I Am This Type of Woman - Reviews

I Am This Type of Woman
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Oh my god. The way Ban Hua keeps glancing toward Rong Xia while Yan Zhen is desperately professing his love? I felt my heart squeeze. It's not even about choosing between them yet—it's about the *awareness* that someone else is watching, caring, present. And that poem! ‘Ay, and a gifted prince have we. Polished, as by the knife and file.' She pulls it out of nowhere just by looking at him. That's not random; that's her mind betraying how she sees him. Meanwhile, Rong Xia just stands there, hands behind his back, eyes locked on her peacock‑tail skirt, half in a trance. He doesn't interrupt. He doesn't swoop in. He gives Yan Zhen space. What kind of man does that? And Ban Hua's little laugh when she catches his gaze from the pavilion—she knows he's there, she enjoys the fact, but she doesn't acknowledge it openly. The tension is thick enough to cut. I'm not sure who she's more interested in reading: Yan Zhen's clumsy confession or Rong Xia's silent devotion. Or maybe… both?
... Read More
I have never laughed so hard at a rejection scene in my entire life. Ban Hua is literally getting ready to turn down Yan Zhen's marriage proposal and her brother Ban Heng is sitting behind her playing with pearls going something like "can't you make yourself look uglier so he gives up easier?" And Ban Hua's response is basically "no, I'm going to look absolutely devastating because why would I ruin my appearance for someone I can't even remember." She puts on this gorgeous dress, applies lip rouge carefully, wipes her fingers clean with a handkerchief like a proper lady — and then casually drops the line about how a woman's best years are more precious than gold and this guy isn't worth wasting any of it on. I was screaming. This is the most Ban Hua thing ever. She's not trying to be unattractive to discourage him. She's going to look incredible while rejecting him, and that is honestly the ultimate power move. But the real plot brilliance here is how the author uses the two carriage scenes to show us Ban Hua's actual position in this world without needing any exposition dump. When she arrives at the Shi family, the narrative takes this little detour to describe her carriage — six fine horses, gemstone inlaid walls, cushions softer than anything normal — all provided by the Department of the Palace because they're terrified she'll be unsatisfied. And then Kangning's carriage arrives and even though it's technically similar, everyone can tell immediately which Junzhu is more favored. The servants practically tremble when they see Ban Hua. Why? Because she's the one who publicly whipped a Tanhua on the street and got him demoted while she got promoted. That single detail tells us everything about her reputation and social position. The plot doesn't need to stop and explain — it just shows us through these small, vivid moments.
... Read More
There are some really rich thematic layers in these chapters that I think deserve attention. The central symbol is obviously the buried gold itself. It's described as something that 'the destined person' would find, but Rong Xia essentially decides that destiny isn't about ownership—it's about recognition and respect. He recognizes the Ban family's claim (even though they didn't technically have it since they lost it) and chooses to leave it. This ties directly into the Buddhist theme of karma that he verbally expresses: 'Good actions bear good fruits, good intention has good rewards.' But here's the thing—the author seems to be questioning whether karma works the way we expect it to. The Bans buried this gold and their 'destiny' with it seems to be falling apart (the withdrawn engagement, the secrecy), while Rong Xia, the one who practices detached observation of karma, is the one who stumbles upon it and handles it with grace. Then there's the fog. So much fog in these chapters—'thick fog enveloped the whole place,' people riding through it, sunlight finally breaking through. The fog feels like a metaphor for the characters' situations. Ban Hua is hidden behind a disguise or at least behind social expectations of what a young woman should be. Rong Xia is navigating between his duties and his genuine interests. The Ban siblings are obscured by secrets about their past. Only when 'the sun finally broke through the fog' do things start to become clearer—and even then, the Shi family carriage appears, which means more complications ahead. The fox fur as a gift is interesting too. White fox fur, described as something Ban Hua 'likes'—it's a traditional romantic gesture in Chinese literature, but the author subverts it by having Ban Hua misinterpret it as a business transaction for a recipe. The fur itself symbolizes warmth, luxury, and yes, romantic interest—but it's filtered through Ban Hua's practical, no-nonsense personality. And that Buddhist quote at the end—'All beings are suffering, they can only rely on themselves'—ties everything together thematically. Each character is on their own path, trying to navigate their circumstances with whatever wisdom they have.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the footnote about 雨前龙井 vs 御前龙井 — two words that sound identical but mean completely different things. One is pre-rain tea, a seasonal quality marker. The other is imperial-palace tea, a status marker. This is the entire novel in a nutshell, isn't it? Everything in this world is about who gets to define what something means. Ban Hua is literally treated like one of the family — the Emperor calls her "family" and gives her tribute from a vassal state — but she's also a subject, a daughter of a marquis, a woman in a space where power is calculated in inches. The Second Prince tries to reduce her to her failed engagements, to the rumors, to gossip. She flips it by making his own violence become evidence against him. And the father-daughter exchange about archery? That's about legacy — what gets passed down, what gets lost, what counts as strength. Ban Huai's self-mockery hides the fact that he's preserving his daughter's reputation while protecting his own. The whole scene is a negotiation of identity in a world that keeps trying to assign it for you.
... Read More
This whole scene with Yan Zhen is giving me whiplash. On one hand, he's earnest—so painfully earnest. He literally stalks Ban Hua to propose, promising a lifetime of devotion with zero concubines. That's either incredibly brave or catastrophically naive. And Ban Hua's inner voice? Brutal. She calls him ‘proof of studying too much and become dumber' and honestly? I'm cackling. But then she flips the script by asking about his mother. Suddenly it's not about romance—it's about power dynamics, family approval, and survival in a patriarchal system. Yan Zhen just can't wrap his head around conflict between wife and mother. He's so sheltered he probably thinks this is the first time such a thing has ever existed. Meanwhile, Ban Hua is over here plotting real‑life scenarios. Who's really the more mature one here? And what happens when he discovers his idealized version of her isn't the full picture?
... Read More
'Carrying so much money at such a young age, don't learn bad things.' — Ban Hua, stealing her brother's silver like it's a moral lesson. I love their relationship so much. It's not sweet in a traditional way. Ban Hua takes Ban Heng's money, calls him an idiot for keeping it, and then immediately buys him the fan he wanted anyway. The cycle is: take his money, give him the thing he asked for, make him feel terrible about the transaction. And he goes along with it every time because he trusts her completely. When Ban Heng says he wants to practice martial arts, Ban Hua just pats his shoulder and says 'En en. Fine, go back and practise.' No grand speech. No 'I believe in you.' Just a pat and an acknowledgment. That's how she shows she cares. And the Grand Princess? 'You this girl, you really won't let anyone push you around even just a little.' She says it with affection, not frustration. She raised her own grandchildren to be soft and useless, and she loves Ban Hua precisely because she isn't soft. But it's the small things that get me. Ban Heng covering his chest to protect the silver the Grand Princess just gave him. The way he turns away 'to avoid looking at the silver that had just failed to be his.' He's hurt but he won't show it. That's sibling love.
... Read More
I have to talk about the pacing in these chapters because the transition from the Ban villa to the foggy road is handled so well. Chapter 4 starts with Rong Xia handling the gold situation—brief, efficient, establishing his character in maybe two pages. Then we cut to the Ban family in their villa, which gives us the comedy relief and backstory about Ban Hua's 'noble pursuit' being a joke. This chapter ends with them deciding to go home. Clean. Chapter 5 opens with the fog. The atmosphere shifts immediately—you can feel the thickness of it just from the prose. The pacing slows down here intentionally. They're riding through fog, encountering Du Jiu, meeting Rong Xia, having this whole conversation. Each beat lands because the author gives it room to breathe. No rushing. The encounter itself is paced like a dance. Du Jiu greets them first—formal, respectful. Then Rong Xia appears from the fog like a vision. Their eyes meet. The polite exchanges. The apology that isn't really an apology. The philosophical deflection. The fox fur offer. The recipe misunderstanding. Ban Heng's conspiracy theory about Rong Xia liking his sister. Ban Huai's denial. The archery conversation. The life philosophy. All of it flows naturally because each moment earns the next. And then—bam—'The city gate is there' and immediately the Shi family carriage appears. The pacing accelerates right at the end to deliver the hook. The author knows exactly when to slow down for character moments and when to speed things up for plot momentum. The only section that felt slightly rushed to me was the opening of Chapter 4 with the gold discovery, but that's maybe two paragraphs and it serves its purpose efficiently. Overall, the pacing here is excellent.
... Read More
The description of the Grand Princess Dening's birthday preparations is SO rich. I could literally see it. The stewards running through guest lists with astrological filters—people with bad bazi shouldn't come near, faces that aren't celebratory enough get rejected, negative speakers excluded. One by one, filtered out. This isn't just a party planning scene; this is a masterclass in showing how power operates through exclusion. And the Ban family's approach to spending! Ban Huai casually says 'if we run out of good tea I will go to the Emperor to ask.' Twelve liangs of yuqianlongjing tea—which by the way is a delicious pun, homophonous with both 'rain-before longjing' and 'imperial longjing'—and Yin-shi notes it down like it's completely normal. The fact that she says 'it's still better that I didn't ask him for one jin' is the kind of dry humor that paints the whole household's personality in one sentence. The pastry scene is another worldbuilding gem. Yuqianlongjing tea brewed with dust-free snow water, rose honey seasoning, kneading utensils specially made, steamer woven from newly grown xiangfei bamboo, steaming water needing half a spoon of flower morning dew, and a piece of burnt sandalwood when removed from the stove. This is a recipe that wastes money on purpose. The kitchen steward literally thinks the recipe's author has ulterior motives to bring the Master down. Every detail screams: this world is opulent, complicated, and full of people who know exactly how to signal their status through seemingly mundane choices. The Bans don't just have wealth—they have the cultural fluency to wield it.
... Read More
Honestly, the pacing in these chapters is so deliberate it almost feels like a tactical maneuver. The author just drops this marriage proposal from Yan Zhen's family out of nowhere, and instead of letting it explode into drama immediately, we get this weird, quiet interlude of tea and polite refusals. It's frustrating! I wanted more heat. But then, watching Yin-shi smoothly deflect the matchmaker while her husband zones out completely—that's classic slow-burn political maneuvering. The real plot hook isn't the rejection itself; it's the invitation to the Shi family's bieyuan banquet. That's the author's way of tying everyone into the same room before the next clash. And that last line from Rong Xia offering to walk Ban Hua home? "Today let me send Junzhu home." It's such a mundane sentence but it changes the entire trajectory. It suggests he's not just a distant cousin watching from afar anymore. He's stepping into her orbit. Will she let him? Does she even want to? The setup is there, but the payoff is dangling by a thread. I just need to know if the banquet becomes a battleground or a truce.
... Read More
I need to talk about Yan-furen because this woman is genuinely tragic and she didn't even try to be. Here's someone who raised her son to be diligent, focused, well-balanced — and then made sure he never actually learned how to talk to women. She says it herself: "If only she had known this would happen, she wouldn't have restricted her son too much. If he had been familiar with women, he wouldn't have lost his soul when he saw Ban Hua." That right there — that is the confession of a mother who prioritized orthodoxy over humanity and now watches the consequences unfold. And what's wild is that she still hasn't learned. She's sitting there thinking about ancestors' rules and matchmaker words while her son is physically collapsing in the courtyard, pale and gasping for air. The contrast between her internal panic ("her breath stuck in her chest") and her external rigidity (refusing to bend even an inch) is devastating. Then there's Ban Heng dropping that casual bombshell to Zhou Changxiao — telling him not to spread the secret about his sister sending Rong Xia home. He trusts Zhou Changxiao enough to share, but makes it crystal clear this is private information. That tells you everything about where loyalties sit in this world. And Rong Xia observing that Ban Hua has never contemplated the mother-in-law question because her own family dynamic was warm and functional while Yan-furen's was cold and rule-bound — that's the quietest, sharpest character analysis in the entire passage. Three houses, three different models of family, all colliding in this one failed proposal.
... Read More
Okay let's talk about the absolute TENSION in this chapter because folks, everyone is armed and they're all smiling. Yun-niang's scene opens with her convinced she's being watched by a snake. Whether it's paranoia or perception, the stakes for her are survival-level. She ran away once and got abandoned. She came back to the Capital to face the woman who caught her and found out her worthless lover left her. She's standing at the lowest possible point in this world's hierarchy and yet she's seeking confrontation. That takes a type of courage that the nobles at the birthday party will never understand. Meanwhile at the Grand Princess's birthday, every interaction is a potential landmine. The Crown Prince's arrival changes the entire power dynamic of the room — suddenly everyone is recalculating alliances in real-time. Ban Heng making the Crown Prince laugh isn't charming; it's a strategic strike that guarantees his family's relevance for decades. The unmarried ladies sneering at Ban Hua behind her back? They're not just jealous — they're assessing threats. In this world, a beautiful woman with powerful protectors is either a sister or a target, and there's no in-between. But the highest stakes scene is the quietest. Rong Xia glancing at Ban Hua across the room while the Crown Prince demands his attention. He has to navigate royal expectations, political positioning, and his own feelings — all while maintaining perfect composure in front of everyone who's watching. One wrong look, one misplaced word, and the careful architecture of his relationship with the Ban family could crumble. Meanwhile Ban Hua sits next to her grandmother, smiling at flattering strangers, sending a tiny invisible wave to the one person who might actually understand what she's navigating. She has wealth and protection but zero agency in this moment. Everyone is performing around her — the Grand Princess playing the doting elder, the guests playing flattering acquaintances, Ban Heng playing the charming cousin, Rong Xia playing the detached aristocrat. And Ban Hua? She's playing 'happy granddaughter' while her eyes track the one person who might see through it all. The real conflict here isn't between characters — it's between what everyone is performing and what they actually feel. And that gap is where all the danger lives.
... Read More
I need to talk about this one passage because the worldbuilding here is absolutely exquisite and I want to sit with it for a while. When Ban Hua arrives at the Shi family, the author takes this whole section to describe her carriage in painstaking detail. Six horses, thoroughly selected, strong and majestic. Standard color but meticulous materials and details — almost as good as a Gongzhu's eight-horse carriage. The interior walls inlaid with magnificent gemstones, cushions of the softest kind. All of this from the Department of the Palace, and they're still worried she won't be satisfied. Just want one word of appreciation from her. This is worldbuilding that does three things at once. First, it establishes the material reality of this society — the Department of the Palace exists, it maintains imperial household logistics, and it has elaborate protocols for different ranks of nobility. Second, it shows us Ban Hua's status without a single exposition sentence — she is so powerful and so feared that an entire government department goes above and beyond just to keep her from being annoyed. Third, and this is the brilliant part, it sets up the contrast with Kangning's carriage. Same rank, similar design, but when they appear side by side, everyone can tell the difference. Status isn't just about title in this world — it's about power, reputation, and the fear you inspire. And then there's the scene at the Shi family gate itself — the servants' shifting behavior, the exchange of silver, the way everyone reads the room in seconds. This is a society where social hierarchy is lived daily, performed constantly, and understood implicitly by everyone involved. The author never stops to explain the rules because the characters already know them instinctively. That's how you build a world — through behavior, not description.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or