I Am This Type of Woman - Reviews

I Am This Type of Woman
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me talk about the conflict and stakes in these chapters because honestly, there's a lot more tension underneath the surface than you might think at first. On the surface, it's a romantic comedy about a marquis who finds buried treasure and a spirited young woman who maybe accidentally tried to steal it. But the underlying conflicts are real. Rong Xia's conflict: He's a man of principle (leaving the gold, apologizing for his guards' intrusion) but he's clearly interested in Ban Hua. The stakes here are emotional—what happens when a man of his station shows genuine interest in a woman whose engagement was withdrawn under mysterious circumstances? He has to navigate his honor against his desire, and the text hints that this might not be easy. Ban Hua's conflict: Her engagement was withdrawn. Why? What happened? She's living with this secret, dealing with her family's reactions, and now this attractive marquis is showing interest. The stakes are enormous—her social standing, her future, her sense of self. When she says 'I don't want to be [a general], I want to live comfortably'—that's not just flippancy, that's someone who's been forced into situations she didn't choose and is now asserting control over what she wants. The Ban siblings' conflict: They buried that gold and clearly needed it. Ban Heng calling himself a 'wastrel' isn't just self-deprecation—it's a survival mechanism. They're in financial or social trouble, and the loss of that treasure (or at least the loss of their claim to it) has real consequences. Ban Huai's worry about 'Count Cheng'an knowing this' suggests there's a bigger power dynamic at play. And then there's the looming Shi family conflict. That ending with 'Thinking of Shi Feixian's secret admiration'—this is the kind of setup that means three people's hearts are about to get complicated. The stakes just got a lot higher. What makes this work so well is that none of these conflicts are abstract. Every character has something tangible to lose, and the author makes you care about each one.
... Read More
'Xie Qilin looked slightly awkward, he turned and got off the horse to bow towards Ban Hua.' This novel is obsessed with how people greet each other. And I mean that in the best possible way. Every bow, every salute, every clasped fist tells you everything about power dynamics, relationships, and social position. The translator even included a whole note about different forms of Chinese salutations — dunshou, jishou, baoquan, shiyi, lianren li, wanfu li. Six different ways to show respect, and each one means something different. Ban Heng and Ban Hua 'saluted Changqing-wang' formally, but Ban Hua winks at Rong Xia privately. The physical performance of respect versus genuine human connection — that's the whole novel right there. The Grand Princess's residence being 'cleaned up in and out several times' with stewards still unsatisfied, every corner inspected 'not even a bug was spared' — this is a world where appearances are armor. Where the smallest detail (a bruise visible only because Ban Hua's skin is pale) can tell the whole story. And autumn. Fans in autumn. Ban Hua calling it ridiculous: 'Playing with fans in the middle of an autumn, do you think you'd look elegant, or look silly?' The season itself feels like a costume the nobles are wearing, and only Ban Hua sees through it.
... Read More
So Yun-niang's backstory hits different than you'd expect. On the surface it's just a throwaway subplot — this girl got eloped with, got abandoned, wandered all the way to the Capital looking for answers. But the way the author structures this is genuinely clever. Yun-niang functions as a dark mirror for Ban Hua. Both women were involved with men connected to the same family, both got tangled up in something that could've destroyed their futures. The key difference? Ban Hua's 'mistake' somehow elevated her instead of ruining her. Fule Junzhu caught Yun-niang and threw her a hundred liangs; she caught Ban Hua and made her a Junzhu. That parallel isn't accidental — it's the author quietly showing us that in this world, a woman's fate depends less on what she does and more on who catches her doing it. The birthday party scene then explodes this whole personal drama into something much bigger. Just when you think we're settling into an intimate character study, BAM — the Crown Prince arrives and suddenly every interaction is weighted with political meaning. Ban Heng coaxing the Crown Prince into laughing is not a side detail, folks. It's the author telling us exactly where the power flows in this world. The plot is layering personal stakes on top of political stakes on top of romantic tension, and it's doing it so smoothly you barely notice. But here's what keeps me wondering: Yun-niang went to the Capital asking 'was I worth anything to him?' The book seems to be asking the same question about Ban Hua — but from the outside, surrounded by admirers and protection, does she even get to ask herself that yet? Or is she already too deep in someone else's design?
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Xie Qilin because THIS MAN is devastating and I keep coming back to him. He's got a silver mask covering his ruined eye and he carries himself like some elegant nobleman in public, but the second we get inside his head it's just... grief. Pure grief. The line that wrecked me was when he thinks about how the world of a one-eye man has 'shrunk, dimmed and narrow.' That's not a physical description, that's a psychological one. He's grieving a version of himself that no longer exists. And his whole engagement situation with Ban Hua? I get it. He heard rumors, he was young and prideful, and he chose the most self-destructive way to reject her — eloping with a courtesan just to make a point, just to prove he wasn't going to bow down. Classic reactive anger dressed up as defiance. But then he realized HE CHOSE THE WRONG WAY to do it, and by then the damage was done. Now he can't even look her in the face. The moment she says 'It's better to not have met. I am not in a good mood whenever I see you' and just rides off? That's not just Ban Hua being sharp — that's someone who's also been hurt, who's also moved on in her own way, and who doesn't owe him the softness he's probably hoping for. Brutal. And then there's Shi Feixian, who just looks at him with this 'guilty and complicated' expression and can't even finish her apology. What did she do? What DOESN'T she say? I'm not ready for this.
... Read More
Let me walk through how the author builds this entire street encounter scene because the pacing is genuinely impressive. We start with political context — the Second Prince did something bold before the Grand Princess's birthday. That's the inciting incident that drops us into the chapter already in motion. Then we cut to Xie Wanyu's interior worry, which gives us emotional grounding and character history without any exposition dump. Good. Efficient. Then Xie Qilin's internal monologue — FOUR YEARS of backstory compressed into about four paragraphs. The engagement, the rumors, the elopement, the regret. All of it flows naturally from his sister's mention of Ban Hua rather than feeling inserted. The author trusts the reader to connect dots. Then we CUT to the street scene and it immediately hits high energy: Shi Feixian's carriage, the guilty look, Ban Heng appearing out of nowhere with his mockery, the escalation, the crowd reaction, Ban Hua's entrance, and then the exit. Each beat raises the temperature. Ban Heng vs Xie Qilin is simmering, then flares, then Ban Hua shuts it down with three sentences and rides off. But the final beat — Xie Qilin telling Shi Feixian he's let go of the past, walking away alone, and her sitting frozen in her carriage — that's the emotional landing. The political drama evaporates and we're left with two people who can't quite articulate what happened between them. Then the chapter cuts to 'On the first floor of a teahouse down the street, Changqing-wang said to the person beside him...' and just... stops. We're given zero resolution for the political thread and dropped into a new scene mid-conversation. Classic serial fiction hook. I am not ready.
... Read More
Okay so I have to talk about this moment where Ban Heng just randomly decides to start practicing martial arts. Like, one day he's out complaining about fans and being an idle noble, and the next he's like 'Sis, please train me.' And Ban Hua is just... what happened to you? What changed? I think it was the scene with the butcher. The way the narrative juxtaposes that domestic violence scene right before Ban Heng's declaration — a man beating his wife and child while the shop manager tries to brush it aside because she couldn't bear a son. Ban Heng watches all of this, and something clicks in him. He's not stupid. He understands power and consequence now. 'This is an interesting drama,' Rong Xia says earlier in the chapter, sipping his tea like nothing matters. But nothing is nothing, is it? Everything is connected. The abuse, the family dynamics at the Grand Princess's, the gift-giving, the social climbing — it's all one web. And Ban Hua's little blackmail scheme with Ban Heng's silver? 'If you keep it yourself then don't ever come to me for money again.' That's not just sibling teasing. That's Ban Hua teaching him a lesson without him even realizing it's a lesson. She's preparing him for the world, whether he knows it or not.
... Read More
The way Ban Hua and Kangning interact in this passage is actually terrifying when you think about it. Both are Junzhus. Both arrive at the same gate in nearly identical carriages. But the moment they step out, everything changes. Ban Hua doesn't even wait for the Shi servants to properly greet Kangning — she just tells her own maids to toss some broken silver to the Gate guards and walks in supported by her attendants. She doesn't perform kindness. She doesn't pretend to be humble. She's too lazy to put on a show, as the narration literally says. And the Shi servants, who were just happily stuffing silver into their purses, turn around and see Kangning and immediately panic. They rush to her with false warmth and call her Junzhu with appropriate reverence. Kangning's response is this slight smile — just a slight smile — and she says "I have been here several times, you don't need to show the way, I will go in myself." Polite. Composed. Perfectly calibrated to seem gracious while actually establishing that she doesn't need anyone's help navigating her own social terrain. She's telling those servants she knows exactly what they just did for Ban Hua and she's not impressed by their表演. Meanwhile Ban Hua watches all of this from inside. "She watched Shi family people crowding around Ban Hua with an indifferent gaze without any remarkable expression on her face." This is the key moment. Kangning is observing, calculating, filing everything away. She's not competing with Ban Hua in this scene — she's studying her. And I have a feeling this is the beginning of something. These two women are clearly intelligent, powerful, and accustomed to getting what they want. Their dynamic is going to be fascinating to watch unfold.
... Read More
Okay, can we talk about Ban Heng? I love him. He throws that cup down and goes full dragon-mode over his sister. "Whoever my sister doesn't like, I won't have her marry." That's the stuff. It shows exactly how he views his role—he's the wall between Hua and the world's expectations. But then he immediately crumbles when she tells him to wipe his hand and be gentler with the cup. The dynamic is everything. He's all thunder but he's also a softie for her. And Zhou Changxiao, bless his heart, just scrolling through the chat trying to keep the peace while internally screaming about Count Rongxia. Meanwhile, Rong Xia is over here being annoyingly composed. He notices everything. When Ban Hua says unimportant things don't trouble her, he feels this "light, not painful, an indescribable feeling of sourness and numbness." That's not nothing. That's a crack in the armor. He's paying attention to her apathy because he cares, or he's hurt by it, or both. And Yin-shi? She's the steady hand. She refuses the match with grace but firmness, sending back the gifts while keeping the diplomatic door ajar for the banquet. It's a masterclass in family politics. Everyone is playing their part, but the emotional undercurrents are where the real story lives.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is deceptively simple on the surface but when you actually break down what's being said versus what's meant, it's brilliant. Let me start with Ban Hua's voice because honestly she's the most fun character to read in terms of dialogue. Her lines are short, direct, and completely unfiltered: "Stop." "I am enjoying the view." "Master is very interesting." She says exactly what she means and the reader loves her for it. Compare that to everyone else who is layering subtext onto every single word. Shi Feixian's greeting to Rong Xia and Ban Hua is textbook fake politeness—"what a coincidence" but her actual expression reads more like "what is this nuisance doing here." The narrator even points this out. And her line to her brother later: she wants to say she dislikes Ban Hua so there'd be no contact, but she swallows it because "afraid elder brother would think she was rude." So much for honesty. Then there's Ban Hua and Ban Heng's exchange about money, which is just pure comedic relief. His bashful laugh when caught asking for money again, her immediate roasting him—this is the kind of sibling banter that makes you go "aww" even while laughing. Rong Xia's dialogue is the most interesting because it's so controlled. Everything he says is perfectly polite, perfectly measured. "Junzhu is jesting with this Rong person?" "Let's go." Not a single slip, not a single raw emotion. But Ban Hua catches it—she sees the gap between his gentle smile and the fact that he doesn't even register Shi Feixian as worth looking at twice.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this absolute comedy of errors unfolding on that haunted mountain. The Ban family—specifically Ban Hua, this absolutely brilliant sister—decides the best place to stash their family's hidden wealth is literally the one mountain everyone avoids because of supernatural rumors. And she's not even being ironic! She's dead serious about 'a crafty rabbit and three caves,' right? While her brother is cowering behind her asking if there's really something unclean here, she's out there methodically burying boxes of gold and gems like she's landscaping a garden. But here's where it gets delicious. Rong Xia and his subordinate Du Jiu are ALREADY on that mountain, presumably waiting to ambush or intercept the Ban family's treasure movements, and they get walked in on. Ban Hua literally threatens them with a hoe while they're just trying to explain themselves. And Du Jiu—poor Du Jiu—is over here having a full existential crisis trying to process what he's witnessing. His lines about 'Jingting Mansion people are too idle?!' had me absolutely losing it. The plot structure here is doing some serious double duty. On the surface it's a treasure-burial scene with comedic family dynamics, but underneath you've got Rong Xia's shadowy operation, the political positioning of Ban Hua as 'Junzhu,' and the genuine tension of two powerful factions accidentally colliding in a haunted forest at nightfall. The author sets up this perfect pressure cooker atmosphere—darkening woods, strange bird sounds, Ban Heng's nerves—and then immediately undercuts it with Ban Hua scolding her brother about his drawing skills. It's brilliant misdirection.
... Read More
'National affairs are for the national pillars to worry about. We have already contributed to the great cause by not dragging them down.' Ban Heng, you absolute unit. I cannot stop thinking about this line. It's delivered with such self-righteous pride, like he's actually proud of his contribution to society. Which is absolutely nothing. This is the kind of dialogue that makes a character instantly lovable — flawed, ridiculous, but somehow charming in his incompetence. And then Ban Hua shoots him a glance and he immediately stops talking. The unspoken communication between these siblings is everything. They don't need to explain themselves to each other. 'Rong Xia couldn't help but showed a slight smile on his face' when Ban Hua winks at him. That's it. That's the whole romance in three words. No dramatic confessions, no tortured longing. Just a wink and a smile across a shop entrance. The Grand Princess saying 'I don't know who in the future can stand your temper' while simultaneously spoiling Ban Hua rotten? Perfect. She's both worried and proud, and the author never forces her to choose one emotion over the other.
... Read More
I need to talk about how good the dialogue is in these chapters because wow. Ban Hua's voice is immediately distinctive. When she says 'Life is only a few short years, so just do whatever is joyful' and then 'Who knows which day that your eyes won't open anymore'—this is a woman who lives fully and doesn't care who knows it. Her dialogue feels so natural and unforced, like someone actually talking rather than characters saying things the author needs them to say. Every line feels like it comes from a real place. And the contrast with Rong Xia is perfect. His dialogue is more measured, more deliberate. When he says 'Buddhism is particular about karma. The good action that you planted today may bear fruits by helping other people tomorrow, so it is certainly a noble pursuit'—he's basically turning her accidental theft into a philosophical masterpiece. That's the kind of sharp wit that makes him endlessly readable. Ban Heng's dialogue is minimal but perfect. 'Sister, you used my name to lie again' and then later just doing the whole 'didn't understand, didn't see' routine? He's the comic relief but he's also genuinely scared of his sister's pitiful eyes. The sibling dynamic writes itself. Du Jiu's internal observations are a gift. The author never has him speak much but his inner monologue—thinking about how 'the lucky man who could marry such a lovable woman should be willing to serve her primping herself in front of the mirror everyday' and being confused about why her engagement was withdrawn—adds so much texture. He's the grounded observer who makes the world feel real. The rhythm of conversation between Ban Hua and Rong Xia is especially well done. You can feel the push and pull—the flirtation that neither of them is quite admitting to, the comedy of errors around the recipe, the underlying current of genuine curiosity. Their voices bounce off each other perfectly.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or