Don’t Be Holy! - Reviews

Don’t Be Holy!
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The worldbuilding in this batch is absolutely exquisite and I need to gush about how the author creates this atmosphere. First, the village itself feels SO alive. We have domestic scenes—Eir making sandwiches, grinding herbs, cooking—but there's this underlying tension that something is WRONG. The village is under Hecate's lingering magic, and you can feel it in every description. The herbs on the kitchen table. The neatly arranged vegetables. The chopping wood sounds that stop abruptly. Everything feels slightly OFF, like a painting where the colors are almost right but not quite. The tutoring center scene is brilliantly crafted. You have this small, cramped space with children learning holy language, and Eir is this adult pretending to be a failing student. The teacher, Mr. Linden, is described with such warmth—his glasses, his headache, his genuine excitement when Eir finally pronounces a word correctly. This mundane scene becomes charged with tension because we KNOW Eir didn't actually learn. She muttered a curse. The contrast between the ordinary (a language class) and the extraordinary (dark magic leaking out) is perfect. The village women scene at the washing place gives us this glimpse of normal community life—gossiping, arranging seating orders, teasing Eir about having a man at home. But underneath, there's this dread. These women are being manipulated by the witch. Their conversations are likely being monitored. The ordinary becomes threatening. Rubel feeding pigeons—that image haunts me. A man trained to kill monsters, gently feeding scraps to birds. The contrast between his violence (kicking Alupu into the air, wielding divine swords) and this tenderness is stunning. It shows us who he might be beneath the mission. The religious atmosphere is thick. Prayers, holy language, divine punishment, sacred curses. The village is deeply religious, but the religion is being weaponized. The witch uses faith to control. Rubel uses faith to hunt. And Eir? She's caught between both, using prayer as both shield and weapon. The world feels dangerous, beautiful, and suffocating all at once. I want to live here and I never want to leave.
... Read More
The line 'fragments of truth are better than fabricated lies' isn't just dialogue, it's basically the thesis statement of the entire novel. Eir says it to justify giving him 'Lu' instead of 'Rubel Shinote,' and she means it as damage control. But the story keeps proving that truth is more complicated than that. Consider the recurring imagery of seeds and sprouts. Rubel is planting crops while simultaneously being planted in Eir's life—rooting himself somewhere he doesn't belong, growing in soil that isn't his. Meanwhile Eir is trying to transplant him back to where he came from, but the longer he stays, the more he takes hold. There's also the graveyard scene with Hecate's blessing being erased—another act of removing something artificial so the dead can rest in truth. The novel keeps coming back to this idea that pretending creates suffering, and only honesty (even painful honesty) allows things to grow properly. And then there's the name itself. 'Rubel' carries the weight of empire, duty, and an identity he can't remember. 'Lu' is lighter, human, unburdened. But Eir keeps choosing the partial truth—not quite the lie, not quite the full truth. Is that compassion or cowardice? The story seems to be asking whether we're allowed to let people be who they want to be, or whether origins and duties define us regardless. Honestly it's giving me a lot to think about and I'm not even halfway through.
... Read More
Alright, real talk on pacing—this thing OPENS WITH A BANG. Like, page one we've got a woman pinned to a bed by a holy knight who is aggressively interrogating her by feeling her up. That's not a slow burn, that's a match being struck in a gasoline puddle. Immediate tension, immediate questions, immediate 'what is happening and why am I hooked.' Then the flashback to three years ago slides in smoothly. No jarring transition, just 'to explain how things reached this point...' and we're there. The mountain sequence moves at a good clip—she finds him, treats him, he wakes up and immediately starts praying like a maniac, she accidentally purifies the land with her out-of-control divine energy. That's a LOT of plot compressed into a relatively short space and it doesn't feel rushed because each beat has a clear purpose. The return to present with the villagers carrying him in is the comedic exhale after all that tension. Good rhythm. Tension-release-tension-release. But honestly? I wanted MORE of the present-day confrontation. The chapter ends with Eir basically accepting her fate—'To think the day would come when Rubel Shinote would end up lying on my bed'—and I'm sitting there like GIVE ME THE NEXT BEAT. The cliffhanger is functional but not especially punchy. It's more of a 'let's see what happens tomorrow' than a 'I need to scroll right now.' Overall though, the pacing holds up. No dragging, no filler, and the author knows when to compress time (the three years of hiding) versus when to slow down and linger (the intimate interrogation scene).
... Read More
I need to talk about the garden scene because I literally cannot. The way Eir trips, reaches out, HAND PLANTED RIGHT ON HIS CHEST, and he just—doesn't move. Doesn't make a joke. Doesn't say anything snide. Just grabs her wrist, says 'shh,' and then helps her up while talking about SEEDLINGS. Like bro, you had us both frozen in the most charged moment possible and you chose to worry about the Plants?? And Eir's internal monologue at that point is PRICELESS. She's thinking about some Baseless Gossip from three years ago about his capabilities while literally pressing her hand against his chest. The absolute state of her brain. 'Her face flushed furiously as her heart pounded uncontrollably. Unlike her racing heartbeat, his chest rose and fell steadily.' That contrast alone is everything. But here's what actually got me—the part where he says 'I decided to trust you anyway.' After everything, after she's been lying to his face this whole time about who he is, he still CHOSES to trust her. And she feels guilty about it. That's not just romantic tension, that's emotional weight. She's supposed to be using him, sending him away, but instead SHE'S the one getting tangled up. He's the one being noble and she's the one crumbling under the moral weight of it. Chef's kiss.
... Read More
Okay so let me just start by saying the plot structure in this stretch is genuinely masterful and I don't use that word lightly. We have this entire section built around one central question — does Rubel figure out what Eir really is? — and the author drags it out like a cat playing with a very nervous mouse. The scene where Mr. Linden wants to test Rubel's holy language skills? Chef's kiss. Because suddenly Eir's whole world is on the line, she's internally screaming, throwing herself into a performance of literacy that she barely pulls off, and you just KNOW something is going to blow. And then it DOESN'T blow, which is somehow even more tense. Because the reader is sitting there going 'it can't stay quiet forever.' That suspension of relief is where the real plot tension lives. Then you've got the subplot thread of the witch's letter — the one that arrives via owl with instructions to cut hair from someone with memory gaps. This is brilliant storytelling economy because it simultaneously answers a question (the witch is actually doing something) and raises three more (why hair? why memory gaps specifically? is Rubel going to cooperate?). The structure here works like dominoes falling into one another. And the ending of this passage — Eir creeping down the hallway toward Rubel's room while he's passed out drunk among bottles of her grandmother's ale — is a perfect act break. She's about to commit a violation of the most personal kind, and we're left hanging on whether she'll do it. The plot doesn't resolve anything here, which is exactly right. Every mini-climax either creates new complications or delays the inevitable confrontation.
... Read More
"It felt like countless glass bottles were falling from the sky, and he had the duty to catch them all. Each time someone died, those bottles shattered more and more, covering the ground with sharp fragments, and Rubel had no choice but to keep moving." This description of Rubel's burden is absolutely brutal and I haven't stopped thinking about it. The fact that he's been trained to not flinch, not stop, not even feel the cuts on his legs — that's not heroism, that's trauma weaponized into duty. And then the stakes escalate because Eir shows up and makes everything worse and better at the same time. The black mist attacking them? That moment where Rubel literally gives up and says 'it's fine' while being dragged to his death? I was SO mad at him. Not because he was being dramatic, but because he'd already decided his life was worth less than anyone else's. That's the thing that scared me most. But then Eir flips the script. She's hanging off his body, pulling him back, yelling at him like a lunatic — and somehow THAT's what brings him back to himself. Not divine power. Not a prayer. A chaotic, desperate woman refusing to let him die quietly. The magic circle at the grave, the ancient spell demanding human blood, the shadow mist that attacks divine energy specifically — the puzzle pieces are coming together and I am NOT okay with how much I care about whether they survive this.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter operate on at least three levels simultaneously, and that's what makes it so tense. Level one: surface stakes. Monsters are coming. Granny's grave might get corrupted. Eir needs to stop them. Simple enough. Level two: the Alupu pack itself. Eir has a dagger. She knows the killing technique — 'strike straight down from above, right in the center of the head. There's a tiny gap there' — but she's one person against a pack in a storm. The author makes you FEEL the odds by having her rehearse prayers backward instead of forward, which tells us everything about how much divine power she's holding back and how fragile her position is. Level three (the real one): what happens if Rubel finds out she's not just some naive village girl? She's hiding that Granny was a witch. She's hiding her own relationship with divine power. She's hiding how much she actually knows about this world. Every conversation between them is edged with the danger of exposure. The moment that elevated the stakes highest for me was when Eir was categorizing her emotions: 'Gratitude… embarrassment…. Was it something like that?' She can identify the physical danger perfectly fine, but the emotional danger — the growing something between her and this man who might at any moment realize she's lying to him — that's the real threat. And then Rubel's hand, covered in wounds from fighting with a broken axe, and Eir tending to it while he sleeps. Both of them hurt. Both of them hiding things. Both of them choosing to stay anyway. That's the thesis of the whole conflict — not 'will they survive the monsters' but 'will they survive being honest with each other?' The chapter doesn't resolve any of that. It just deepens it. And that's why I couldn't stop reading.
... Read More
I am not okay with how good the dialogue in this is. Let's start with the title quote because it's the perfect introduction to Rubel's voice: 'What kind of house only has an axe for a weapon?' This man fights through a pack of Alupu in a rainstorm and his FIRST COMPLAINT is about the available weaponry. That is character so efficiently rendered it hurts. 'Eir, doesn't living with him bother you at all? Even if you see him as a sibling, you're not actually related by blood.' Sibling, my foot. Eir's internal voice is SO distinct from her spoken voice. Outwardly she plays the naive girl, but internally she's sharp and sarcastic and completely done with everyone's nonsense. The gap between what she says and what she thinks is where the humor lives. The conversation about Granny's grave is where the dialogue does heavy lifting: 'Purification doesn't return things to their original state.' 'So what? Nature changes everything.' 'But that happens gradually. Purifying something tainted by darkness requires dramatic change. Granny's soul won't be able to remain there anymore.' This isn't just exposition. This is two people with fundamentally different worldviews colliding. Rubel thinks in terms of God's will and practical solutions. Eir thinks in terms of personal connections and permanence. And they're both RIGHT. His 'I came to save you' followed by the immediate deflection into 'Somehow, that's what happens when you live together' is the kind of dialogue that makes you slam the book shut and stare at the wall. He said the thing and then immediately pretended it was nothing. Classic Rubel. The narrative voice itself is also doing something special — it's close third person that slides between Eir's perspective and omniscient observation, sometimes staying inside her head for paragraphs, sometimes pulling back to describe Rubel's actions from outside. It never feels jarring because the transitions are seamless.
... Read More
Okay, so this batch is absolutely racking my brain. The plot here is doing this thing where it keeps pulling the rug out from under you, and I love it. Let me try to untangle what I think is happening because there are SO many layers. First, the obvious plot: Rubel Shinote is some kind of divine agent who infiltrated this village to hunt witches. He's supposed to be gathering information, watching people, finding this new witch who killed Hecate. But here's the thing—the plot keeps hinting that he's NOT just observing anymore. When he notices Eir's worn shoes? That's not mission-focused observation. That's someone who's actually STARTED to see a person instead of a subject. The witch plot is fascinating too. Hecate is dead, but her spell is still lingering. The new witch has been living in the village this whole time, manipulating people. And get this—Eir might be connected to her? Or maybe she's the culprit? The text says "could that woman really be the culprit?" which makes me wonder if Eir is more than she seems. But then again, Eir is terrified of being discovered. She's hiding something huge. The subplot with the holy language class is brilliant plotting. Mr. Linden is this patient teacher who finally sees Eir pronounce "Vurte" correctly after THREE YEARS. But Eir didn't learn it—she muttered a curse in the holy language when she saw Rubel. The plot twist here is that her "failure" was actually her true self breaking through. She's been pretending to be incompetent this whole time, but her magical nature is leaking out. And that ending with the knocking at the door? Chef's kiss. Someone's coming. Is it danger? Is it help? The plot is building this tension where everything feels like it's about to explode. My big question: Is Eir a witch? Is she innocent? Or is she playing both sides? And what's Rubel going to do when he discovers the truth?
... Read More
Oh my god, the Rubel and Eir dynamic in this batch is EVERYTHING and I am shook. Let me unpack why this relationship has me completely obsessed. On the surface, they're living together. She makes his sandwiches. He grumbles about food. It seems domestic, right? WRONG. Everything between them is loaded with double meanings and hidden agendas. Rubel is supposed to be her neighbor, but we KNOW he's some kind of divine hunter infiltrating the village. His internal monologue gives it away—"he had to monitor and understand." "What if she tripped over those worn shoes, causing a carriage accident and dying?" This is someone who's supposed to be detached, but he's already imagining scenarios where she's DEAD. That's not detachment, folks. That's obsession disguised as duty. But here's what breaks my heart—Eir. She's living with this man who's secretly hunting witches, and she's TERRIFIED. Not just of being discovered as a witch, but of HIM discovering her. When she sees him at the tutoring center, she mutters a curse in the holy language without thinking. Her true self leaks out. She can't even control her magical nature around him. The shoe detail killed me. Rubel notices her worn leather shoes about to fall apart. Why does this matter? Because he's STARTED to observe her as a person, not just a subject. He's noticing things that have nothing to do with the mission. And Eir? She's hyper-aware of him. She sits far away during festivals. She's terrified he'll hear her pray. Their entire relationship is built on mutual deception, but the deception is cracking. That moment when Mr. Linden gets excited about Eir finally pronouncing "Vurte"—and Rubel smoothly avoids his embrace saying "I just came to observe"—THIS is the tragedy. Rubel is trying to maintain his cover, but he's failing. He cares. He's failing to care on purpose, and it's tearing him apart. The relationship arc here is devastating. Two people who need each other but can't admit it. Two people who are dangerous to each other but drawn together. I'm screaming.
... Read More
Okay so first of all—can we just take a second to appreciate how many plot threads are being set up here? Like, I literally cannot catch my breath. You've got the mystery man showing up half-dead on her doorstep, the locked room with stones that absolutely should not be touched, the grandmother's curses and secrets, AND the revelation that our protagonist used to be a priestess with a very… particular… problem when she administers blessings? What even IS that? I'm not even going to unpack it because if I start speculating I will never stop. But what really got me is the structural tension in how the plot reveals information. It doesn't just dump everything at once—it layers it. First, the locks. She spent the NIGHT locking that door, and he opens it before noon like it's nothing. Then Alf shows up and his attitude COMPLETELY shifts because of the grandmother's spell. The story makes you feel Eir's panic in real time because WE don't fully understand what's happening either—we're just as confused as she is about why Alf suddenly thinks this stranger is her grandfather's grandson or whatever delusion the magic fed him. That's brilliant misdirection. The grandmother built a house of secrets and now every character who enters it starts acting according to whatever cursed logic governs this place. And then—the blessing incident. "An odd moan escaped from the one being blessed." The way the narrative pivots from pure survival horror into THIS realm of tension? I literally gasped. The plot isn't just moving forward, it's diving deeper into completely new territory every time I think I understand what kind of story this is. Is it dark fantasy? Psychological horror? Romance-adjacent tension? It's ALL of them, and that tonal flexibility is what makes it so addictive.
... Read More
Can we talk about the sensory writing in this book because it is NOT wasting any words? Let me just pull a couple moments that hit different. The opening scene: 'A room without a lit candle.' Three words. Dark, tense, isolated. You immediately know something is wrong. Then the light 'seeping through the half-open door' gives you just enough visibility to be uncomfortable—you're seeing this like a voyeur, which is exactly the vibe the author wants. And the mountain scene where Eir finds Rubel—'his red hair like his was rare. So were his strikingly noble features, unforgettable to anyone who had seen them.' The author is basically telling us this man is visually significant without just saying 'he was handsome.' Show, don't tell, and it lands. The cabin itself feels like a real place. You can picture it—Eir mixing herbs, blood-soaked bandages piling up 'like a mountain,' water turning deep red in the basin. These are domestic, grounded details that make the fantasy element feel earned rather than decorative. The Divine Empire's presence is felt even though we're in a remote village. Rubel's prayers in the 'sacred tongue,' the mention of the capital, the flower petals raining during triumphal returns—these fragments build a world that feels larger than the page. You know this empire has history, politics, and religion, and they all press against this small mountain setting like tide against a rock. Also the visual of Rubel finally waking up and immediately resuming his investigation like 'where is it? where is it?' while Eir is trying not to die of embarrassment—this is cinematic. I can literally see this as a frame-by-frame sequence.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or