I Decided to Forget Him - Reviews

I Decided to Forget Him
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
'You're welcome to listen to any other piece you like. But until the Jubilion, you are not to listen to this piece. No matter whose performance it is, don't listen to it.' The way Astaire speaks is just... distinct. He's playful one moment — offering her a reward for being a good girl, which immediately earns his own correction about not thinking of her as a child — and then completely serious the next. That tonal whiplash is the point. His dialogue carries weight precisely because he modulates it so deliberately. And the myth section? Completely different voice, almost scriptural, with those bracketed divine words '[We entrust our land to you. Let it flourish for all your days.]' that give it this ancient, liturgical quality. The contrast between the myth's formal cadence and Astaire's conversational sharpness creates this beautiful texture. Even Danyu's internal monologue has its own rhythm — short, punchy, increasingly desperate as she gets closer to the realization she doesn't want to hear. 'What on earth had I been working these hands so hard for.' That's not dialogue, that's the narrative voice breaking through, and it hits harder than any spoken line could.
... Read More
"You're calling me Sio again." That's it. That's the line. Three words and Sio's entire guarded posture cracks. Everything about his character has been built on formal distance—Mr. this, that, the respect he demands, the bet he keeps secret even from the person it concerns. And Danyu just... slips back into it like nothing happened. Like the illness, the piano, the confession about pouring her hidden self out onto the keys—it all led to this tiny, almost careless restoration of intimacy. The author writes Sio's response with such economy. He doesn't press. He doesn't gloat. He just *notices*. And then later, when she declares she'll win the Jubilion, he accepts it with 'complete ease.' No skepticism. No patronizing. Just: "If you've found your sound, then perhaps. But it won't be easy." Clear green eyes. Sincerity. That's Sio's voice—minimal, precise, devastatingly honest. He could've said anything. He chose the truth. And Danyu's voice here? She's all impulsivity. She opens her mouth to ask 'Could it be that the reason you never accepted me until now...' and then stops herself. 'Never mind. I'll ask later.' She doesn't want the answer right now. Why? Because she's still fragile. Because she needs to believe in herself before she hears whatever truth is waiting. The author lets her walk away from her own question—and honestly, that restraint is genius. Some questions are too heavy for the moment they're asked.
... Read More
I need to talk about the Seydel section because my hands are still shaking. This isn't just worldbuilding trivia—this is the single most important thematic mirror in the entire novel. Astaire literally HANDS her a book about a genius who sang the language of gods and then destroyed himself because no one understood him. Who is Seydel? A farmer's son. Ordinary origins. A boy who walked through fields murmuring music that made crops grow and hearts race—and then became so alienated by the very people his gift sustained that he cut off his own hand and eventually hanged himself at his piano at twenty-nine. 'Seydel had a handful of students. They awakened to sound, but in the end they never understood Seydel's language.' Danyu is reading this while bedridden, unable to play, wondering why Astaire withdrew from the Jubilion. She doesn't yet see the reflection. But I—DEAR GOD—I see it. She has found her sound. She is ready to stand in front of an audience. The temptation of the Jubilion is literally the temptation that killed Seydel: the desire for the gods' wisdom, for recognition, for connection through music that can never truly be reciprocated. Astaire knows this. That's WHY he gave her his spot. He's saying: go, win, but don't become what killed him. The irony that Seydel 'always surrounded by people' was 'genuinely alone' hits different when you realize Danyu's entire arc is about finding someone who actually hears her—not her technique, not her compliance, but the messy, passionate, cowardly, pathetic thing she buried inside.
... Read More
Can we talk about how Sio speaks in this passage? Because his dialogue is doing SO much heavy lifting and I want to unpack it. First, notice how Sio rarely gives straight answers. When she asks why he didn't tell her about his hands, he responds with "What would be left of me if music were gone?" He flips the question back. He deflects. This is a person who has spent years performing — not just on stage, but in conversation. Every exchange is calculated, even when it looks spontaneous. The most remarkable lines are the ones where he's actually being honest, because they're so rare they hit like physical blows: "I thought it wouldn't be so bad, being able to stay that beautiful in at least one person's world." That's not deflection. That's not performance. That's someone who has lowercased his own voice to almost nothing, and when it comes out, it's devastating. Compare that to Astaire's dialogue, which is spare but warm. "I will wait. Until you come to find me." Simple. Direct. No ornamentation. Astaire doesn't perform. He states. And the protagonist's dialogue — or rather, her lack of it — is telling. She can't form words in several key moments. "Not a single one of them remained." "She could not bring herself to open her mouth." Her voice fails her when it matters most, which is interesting because she's clearly the more verbal character elsewhere. Sio has the words but won't use them honestly; she has the honesty but can't find the words. They're mirror images in their communication breakdown. The narrative voice itself is fascinating too. It stays intimately close to the protagonist's perspective, filtering everything through her confusion and dawning horror. We don't get Sio's internal monologue — we only get his external behavior, which makes him feel almost unknowable. Is he manipulative? Is he genuinely broken? The narrative refuses to tell us, and that refusal is part of the voice's power. Also: "Have you lost your mind?" — that line. After everything, that's what she manages. Underwhelming? Maybe. But devastatingly human.
... Read More
'Your sound had always been directed toward Sio.' I mean — that line absolutely destroyed me. For so long, Danyu's entire motivation has been Sio Lieselotte. She wanted to be like him, to draw closer to him, her hands were working themselves raw trying to catch up to his level. And then Astaire just... shatters that. By playing the Tempest in a way she'd never heard before, he forces her to see that she's been performing someone else's music her whole life. The relationship between these three characters is devastatingly layered. Sio, who clearly knows more about the Jubilion than he's saying. Astaire, who's simultaneously Danyu's teacher, her opponent, and someone carrying his own hidden pain from university days when he nearly quit piano. And Danyu, at the center of it all, finally asking the question: 'Where is it?' — not asking about Sio, but about herself. That moment when she grabs his sleeve and pleads for her own sound, that's not a romantic gesture necessarily, it's something deeper. It's someone reaching out because for the first time she doesn't know who she is outside of her obsession with Sio.
... Read More
I am genuinely not okay with the lipstick scene. Let me just say that first. Astaire sees her in makeup for the first time, brushes his thumb across her lips, looks at the red on his fingers with this dazed expression — and then says 'It smeared. A shame, after going to the trouble of looking so nice.' Then he tidies the smeared edge himself. This man is playing 4D chess with her nervous system and he knows it. When he touches her face again, it overlaps with the memory of the day he kissed her, and her face flushes instantly. Astaire's reaction? A light laugh. He's enjoying this. Not in a mean way — in the way someone enjoys watching something beautiful unfold that they helped make possible. But the emotional core that absolutely wrecked me was the piano scene. Danyu plays the Pathétique — 'beautiful yet desolate' — and only after the final note does she realize she's crying. 'It was not I who had been absorbed into the music, but the music that had resonated within me.' That line. She spent eight years thinking her piano playing was about Sio, about reaching him, about resembling him. And in that moment of playing for herself, the music breaks her open because it's been holding all this grief she never let herself feel. Astaire notices again that she's crying even though he's not looking at her. He says 'I'll do my best to help you. So please don't cry.' And then he leaves without turning around because she asked him to pretend not to notice. That is such a tender, complicated moment between them. She told him to pretend, and he agreed. 'If you'd like, I'll play along, miss.' He's giving her exactly what she needs — space and dignity — while somehow still being the one who sees everything.
... Read More
I need to talk about the pond scene. Just... the pond scene. Because on the surface it reads as a violent confrontation, and maybe that's what Sio INTENDED — to hurt her the way he's hurting, to make her feel something real instead of that safe, curated version of love she'd been offering him. But underneath all that terror and confusion, there's something heartbreaking happening. When he asks her "What kind of person I am. What I was thinking. How is that possible if you loved me?" — he's not actually accusing her. He's accusing himself. He can't reconcile why someone would love him when he knows what he really is. The trembling hands, the illness, the degradation. He built this perfect image and now it's crumbling, and his first instinct isn't to beg for her to stay — it's to push her away by showing her exactly what she'd be rejecting. The worst line in the entire passage: "If I could, I wanted to remain that person to the end. I thought it wouldn't be so bad, being able to stay that beautiful in at least one person's world." That is a person who has already died inside. He's just waiting for his body to catch up. And her reaction! She covers her face. She can't bear to look at his trembling hand. She's been honest with herself — she DID love the performance, the music, the composed version of him. That realization cracks something open in her. She sits at the piano afterward and plays nothing. Meaningless notes drifting aimlessly. How do you play when the person you thought you knew doesn't exist anymore? The Astaire threads here are so tender by contrast. The hairpin exchange. His gentle touch of her hair. The kiss to the red strands, not her lips — he respects her too much to cross that line. He's waiting. After everything, he's still waiting. And she left the pin with him like a promise. But the central relationship — God, the central relationship is shattered and I don't know if it can be put back together. Or if it should be.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the pacing in these chapters is absolutely masterful and I'm still recovering. The chapter opens with chaos — a chair scraping, murmurs, Sio walking off mid-performance. Immediate disorientation. We're thrown into the same confusion as the protagonist, and that's intentional. The author doesn't give us answers right away. We get fragments: Sio's trembling hand, Astaire's calm explanation, the word "seizure" dropped like a bomb. Each piece of information hits harder because we have to assemble it ourselves. Then — and this is where the pacing does something brilliant — it suddenly SLOWS DOWN. Everything goes quiet. She's walking through trees, feeling grass against her bare skin, trying to compose herself before finding Sio. The reader breathes. The tension doesn't release; it compresses. Like a spring being wound tighter. And then the pond scene hits. And it's a complete tonal whiplash. One moment she's gathering composure, the next she's pinned to the ground, terrified, biting someone's shoulder. The author doesn't warn you. One second you're in a literary drama, the next you're in something raw and ugly and real. But then — AND THIS IS THE GENIUS PART — after the violence, after the confrontation, Sio just... becomes gentle again. Picking grass from her hair. Draping his jacket. Walking away into moonlight. The pacing shift here is almost surgical. It goes from chaotic to tender to silent in the span of paragraphs, and you can't predict which version of him you're going to get next. The ending of this section — four bells ringing, the winner announced, her sitting at a piano playing nothing — is devastating because it comes SO QUIETLY. All that tension, all that violence, and it ends with silence and meaningless notes. The author trusts the reader to sit with that discomfort. There's no filler. No padded scenes. Every paragraph either advances the plot or deepens the emotional damage. I turned these pages fast, but I also had to stop and reread things. That's good pacing.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—Astaire is a MENACE and I am HERE for it. The fact that he made a bet with Sio about Danyu without telling her?? And then drops the most devastating gesture of the entire arc by forfeiting his spot in the Jubilion and GIFTING it to her?? I literally threw my phone across the room. The man claims he 'no longer has any need to seek wisdom from the gods' which is such a soft way of saying something WAY more complicated. Did he lose faith in the system? Did he decide Danyu deserved it more? Or did he do it FOR her—quietly, without asking for credit, while she was sick in bed barely able to hold a spoon? And Sio. Oh, dear, wonderful Sio. The moment Danyu says 'You're calling me Sio again' and he catches it—that shift is EVERYTHING. Something inside her unlocked. She didn't even know it herself. The fact that she can play without fear now, that she's found her sound, and she tells him 'I'm going to win the Jubilion' like it's already happened... and he doesn't laugh. He says 'If you've found your sound, then perhaps.' That man could NOT be more proud without saying it out loud. But the real gut punch? Her mother IS on the judging panel. Danyu never once considered this. She looks at her mother with hollow eyes and the woman just smiles like 'don't look at me like that'—but you KNOW something is off. Her mother wanted this spot for Danyu AND claims it wasn't personal interest. Sure, Julie. Sure. The game is deeper than anyone admits.
... Read More
Okay so this whole bet Astaire sets up is genuinely the kind of plot twist that made me sit up straight. 'Miss Danyu. Would you like to make a wager with me?' — and then he dangles this entire mythology about the gods, the land of Seydel, the Jubilion festival happening every ten years where the chosen can ask the gods a single question. The worldbuilding here isn't just exposition for its own sake; it's literally the mechanism that drives Danyu's entire arc forward. And the stakes? Two months to prepare for a competition she has zero business entering against someone like Sio. But here's what got me: when Astaire reveals that Sio won't even be competing, my first thought was exactly what Danyu's probably thinking — WHAT DOES THAT MEAN. What happened to Sio? Why isn't he there? It's such a clean narrative pivot, going from 'you can't possibly win' to 'the real obstacle is me.' The plot keeps shifting the goalposts in a way that's genuinely exciting rather than frustrating, which says a lot.
... Read More
The stakes in these chapters are enormous and the author refuses to let anyone win cleanly. On the surface, the conflict is clear: Sio has a neurological condition destroying his ability to play, he entered the Jubilion hoping divine intervention might save him, he lost, and now he's facing a future without music. That's devastating enough. But the author keeps piling on additional layers of conflict until there's nowhere left to hide. Sio vs. himself is the deepest wound. He's fighting a body that's betraying him, and worse, he's fighting the knowledge that his entire identity was contingent on being a musician. "Nothing. Without music, I'm nothing." That's not drama — that's a person who has evaluated their own existence and found it wanting. Sio vs. the protagonist is equally destructive. She claims to love him. He claims she only loved a performance. Both might be right. The conflict here isn't solvable because it's not really about facts — it's about whether love can survive the removal of romance, beauty, and performance. Can you love someone who is nothing but themselves, stripped of everything that made them admirable? The protagonist's internal conflict is quietly devastating. She won the Jubilion. She should be celebrating. Instead, she's sitting at a piano producing nothing. Her victory is hollow because the cost was Sio's dignity, his trust, maybe his sanity. What does it mean to win when the person you wanted to share it with has been destroyed? Astaire's conflict is the most restrained but possibly the most painful. He waited. He was told to wait. He holds a hairpin and believes a promise. And yet the person he's waiting for walked away toward someone else. His conflict isn't loud — it's the quiet conflict of someone who loves faithfully in a story that doesn't reward faithfulness. And the societal conflict — class barriers, the artificiality of the Jubilion, the way the system forces people like Sio to degrade themselves just to participate — this isn't resolved either. The system wins. Sio loses. The protagonist wins by accident of the rules. Nobody is free. The tension never releases. It transforms. From external drama to internal silence. From public performance to private suffering. From noise to meaningless piano keys. And that's what makes these chapters so devastating — the stakes keep rising even as the characters disappear into themselves.
... Read More
Okay, let me just say this straight: Sio Lieselotte is a cruel man and I hate him for it. Not because he rejected Danyu—fair enough, you can't force feelings—but because he never once thought to tell her about his engagement. Eight years. Eight years of her loving him in silence, of her showing up to salons hoping to catch a glimpse of him, of her pacing in front of doors trying to work up the courage to tell him how she felt. And he just... never said anything. Never thought it mattered. "I simply didn't think it was something you needed to know. And it wasn't." That line. That absolutely devastating line delivered with such casual certainty. He genuinely couldn't understand why this hurt her. To him, her feelings were background noise, something that didn't warrant a conversation. But here's what made me reconsider—maybe a little—when he actually smiled and said Astaire was good for her, that he'd recommended him specifically because he thought Astaire would get her back behind the piano. He wasn't trying to hurt her. He was just... so fundamentally unable to grasp what she needed from him. Kindness as cruelty. That's the tragedy right there. And Astaire? The man who immediately read her distress when she walked past him at the piano. Who knew her face better than anyone. Who asked "Do you truly want to be free of Sio?" with this look in his eyes that suggested he already knew the answer and was offering her an out. There's something dangerous and tender about him that I can't quite name yet.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or