If I Could See You Once More - Reviews

If I Could See You Once More
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
"That means… you haven't forgotten?" The way Rainer asks this question — voice barely holding together, that faintest tremor she nearly misses — and then Judith's face just completely blank because she genuinely has no idea what he's referring to. I had to put the book down and just stare at the ceiling for a solid minute. These two are navigating each other like two blind people in a room full of furniture and neither one will admit it. Judith hears voices, sees visions, knows things she can't explain. Rainer is a man who values control above all else, and here he is being pulled toward someone who might actually be able to see into parts of himself he's buried. When he says "Griene. That's the second time now. There won't be a third." — he sounds so tired. Not angry. Just… exhausted by her mystery. But then the masterclass moment: she asks about the scar. He tells her the whole story — the pirates, the explosives, the shrapnel — and then casually drops that someone warned him in time. Someone SAVED his life. And Judith, god help her, asks "What became of them?" With zero tact. Zero filter. It's the most Judith thing ever and I would die for her. Rainer's humorless laugh after that is everything. He's pulling away, closing off, retreating behind that aristocratic composure. But the reader — we're ALL watching him carefully. We saw him notice her wince when the physician unwrapped her bandages. We saw him summon a doctor mid-journey without being asked. We saw him sit across the compartment instead of closer, deliberately maintaining distance while clearly caring about every detail of her condition. "He needn't have sat quite so far away." — Judith thinking this while also being completely unable to communicate anything useful. I love them so much it hurts.
... Read More
Can we just talk about Lorentz for a second because I have SO MANY QUESTIONS. On paper, he's everything. The empire's most eligible bachelor. Inherited a duchy that controls the capital's economy. Deep violet eyes, gentle smile, immaculate posture. He waits for his wife every night in the garden. He says things like "You need not love me in return. I only wish that you are not suffering." He was beside himself when she collapsed. His arms are literally trembling when he holds her. And yet. And YET. Something is SO OFF about this man. The first clue — and this hit me HARD — is when he calls her "Erika." Not Judith. Not his wife's name. ERIKA. And then later he says "Eri!" like it's the most natural pet name in the world. This isn't a slip of the tongue. This is someone who has been saying this name to someone — possibly the SAME PERSON, possibly a different person entirely — for a long time. Then there's Rainer. Grand Duke Rainer Waldemar Stefan Roswald. Firstborn son of the Emperor, fallen from favor, exiled to dangerous fronts. When Judith hears his name, she recognizes him from her days as a Palace Guard. But here's the thing — when Rainer sees her, he says something that made me freeze: "You and your wife both have quite the gift for eavesdropping. They say you grow to resemble the one you love — there may be something to that after all." He says this while looking at LORENTZ. NOT JUDITH. He's commenting on how LORENTZ and JUDITH resemble each other. Like they've been together long enough to grow similar. But wait — Judith's backstory says they just got married, and she's clearly not happy. And Lorentz calling her "Erika" suggests he knew a DIFFERENT woman before. So what if — and hear me out — Lorentz married someone who looks exactly like Erika? And what if that someone ISN'T Judith at all? What if this woman waking up in the guest suite is actually Erika herself, but trapped inside Judith's body? Or what if Judith's consciousness was overwritten and what we're seeing is Erika trying to piece together who she was? The relationship dynamics here are a goddamn maze. Lorentz's devotion feels genuine but directed at someone else. Rainer is clearly close to whoever Erika was. And Judith — or whomever is currently inhabiting this body — is caught in the middle, remembering things that don't match her current life. I need answers. I need them NOW.
... Read More
Let me just say this out loud: the stakes in this section are NUCLEAR and the author is stacking them on top of each other like a house of cards in an earthquake. On the surface, there's an assassination attempt, a family crest found on the murder weapon, treason investigations flying everywhere. But underneath that is SO much more. Judith is a suspect in her own marriage. Rainer is watching her, using her as both a hostage and a monitor, and he genuinely seems torn about it — which makes him more dangerous, not less. And Lorenz — wait, Erika — is sitting across from her every night, sharing a bed, pretending to be her husband, while his real identity is this elaborate fiction held together by lies. The moment Rainer says "I want you to be unharmed. To be happy" and then immediately pivots to interrogating her about her love for the Duke — that is the emotional core of every conflict in this story compressed into one paragraph. Judith's body is failing her (the wound, the sedative, the alcohol), her mind is clouded, and yet she's still sharp enough to notice things. She still asks the right questions. She still names the truth even when she's too drunk to filter it. Meanwhile Lorenz is losing his mind over Rainer being alive, over the possibility that Judith might figure it out, and he's already moving pieces on the board — sending for Heinrich, planning whatever comes next. The Emperor will be furious. The Duke's reputation is burning. And Judith is standing in the middle of all of it with a bandaged shoulder and a shawl she doesn't understand and a marriage that might be built on sand. I'm not okay. I need the next chapter immediately.
... Read More
There's a recurring motif running through these chapters that I can't stop thinking about — the relationship between physical marks and invisible wounds. Judith's shoulder wound, bandaged and changing, healing under Rainer's hands. Rainer's scar from the pirate campaign, hidden beneath his clothes, a piece of shrapnel's legacy. And then the deeper pattern: the scarlet fever survivors, their minds damaged, their identities fragmented, becoming someone else entirely. Judith says "Deep wounds tend to leave marks — that's all." But that's not all, is it? The marks are just evidence. The real question is what caused the wound, who caused it, and whether it can ever truly heal. The title of that tabloid — "Belheim's Downfall" — is itself a kind of scar on Judith's reputation, written in public for everyone to see and judge. And Lorenz's response isn't to defend her honor but to control her. The newspaper tore up, stuffed into a wastebasket — discarded, dismissed, disposable. That image of Lorenz's study with the shredded headlines is such a perfect visual metaphor for how these characters treat each other's dignity. And Clara Hoffmann — the psychiatrist studying neurological and psychological sequelae — she represents the intersection of all these themes. Science trying to understand what the body and mind endure. In an era where "madness" is still being redefined from demonic possession to brain damage, the very idea that trauma could alter personality is radical. Judith might literally be losing herself, and the only person who can help is a woman the capital hasn't even met yet. "The address was definitely…" Lorenz covered Norman's note. Everything is covered, redacted, hidden. The symbolism is suffocating and I love it.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in controlled pacing and I need to break down why it works so well. Scene one: the conservatory audience. Starts slow—polite conversation, tea offers, social calibration. Then BAM, Rainer discovers the princess hiding behind a plant and the whole energy shifts from stiff court drama to domestic chaos. The transition is so smooth you don't notice it happening until you're already laughing at Dorothea being caught. Then Wenzel arrives with urgent news and Rainer bolts. One moment they're a family having breakfast, the next the political machinery has yanked its primary engine into a different room. The tempo change is violent but the author makes it feel natural because we've already been told something is wrong through Rainer's earlier tension. Scene two: the schoolroom with Professor Kassel. This is where the chapter earns its keep as more than just character drama. Kassel literally double-takes when he sees Judith—"His eyes went wide. He pushed his spectacles up"—and then pivots into a strategic analysis of the assassination attempt. Judith dissecting the military band's positioning on the map, exposing the jurisdictional blind spot... this is the author sliding in plot-relevant information disguised as a classroom moment. Dorothea actually LEARNING from it, getting excited—serves double duty as both worldbuilding and character development for the princess. And Wilhelmina's visible displeasure at being sidelined? Efficient. One expression tells us everything about the power dynamics in that room. Scene three: the garden at dusk. After the high-energy schoolroom, we drop into near-silence. Two people walking, short exchanged dialogue, heavy subtext. The chapter structure here mirrors Judith's internal state—after the external chaos of court and palace and lessons, she needs this quiet confrontation with Rainer. But it's not actually quiet, is it? Every line carries two meanings. "I'm currently keeping watch over you." Is that a threat or a confession? The pacing between lines matters as much as the lines themselves. What I love most is how the chapter ends. Not with a bang but with a cutoff. Judith asks about the Duke of Belheim—her most pointed question of the chapter—and Rainer shuts it down with a single name. The narrative equivalent of a door slamming. But it's not a cliffhanger that makes you angry; it's one that makes you immediately want to open the next chapter. If I had one complaint it'd be that the transition from the schoolroom to Judith's quarters felt slightly abrupt—the sunset-to-darkness shift happens off-page and I wanted a beat more to land in the quieter mood. But honestly? That minor hurry might be intentional, pushing us toward the garden confrontation faster than Judith herself might have wanted.
... Read More
The structure of these chapters is doing something really clever and I want to unpack it. We open with Judith already in crisis mode — she knows pieces of the truth but not enough, she's overheard Lorenz talking about possession and vessel and frequency, she's connecting her own death-and-return to the people in Altmere who sometimes "begin acting like entirely different persons without warning." The chapter drops all of this on her in a rapid-fire cascade and she can barely hold it together. Then Lorenz arrives. Tea. Conversation that sounds normal but isn't. She drinks. Blackout. Cut to Rainer. A full chapter later, we're a WEEK into her missing time, and we learn this through the newspaper headline about Rainer's victory. The temporal jump is jarring on purpose — we're meant to feel the same disorientation Judith feels. Then back to Judith waking up in Rainer's arms with no memory, discovering she's been wearing a disguise the whole time, realizing she stood through an entire ceremony without a single recollection. And the chapter ends with Lorenz's smile — the same pleasant, unhurried smile from the tea scene — while Judith's eyes meet his across the podium, and his expression changes. Just slightly. But enough. The pacing here is a masterclass in controlled dread. Each section gives us just enough information to feel terrified but never enough to feel safe. The seven-day gap isn't filler — it's the entire point. Something happened while Judith wasn't there, and we're going to find out what, and the fact that Lorenz is still smiling about it is the worst feeling in the world.
... Read More
There are so many symbols layered into these chapters I keep finding new ones every time I reread. The RED EYES first. Rainer's crimson irises are the most obvious one — they're literally the mark of his mother's lineage, the proof the Emperor used to despise Ottilie, the reason Rainer was never welcomed in his own home. But they also make him invisible in plain sight now, because he hides them with eye drops. The trait that made him an outcast is now his camouflage. That's not accidental writing. Then there's the HERBAL SCENT. It appears in Judith's room, in Lorenz's tea, at the pavilion, clinging to Judith like a ghost. It's the signature of whatever illness swept through Altmere over ten years ago — the same illness that caused people to "begin acting like entirely different persons without warning." The scent is the smell of possession. Of replacement. Of something taking up residence in a vessel. Altmere itself is the biggest symbol. It's where everything converges. Where Judith's memories are gone. Where people change without warning. Where Lorenz sponsors a massive public project to mask whatever he's actually doing. The northern shore, set apart from the industrial district — Perle Plaza — is literally built over the water, a glass pavilion catching sunlight while something dark happens underneath. And the hat with the pin. Judith wearing it without remembering, hiding her face behind a mesh veil, removing the pin and having nowhere to put it because there are no pockets — these are details about a woman who is being ERASED from her own life, piece by piece, and nobody notices except Rainer, who notices because he was the one who loved her first.
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about this ONE moment for a second because I am not okay. "Griene." That's all he says. Just that one word, across a crowd of thousands, after TWO YEARS of her being completely gone, after she walked into his victory banquet looking like someone had swapped her brain for a mannequin's, and he just... He calls her by her old name like the years didn't happen. And Judith's reaction? She just... freezes. Goes completely blank. Like she doesn't even know what to do with that. But here's what absolutely wrecked me — the narration explicitly tells us Rainer thought of her as the one person who felt like home. "If there was anyone in the world who came close to being something he ought to return to — Judith Griene." After his mother committed suicide because the Emperor couldn't stop despising her, after he was pushed out of the succession line because of his red eyes, after a lifetime of being treated like a thorn-bed... Judith was his anchor. And then she just disappeared. And now she's married to someone else. And she looks at him with those eyes — "utterly indifferent" — and he can't even look at her without pulling his hood down because his crimson irises give him away. This man has been carrying around THIS much unresolved feeling for God knows how long and all he could manage at the pavilion was one whispered name before she stumbled and he caught her. A week later she still doesn't remember any of it. I can't. I genuinely can't.
... Read More
Okay, let me just say — the visual storytelling in this passage is absolutely *chef's kiss*. The moment when the carriage rolls away and the text describes trees blazing with autumn color, leaves passing in streaks of red and gold? That's not just set dressing. That's a mood. It's cold. It's moving. And it perfectly mirrors Judith's internal state — everything is shifting and changing around her while she sits frozen inside. But the scene that absolutely got me was the vision sequence. You know that moment when Lorenz extends his hand and there's a sharp tingle, a static spark? That tiny physical detail — Tap. Tap. She drummed her fingers — is doing so much work. The author uses tactile sensations as doorways into memory. The static shock becomes a trigger, and suddenly we're plunged into this warm summer scene at Altmere where Judith (or a version of her) is dancing, humming to herself, completely carefree. The contrast between the cold carriage interior and the golden summer memory is visceral. I could feel the temperature difference. And then the masterstroke — her vision goes dark and comes back, and suddenly she's looking at her own real hand around Lorenz's gloved one, the hem of her warm dress suited to the season. The boundary between past and present literally dissolves. That's not just good imagery, that's layered, cinematic storytelling. The Belheim townhouse itself also feels alive. Rita the maid exists in that world and makes it feel larger — a capital townhouse with servants who have histories, routines, expectations. When Rita mentions Judith always used to say gossip columns put her to sleep, suddenly this house has a history that existed before the current moments we're witnessing. The setting breathes.
... Read More
The dialogue in this passage is absolutely vicious and I love it. Lorenz speaks in this soft, measured way—always polite, always gentle—and yet every line feels like it has a second meaning lurking underneath. When he says "We are husband and wife, after all," it sounds sweet on the surface but Judith's reaction tells us there's something hollow about it. And that line—"I need you just as much as you need me"—could be devotion or it could be possession. The author lets you sit in that uncertainty. Rainer's dialogue is a completely different beast. Short. Sharp. Loaded. "There is a proper limit to everything — and for that reason, there is a limit to what one can endure and let pass as well." That's not a conversation starter; that's a threat wrapped in aristocratic politeness. And his single word "Griene" when Judith introduces herself? Chilling. He's reminding her of who she was before she became his wife. Before she disappeared into the Belheim name. Judith herself has this fascinating double voice—her external dialogue is proper and restrained ("I behaved rudely toward Your Highness..."), but her internal monologue is sharp, analytical, almost clinical. Even her observation that "Memory isn't the sort of thing that breaks off cleanly, like a sentence ending at a period" carries this dry, almost sarcastic tone that completely contradicts her demure exterior. The contrast between what characters say and what they mean is THE engine of this whole story.
... Read More
I need to talk about Isabel Falkenhayn because the author wrote her in a way that makes you want to throw the book across the room and also somehow respect her commitment to being a villain. Let me just quote this exchange because it's perfection: "A mere maid could hardly have devised something this brazen on her own. Don't you think, Duchess?" SHE JUST LEAPS FROM 'MY BROOCH IS STOLEN' TO 'YOU MUST BE THE MASTERMIND' WITH ZERO EVIDENCE. And then when Judith calmly dismantles her logic — piece by piece, like she's grading a particularly stupid essay — Isabel just SCREAMS. 'What kind of sophist—' NO, YOUR RHETORIC IS TERMITE-INFESTED, COUNTESs. That's my response. But here's what I love: Judith's voice in this scene is so controlled, so deadpan, that it becomes almost funny. She says things like 'It seems this is simply how the Countess conducts herself. Slandering people, tearing them down — without a shred of proper evidence' with the energy of someone reading a grocery list. Meanwhile Isabel is over here losing her absolute mind. The contrast is COMEDY GOLD. And then the moment Judith touches Isabel's hand and gets that vision — 'Before any trace of dawn had crept in, a dim corridor lit by gas lamps came into view' — the prose literally shifts from sharp courtroom drama to Gothic horror in one paragraph. The author's ability to modulate tone within a single scene is unmatched. Judith goes from defusing a petty noblewoman's accusation to uncovering a real conspiracy in the span of a hand touch. No wonder she 'pressed her eyes shut and rubbed her temple with a sigh' — her head must be pounding by this point.
... Read More
Let me just say this straight: THE STAKES JUST GO THROUGH THE ROOF. Previously, the conflict felt manageable. Judith has memory gaps. She has headaches. A doctor is coming. Maybe it's stress, maybe it's a treatable condition. THAT was the old stakes level. Now? Now her HUSBAND is actively plotting to KILL HER. Not threaten. Not endanger. PLAN. DISCUSS. AGREE WITH AN ACCOLICE about the logistics. "If we fail, there's no telling how many more years we'd have to wait. We were fortunate this time — there may not be a next." They're not even passionate about it. It's BUREAUCRATIC murder. Administrative homicide. That's what makes it worse. And Judith is ALONE in knowing this. She can't tell Lorenz she heard them—obviously. She can't tell Norman because Norman is working with Lorenz's version of events. She can't even trust her own perception because this is the THIRD time she's experienced something unexplainable. What if she's wrong? What if she's imagining it? That uncertainty is the REAL conflict here—the external threat is murder, but the INTERNAL conflict is: HOW DOES SHE KNOW WHAT'S REAL ANYMORE? The scene with Norman is CRUEL in hindsight. He talks about memory loss, about consulting a psychiatrist, and Lorenz takes the slip of paper with the specialist's information. Clara Hoffmann. We'll see her later. But notice: Lorenz controls the flow of information. He decides what Norman knows. He decides what Judith knows. He even decides WHICH doctor sees her. The physical stakes are lethal. The psychological stakes are erasure. And Judith, standing at that window gripping the ledge with trembling hands, has to decide: do I play along and survive, or do I fight and risk everything? She asked to enter the study. She's already fighting. I just hope she's ready for what's coming.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or