I Decided to Forget Him - Reviews

I Decided to Forget Him
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's this one image that won't leave me: Danyu sitting at the piano after weeks of recovery, her mother running in panicking every time she sits down. The piano has become a trigger—not just for music, but for fear. For illness. For the moment everything changed. And then the mother offers her a book instead. 'Astaire left this for you to have.' The detail that he 'came while you were ill' and 'just dropped off the book and left'—it paints a picture of a man who knows exactly when to appear and when to vanish. The book itself is physical weight: 'The weight of the book in her hand felt oddly burdensome.' Not light. Not trivial. Heavy. The world-building around the Jubilion is slowly accumulating terror. It's not just a music competition. It's a sacred occasion where winners can 'seek wisdom from the gods'—who 'knew everything.' The premise itself is mythological. This is a world where music isn't entertainment; it's a conduit to divine power. Which makes Seydel's story even more horrifying in context: a man who could channel the gods directly, and the gods abandoned him. The author never explains the mechanics of this world outright. We learn through implication—the wax-sealed letter with no postmark, the judging panel's ability to grant exemptions, the mother's casual authority. Every detail whispers that this kingdom runs on invisible hierarchies and unspoken rules, and Danyu is about to crash through all of them.
... Read More
The storeroom scene. I need to write about this because it's one of those moments that just... lingers. After Danyu escapes the salon, Astaire leads her to this small space with sunlight pouring through a large window. Dust-covered table, things piled up that nobody uses anymore. He spreads his coat over it like some kind of makeshift chair for her. And when he opens the window, the wind kicks up the dust and it looks like snowflakes. "It looks like snowflakes but it isn't cold, and it can't be caught." She reached out to touch them and they scattered through her fingers. A tired laugh escaped her. This is the most perfect metaphor I've ever encountered in fiction and I don't even know if that's intentional or just how good this author is at showing rather than telling. The whole scene feels like a pressure valve releasing. The salon was loud—people debating in front of paintings, champagne glasses clinking, Winkler racing through piano pieces with aggressive速度. Then suddenly: quiet. Sunlight. Dust. Just the two of them in this forgotten room where nothing matters except what's happening between them. And the visual of dust catching light like snow—that's the kind of image that stays with you. It transforms an ugly storage closet into something almost sacred. The place where she finally falls apart. Where Astaire's shirt gets soaked with her tears and he doesn't even care.
... Read More
Okay let's talk about Sio because WHAT is he doing here. The man is ENGAGED but he still makes Danyu potato soup like nothing happened. Like bro, you can't just casually feed someone who broke down crying at your piano and then act like it's totally normal. That's not normal that's romantic poisoning and I love it. But the real chaos is Astaire. He takes care of her for THREE DAYS apparently while she locks herself in the salon and plays until her hands give out, and then the SECOND Sio shows up, he's gone. Just leaves. And he kisses her hand like it's a farewell. Like he knows he's been replaced in her emotional hierarchy. I kept waiting for him to say something bitter or jealous but he just... accepts it? Says "even though it may have been what I intended" which is the most Astaire way to handle having his heart basically broken without making it dramatic. And Danyu?? She doesn't even try to stop him from leaving. She reaches out and her hand just... slips. Because her hands are destroyed from playing for three days straight. Which is honestly the most heartbreaking detail. She physically couldn't hold onto him even if she wanted to. The triangular tension here is NOT subtle but it works because every interaction reveals something new. Sio feeding her soup = childhood intimacy resurfacing. Astaire leaving = he's done competing with a ghost. Danyu caught between them both = still figuring out who she is outside of loving Sio. Also side note: Sio saying "There may be mistakes" before playing is peak humble-brag energy from someone who literally pursues perfection. He's setting expectations so low they're underground and we all know he's about to absolutely devastate her with his playing.
... Read More
Astaire's dialogue is a masterclass in what characters choose NOT to say directly. Watch how he reveals his intentions through layers: 'I had ulterior motives for choosing that particular method.' Then a beat. Then: 'You thought of me as a child. If you hadn't, you wouldn't have kissed me like that.' He could have just said 'I wanted you to see me differently.' But instead he makes her say the thing she was afraid to admit, and then he corrects her assumption about what that thing means. This is a man who speaks in revelations, not statements. Danyu's voice is noticeably different — more straightforward, more literal. 'I'm not crying.' 'You got one thing right.' 'Your method had no effect at all.' She's a person who says exactly what she means, which is why Astaire finds her 'endearing' when she can't tell a lie. Their dialogue styles create a push-pull rhythm: she's direct, he's layered; she's honest to a fault, he's strategic with his words. The most remarkable dialogue moment is the entire handkerchief exchange. It's not words — it's action as dialogue. He leaves without looking. The handkerchief remains. She doesn't acknowledge it directly but the narrative gives it its own paragraph. That's storytelling through silence. And Astaire's declaration — 'I have never thought of you as a child. The reason I kissed you that day was because I saw you as a woman' — is blunt to the point of almost being crude. But it lands because Danyu is someone who 'had no talent for reading between the lines.' He meets her where she is. That's not just good dialogue; that's character-driven communication.
... Read More
The structural choice to open with Astaire mimicking Sio's sound is brilliant framing. It immediately establishes the central tension — Danyu's voice vs. Sio's shadow — and then the narrative folds backward into the examination memory before coming present. The flashback doesn't feel tacked on; it's the emotional key that unlocks why Danyu is in this position at all. What's striking is how the pacing mirrors Danyu's internal process. The long scene in the salon moves at a deliberate, almost meditative pace — she plays, she cries, she speaks, Astaire responds, he leaves. It's unhurried because Danyu is unlearning eight years of fixation. Then Astaire abruptly changes the tempo: 'Let's get ready to go out.' The lesson isn't over, the piece isn't learned, but he's prioritizing something else entirely. 'What Miss Danyu needs first is a wider range of experiences.' This is the author telling us through structure that Danyu's healing won't happen at the piano — it happens in the world. The maid scene provides necessary comic relief but also functions as a rhythm break. It's funny, yes, but it also signals that Danyu's whole life has been so insular that even changing clothes feels like a plot event. 'How had it come to this?' she asks herself, and the answer is: eight years of her life shrinking down to one person. The destination — Madame Frida's salon — is a perfect chapter cliffhanger of sorts. Not an action cliffhanger, but a social one. We know from the text that Madame Frida mentioned Sio's name and caught Danyu's discomfort. The chapter ends there, and we're left wondering what happens when Danyu enters a room full of people who know her only as 'Sio's student.' The pacing builds toward that moment of exposure beautifully.
... Read More
Okay, can we talk about how Sio Lieselotte is literally everywhere in this text even though he barely appears? He's the ghost haunting every interaction between Danyu and Astaire. The way Danyu learned piano by ear solely from watching Sio play — that's not just a musical choice, that's code for how she experienced everything. She didn't learn music, she learned Sio. And Astaire immediately sees it. He says learning by ear from someone else before developing your own interpretation means you end up following that person without realizing it. That hit different, honestly. But the real moment for me was when Astaire touches her hair without thinking and then carefully lifts her frozen hand away. That's not the move of a man who sees her as a child or as Sio's shadow. He's flustered too, just in a quieter way. Sio's whole presence in this section is defined by absence and damage — 'used to,' Danyu thinks, 'something now lost.' That one word 'used to' does so much work. Sio lost something, maybe his sound, maybe himself, and Danyu spent eight years trying to become him just to understand him. And then Madame Frida saying 'Lieselotte' under her breath and catching Danyu's discomfort — these people are keeping score, you know? Danyu is known as Sio's longest student, the one who didn't become a lover, the one with no official activities. There's a whole social world here judging her by association, and Astaire seems to be the first person who actually wants her to exist outside of that definition.
... Read More
Let me just lay out the stakes because this is getting INSANE. Danyu has never performed in front of an audience. She's barely recovered from an illness that left her arms useless for FIVE DAYS. She has no objective assessment of her abilities, no maturity, no reputation. And somehow—somehow—she's been handed the golden ticket to the Jubilion through Astaire's sacrifice. The judging panel approved it. Her own MOTHER sat on that panel and 'believed she was qualified.' Okay but also—WHAT? The mother's explanation is so polished, so rational. 'Personal interest has no place in it.' Right. Because giving your daughter a competitive advantage through your professional connections is totally neutral behavior. Don't even get me started. Meanwhile Astaire has withdrawn. Won't compete. Will come to WATCH. This means Danyu is stepping into a arena where her rival—the guy who made a bet with Sio about whether she'd ever amount to anything—is now literally in the audience, observing, waiting. And Sio? He's going to be there too. He told her 'I have something I want to say when the Jubilion is over.' SOMETHING. Not nothing. Not casual. He is bracing himself to confess whatever he's been hiding, and the tension of that waiting is making my teeth ache. The Jubilion winner seeks wisdom from the gods. Astaire gave up his turn saying he 'no longer has any need.' What does that mean? What did he ask before? And what happens when Danyu stands where he stood and realizes the gods don't answer the way she expects?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or