Fallen Idol Group - Reviews

Fallen Idol Group
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay, so this whole livestream sequence is actually really cleverly constructed if you step back and look at it. On the surface it's just a group chat with fans, but underneath there are literally multiple layers of performance happening at once. Tan Qing crying on camera? That's performed emotion. The heart rate monitors? That's the truth trying to break through the performance. Zhu Lianzhen deflecting every relationship question? Also performance. And then AFTER the stream ends, when they're alone on the terrace, that's when the actual plot happens—the unspoken stuff between them. What really got me was how the author uses the gender-swap hypothetical as a narrative trap. Koty sets it up like it's just a fun game, but everyone—including the readers—knows it's actually a test. Zhu Lianzhen sees through it immediately: "What, did they want to see his heart rate spike, or were they fishing for him to say 'Tan Qing'?" And he refuses to play. That's not just plot avoidance, that's self-preservation. Then Tan Qing drops that line—"He's never liked anyone before"—which is either the most protective thing he could say or the most accidentally honest thing, and Zhu Lianzhen internally spirals about it. The scene ends with Zhu Lianzhen asking about the crying technique, Tan Qing washing his hands, looking at the night sky, and then asking "Why would you think that?" which is such a perfect deflection. The author never confirms anything, never resolves the tension, just leaves it hanging. That's what makes this chapter so addictive—you want answers but the story is deliberately denying them.
... Read More
The domestic intimacy of this chapter is what gets me every time. Not the grand gestures or dramatic confessions—the mundane, almost boring details that somehow carry more weight than anything else. "Zhu Lianzhen rubbed his thumb over the uneven ridges of the keys. The room was so quiet that the tiny motion was the only sound." Read that again. He's FIDGETING with a key while the other person is literally holding a thermometer in his mouth. The specificity of that gesture—tracing the ridges, the only sound in the room—is cinematic. You can hear the silence. You can feel the weight of not looking away. And then the phone-on-chest speaker scene—"Zhu Lianzhen put it on speaker and placed it on his chest, talking to Tan Qing like that"—the physical arrangement of bodies separated by distance but connected through vibration and sound creates this haunting sense of near-touch. Later when Tan Qing says 'heartbeat' and Zhu Lianzhen presses the phone to his own ear... the narrator doesn't need to describe the room anymore because the EMOTIONAL landscape has completely replaced the physical one. The dream sequence is even more visually striking. Mist-spraying machines, a gray moth landing on a nose, Koty's absurd scream, and then the quiet moment where Tan Qing's hand becomes a perch for something beautiful. It's surreal but grounded in sensory detail—the dust on the moth's wings, the awkward flight pattern, the sudden silence when transformation happens. This author understands that atmosphere isn't built through description alone but through the COLLISION of the ordinary and the strange.
... Read More
Okay so this scene where Tan Qing wipes Zhu Lianzhen's lip gloss is literally one of the most loaded moments in the entire book and I need to process this. Koty turns around and immediately catches them and his reaction is just pure GLEAMING eyes like he just won the lottery of gossip material. And then Tan Qing's response — "I wouldn't be that rough" — which is apparently the most casual thing you could say after being caught in an intimate moment with someone at a public awards show?? Zhu Lianzhen didn't even process it himself at first, which tells me everything about how their dynamic works. He's flustered and bristles like a cat, but Tan Qing? Tan Qing is completely unbothered because this is just... normal for them now. The fact that Koty scoots away giving a mysterious wink and saying "my lips are sealed" is peak friend group energy. Meanwhile the netizens watching the livestream have lost their absolute minds. "how can he be so blatant in public!" — babe, you have no idea. This guy has been basically living in a villa that belongs to his bandmate and neither of them will admit it out loud. The power dynamic here is everything. Tan Qing holds all the cards — he's the one with the hidden resources, the one who bought the villa, the one who can casually wipe someone's face at a national livestream without breaking eye contact. Zhu Lianzhen is the one getting flustered and deflecting. But honestly? I think Zhu Lianzhen's also kind of into it, otherwise why lean in at all?
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this opening section because it is genuinely the funniest plot device I have encountered in ages. The entire chapter basically runs on this dual track of external observation versus internal group dynamic, and it works so well. On one hand, you've got these paparazzi teams staking out each member's home, trying to dig up scandalous dirt. The editor-in-chief's conclusion that there's 'absolutely nothing they could use to squeeze money out of Pei Qiao' is a perfect comedic beat, but it also sets up something deeper — these guys are so impenetrably normal that the media has no fuel. That's a statement in itself about who Acemon actually is versus how the public perceives them. And then each member's week is laid out like a character dossier: Ji Yunting eating dim sum for two hours, reading a tragic romance novel and crying, getting absolutely wasted, then buying all the candied hawthorn from an old lady and reselling it on the street. This is not a side character energy — this is the kind of deeply specific, oddly touching detail that makes a protagonist feel real. Koty being a chaotic rich boy who pays for everyone but has zero self-awareness about what anyone else is thinking. Fu Rong at 4 AM throwing out trash bags in different bins like some kind of method actor preparing for a role called 'Paranoid but Also Just Really Environmental.' Tan Qing living like a hermit who occasionally emerges for groceries. Zhu Lianzhen apparently the only one with a healthy lifestyle, and even that gets undercut because he was just being careful about the paparazzi. The plot structure here is brilliant because each vignette does double duty — it advances the worldbuilding of who these people are while also setting up the interpersonal comedy that follows during the photoshoot. Nothing feels wasted. Even the magazine interview later, where each member gives a totally different answer to the same question, reveals something essential about where they stand emotionally as a group.
... Read More
This sequence moves in such a deliberate, almost suffocating way—and I mean that as a compliment. It starts in media res with Zhu Lianzhen half-awake, memories fragmented, which immediately puts us in his disoriented headspace. Then we get the hospital report, the walk back to the dorm, the confrontation with the team, and finally the quiet breakdown at the end. Each beat lands because the author gives it room to breathe. The transition from the chaotic hospital scene to the crowded dorm with Koty's dramatic "I prayed for you all night under the stars" is such a perfect tonal shift. It goes from medical tension to comedic relief to underlying seriousness so smoothly you barely notice the pivot. Then Fu Rong drops the truth bomb about Tan Qing being angry and the whole mood shifts again. What I find most effective is how the pacing mirrors Zhu Lianzhen's mental state. He's slow to process, defensive, deflecting—like reading through a fog. The author doesn't rush his realizations. Each conversation circles back to the same unspoken truth until finally, at the end, Ah-Xu just says the thing aloud and the structure collapses around him. No grand confession, no dramatic reveal—just a guy sitting on his bed realizing his life is about to change. Perfect.
... Read More
The opening image of this chapter is so quietly perfect—the evening wind blowing between them, granting a moment of peace before the storm of conversation hits. You can practically feel the temperature, the stillness, the cat trotting over on command. It's so domestic and yet so charged, like a scene from a film where the camera lingers a beat too long on two people standing too close on a threshold. Then the scene shifts entirely—we're suddenly in Zhu Lianzhen's childhood, and the worldbuilding here is brutal in its subtlety. Four years old, packing an Ultraman backpack with cookies and AD calcium milk, sneaking out on a dark windy night. The butler picking him up five minutes later. The parents renting out an entire amusement park for his birthday because they can, even though he would've preferred the noisy crowd. These details don't just paint a picture of wealth—they paint a picture of a golden cage. "He didn't even make it five minutes before the butler in the downstairs lobby picked him up and brought him back." His entire life has been managed, monitored, protected to the point of suffocation. No wonder he's so obsessed with drawing lines and setting ground rules with Tan Qing. Control is the only thing he's ever had, and Tan Qing makes him lose control every single time. The contrast between the evening scene and the childhood flashback creates this haunting parallel—two different times, same trapped boy. The world of this story isn't just showbiz and wealth; it's the psychological architecture of someone who has everything except the freedom to want what he actually wants.
... Read More
Can we just acknowledge that the stakes in this story are absolutely lethal and the author knows it? These two men are hiding a relationship that could destroy their careers, their fanbases, everything they've built. And every single physical moment between them is under threat of exposure. The concert scene is Peak Stakes Because On Stage they're performing intimacy for thousands of people while actually having a panic attack about it. Tan Qing leans in and the audience SCREAMS but Zhu Lianzhen is internally screaming because he knows what this looks like and he's terrified of crossing a line he can't come back from. Then backstage—no audience, no cameras, just them—and even that gets interrupted by FOOTSTEPS. Just someone walking down the hallway and suddenly they're not allowed to touch. The stakes aren't just career damage. The stakes are that they can't even HAVE a normal intimate moment without the world pressing in. And Zhu Lianzhen saying "This was a concert. Just because you're good at acting doesn't mean I won't slip up"—that's not anger, that's terror dressed up as frustration. He's afraid he'll give something away because he's human and Tan Qing is performing and the gap between them is literally tearing him apart. What are they really risking here? Everything. And the author makes you feel every single second of that weight.
... Read More
There are so many layers to this chapter and I want to sit with just one for a moment: the idea of being watched and judged for what you don't know. Every student in that classroom is a mannequin — an empty vessel pretending to be a person. But Koty is real, and that reality makes him visible in a way the others aren't. When the teacher asks "Which student took the eraser?" and Koty freezes, or when she calls on him by name and all those plastic heads turn to stare — this is the nightmare of being the only authentic thing in a world of performance. The mannequins don't have to try. They don't have to know anything. They just exist, perfectly still, perfectly compliant. Koty has to participate. He has to search. He has to answer. And every time he fails, the judgment multiplies. The eraser itself is such a rich symbol here. It's something used to clean mistakes, to erase errors, to make things look like they were never wrong in the first place. Koty finds it in a drawer — hidden, misplaced, forgotten — and the moment his fingers touch it, the mannequin beside him moves. The eraser connects to the theme of correcting what cannot be corrected, of pretending the past didn't happen. And then Zhu Lianzhen retrieves it and places it on the teacher's desk, and she nods in approval. The system rewards compliance, not understanding. The eraser doesn't need to be understood; it just needs to be returned. Then there's the chalk. "Use parentheses." Tan Qing's instruction is brief, practical, but it carries this weight about form versus content. The answer is correct — 3, -4 — but the parentheses matter. The presentation matters. In this world, how you appear to know something matters more than whether you actually understand it. Zhu Lianzhen writes it "neatly" with "round and plump" handwriting, and Tan Qing claps with deliberate pride. They're performing competence for an audience that isn't even there — except, of course, the hidden cameras are always watching. The parabola itself is worth considering. y = x² - 6x + 5. A curve that dips and rises, finding its vertex, its turning point. The word "vertex" comes from Latin meaning "turn" or "harpoon" — a point where direction changes. Both Zhu Lianzhen and Koty are at their vertices in this chapter. Koty's moment of maximum exposure, maximum fear, maximum vulnerability. Zhu Lianzhen's moment of running, of choosing survival over loyalty, of carrying that regret forward. They've both reached a turning point, and neither of them knows which direction comes next. And the repeated question — "Why don't you know?" — echoes beyond the classroom. It's not just about math. It's about why you're here. Why you're afraid. Why you can't figure out the rules. It's the question every participant in this show has been asking themselves, and the terrifying answer might just be: you don't have to know. You just have to keep moving.
... Read More
Okay so I have to talk about this entire section because the plotting here is genuinely sneaky in the best way. You've got a variety show crew trying to manufacture drama to test Tan Qing's reaction, but the whole thing keeps spiraling into something way more interesting than anyone anticipated. The director comes in with all these standard reality-TV tricks—rude staff member, overhearing gossip, the whole tired playbook—and everyone immediately shuts it down because 'those little tricks won't faze him at all.' That line alone tells you everything you need to know about Tan Qing: he's not an ordinary celebrity who cracks under manufactured pressure. He's something else entirely. Then the conversation derails into absolute chaos when they start brainstorming scenarios, and honestly this is where the plot gets delicious. The marriage certificate idea, the murder discovery, the trolley problem where Fu Rong literally makes the tracks N-shaped so everyone dies—that's not just comedy, it's worldbuilding through dysfunction. These guys have a reputation for being toxic internally, right? And yet here they are, willingly stepping into a show designed to exploit every crack in their relationships. The real plot engine kicks in when they land on the love triangle test. Two teammates dating the same person, Tan Qing discovers it. This isn't just TV drama bait—it's actually probing the core question: would Tan Qing protect loyalty or do what's "right" for the group's image? The show wants content. The company wants damage control. And Tan Qing? I don't think he cares about either of those things. The fact that Zhu Lianzhen gets volunteered against his will because he's supposedly the only one who could credibly hide a secret relationship… that's dramatic irony at its finest. The guy who can't even lie his way through a kabedon scene is now pretending to be a secret boyfriend. This plot is setting itself up for something explosive and I can't look away.
... Read More
Okay so I just finished these four chapters and I am *shook*. Let me process this. The whole arc has been building toward something, and then BAM—Tan Ruisheng drops that Tan Qing is not his biological child and I was not ready for that at all. Like, this changes EVERYTHING. Let me back up because the structure of these chapters is actually really smart. We start with domestic fluff—Zhu Lianzhen mopping up rainwater, them having a quiet dinner together. It feels cozy, safe. Then Tan Qing gets the call and suddenly we're in a five-hour rain-soaked drive to Beijing. The stakes shift instantly from 'what are we having for dinner' to 'am I going to see my dying father one last time?' And then the real meat hits: Tan Ruisheng wasn't around much because he started his directing career late, was always working as someone's assistant, couldn't be there. But Tan Qing was never difficult about it. Never made a fuss. Just said 'nothing' or 'whatever' when asked for birthday gifts because he remembered his dad said cream wasn't healthy. That detail about the cake—I keep coming back to it. This kid who never asked for anything, who read his father's moods like a book, who was 'already really smart when he was just a few years old.' And now we find out HE ISN'T EVEN HIS SON. The whole relationship they had, the distance, the silence for twenty years—it all gets reframed in one sentence. What does that mean for Tan Qing's identity? For how he saw himself? For why his dad never reached out? I need to know more. The author really knows how to save the biggest revelation for the absolute end of a chapter block. Brilliant.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this one line and I can't stop thinking about it. "It was the place where we lived together. I just didn't want it to become someone else's home." I know this sounds like a simple line but Zhu Lianzhen's entire inner monologue after that is basically the thesis of this whole relationship arc. The word "home" is doing SO much work here. For him, that apartment was just a secret hiding spot — where they got paparazzi'd, where they fought, where things ended badly. But for Tan Qing? He kept it exactly the same. He goes over and cleans it regularly. It's not an investment property, it's not strategically located. It's just... the place he lived with the person he loved, and he refused to let it become someone else's home. And then the scene where Zhu Lianzhen is on the phone with his mom at 3 AM — he talks about how joy is something you want to share. He has his family. He called his mom right after winning. But Tan Qing has no one. No one to call. That's when Zhu Lianzhen gets up and checks on him and finds him sitting alone in the dark with a glass of alcohol. The contrast between these two characters' relationships with solitude and connection is everywhere in this passage. Tan Qing's silence is a recurring motif throughout the book — his loneliness isn't dramatic, it's just quietly devastating.
... Read More
We open with a full-blown crisis—face turning into Koty, phone numbers flying away, desperate 911-style calls—and by the time we reach the hospital the whole energy shifts. The author deliberately slows everything down after the car ride. The IV drip, the medicine box, Zhu Lianzhen puckering his lips at the ceiling like some weird serene fish. The silence in that hospital room is so thick you can almost hear Ah-Xu scrolling on her phone. And then—just as you think the chapter is winding down into a quiet, tender moment—Tan Qing lifts that sleeve and finds the scar.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or