Don’t Be Holy! - Reviews

Don’t Be Holy!
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Can we just take a moment for Eir? Because this character is absolutely falling apart and the book makes you feel every single crack in real time. She's a former priest who has betrayed her faith, is hiding her true identity, and now has this man living in her house who seems to sense something is wrong but hasn't fully figured it out yet. The psychological toll of this is written into her body — the cold sweats, the nightmares, the way she has to physically stop herself from reaching for forbidden spells. But what wrecked me was the scene where she's praying to an upside-down divine emblem. Think about the imagery: this woman who once knew how to channel divine energy now has to reorient her entire spiritual practice just to access power again. She's compromising her beliefs, her safety, and her sanity all at once. And then she prays "Thank you for giving me an answer so I don't stray down the wrong path" to an unknown recipient — meaning the witch, meaning something outside her faith — and you realize how far she's already drifted. The most devastating moment for me though was watching her try to be rational about Rubel. She's calculating whether she can knock him unconscious, whether she can use witch magic, whether she can manipulate the situation. She's treating her own survival as a series of tactical decisions while the emotional cost accumulates like unread messages. And the fact that she still follows him home that evening, still engages with him, still let him walk backward toward her while she sweated through her shirt — she's trapped in this relationship she didn't choose and can't escape. The book doesn't give you catharsis here. It gives you a woman moving through a nightmare with her eyes open, and that's somehow worse.
... Read More
I need to talk about Rubel because this character is doing something genuinely fascinating and I'm not sure I have the vocabulary for it. On the surface, he's this amnesiac nobleman who just showed up and is learning holy language from scratch, but read the details: he deliberately chooses the smallest, most isolated room in the house. He drinks grandmother's alcohol in private. He whispers prayers that are clearly coded messages to Eir and then walks away like nothing happened. And when she calls him out on waiting for her outside, his response is 'Did you think I was waiting for Otis?' — which is not a denial. The relationship between these two has this incredible double layer. To everyone else, they're just... living together, having odd interactions. But underneath, Eir is terrified he knows her secret and Rubel is testing her constantly through prayer verses that function as both religious instruction and personal accusation. The moment where he walks backward while looking at her, noticing she said 'vurte' instead of 'volte,' is pure character revelation — he's observant, he's patient, and he's been collecting inconsistencies the way a detective collects clues. And then there's the drunk scene at the end. Someone who functions at peak competence during the day collapses into alcoholic oblivion at night. What is he running from? His own memories, maybe. Or maybe the realization that Eir is lying to him about everything and he doesn't want to face it yet. Their dynamic right now is this suffocating dance where neither can move forward or backward without exposing something catastrophic.
... Read More
Let's talk stakes, because they are MOUNTING. On the surface level, Eir has taken in a member of the enemy military—literally the commander leading the Divine Empire's campaign against witches—and she's hiding him in her grandmother's house, which is apparently cursed, full of forbidden rooms and magical traps. That's bad enough. But then there's the deeper conflict: Eir herself is caught between two worlds. She's a priestess of the Divine Empire, which means she's supposed to hunt witches, but she saved a witch (her grandmother) and now lives in a house built by that witch's magic. She's a traitor to her order and a guest in a dead woman's curse, with nowhere else to go. The external conflict is immediate and visceral: the man claims not to remember who he is, but the narration tells us he's LYING. So either he's playing dumb to figure out why he was found in her house, or he genuinely doesn't know and something worse is going on. Meanwhile, Alf arrives and the grandmother's spell already starts warping his perception. How long before someone ELSE comes looking for this man? The Divine Empire wouldn't just let their commander disappear, and if they find out he's in a witch's house being cared for by a disgraced priestess—what then? And let's not forget the most dangerous conflict of all: Eir's secret. The chapter ends with the revelation that her divine blessings cause involuntary pleasure in those she touches. This isn't just embarrassing—it's terrifying in a world where she's already on the wrong side of authority. If this gets out, if the Divine Empire finds out their priestesses are producing… whatever that was… what happens to her? To anyone she's blessed? The stakes aren't just personal anymore, they're existential. The text says: "How much longer would she have to live righteously while drowning in shame?" That line encapsulates everything. She's been failing at being good, at being accepted, at being safe. And now she's brought a war criminal into her home, activated her grandmother's curses, and暴露了一个足以毁掉她一切的秘密. There is no going back from this. Every conflict in this chapter is accelerating toward a collision that I am absolutely NOT ready for.
... Read More
The stakes in this section are absolutely ferocious and I want to emphasize how the author layers them. On the surface level, Eir is a priest who has fallen from grace and is hiding in a village. Simple enough. But then you add Rubel into the equation and suddenly every interaction is a potential death sentence for her. He has divine energy. He knows prayers. He's observant in a way that nobody else in this village seems to be. The worst part is that Eir knows she's walking a razor's edge and she keeps walking it. In the classroom scene, she's internally preparing for her head to roll while externally performing enthusiasm for learning letters she supposedly couldn't read before. She manipulates Otis into asking Rubel to read, she volunteers answers faster than anyone has ever heard her speak, and she does it all while sweating through what must have been the most stressful twenty minutes of her life. And Mr. Linden — sweet, oblivious Mr. Linden — thinks she's having a breakthrough. But the stakes escalate beyond just exposure. The witch's letter introduces a new variable: Eir is now actively seeking magical solutions, including potentially summoning monsters or using forbidden spells. She caught herself searching grandmother's books and had to physically stop and pray to redirect herself. This is character erosion happening in real time — every solution she considers makes her less of the person she was trying to protect. And Rubel's prayer verses aren't just threats, they're accusations wrapped in scripture. 'Those who feed on others' blood and sweat shall receive the greatest punishment.' 'Violation is the greatest betrayal.' He's not just suspecting her — he's narrating her crimes back to her in the language of her own faith.
... Read More
There's some genuinely interesting thematic material buried under all the comedy here and I think the author knows it even if they're playing it for laughs. The central metaphor is pretty bold: Eir's body is literally dangerous to others. Her divine power—something meant to bless and heal—causes involuntary physiological responses in people. She's been in hiding not just because she's a fugitive, but because her very existence is a threat to the sacred order. Touch her, bless her, and the most disciplined holy knights lose control. That's a powerful image for anything about women's bodies being simultaneously worshipped and feared. Then you've got Rubel, the man who CANNOT be affected. His purity isn't just a quirk—it's his armor against a world that would use his body as a weapon. He's the only one who can touch her without consequence, which makes him both the most dangerous person near her and the only safe one. That's not accidental writing, that's theme doing heavy lifting. The curse of forgetting is another layer. Eir is literally erased from memory—which is the ultimate form of invisibility, especially for a woman whose power comes through physical contact. She can't be remembered, can't be claimed, can't belong. And yet her body speaks louder than any memory ever could. The title itself, Romance Guide, is almost ironic given that this story seems to be about the collision between institutional holiness (the Divine Empire, the temple, Rubel's vows) and the messy, uncontrollable reality of human bodies. The guide isn't teaching romance—it's documenting a collision course.
... Read More
Okay so this whole setup is genuinely clever. Eir is basically running on fumes here—she's a fugitive from the temple, her lifespan is already shortened from whatever divine punishment she took, AND she's hiding a man who is literally the most famous knight in the empire. What could possibly go wrong? Everything, obviously. But the real plot meat is how the story slowly peels back who Rubel actually is. You've got this whole mystery wrapper—memory loss, mysterious injury, knights wiped out—but then there are THESE moments where he just snaps back into 'Lord Rubel Shinote' mode and it's terrifying. Like that lightning strike scene where his gaze changes and he looks like the Holy Knight again. The author is playing with dramatic irony so well here. We KNOW he's more than 'Ru' or 'Lu,' and Eir knows too, but the villagers are just over there like 'yeah Lucas sounds good bro.' Also love how Eir keeps trying to push him away logically—go find your parents, go back to the temple, I'm just a debtor—but the plot keeps forcing them together. First the gods punish her lies, now she can't even rid herself of the source of her problems. Classic narrative tightening.
... Read More
"Haam." That's the only sound he makes when he wakes up. One syllable and I was already obsessed. Not because it's romantic—well, okay maybe a little—but because it's so HUMAN. This guy who's apparently the greatest knight in the Divine Empire, the one leading their frontlines against witches, shows up making animal noises like a regular person who just woke up in a stranger's house. And Eir? She's so flustered. She's YELLING about soup and locks and lies and I swear to god I was screaming internally. The scene where she grabs him by the collar—"You!"—and her face is twisted with anger but her voice is trembling with fear? That's not just tension, that's the most honest emotional moment in the entire chapter. She's scared of him, she's scared of what he represents (the enemy empire, the danger he brings), but she's also… curious? Protective? I don't know what it is but it's there, bubbling under every hostile word she says. And then the grandmother flashback hits you like a truck. Reading about how Eir came to this house—half-dead, running away from everything, finding an old witch being attacked by three others—and how she HELPED anyway, even though she knew it was dangerous. That moment when she passed out muttering about respecting the elderly? I literally sobbed. This girl who has lost everything, who feels like her entire life has been a series of wrong turns and shameful moments, still chose kindness. She still chose to save someone. The text explicitly says: "It was as if she understood Eir's despair—the way her future seemed bleak, how even breathing and eating felt burdensome." And that breaks me. The grandmother saw her. Saw her. Not as a priestess, not as a disgrace, just as a tired girl who needed somewhere to land. That's the emotional core of this whole thing—the idea that two broken people found each other across different timelines, and now Eir is dealing with the consequences of that kindness. Also CAN WE TALK ABOUT THE MOAN THING. I am not ready. I am not ready at all.
... Read More
I have to talk about the dialogue in this passage because it's doing such sophisticated work and I'm honestly impressed. Let me start with the Eir-Rubel exchanges because they're electric. Look at this exchange: "Were you waiting for me?" / "Did you think I was waiting for Otis?" That's it. That's the whole thing. Two lines and you get so much — Rubel's dry humor, his awareness of how ridiculous the situation looks, the fact that he WAS waiting for her but won't admit it directly, and Eir's genuine confusion mixed with suspicion. The subtext is so dense you could carve bread on it. Then there's the prayer scene where he whispers that verse and she jumps like she's been electrocuted, and his follow-up is this incredibly casual "What's with those hands?" as if he didn't just watch her have a visceral religious trauma response. The banter between them has this razor edge — she's always deflecting, always fighting back with nonsense arguments, and he's always pushing just enough to make her uncomfortable without crossing into outright confrontation. Mr. Linden's voice is a masterclass in creating distinct character speech patterns. His enthusiastic exclamation — "Oh! My goodness, that's close, child. It's 'Abrol,' Abrol! Oh Lord, my word." — immediately tells us he's devout, emotional, slightly chaotic, and completely invested in his students. Otis's mumbled "Hey! Uh, bro! Can you read this character?" contrasts perfectly, showing a teenage boy who'd rather be anywhere else but is bribed into participation. And Rubel's dialogue is almost always understated, which makes it punch harder. "I may know how to recite prayers, but I'm not sure if I remember how to read the letters." Delivered flatly, while secretly being the most literate person in the room. The man speaks in minimum viable sentences and each one carries weight.
... Read More
I need a minute. The way Eir climbs up Rubel like a tree. The way he feels her breath on his neck and his hand twitches like he wants to hold her instead of push her away. The way she throws the knife with him as her platform, completely trusting that he won't drop her, and for once in his life he doesn't. 'I told you. I'm good at throwing knives.' Bro. You're wrapped around a holy knight's neck in midair, being dragged toward an ancient curse, and your confidence is THAT solid. I love her. I hate that I love her. I'm obsessed. And then she lets go of him to throw the dagger, the mist loosens just enough, they start falling — and he shakes her off to protect her, takes the hit himself. Classic. Absolutely classic move. But she doesn't let him have that sacrifice. No, she throws HERSELF at the grave instead because apparently she has a one-upmanship problem when it comes to self-destruction. Now he's unconscious dreaming about alternate timelines where he never softened for her. Of course. Of COURSE. The universe is playing 4D chess with these two and I am here for it. Also the line 'You're going to save me?' and her response 'Just watch.' with eyes flashing? I'm not breathing.
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is what sold me. Rubel's voice is so distinct — short, clipped, barely hiding whatever emotion is underneath. 'What do you mean it's fine!' and his response is just... 'I'll give you the benefit of the doubt that this isn't your doing, so let go.' Deadpan in the middle of a life-or-death situation. That's not coldness, that's a love language. Eir on the other hand? She talks in bursts. She interrupts herself, contradicts herself, argues with people who aren't even talking back. 'Th-this is a misunderstanding! I didn't untie that rope, I just came because I was worried about Sarah…… I was going to stay still like you said!' — the frantic energy, the pathetic excuses piling on top of each other, the sheer volume of words coming out when she's terrified? Real. So real. And then there's the narration. The author shifts between Rubel's tight, analytical POV and Eir's more emotional, reactive inner monologue, and you can feel the difference. When it's Rubel's head, everything is sharp edges and observation. When it's Eir's, it's all sensation and impulse. That contrast IS the chemistry. 'Hah.' — just that one sound he makes when Eir explains she fell while tied up trying to keep her promise. No words. Just a breath that contains an entire conversation. I wish I could write like that.
... Read More
There are some scenes in this book that just hit different and the final one — Eir walking down that dark hallway to Rubel's room — is absolutely cinematic. Let me paint it because the author does it so well: dark corridor, only moonlight coming through the windows, six or seven steps that feel like an eternity. Her heartbeat is thundering in her ears. She's tiptoeing in her nightgown like some kind of desperate, guilt-ridden thief entering the lair of the very person she's trying to protect herself against. And then the smell hits her. Not danger. Not a weapon. Alcohol. The subversion of expectation in that sensory detail is gorgeous — you expect the room of a suspicious amnesiac to smell like mystery or menace, but it smells like stale brew and poor life choices. The bottles everywhere, specifically grandmother's bottles, tells us so much about this household and its hidden histories without a single exposition dump. But the real worldbuilding win here is the owl. Not just 'an owl delivered a letter' but an owl that looks exactly like the one drawn on the envelope, which means the witch's magic has this specific visual signature. The fact that it disappears the moment the envelope is opened — no dramatic flight, just gone — makes the magical system feel precise and lived-in. This isn't a world where magic is vague and wobbly; it has rules and aesthetics. The upside-down divine emblem in Eir's room, the way she has to physically contort herself to pray despite being a former practitioner, the cold sweat and the nightmares — all of these details build a world where faith isn't abstract but physical, where your relationship with God leaves marks on your body.
... Read More
The sensory details in this section are INSANE. Let me just... 'Rain poured down as if someone were emptying water from above' — okay that's not even a fancy metaphor, that's just how it FEELS. You're right there with Eir, soaked to the bone, thunder shaking the ground, magic lamp casting everything in this sickly yellow light. And then the Alupu scene: 'In the silver-tinted forest, her eyes met blood-red ones.' One sentence. That's all it takes. Silver and red. Predator and prey. Your heart stops. But the REAL masterpiece is Rubel appearing. Lightning flashes, and suddenly there's this 'crimson-dark head moving in the distance, raising a sharp axe.' Then 'thwack. An Alupu's body was instantly split in half.' The rhythm of those onomatopoeias — thwack, thwack — it's mechanical. Almost industrial. This isn't a fight, it's slaughter. And the narration refuses to look away from it even when Eir does: 'The sight was so horrific even in the dim magic lamp light that Eir quietly turned her gaze away.' The burning corpses scene is another level. 'The smell of burning monsters after so long made her cough.' 'A pungent smell like burning oil spread through the room instantly.' You can SMELL this chapter. The wet earth, the monster essence, the rain, the herbs, the blood — it's overwhelming in the best way. And the contrast between the violent outdoor scenes and the intimate indoor scene where she's wrapping his wounds, steam rising from his body while she's shivering in a blanket — the temperature play is deliberate. Hot and cold, fire and rain, violence and tenderness all in one house.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or