I Thought You Had Forgotten Me - Reviews

I Thought You Had Forgotten Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about El because THIS MAN. The prologue has him absolutely unhinged — blood-soaked, golden eyes like a predator, trembling hands, and that line 'I only need you. It's been that way from the beginning.' That is not the dialogue of a mentally stable person, folks, and I am absolutely obsessed. But then you go back to Chapter 1 and see WHY. Young El is this terrified twelve-year-old who just lost the ONLY person who ever showed him warmth, and he's screaming at shattered glass because his hand keeps cutting on the mirror pieces. The detail about him cutting his own hand trying to reach her — that broke me. A child who has never been touched gently, who has never had anyone stay, and suddenly she's gone and he can't even touch her without bleeding. And Lea's side of it! She's this hardened orphan who survived by blending in and never sticking out, who smiles at everyone and plays along, and the ONE thing she actually cared about was this terrifying child emperor. Her internal monologue is so raw: 'My attachment is to this child. If I leave, this child will be left alone.' She literally throws herself in front of a sword meant for him. Not because she's heroic — because she genuinely cannot imagine a world where he gets hurt. Now she's back as a human and sees his emblem at the banquet and her immediate thought isn't about her new body or danger — it's 'whether that child was safe.' Six years of her life and her first concern is still HIM.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about how EL and Karlea's dynamic has shifted so drastically but also stayed exactly the same? Like. He treats her with this casual warmth now—twirling her hair like he used to with the mirror tassels, leaning his head on her shoulder in the carriage, calling her 'Lea'—but she's over here having a full existential crisis because that familiarity isn't meant for HER. That tenderness is directed at the original Karlea von Bloodina, right? Or at least it feels that way. And the moment where she asks him if he misses the former Karlea? I literally gasped. And his answer—"No. Stay by my side. That's what matters now."—I think he genuinely means it, but does he? Or is he just being kind to someone who looks like someone else? The ambiguity is killing me. Then Duke Brishel is over here scheming, treating Saskia like a pawn. "There's always someone who can replace you." CHILLING. The man is pure ice. And the way he connects Karlea's sudden personality change to the mirror—that's not nothing. He's suspicious, he's hunting, and he's about to turn this into a weapon against the emperor. I have a terrible feeling about where this goes.
... Read More
The plot mechanics in this section are doing SO MUCH work. Let me unpack what's happening because the layers are incredible. Karlea is a transmigrated character—she was originally something else entirely (a magic mirror, apparently) and now inhabits the body of Karlea von Bloodina, the villain supporting character from the original novel. She has genuine amnesia, which means she doesn't remember her past life OR her original character's history. But here's the twist: her body remembers things. The dream sequence proves this. Her body responds to touch in ways that suggest she's experienced intimacy before, even if her mind doesn't have the memories. Meanwhile, Aizen has the original novel's knowledge in a way—he remembers what "his sister" was like. He recalls her saying things like "I will become His Majesty's woman" and calling it madness. He knew the REAL Karlea, the ambitious one who coveted the Emperor. So when this new Karlea appears, humble and apologetic, his entire framework for understanding her shatters. The banquet incident creates a perfect plot catalyst: the Emperor danced the first dance with HER, not the saintess, not some other character. This upends every expectation Aizen and presumably the reader had. And Karlea herself has NO IDEA what this means politically. She's asking "what happened at the banquet?" like a normal person would, completely oblivious to the fact that she's become the center of court intrigue. This is really smart plotting—the protagonist's ignorance creates dramatic irony that keeps tension high while the reader watches her navigate danger she can't see.
... Read More
The pacing here is absolutely brilliant and I want to talk about how the author controls the rhythm. We open at maximum intensity—a full romantic dream sequence that's written with breathless, feverish prose. Short sentences. Fragments. "It hurts. It hurts. It hurts so much." Then "The pain instantly transformed into something else." The sensory overload is deliberate. You can't read this scene slowly; it demands to be devoured. Then—SLAM—reality hits. Karlea wakes up. The prose shifts to her panicked internal monologue, still breathless but now comedic in its own right. Cassie entering like a ghost sighting is the perfect tonal release after the dream's intensity. And then the chapter pivots HARD into political drama with Aizen's entrance. The transition works because the emotional energy carries forward—Karlea is still flustered, still processing, still not quite herself. She meets Aizen's coldness with genuine warmth (whether feigned or not, it doesn't matter yet), and the scene plays out like a tension弹簧 that keeps getting pulled tighter. The chapter ends on one of the best cliffhanger-adjacent moments I've read: Karlea asking him to explain the banquet incident, and him getting physically choked up saying "You mean dancing with His Majesty the Emperor..." She raises her hand and he stops speaking. The scene cuts there, mid-sentence, mid-emotion. You NEED to know what happens next. The structural choice to open with the most charged scene and end with the most charged dialogue moment means the entire chapter vibrates at the same frequency.
... Read More
Let me just lay this out. Saskia spent years—her WHOLE LIFE really—trying to become the perfect match for the emperor. She was beautiful, noble, carefully cultivated. She believed that if she just became impeccable enough, he would notice her. And then Kraniel starts showing interest in KARLEA VON BLOODINA. The woman who does nothing. The 'madwoman of society.' The one everyone mocks. And Saskia's entire worldview cracks open in real time. The moment that hits hardest is when she sees Kraniel's expression change—not cold, but soft, almost tender, directed at Karlea. 'So that man could smile like that too.' She's not thinking about politics or her father's rebellion. She's thinking about a human being she admired from afar and realizing she never actually knew him at all. And worse—she realizes she was never seen by him. Not really. 'I absolutely cannot allow that.' Her father would abandon her if the emperor broke his two-year standoff. So Saskia is trapped between pride and survival, between love and strategy, and she's making choices that will probably destroy everyone around her including herself. The stakes here aren't just 'will the rebellion succeed'—they're deeply personal. Every character in this chapter is fighting for something intimate: Saskia wants to be chosen. Kraniel wants to protect without losing himself. Karlea wants to survive without becoming cruel. And the nobles? They just want to keep their heads. Nobody is safe here. The tension doesn't come from big battles—it comes from the fact that everyone is one wrong word away from catastrophe.
... Read More
I need to process this scene. Karlea finally works up the courage to ask El to believe her no matter what strange things she says later—basically her roundabout way of saying she's not who he thinks she is, that she's the mirror—and he looks at her with this devastating expression and just says "I believe you." Like, he doesn't know WHY but he TRUSTS her. I actually had to put the book down. But then immediately after this deeply vulnerable moment, he falls ASLEEP on her shoulder. And Karlea is like... holding her breath, tapping his hand gently, thinking about how he used to be a lonely child on a wide bed and now he has someone to lean on. "Because the mirror is by your side." MY HEART CANNOT HANDLE THIS. The emotional whiplash is real. One minute she's pouring her soul out, the next she's watching him sleep and feeling this bittersweet tenderness. She's not the mirror anymore in his eyes, but he's finding peace with her anyway. Is that enough? She keeps telling herself yes but then he says something flirty like "next time try to love me more passionately" and her mood tanks again. The rollercoaster is REAL and I am here for it.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about this opening dream sequence because WOW. The author just dropped the most intensely sensual scene and I was NOT prepared. Karlea wakes up drenched in sweat, face red, absolutely flustered—and the dream itself? It's not just physical, it's layered with meaning. The way he calls her "Lea" instead of "Mirror" hits differently. She explains it's from a lake fairy, that looking at the mirror's surface reminded him of a frosty lake, so he gave her that name. That's the kind of detail that makes you GOBBLE. Someone chose a name for her based on how it made HIM feel when he looked into a mirror. That's intimate in a way I didn't expect from a dream sequence. But here's what actually got me—when she wakes up and touches her lips, they feel raw and warm, like something had touched them and disappeared. Her skin feels more sensitive. The dream BLED into reality for her. And she has no idea who he was in the dream but her BODY remembers everything. That line about "I'll give you everything I couldn't before. Everything I have is yours"—who does that?! This man in her dream is already promising her the world while whispering sweet nothings, and she's just WAKING UP to it. Then Cassie walks in and Karlea's just sitting there trying to compose herself. The embarrassment is palpable. I'm literally wheezing.
... Read More
There's so much going on beneath the surface in these chapters that I want to unpack. The mirror motif alone could fill an essay. The magic mirror is EVERYTHING here. It was Karlea's former self — a servant who observed, recorded, and reported. Now it's bound to a new host, and its ability to project astrally becomes the vehicle through which Karlea discovers the truth about El. But mirrors have always been symbols of identity, reflection, and duality. She literally sees her old body from the outside while inhabiting it. She looks into the hand mirror decorated with flowers and her vision flips — the reflection becomes the real world. The mirror doesn't just show images; it shows TRUTH. And what it shows is that the emperor, the most powerful person in the empire, is suffering in private while performing strength publicly. Then there's the blood in Karlea's diary. A dark red smear on the corner of a leather notebook. Whose blood is it? We don't know yet, but the implication is clear — this isn't just a record of petty cruelties and revenge fantasies. This is evidence of something worse. The diary represents Karlea's past life, the sins of the woman whose body she inhabits, and the blood is the physical trace of consequences she'll have to face. She reads through it hoping to find helpful information and instead finds 'how bad Karlea's personality was.' The tragedy is that she's trying to be better than the original, but she's trapped inside someone else's wreckage. And the names — Kraniel vs. El vs. Lea. He calls her 'Lea' when he's alone with Aizen, and the name visibly affects everyone who hears it. Aizen stutters. The text specifically notes 'At that title, Aizen stuttered.' This is the emperor's intimate name for her, and it carries weight because it's used in a moment of raw honesty. Meanwhile, 'Your Majesty' and 'emperor' are the titles everyone else uses — formal, distant, filled with fear. The naming hierarchy mirrors the power hierarchy, but Karlea keeps slipping between them, not knowing which version of him she's actually talking to. The final image — the hooded woman in his bedroom, the words 'Your Majesty' spoken with familiarity rather than reverence — it all points to a theme: beneath the labels and performances, these characters are just people trying to survive each other. The emperor is sick. The fake fiancée is actually caring. The confidant is terrified. None of them are what they appear to be.
... Read More
The contrast between Lea's inner voice and outer performance is honestly comedy gold. Here's this woman who spent twenty-two years perfecting the art of 'smile and talk well wherever you are, and don't be the nail that sticks out,' and she transmigrates into a body where apparently NO ONE expects her to smile. Watch her try to apply her survival skills to a brand new situation: The noblewoman slaps her, douses her in wine, and Lea's response is basically: *Oh honey, you seem upset. Let me use my best customer-service face.* She takes the woman's hand and soothes her. She apologizes profusely. She's doing the thing she's always done — de-escalate, please everyone, survive. And the reaction? "S-sorry?" The woman is OFFENDED by the apology. Lea's internal monologue: 'It was exactly like looking at food waste that couldn't even be recycled.' SHE'S BEEN REWRITTEN INTO SOMEONE TOXIC AND THE PEOPLE AROUND HER ARE JUST AS BROKEN. But her voice when she's alone with her thoughts? That's where it gets good. The casual self-deprecation — 'Right. I shouldn't have taken that d*mn part-time job. No, that's not it. I shouldn't have stopped by that food stall' — this is a modern person's voice, relatable and funny, and it grounds the whole fantasy setting. She's not some noble lady having an elegant adventure. She's a girl who died eating tteokbokki and now she's a mirror and then a human again and she's just trying to figure out what the actual hell is going on.
... Read More
"My emperor is twisted, too twisted." Yet somehow, why? She found herself smiling. I've read this line five times and it still hits me in the chest. Let me unpack this because it's THE emotional core of everything. Karlea looks at the emperor hiding somewhere in this banquet, watching her get cornered by six enemies—and her first thought isn't fear. It isn't resentment. It's recognition. She sees the parallel between how THIS tyrant tests her and how THE CHILD he used to be used to test her too. "That child, unable to trust people, would deliberately say hurtful things. As if testing whether she could endure." This is so painfully beautiful. The emperor has spent his entire life building walls. He can't just say "I need you" without wrapping it in layers of provocation and danger. He creates a scenario where she COULD fail, where she could break down and prove herself unworthy—not because he wants her to fail, but because he's terrified of needing someone and being abandoned. And Karlea? She STRIVED to show him she wouldn't abandon him. She says this out loud: "I won't abandon you, my emperor." Over time, her patience seeped through his defenses. That's why she can laugh off his terrifying threats. That's why she smiles when he sets her up to look like prey at a banquet. She understands him better than anyone in this room. Even Saskia, who harbors decades of unrequited love, doesn't understand him the way Karlea does. And that's the real romance here—not grand declarations, but two broken people who recognize each other's patterns and choose to stay anyway.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or