Judith thinks about how she used to tell Norman everything without a second thought. "In the old days, I would have told him about the hallucinations without a second thought. But not now." Something in her has already shifted. She's learning to guard herself, and it breaks my heart because she shouldn't have to guard herself from her HUSBAND. And yet—she ASKS to enter the study. She WANTS to know what's behind that door. That's either the most brave thing I've ever read or the most desperate. Maybe both.
... Read More
"Two beds in this room." That's all Rainer says and it carries more weight than a thousand lines of description. This one line tells us about power, about surveillance, about how close and far apart these two people are. Let me just sit with the imagery of this scene for a moment because the author is doing something really craftful here. The top-floor suite with its antique furniture beneath high ceilings, the gas lamp Rainer lights himself casting everything in warm shadow, the rough fabric of the curtains dragging across the rail — it's cinematic in the best way. Moonlight first, then darkness. He literally closes off the outside world so they're alone in that artificial glow. And Judith standing with her spine straight, hands clasped behind her back, unable to relax because her body remembers a posture she hasn't needed in years but can't quite shake off. Habit. She calls it habit but it's really survival. The empty brandy glass with its heavy residual scent, the half-finished sugar water — these tiny domestic details make the scene feel lived-in, real. There's a hospitality to this space that feels almost domestic until you remember what's actually happening in it. A prince visiting a wounded woman late at night. Two beds. No one else in the room. The atmosphere is thick enough to cut with a knife and I loved every second of it.
... Read More
Okay so I have to talk about the way Rainer and Judith move around each other in this chapter because it is literally the most delicious tension I've read in months. Watch how he circles her like he's calculating something. He brings the shawl, he moves to the window, draws the curtains himself, turns away when he asks his questions — every gesture is controlled, deliberate, while Judith is standing there drunk and bandaged trying to hold onto her composure. And then at the end, when Rainer asks her why she married Belheim? That's not a casual question. He's probing. He already knows the answer isn't what she'll say out loud. He says "I want you to be unharmed. To be happy" and then immediately follows it with that knife twist about whether she loves her husband. It's either deeply caring or deeply manipulative or both at the same time and I cannot tell which. What gets me is that Judith asks him a question too — "You truly love Duke Belheim, don't you" — and she's drunk enough to say what she's been thinking, but she's also RIGHT. This is the heart of it. Rainer is obsessed with the Duke in a way that has nothing to do with politics and everything to do with something older and messier. Their entire history is this unspoken ghost between Judith and Rainer, and the Duke is the person neither of them can stop circling. When Rainer leaves with his back turned and she can't read his expression — that's not just dramatic. That's the whole novel in one image. I need to know what he's thinking. And honestly, I need to know whether his concern for Judith is genuine or whether it's another move in a game I haven't figured out yet.
... Read More
I need a minute. Two years of marriage. Two years of Lorenz being the perfect husband—the one who looked at her like she was everything, who never pushed, who waited patiently for her heart to open. And in this chapter, we see the mask slip. Just a little. But oh, it's enough to shatter everything. The most painful scene has to be in the carriage. Lorenz takes her hand and whispers, "I need you just as much as you need me." And Judith feels it—that unpleasant heartbeat, that wrongness. Because something just shifted in his face. His pale violet eyes went COLD. Not warm. Not gentle. Just... empty. And then he smiled like nothing happened. She thought: "Is that look meant for me?" The betrayal isn't just that he might have loved someone else first (Erika? Who is she?). The betrayal is that Judith spent two years believing this man's affection was real, and now she's seeing glimpses of a different person entirely—someone who rages, who threatens imperial family members, who laughs openly. These "flawed, incomplete glimpses" looked, somehow, more TRUE than anything she'd ever seen from him before. And the worst part? She still says "I already do" when he asks her to lean on him. She's still trying. After all this. That's either the most beautiful thing or the most tragic thing I've ever read. Maybe both.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or