I Decided to Forget Him - Reviews

I Decided to Forget Him
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
What a masterclass in building toward a breaking point. Let me trace the architecture of this chapter because it's deliberately constructed to make you feel like you're being squeezed. It starts with Danyu arriving at the salon alongside Astaire—and immediately the gossip mill is churning. Young male teacher, young female student. The kind of rumor that makes gossips' teeth sharpen. She's already on edge before she even steps inside. Then Winkler at the piano—brilliant technique, zero soul. Classic contrast to Sio's philosophy: "The hands that play the piano are merely a tool for expressing the music. The essence lies in the heart." We get this flashback-adjacent memory of Sio's voice, which immediately undercuts any stability Danyu might have felt. And then HE appears. Leaning against the wall. Champagne in hand. Eight years of unspoken feelings compressed into a conversation that lasts maybe three minutes but contains every confession she ever made and every rejection she ever swallowed. The structure is brutal in its efficiency. Rumor → piano performance → memory → Sio appears → confrontation → she escapes to Astaire → breakdown → the question that changes everything. And that ending question from Astaire—"Do you truly want to be free of Sio?"—isn't just a plot turn, it's a pivot point for the entire narrative. Up until now, Danyu has been walking forward without knowing where. This question forces her to actually choose. The plot stops being about what happens to her and starts being about what she decides.
... Read More
I finished this and immediately sat there staring at the wall because the pacing is absolutely ruthless in the best way. Let me break down why this works so well. The chapter opens at maximum tension—Danyu walks into a room where everyone already knows her business before she's even breathed a word. The gossip is established immediately. Then she's distracted by the piano, by Winkler's performance, by memories of Sio, by Astaire disappearing into a crowd. Every beat pulls her further from solid ground. And then Sio speaks. Just one line: "I was wondering who had come in with Astaire." And the entire weight of eight years collapses onto that single sentence. What's genius about the pacing here is that the confrontation between Danyu and Sio doesn't drag. It's sharp, almost brutal in its brevity. She asks for so little—a warning, a kindness, a single acknowledgment—and gets nothing but polite indifference. The dialogue moves fast because she doesn't have the luxury of lingering. She can't afford to stay in this room with him any longer. Then the escape to the storeroom slows everything down. The wind, the dust, the sunlight. The crying scene unfolds at a completely different rhythm—slow, messy, unhurried. It gives the reader space to breathe after the tension spike. And that final question from Astaire arrives like a hammer. After all that catharsis, after all that release, he asks the one question that resets the entire board. The chapter doesn't end with resolution. It ends with a door opening. And that's what keeps it stuck in my head.
... Read More
I need to talk about the piano scene. The one where she drinks the champagne, presses a key with her other hand, and makes that discord ring through the whole salon. That was... I don't even know how to describe it. She had walked in there already trembling, had just stood face to face with the man she'd loved for eight years, and he looked at her like she was nothing. Like she never was anything. And then this girl is touching Astaire's arm, whispering in his ear, and something in Danyu just snapped. It wasn't about jealousy, not really. It was the final thread snapping. She'd rehearsed this moment in her head a thousand times—walking away with her head held high, telling Sio he meant nothing to her. But the real her? Still the same girl from years ago, still carrying him in her chest. When she played that dissonant chord, it was the only honest sound she could make. Everything else had been polished lies. And then she cried. Not private tears, not the swallowed kind she always held back. Full-on, ugly sobbing into Astaire's shoulder, telling him everything—the first time she met Sio, the birthday where he introduced his fiancée like it was nothing, every year she told herself it wasn't too late to turn back. "Starting was easy. Why is ending so hard?" She was completely taken in. I felt that in my bones. There's something devastating about watching someone realize they've been carrying a grief that big for eight years and finally let it out. And Astaire—god, Astaire just held her. Didn't pretend not to notice. Didn't tell her to stop. Just said 'you can cry now, there's no one here' and let her fall apart. That scene where dust looks like snowflakes in the sunlight but isn't cold and can't be caught? I keep thinking about that. That's exactly what this was. Eight years of something that looked beautiful but couldn't be held.
... Read More
"Be as cowardly as you want, Danyu Astrid." This line wrecked me. Not because it's profound - though it is - but because it's the moment Danyu stops fighting herself. For EIGHT YEARS she's been trying to erase Sio from her memory like deleting files from a corrupted hard drive. Denial as survival. And Astaire's voice from somewhere deep inside her basically says: yeah you're a coward, and that's okay, just stop pretending you're a noble tragic heroine. And then the breakdown. She hears Sio play Seydel and she just... collapses. Laughing and crying at the same time. Not because the music is sad - because it's BEAUTIFUL and she finally understands that her music, her SOUND, lives in the acceptance of everything she's felt, not in the erasure of it. The chaos in Seydel's eighth sonata mirrors her own chaos, and Sio channels it so perfectly because HE was once lost there too. Two broken people making beautiful broken music together, and she can't hold it together anymore. The moment with Sio's soup though - that's where I completely lost it. Warm potato soup. From the man she confessed to years ago, the man whose engagement she was terrified of, serving her something he made himself in his quiet little townhouse. The warmth thawing her cold fingertips and then her heart. The memory of eating together as children while now they're these complicated broken adults who can barely look at each other without something shifting between them. "My music is no longer here. My music is somewhere farther from here, in my present." She opens her eyes and Astaire is there instead of Sio. Her past is gone and what's left is this complicated new present where Sio is engaged to someone else and Astaire is watching her like she's something fragile and precious and he doesn't know what to do with that feeling.
... Read More
The way these characters talk to each other is EVERYTHING. Astaire especially has this incredible voice - he says things that seem calm on the surface but are carrying SO much underneath. His line "I'm angry. That you ended up here, after all. Even though it may have been what I intended." is a masterclass in controlled emotional devastation. He sent her to Sio. He WANTED her to find her sound through confronting her past. And now that she has, he's sitting there in his sickbed equivalent watching her heal and realizing he was never really in the picture. He says he's angry but what he's really saying is: I hoped this would bring us closer and it brought you back to HIM instead. And Danyu's confession to him is so raw and unfiltered: "Isn't that funny? That a person's life could be filled with someone other than themselves." She's not performing for anyone here. She's half-dead from exhaustion, hands destroyed, face probably a mess, and she just... tells the truth. No filters, no dignity, just honesty. That's when you know a character's voice is genuine. Sio's dialogue is a completely different flavor - economical, almost minimal. "There may be mistakes." "I don't do Seydel." "Eat." Three words. That's it. But each one carries重量. Especially "Eat." After everything - the breakdown, the three-day piano marathon, the emotional unraveling - his response is basically "you haven't eaten in a week, here, shut up and eat." That's Sio's love language and honestly it's the healthiest romance trope I've ever encountered. The narrative voice itself is also doing heavy lifting. It's first person but not confessional - it's observant, sensory, almost dreamlike during the music scenes. The prose gets lyrical when describing the playing and brutal in its simplicity during emotional moments. That contrast is deliberate and it works.
... Read More
There are so many layers underneath this passage that I barely knew how to process all of them at once. Let's start with the most obvious symbol: Sio's hands. For a musician, hands are everything — they're the bridge between internal artistry and external expression. When those hands betray him, it's not just a medical condition; it's an existential crisis. His body has become an enemy. The very instruments of his identity are turning against him. And the tragedy is that he can't control it. The trembling is involuntary. This is someone whose entire sense of self was built on precision and control, and now even his nervous system won't obey. The piano itself is symbolic — she sits at it at the end and produces nothing. Meaningless notes. When the artist loses their art, what remains? The novel seems to be asking this question of Sio specifically, but also of everyone connected to him. What are you without the thing that defined you? Hair as symbolism is everywhere. Her hair falls down when she removes the pin — a shedding of performed identity, a return to something more natural and vulnerable. Astaire touches her hair. He kisses her red strands. Hair as intimacy, as memory, as something left behind when someone departs. The amber flower pin she gives him is almost sacramental — an object that carries the promise of return. The water imagery — the pond, the trees, the cool breeze — creates a liminal space. This isn't the stage. This isn't the chapel. This is somewhere outside the social structures that have defined everyone's lives up to this point. In this liminal space, truth comes out. Sio stops performing. The protagonist stops pretending she understands. Class is another thread — the Jubilion as an institution that requires noble birth, Sio's workaround through engagement, the entire system that forces people to perform identities they don't want. The novel keeps asking: who gets to be seen as they truly are, and who has to costume themselves to participate? And finally: the silence at the end. Four bells. A winner announced. And nothing. The silence after music dies is perhaps the most powerful image in the passage.
... Read More
The Pathétique sonata isn't just background music here — it's the emotional climax of the entire section. Danyu chose it deliberately for her practical examination, and now she chooses it again in Astaire's presence. 'A succession of notes, beautiful yet desolate.' That's her life in Beethoven's architecture: the storm of her opening movement (eight years of obsession), the slow middle (the grief she's been avoiding), and the Allegro finale where she finally reaches some kind of resolution. But the real plot mechanic here is Astaire's intervention. He's not just a new teacher — he's systematically dismantling the entire ecosystem that kept Danyu trapped. First, he forces her to confront that her playing resembles Sio's because she learned by ear from him. Then he declares that learning by ear is a 'bad habit' because it prevents independent interpretation. Then he changes their meeting location to his house. Then he takes her out into the world. Each action is a plot move that chips away at the Sio-centered universe Danyu has inhabited for eight years. The examination flashback serves as backstory that explains the present: Danyu bowed and ran away because she felt she'd disgraced Sio. She was so consumed with his opinion that she couldn't even face Astaire, who was sitting right there. That moment of shame has been her anchor, and the plot is now about whether she can unmoor herself. Madame Frida's salon at the end introduces a new plot vector — the social world that has been observing Danyu's relationship with Sio from the outside. The text mentions that Sio's female students became his lovers and then left him, while male students couldn't handle his standards. Danyu is the anomaly — eight years, no romance, no departure. The plot is setting up the question: what was different about her, and what happens now that she's stepping into a world where that mystery will be examined?
... Read More
The central metaphor of this entire passage is the iron door with locks. Astaire describes it perfectly - everyone has a door inside them and some people's doors have no lock while others have dozens. Danyu's door had MORE locks than she could count, and the keys were the life she'd lived. No one but her could know where her keys were. This is such a clean metaphor for self-discovery. You can't find your authentic voice - whether that's musical or personal - by looking at someone else's door. By looking at Sio. She defined her sound as whatever Sio's sound was, and that's why it was always going to be impossible. She was trying to open a door that wasn't hers. And then the resolution - the door that had dozens of locks now has only ONE remaining. Not because she unlocked them all, but because she stopped trying to pick every single one and just found the one key that actually matters: acceptance. The key is acknowledging that Sio is part of her story, not something to delete from it. "The true meaning of forgetting that she had found within the music was not deletion, but the courage to stop running from the past." THIS is the thematic core. Forgetting doesn't mean erasing. It means integrating. It means the past becomes part of your foundation instead of a ghost you're haunted by. The Seydel eighth sonata itself functions as symbolism too - it's about a man lost and plunged into confusion, pretending calm while chaos gnaws at his heels. Sio channels this because he knows what it means to stand at that exact edge. Danyu channels it because she's there now. The music becomes the vessel for translating pain into sound, and that's what "finding your sound" actually means - it's not about technical perfection, it's about having the courage to let your genuine emotions ring out without filtering them through someone else's interpretation.
... Read More
'At the end of the notes sinking endlessly downward, all that remained was emptiness and desolation.' I kept replaying this scene in my head for like an hour after I finished reading. Astaire playing the Tempest — and it being nothing like Sio's version. Not worse, not better, just completely alien. The way the author describes it: 'a sprint,' 'nearly twice the speed of a standard Tempest,' 'absolute solitude, the solitude of standing alone on unfamiliar ground.' I could literally feel that emptiness. And then Danyu's reaction — pressing her hand over her mouth to stop from crying out 'that it was absurd' — this is the moment the book transitions from something pleasant to read into something that actually gets under your skin. The emotional journey here isn't some simple romance arc, it's about a young woman confronting the fact that everything she thought defined her was built on someone else's foundation. When Astaire tells her 'Everyone is born with their own music,' his bitter smile afterward — 'making music takes more courage than people expect' — there's so much grief buried in those words. This character has been hurt by his own pursuit of sound, and now he's handing that same dangerous gift to Danyu.
... Read More
Let me unpack the musical metaphors because they're everywhere and they're doing heavy lifting. Winkler plays with speed and precision but no beauty—everything technique, nothing soul. Sio, meanwhile, built his entire philosophy around the idea that the heart matters more than the hands. "Try to play the story inside the score." And yet—here's the bitter irony—Sio himself never made a single mistake. The infuriating man. So Danyu is caught between two models of musicianship, two models of love. Winkler's approach is the surface performance: polished, impressive, empty. Sio's approach is the ideal: deep, emotional, truthful. But she can't achieve either. Her playing is hindered by lack of confidence, and her feelings for Sio are hindered by his inability to receive them. The discordant chord she plays at the piano is the most honest moment in the entire text. It's not pretty. It's not technically correct. But it's true. It's the sound of eight years of swallowed feelings finally breaking through. And then there's the music she's been playing—a piece with no end in sight, reaching a fork in the road, left or right, not knowing which way to go. "Today's me whispers to go left. Tomorrow's me whispers to go right." That's her life. That's the piece she's been performing for eight years without knowing how to finish it. The ending places its final note at the realization: whatever lies ahead, it is not him.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author weaponizes stillness. Danyu spends THREE DAYS bedridden and FIVE MORE days unable to move her arms. The entire middle section of this chapter is her doing NOTHING—sitting in silence, browsing a book, writing letters that go unanswered. And yet I could not STOP reading. How? By nesting revelations inside inaction. She can't play piano, so she reads about Seydel. She can't contact Astaire, so she discovers his note. She can't move forward in the plot, so the plot moves forward ON HER. The mother's revelation about the recommendation letter lands like a bomb because we've been coiled tight through days of forced pause. The structure is essentially: 1. Intimacy with Sio (emotional peak) 2. Withdrawal and illness (descent) 3. The Seydel biography (thematic echo chamber) 4. Astaire's note (inciting incident of the new act) 5. The mother's revelation (world-level escalation) Each section feeds the next. The Seydel story isn't filler—it's the thematic pressure cooker that makes the recommendation letter hit harder. When she reads 'He was only twenty-nine years old' and then immediately finds Astaire's note on the same page, the author is basically screaming at us: THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU DON'T STOP. The chapter ends mid-sentence essentially—her mother saying 'You can't disappoint...' and trailing off. No resolution. Just the promise of confrontation. The pacing here is masterful manipulation.
... Read More
Okay, let me just... process this. Sio Lieselotte. Eight years. EIGHT years of knowing him, of building this whole mental architecture around who he was, and apparently it was all a facade he maintained with terrifying precision. The most devastating moment isn't even the big dramatic one — it's when he's picking blades of grass out of her hair. After everything. After pressing her to the ground, after that horrifying confrontation, he's gently removing debris from her hair like none of it happened. And then he drapes his jacket over her shoulders. What is that? That's someone who loves her so much it's killing him, but who also believes he is fundamentally unlovable in his true form. And she — Danyu Astrid — I need to talk about what she did wrong because this is complicated. She says she loved him. But Sio calls her out and honestly? He's not entirely wrong. He says the Sio she loved was the one at the piano, the fantastical version, the perfect performance. Was she in love with HIM, or with the idea of him? That's a question that should make anyone uncomfortable. Then there's Astaire. The guy who literally waited for her, who held onto that hairpin like a religious artifact, who said "I will wait until you come to find me" with this incredible quiet devotion. And she takes the pin, says she'll come back, and then walks straight into Sio's arms again. Not that she had a choice in this scene, but the thematic weight is there. Sio's arc here is brutal. He went from someone composed enough to bow to an audience while his hands shook to someone so broken he couldn't even maintain the performance. The engagement to Ilse wasn't romantic — it was strategic. A workaround for class barriers. He treated his own life like a chessboard. And when the board collapsed, he had nothing left. What scares me most is that this isn't over. He's not redeemed. She's not forgiven. They're both sitting in wreckage and the novel seems determined to keep poking at it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or