I Thought You Had Forgotten Me - Reviews

I Thought You Had Forgotten Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
"Every moment of contact with him was sweet." — Lea said this while literally being consumed in a kiss by a blood-soaked man who sounds like he might eat her soul, and yet the narration goes ''No, it was her soul being fulfilled.' I SCREAMED. This is the most romantic thing I have ever read and I am not okay. But the emotional core of this whole setup is SO tragic on another level. Lea spent three years as a MIRROR. She couldn't move. She couldn't hug him. She could only watch this boy grow up beside her, reflect his image, hear his quietest whispers. When he mumbled 'Mirror, I wish you could become human,' she laughed it off playfully — but internally she thought 'it might be enjoyable to watch this child grow up from beside him.' She wanted so badly to just be near him, even if she couldn't do anything about it. And then she gets a body again and the first thing she does is throw herself in front of a sword. No hesitation. The author writes it almost casually — 'In that brief moment, she thought of several things... What ultimately came to mind was just one thing: I don't want you to get hurt.' Just one thought. Not 'what about me' or 'why me' — just him. The prologue is essentially the payoff of three years of buildup. That trembling breath, the gentle grip around her neck despite all that blood and rage — he's so afraid of losing her again. And she thinks 'There was no way she could reject him. It must have been from the moment she first saw him.' FROM THE BEGINNING. They're both so wrecked for each other it's ridiculous.
... Read More
There's this recurring image of the decorative tassels on the mirror that young El used to twirl when he was troubled. Now he's doing the exact same thing with Karlea's hair. Is this coincidence or does the author mean something deeper? It's as if the connection he had with the mirror has literally transferred to her body—same gesture, same comfort, but attached to a completely different person. The line between Karlea and the mirror keeps dissolving. And the dream sequence—so visceral and intimate, almost predatory. His teeth marks on her shoulder, the way he moves through her like he's trying to memorize her body. It contrasts sharply with the daytime tenderness. Is this the emperor's hunger for control? For ownership? Or is it something more primal—his subconscious recognizing her even in dreams? Duke Brishel's obsession with "fragments" of the mirror is another symbolic layer. He wants to SHATTER what makes the emperor who he is. The mirror represents the emperor's vulnerability, his connection to something pure, and Brishel wants to weaponize it. Meanwhile Karlea is caught between being a person and being an object—sometimes a mirror, sometimes a tool, sometimes a fiancée. The question the text keeps asking is: when everyone projects their needs onto you, who are you really?
... Read More
There's something deeply symbolic about a character who spends her first transmigration as a MIRROR. Think about it — a mirror's entire purpose is to reflect others. It has no voice of its own, no body, no agency. It only exists to show you what's in front of it. And Lea, the orphan who learned early to 'smile and talk well' and never stick out — that's EXACTLY what she was doing as a person too. She was reflecting what others wanted to see. As a mirror, she literally becomes that metaphor. She watches El grow up. She reflects his image back at him. And in those three years, despite having no power, no voice, no ability to actually TOUCH him — she becomes the one person who sees him truly. Not the tyrant, not the monster, just the scared child who wished she could become human. The broken mirror at the end is devastating on a symbolic level. She shattered trying to protect him. And then when she wakes up in a new body, Cassie offers her a HAND mirror — the exact same object, but now she CAN look at herself. She sees a beautiful stranger and gasps. 'I've never seen such a beautiful woman before!' The mirror goes from being a tool of reflection (passive, observing) to a tool of self-discovery (active, seeing herself). And then there's the whole premise of the novel she transmigrated into — 'I Wish I Could Share You.' Two male leads, a saintess, obsession. But Lea is neither the saintess nor the female lead. She's the OBJECT. The magic mirror. And somehow, she becomes the most important person in the tyrant's life. The story flips the entire genre on its head.
... Read More
'To those who bully you and annoy you. That you're not an evil mirror. That you're my mirror. That's what I'll say.' I need to just—this memory from their past, triggered by the hand-holding scene, completely reframes everything. A mirror. He called her his mirror. Not his weapon, not his tool, not his subject. His MIRROR. Something that reflects truth. Something that shows the world what it really is. And think about what she's reflecting back at him right now. She's reflecting mercy when he wants vengeance. She's saying 'I don't like seeing blood' when he's standing there ready to unleash it. She's the moral compass he lost somewhere along the way, and he knows it. That's why he brought her here—not just as a trophy, but because he needed HER to make the call. He could destroy every person in that room himself, but he wanted her to choose for him. He wanted her to be the one who said 'no' The whole 'evil mirror' rumor that she's supposed to bear is also fascinating. People think she's a corrupting influence, a reflection of darkness. But the story keeps showing the opposite—she reflects light into spaces where Kraniel has only ever known shadow. She's the mirror that shows him he can still be something other than a monster.
... Read More
So I just finished reading these chapters and honestly the pacing is everything right now. Let me break down why. The section starts with Kraniel proposing this contract arrangement — fake engagement, public displays, all of it. It's tense, it's awkward, Karlea is internally screaming but outwardly agreeing to everything. And then immediately after, Kraniel kisses HER hand and declares it done before she can even process what's happening. That's classic misdirection pacing — the scene builds like it's going to be a serious negotiation and then suddenly it's already irreversible. Very satisfying. Then we cut to Aizen's POV and get this entire side conversation with the emperor about his sister. This could've been boring exposition but the author makes it work because we're learning things we didn't know — like that the mirror chose Karlea specifically, and that Kraniel said something about 'the choice is not mine' which is clearly referring to the mirror's agency. Aizen's terror at the end is the perfect button on this scene. 'Even that brief glance caused such a reaction.' Chills. Next cut: Karlea raiding the room. This is where I almost wanted to skim, honestly. The search itself isn't super exciting, but the diary discovery — the blood, the entry about a 'friend' who insulted her, the line 'pretending to be my friend and daring to insult me? Next time I see him, I'll tear his face off' — this is genuinely good character work through object. A handwritten notebook with blood on it. That's a visual that sticks. Then the mirror ability activates. The transition from physical search to astral projection is smooth — she's looking in the mirror, her vision flips, and suddenly she's floating. No clunky explanation paragraphs, just: she REMEMBERS this ability from her mirror days and proceeds to use it. Efficient storytelling. And then the real payoff: she appears in El's bedroom and finds him SICK. The scene lingers on his pain, her concern, and then the hooded figure arrives. The chapter doesn't resolve anything. It ends mid-conversation with this woman scolding him. We don't know who she is, we don't know the nature of their relationship, we don't know what illness afflicts him. Perfect cliffhanger. The structure is basically: tension (proposal) → complication (Aizen's warning) → discovery (diary) → supernatural shift (astral projection) → emotional core (seeing him suffering) → new mystery (who is the woman?). Each beat lands and pushes forward. No dragging. The only moment I felt slightly bored was the diary-reading section but even that had the blood detail to keep me going.
... Read More
Can we just appreciate how good Kraniel's dialogue is in these chapters? The man speaks in three different tones depending on who he's talking to and it's so intentional it hurts. With Karlea: "How can you trust me?" / "This is a kind of contract romance. You'll have to show the nobles the image of lovers to the point of disgust." / "Even a fake romance? Even if it means staying attached to me throughout appropriate official occasions? Are you confident you can do all that?" Notice the repetition. He keeps asking, keeps pushing, like he's testing whether she'll actually follow through. And when she says "Yes, I'll burn myself to help you!" — his response is basically to just kiss her hand and declare it done. The dialogue here is ALL subtext. He's not saying what he really means (which is: I need you, don't leave me, please trust me) but he's also not being malicious about it. There's a genuine warmth underneath the manipulation, and that's what makes his voice distinct. With Aizen: "What. Now that she's lost her memory, have you developed tender feelings for your sister?" / "There will be no danger to your family." / "I will never hurt Lea with my own hands." Cold. Sharp. One-liners that land like knives. This is the emperor speaking, and every word is calculated. The jealousy in "have you developed tender feelings for your sister?" is pure venom disguised as casual inquiry. And then the shift at the end — "I will never hurt Lea with my own hands" — this is different. It's almost vulnerable, but he delivers it with such authority that it still sounds like a threat. His voice doesn't soften; it just changes frequency. And Karlea's internal monologue? Oh my god. The contrast between her outward compliance and inner panic is comedy gold: "Wait, what are you asking me to do?" / "Hey, wait. Hey!" / "So she did... write a diary after all." / "Crazy, I must be really crazy." She's constantly narrating her own disbelief, which makes her feel so alive and human despite being in someone else's body. And then there's the mirror's voice when she's giving information — calm, efficient, almost clinical. Three distinct registers in one character. The hooded woman's dialogue is sparse but loaded: "Your Majesty. You're really stubborn." / "You should have called for me before it got this bad, Your Majesty." That casual scolding tone with a title? Who IS this person? The way she speaks implies familiarity and authority simultaneously, and I need to know more immediately.
... Read More
Okay so let me just — wait, hold up. She transmigrated TWICE? First as a talking magic mirror, then as a human noblewoman in the SAME WORLD six years later. That is actually such a creative way to do transmigration. I was completely thrown off when she became a mirror and was like 'what the heck is happening' but then the death scene hit and I genuinely teared up. And then BAM, slap in the face, new body, amnesia cover — the author just refuses to let you breathe. The structure is interesting too. The prologue drops you right at the climax of their reunion as ADULTS — blood-soaked El, trembling hands, that devastating 'Don't run away from me' — and THEN you go back to Chapter 1 and watch them as child and mirror. So every sweet moment between Lea and young El is loaded with dramatic irony because you ALREADY KNOW how this ends. You already know she dies for him. That makes those three years together feel so much more precious and heartbreaking. Also the timing is no accident — she wakes up exactly when the original novel begins, meaning she gets to witness El's entire arc from age 18 to 21, the age the story originally started. She's basically been rewritten into the timeline. The author sets up this wonderful tension where Lea thinks she protected him enough to make him 'kinder,' but then Cassie reacts to her smiling like it's some kind of alien event. So... what the hell did the ORIGINAL Lea do? What's her personality? The mystery is already spinning.
... Read More
'I heard some voices evaluating the gift I sent… What should I do with them?' My heart actually stopped when he said that. This man—who everyone fears, who crushed a rebellion six years ago, who made half the nobility beg for their lives—was asking a count's daughter for permission to execute people. And she just looked at him and said 'Well, the dead cannot speak, Your Majesty?' Like she was discussing the weather. And he smiled. He actually SMILED. But the real moment—the one I can't stop thinking about—was when he asked 'Did that woman seem pitiful to you?' and Karlea immediately shook her head. Not because she was afraid of him, not because she was being politically smart. Because she genuinely doesn't want him to be called a tyrant. She sees something in Saskia that even Kraniel himself might not see, and she's protecting him from becoming exactly what his enemies want him to be. And then—the hand thing. He held out his hand like a toddler asking for something. 'Don't think unnecessary thoughts, hand.' I screamed into my pillow. This is the same man who once pouted and ground his teeth saying 'That you're my mirror. That's what I'll say' and now he's waving his hand in front of her face like 'take it, hmm?' The contrast between the terrifying emperor and this slightly childish guy who just wants to hold hands is doing things to my nervous system.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this reveal where we find out Kraniel/El is actually physically suffering and basically no one seems to know except Karlea, and honestly my heart? It just shattered a little. Think about it. The whole chapters leading up to this, we see this cold, calculating emperor who's manipulating everyone like chess pieces. He's all sharp edges and golden eyes that see through lies. And then BAM — he's lying in bed, pale, rubbing his cheek like he's in pain, enduring something. And who notices? Only Karlea. Only someone who used to BE a mirror watching over him from the shadows. And then the saintess shows up — this hooded woman who knows the secret passage, who scolds him casually like they're some kind of established couple — and Karlea's astral form is LITERALLY freezing because she feels jealousy. Her own fingers go cold in a state where she shouldn't be able to feel temperature. She's like 'that's not possible, I must be crazy, the original Karlea's influence is too strong' but we ALL know it's not that, right? It's because she actually cares about El now. The dynamic between them has shifted SO much. Remember when he first grabbed her hand and kissed it, playing this whole performance? He was manipulating her. But look at his expression — 'his golden eyes curved prettily.' That smile. He genuinely seemed happy that she agreed to this. Not just strategically pleased but actually delighted. And then later, when he's alone in his room in pain, the only person whose soul-wandered into his bedroom is hers because she was searching for information to HELP him. Also can we talk about Aizen? His reaction to seeing his lord's gaze — 'His lord's eyes, sweetly curved yet filled with chilling obsession and madness.' That word. Obsession. Aizen has known this emperor forever and even HE is shaken by how different Karlea makes him. And Karlea herself notices it: 'his sister looked as if she was worried the tyrant emperor might break or shatter.' Who would've thought the most feared person in the empire needs someone to worry about him not breaking? I keep re-reading the line where Kraniel says 'I will never hurt Lea with my own hands' and Aizen's reaction to the name 'Lea' — like, this man has been calling her by her nickname privately and his confidant just found out. The layers here. The secrets. I'm obsessed.
... Read More
Can we just appreciate how perfectly Karlea's voice works in this scene? The author wrote her inner monologue and her spoken dialogue in two completely different registers, and it's chef's kiss. Her internal voice is sharp, analytical, almost bored—"This was his test," "My emperor is twisted," "I guess the original Karlea also fell for this woman's whispers and died." She's constantly stepping back and observing the situation like she's reading someone else's disaster. Very dry. Very detached. But when she speaks out loud? Oh, it's theatrical. "I'll apologize in advance." Whispered softly, then immediately weaponized. "Since you cowardly ganged up on me first, I'll use a bit of force too." Said almost kindly, like she's correcting a child's manners. "Lady, wine isn't for pouring on people's faces, but for drinking." This line made me SCREAM laughing. She's educating these violent noble ladies on proper wine etiquette WHILE fighting them. And the contrast with Sophia? Sophia is all explosive emotion—growling, demanding, shrieking. Her dialogue is raw and desperate. She can't even finish her sentences. Meanwhile Karlea speaks in complete, calm sentences while physically dismantling six opponents. The author really understood that in a scene like this, the most powerful dialogue isn't shouting—it's the person who stays composed while everything around them loses their minds. The narrative voice itself is also doing interesting work. Karlea's POV is layered—she's literally narrating from the perspective of someone who KNOWS how this scene is supposed to go, and is actively rewriting the ending in real time. That meta-awareness gives every thought a double edge.
... Read More
"I waited for you." That's it. That's the line that wrecked me. Four words and suddenly I'm questioning everything about how we define obsession versus devotion. The emperor—El—has been alone for however long after his mirror departed, and when he realizes she's not coming to find him on her own, his first emotion isn't anger. It's something that resembles despair. Then he decides to MAKE her come. Not gently. Not with a handwritten letter. With an imperial decree that essentially traps every young woman in the capital. And our protagonist? She fainted from shock, then recovered to eat FOUR plates of veal. Because she was a MIRROR for years and couldn't even drink water. The moment she gets to taste food is both hilarious and heartbreakingly humanizing. "Sniff, it's so, so delicious." Cassie asking if she's crying because it's delicious and she just says YES. This woman is experiencing humanity like a newborn, and all the romantic tension in the world can't compete with the genuine thrill of tasting meat for the first time. But then she remembers why she's really there. "Finally, you. My young tyrant." She knows she might die. She knows the original Karlea was jealous, obsessive, destructive. She knows everyone at the banquet probably hates her. And she's going anyway. Because she gets to see him. Hundreds of times better than dying and leaving his side forever. That's the emotional core of this whole thing—it's not about romance in the traditional sense. It's about someone who was never a person, who watched from glass for years, who finally gets a body and the first thing they want to do is find the person they loved from across a reflection. How do you not feel something for that?
... Read More
The pacing in this section is actually kind of masterful if you pay attention to how it breathes. Chapter 7 opens with sensory overload—beautiful descriptions, confusion, the slow dawning horror of realization. Then BAM, she faints. Chapter transition. Then we cut to El's POV, which is heavier, darker, slower, like the emotional weight of the story briefly shifting to the other side of the mirror. His section moves deliberately—each action described with care, each emotion layered. He laughs, he calls the chamberlain, he issues the decree. By the time we return to Karlea, the pacing snaps back into motion with comedic energy (the food scene, which is pure relief after that heavy emperor section). But then the butler bursts in with the decree, and suddenly the comedy evaporates. She has to go. She has to face everything. And the chapter closes on that frozen moment—her walking into the banquet hall, the silence, everyone staring behind her. Cliffhanger that actually earns its keep. What I love is how the author uses tone shifts as pacing tools. The fainting/comedy beat acts as a pressure valve after the transmigration shock. El's section is the dark undercurrent that makes everything feel more dangerous. Then Karlea's determination at the end pulls it all back together. If the author had kept the tension at maximum throughout, it would have numbed us. Instead, we get highs and lows that make the final scene hit harder. The only thing I'd question is whether the food scene, while charming, slightly deflates the tension right before the banquet announcement—but honestly, it works because it reminds us what's at stake: she's not just a plot device, she's someone who got to BE HUMAN for the first time and is willing to risk everything to keep experiencing it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or