Don’t Be Holy! - Reviews

Don’t Be Holy!
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—this opening chapter arrangement is actually really clever. You start IN medias res with this tense scene where Rubel has Eir pinned down and is basically frisking her like some kind of holy knight detective, right? And then you flashback to explain HOW we got here. That's a classic structure move and it works because now you're not just wondering 'is she going to get raped' (spoiler: she doesn't), you're wondering 'how the hell did this extremely competent holy knight end up tied up and gagged in a random herbalist's house?' That's a much better mystery. The backstory drop is efficient too—three years of hiding, a curse that makes everyone forget her, and this one weird detail about her divine power causing... uh... physiological reactions. I love how the author plants that as this looming plot device without fully explaining it yet. It's like a Chekhov's gun that's also a Chekhov's awkward situation. The villager scene where they carry him in bound and gagged is genuinely hilarious because it subverts every expectation. You'd think the hero would be carried in triumphantly, but no—he's treated like a criminal because Eir panicked. That's character-driven comedy at its finest. I'm also curious about the curse mechanic. 'Those who remember you deeply may break the curse.' Rubel clearly had SOME connection to her at the temple three years ago (he was the one who summoned and scolded her), so what happens when he starts remembering? That's the elephant in the room and I'm here for it.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about how Rubel literally has a god-tier aura but completely loses his composure around this one girl? Like, first he shows up looking like a death god, kicking monsters into trees, threatening her with questions — and then what? He notices her bangs are slightly curly. CURLY. We are NOT doing this. The whole dynamic is so deliciously frustrating. He saves her life, obviously, because of course he does, but then he won't even admit he cares. Instead he gives her the benefit of the doubt and walks away. And Eir?! This girl who was ready to die at that grave, who prayed to sacrifice herself without hesitation — suddenly she's scrambling up a stranger's body like a climbing frame, screaming at him not to give up, crying because he accepted death too easily. 'I'm not doing this to save you right now.' — said while wrapped around his neck. THE LIES. Neither of you believes that. And the dream sequence at the end??? That hit me like a truck. Rubel experiencing alternate memories where he acted differently — where he was colder, more calculating, almost cruel — and he immediately recognized it as wrong. It felt artificial. It showed me everything I needed to know about who he actually is versus who he's been pretending to be. She changed him. She doesn't even know it yet.
... Read More
Let me just lay out the conflict stack because it is STACKED. External conflict: Eir is a fugitive priestess hiding from the temple that exiled her. If she's discovered, what happens? The text doesn't say explicitly but the fear is visceral—she's been running for three years, changing her name, living as a simple herbalist. The stakes feel genuinely life-threatening even though we haven't seen the consequences yet. Rubel's external conflict is clearer: he's hunting something—or someone. That mark on her neck that glows? He saw it. He's not just investigating randomly; he has a specific target and Eir just became it. The confrontation in chapter one is him closing in. But the INTERNAL conflicts are where this actually bites. Eir's guilt is enormous—she left the temple, she broke whatever rules brought her here, and now she's protecting a man who represents everything she fled. And Rubel? He's torn between his duty (investigate the mark, follow the evidence) and this growing confusion about the woman he's interrogating. He keeps expecting her to be dangerous, but she's just... tired. Sad. Human. The stakes escalate beautifully in the flashback: Eir's divine energy goes out of control and PURIFIES THE LAND. That's not just a power outage—that's evidence. Tomorrow, villagers will notice. The curse protects her from being REMEMBERED, but it can't hide a completely transformed landscape. Every solution she creates plants the seed of the next problem. And the ultimate stake looms over everything: if Rubel remembers her, the curse breaks. If the curse breaks, she loses her protection. But if he doesn't remember her... she stays invisible forever. She's trapped between being found and being forgotten, and neither option is safe.
... Read More
The dialogue in this batch is absolutely masterful and I need to dissect why it works so well. First, let's talk about Eir's voice. On the surface, she sounds like a bumbling, frustrated student. "Al-et?! Anyone can see that it's 'Iwatasia'!" But her internal monologue is completely different—sharp, observant, terrified. This contrast IS her character. She performs incompetence while her inner voice screams with intelligence. When she mutters "Vurte" and realizes what she's done, the dialogue captures that moment of horror perfectly. Her external voice fails her; her internal voice betrays her. Rubel's dialogue is equally layered. He grumbles about food, complains about meals, acts like a typical grumpy husband. But his internal thoughts reveal a calculating mind analyzing everything. "What if she tripped over those worn shoes, causing a carriage accident and dying?" This is someone who's supposed to be warm and domestic but is actually cold and strategic. The gap between his spoken words and his thoughts creates incredible tension. Mr. Linden's voice is wonderfully distinct—warm, patient, slightly exasperated but genuinely caring. "My goodness. God has blessed you." This is a man who genuinely wants Eir to succeed, making the irony of her fake failures even more painful. His excitement feels real, which makes us ache for Eir. The child characters, like Otis, provide comic relief but also highlight Eir's isolation. "I can read this, but Eir can't, right?" This teasing from a twelve-year-old emphasizes how alone Eir is—she can't even share this burden with a child. The dialogue between Eir and the village women at the washing place reveals so much. They tease her about having a man at home, arrange seating orders cheerfully—but we KNOW they're being manipulated. Their casual conversation becomes threatening in retrospect. The holy language moments are particularly powerful. When Eir mutters "Vurte"—a curse in the sacred tongue—it's dialogue as revelation. Her true self breaks through her carefully constructed performance. The fact that Mr. Linden thinks she LEARNED it, when actually her magic is leaking out, is brilliant dramatic irony. Every conversation in this batch serves multiple purposes—advancing plot, revealing character, building tension. The dialogue never feels wasted. It's tight, purposeful, and loaded with subtext. I'm taking notes.
... Read More
This batch emotionally wrecked me and I need to talk about it because the emotional lines here are so complex and painful. Let me start with Eir's internal state, because wow. She's living this double life—pretending to be a clumsy, failing student while actually being someone with immense magical power. The emotional toll of this is IMMEasurable. When she pinches her thigh and thinks "Can't even lie. It hurts when I do. But what sense does it make to live a life where I have to deceive someone forever?"—I felt this in my SOUL. The exhaustion of constant performance. The loneliness of having to hide your true self from the person you're closest to. And Rubel! His emotional journey is equally painful. He tells himself he's there for the mission, but his actions betray him. He notices her shoes. He imagines her death and feels overwhelmed. He crosses himself and prays, scolding his own wandering thoughts. This is someone fighting his own heart. He's supposed to be a divine agent, cold and detached, but he's developing feelings for his target. The guilt is destroying him. The romantic tension is palpable in every scene. When Eir brings him sandwiches, she's performing the role of caring wife while terrified he'll discover her secrets. When he grumbles about food, he's maintaining distance while secretly wanting to stay close. Their entire interaction is this painful dance of approach and retreat. But the emotional peak for me was Eir's realization about lying. "What sense does it make to live a life where I have to deceive someone forever? It makes no sense." This is her breaking point. She's exhausted from pretending. She's tired of hiding. And she's starting to wonder if there's another way. The emotional line here isn't just about romance—it's about the pain of invisibility. Two people who see each other's true selves but can't acknowledge it. The yearning. The fear. The hope that maybe, just maybe, they'll find a way to be honest. I'm emotionally compromised and I need a hug.
... Read More
'It's because I live in the same house as you. Somehow, that's what happens when you live together.' I need a minute. I need to sit with that line. Because everything about Rubel and Eir's relationship in these chapters is built on what they DON'T say to each other. He shows up to stop her from going to the grave but doesn't say he was worried. She gives him armor and a sword but frames it as repayment. They bicker about herbs and painkillers like it's nothing, but she's tending his wounds and he's taking it. The shoulder armor detail killed me though. She looked at his wound—the one he got deflecting attacks with his left side—and somehow understood his fighting style just from seeing it. That's observation. That's PAYING ATTENTION. And he notices that she noticed. 'Maybe she's not such a fool after all' isn't just about the armor. It's about realizing she's been watching him this whole time. Their dynamic at home is hilarious in a painfully realistic way. The villagers are out here losing their minds over Rubel while Eir is basically like 'we barely talk.' And she's right! Their conversations go like: 'What are you doing?' 'What do you mean? I need to treat these wounds.' That's it. That's the romance. Zero chemistry lines, maximum tension through sheer proximity and unspoken care. He thinks she's naive, she thinks he's cold, but they keep proving each other wrong without saying a word about it. The ending with all those girls sighing 'I think I've fallen in love with Lu' while Eir is over here thinking 'do boys count as children if they're helping in the garden?' is comedy gold but also kind of sad—everyone sees what's between them except them.
... Read More
I need to talk about the dynamic between Eir and this mysterious man because OMFG. The power imbalance alone is fascinating—she literally kidnapped him, tied him up, stole his soup, and then panicked when he opened a forbidden room like it was nothing. And he's just… sitting there. Calm. Eating her food. Making comments about how beautiful the stones are like he didn't just violate every single rule in that house. What's interesting is that neither of them trusts the other but they're both trapped in the same space. Eir keeps trying to assert control—"I saved you so leave now"—and he immediately undercuts it by saying he doesn't remember anything. Classic move. Whether he's genuinely amnesiac or lying (and my money is on lying, because the narration literally says 'He's lying' right after he says it), he's manipulating the situation to stay. And Eir, despite being terrified, is still playing along with this whole charade instead of throwing him out. Why? Because she's compassionate underneath all that chaos. She's a priestess who saved a wounded stranger, after all. Then there's the grandmother angle. We only see her through flashbacks but her presence is EVERYWHERE. The locks, the stones, the spell that makes people believe whatever fiction the house feeds them—it's all HER design. And Eir? She's living in the ghost of this woman who clearly knew things about the world that Eir is only now beginning to understand. The granddaughter-grandmother relationship is heartbreaking in its silence. The old woman saved Eir's life but also trapped her in a web of magical obligation. Now Eir has to navigate all of this alone while a literal war is happening outside. And Alf—poor Alf. He comes in concerned and within seconds the grandmother's curse rewrites his perception of reality. He goes from worried friend to someone who believes this stranger is family. It's creepy and it shows how deeply the house's magic controls everyone who enters it.
... Read More
I need to pause and just APPRECIATE the atmosphere in this chapter because it is STUNNING. From the very first paragraph—"Every lock she had and spent the night installing them"—you're immediately dropped into this claustrophobic, paranoid world where a young woman is locking doors like her life depends on it (and honestly, maybe it does). The house itself is a character. It's small, it's old, it's filled with things that must never be touched, and it's the only place Eir has left after her grandmother died and all her belongings were burned. The lighting throughout this chapter is incredible. That bright sunlight that immediately makes Eir uneasy because "Granny told me to always keep the curtains drawn because of the medicine bottles"—this tiny detail tells you SO MUCH about the grandmother's obsession with secrecy and protection. And then the room with the tree trunks bursting through the floor, branches spreading across the walls, stones on a platform in the center. What IS that room? A ritual space? A prison for something? The imagery is so vivid I can see it like a film frame. The worldbuilding here is masterfully slow. We don't get exposition dumps about the Divine Empire, the war with Albarm, or the history of witches. Instead, we get fragments—a mention of the three-year war, a reference to the Northern Purification Squad, a glimpse into a society where priests and holy knights hunt monsters and retrieve treasures, and witches who were supposedly hunted to extinction a century ago but clearly aren't extinct at all. The grandmother is one. Eir is a priestess. The man is a knight. Three sides of a conflict, all colliding in one small house. The most chilling detail? The spell. It doesn't just make people friendly—it makes them BELIEVE things. Alf genuinely thinks this stranger is Eir's relative. The magic rewrite their perception of reality. That's not just worldbuilding, that's terror. It means no one in this house can trust their own thoughts. Everyone is vulnerable to the grandmother's lingering influence even after she's gone.
... Read More
This batch is absolutely THICK with thematic depth and I need to unpack the symbolism because it's refusing to be ignored. Let me start with the biggest symbol: LANGUAGE. Holy language, Imperial language, magical incantations, curses spoken backwards. Language here is power. It's also deception. Eir pretends not to know holy language, but her true self speaks it fluently—when she mutters "Vurte," she's not performing anymore. She's being herself. The theme here is profound: truth cannot be suppressed forever. Your real self will leak out through the cracks. The worn shoes are another powerful symbol. Rubel notices Eir's shoes about to fall apart. These represent her precarious situation—holding it together barely, one step from disaster. If she trips, everything collapses. The shoes are also domestic detail that Rubel shouldn't care about—but he does. This shows how his mission is corrupting his humanity; he's noticing personal details instead of just gathering intelligence. Food and sandwiches symbolize care and connection. Eir makes Rubel sandwiches every day. This is her way of showing love while maintaining her cover. She's performing domesticity while hiding her true nature. The ham, the herbs, the vegetables—all symbols of the normal life she's trying to build while living a lie. The pigeons Rubel feeds symbolize his capacity for tenderness. This man who kills monsters with divine swords also gently feeds birds. The contradiction is the point—he's not just a weapon. He's a person with capacity for love, even if he denies it. Witchcraft and divine magic represent two sides of power—one manipulative and hidden, one overt and judgmental. But the text complicates this. The witch manipulates through faith. Rubel uses faith to hunt. Both are using belief as a tool. The theme asks: What's the difference between divine justice and witchcraft manipulation? Both involve power over others. Both involve secrecy. Eir's repeated failures in class symbolize the impossible position of marginalized people—you're expected to perform competence while being sabotaged by systems that want you to fail. Her "stupidity" is actually survival. She's been failed six times, but that's because she's been pretending. Her true ability emerges only when she stops performing. The knocking at the door at the end symbolizes inevitable confrontation. You can't hide forever. Truth will come knocking. The question is whether you'll be ready when it arrives.
... Read More
There are two scenes in this batch that just hit different, and I need to unpack both. First: the flashback to the day Eir first saw Rubel kneeling before the Emperor. The writing here is SO vivid—I can literally see it. 'His cloak billowing like a banner. The high priest's hand, bestowing blessings, radiated a white light... the lining of his cloak matched the deep red of the carpet beneath him and his hair.' This is cinematic framing at its finest. The red-on-red imagery, the white light from above, the reverent posture. It paints him as almost too perfect, too sacred, and that's intentional because Eir is SUPPOSED to see him that way initially. It establishes the pedestal she puts him on before everything comes crashing down. Then you've got the rainstorm scene at the end—completely different energy. Torrential rain, villagers in raincoats shouting about monsters from the east, and Rubel stepping out into the storm to face them while Eir watches from inside, lamp in hand. The image of his red hair and clothes soaked through, clinging to his frame, is striking. But what really sells the atmosphere is how the lightning flash reveals him for a split second—sharp, reflected, almost supernatural—before he becomes the stoic knight again. The author uses weather as emotional punctuation here, and it works beautifully.
... Read More
This whole dynamic between Rubel and Eir is giving me whiplash in the best way possible. Like, on one hand you've got this guy who is SO pure that physical proximity to a woman doesn't even register as arousing for him. Think about the opening scene—Eir is basically half-naked, pinned under him, and his internal monologue is just... bureaucracy. 'Intercourse is a mutual act requiring both parties to disrobe. I am merely undressing you.' BROTHER. You are a walking immune system to romance tropes. And Eir! Oh my god, Eir is suffering. She's been running for THREE YEARS, hiding her identity, dealing with this curse that erases her from everyone's memory, and now this absurd holy knight shows up and treats her body like a crime scene to be investigated. Her reaction isn't romantic fluster— it's pure exhaustion. 'How many times do I have to tell you?' She's not blushing, she's DONE. But here's the thing that actually got me—the flashback scene where she finds him bleeding on the mountain. She could have walked away. She had every reason to. But she didn't. She treated his wounds, carried him, stayed up all night. That's not just duty, that's this deep-seated kindness that's been buried under three years of fear and survival mode. And Rubel, meanwhile, wakes up and immediately assumes she's a threat. There's something almost tragic about how disconnected they are—she risked everything to save him, and he sees her as a puzzle to solve. Yet the fact that he's the ONLY person who might remember her? That's the emotional landmine waiting to go off. I can already feel the eventual softening coming and I am NOT ready.
... Read More
Okay so here's the thing about this chapter that I keep circling back to—the plot doesn't just happen TO Eir, it happens because of something SHE CHOSE. That's what makes it click. The village chief drops the hint about monsters in the east, and most people would've been like, 'okay, noted, hope they don't come here,' but Eir? She immediately connects the dots: east = Granny's grave, monsters = corruption risk, corruption = whatever terrible thing Granny warned about. Her brain works fast. And then she grabs a dagger and goes into a storm alone. No fanfare, no dramatic declaration, just... action. But the real twist? Rubel shows up after. Not because she asked him to, not because he understood why she was going—but because apparently living in the same house means something to him now too. When he finally says it outright—"I came to save you"—it hits different because the whole chapter has been building this tension where you're not sure if he's going to be an obstacle or an ally. Turns out he was both. The Alupu attack scene is where the plot really earns its stakes. Eir has a plan—stun them with divine power, kill the closest one, lure the rest away—and it almost works. Then Rubel appears like some kind of blood-soaked force of nature and just... ends them. The pacing there is genius because you're suspended between 'is Eir going to die?' and 'who IS this guy?' Two questions answered at once. Then the next day gifts—armor and a sword—ties the whole emotional arc to the plot. She figured out his fighting style from a wound. That's not just cute, it's plot-relevant. And his line 'Maybe she's not such a fool after all' is the smallest character beat but it changes everything about how he sees her. The chapter ends on this domestic setup that somehow feels like the calm before a much bigger storm.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or