Deliberate Fall - Reviews

Deliberate Fall
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about the absolute genius of the test paper subplot. Song Ji'an finds Sheng Jia's forgotten stack of exams on the playground, decides to deliver them, takes the shortcut through the abandoned clearing, and accidentally witnesses the entire Xu Lijing/Sheng Jia confrontation. This is such clean plotting. The test papers aren't just a convenient MacGuffin—they're a literal and metaphorical bridge. They connect Sheng Jia to the second-year classroom, Song Ji'an to that world, and eventually lead to the whole Xu Lijing backstory being unpacked. Without those papers, Song Ji'an would never have gone to the clearing, never overheard anything, never sat down on those cement steps for the most important conversation of the story so far. And then there's the parallel structure I can't stop thinking about. Two girls, both dealing with injustice, both with their own theories about how the world should work. Song Ji'an asks Sheng Jia, "If you were Xu Lijing, what would you do?" and Sheng Jia says she'd beat the girl harder. But then later she admits that's a lie—and what she'd actually do is remember the humiliation and wait for the perfect moment to bite back. Dormancy is her true nature, the chapter title says. The fact that the author makes us hear Sheng Jia's stated philosophy and then immediately undermine it in the same breath? That's plot craftsmanship right there. The story doesn't just tell you who these characters are—it makes them contradict themselves, and that contradiction IS the plot.
... Read More
The marathon metaphor is doing SO much heavy lifting in this section and I need to unpack it. A marathon isn't a sprint. It's endurance. It's knowing the route so well that your body remembers it even when your mind is tired. Sheng Jia says she knows every street in Jingjiang because as a kid she had nowhere else to go — she wandered endlessly, afraid to come home. The city itself became her shelter, and now that same city is the course she'll run. Symbolically, that's devastating. She found somewhere she belongs not because someone welcomed her, but because she had nowhere else. And Song Ji'an, who has resources and family and a name that opens doors, is trying to earn her own worth through this marathon and this scholarship gesture. Two girls, opposite ends of the spectrum, both running toward something they're not sure they're allowed to have. The line "she hoped that she could be more ruthless when facing Song Ji'an in the future" — that's the thematic core right there. Sheng Jia knows that vulnerability is a liability in her world, but Song Ji'an makes it impossible to stay armored. Every chapter is another crack in the shell.
... Read More
"The expression on her face was still very cold, but the corners of her lips slightly curved in a place where Song Ji'an couldn't see." I need to just sit with this sentence for a moment. This is the kind of detail that tells you everything about Sheng Jia's character and her relationship with Song Ji'an in a single gesture. She just had a vulnerable, almost confessional moment with someone—she let Song Ji'an see her cry in front of Xu Lijing, she explained her past, she admitted she was lying about what she'd do in that café situation. And the second Song Ji'an isn't looking, she allows herself to smile. Why? I think it's because Song Ji'an is the one person Sheng Jia can be honest with without fear. The smile isn't happiness—it's something more complicated. Relief, maybe. Or the satisfaction of being seen and not rejected. Song Ji'an didn't run away when she heard the whole truth. She sat on those same steps Xu Lijing had just left and asked questions with genuine curiosity, not judgment. And Sheng Jia, who is used to handling everything alone, got to share something for once. But it's also deeply sad, because that smile exists only in the blind spot. Song Ji'an never knows about it. She walks away thinking Sheng Jia was cold and dismissive, when in reality the coldest exterior in the book just cracked open for exactly three seconds. That gap between what Song Ji'an perceives and what actually happened—that's the emotional core of their entire relationship. One girl sees a wall. The other girl is building something behind it that she doesn't know how to name.
... Read More
Let me be clear about something: the stakes in this book are not whether these two girls will end up together or not. The stakes are whether Sheng Jia can maintain her dignity while surviving. Every interaction with Song Ji'an raises the tension because Sheng Jia is constantly negotiating between acceptance and self-preservation. When Song Ji'an waits for her after work, Sheng Jia could just say no and walk home. She doesn't — not because she's weak, but because she's exhausted and the CDC is far and the night is dark. The tetanus shot scene is where this conflict peaks. Sheng Jia has been bleeding. She needs medical care. And she chooses the cheapest option because five hundred yuan is a week of her life, maybe more, and Song Ji'an — sweet, oblivious, rich Song Ji'an — offers to pay without even realizing the enormity of that gesture to someone in Sheng Jia's position. The look Sheng Jia gives her after Song Ji'an mentions the price? Chilling. Not because she's angry at Song Ji'an, but because she's trapped in a system where accepting kindness feels like losing. Meanwhile, Song Ji'an has her own conflict — her mother's absence, Auntie Zhao's death, the pressure to be "well-behaved and sensible." She runs away from a goodbye dinner because she can't face going straight home to an empty villa. These two girls are both lonely, but their loneliness comes from opposite directions, and that's what makes their collision so compelling. The author maintains tension throughout by never letting either girl fully understand the other's world, even as they get closer. And that's exactly how it should be.
... Read More
The central tension of these chapters isn't between Song Ji'an and Sheng Jia, or even Xu Lijing and Sheng Jia. It's between two ways of being in a cruel world. Song Ji'an represents one philosophy: handle things quickly, directly, openly. Beat the person who hurt you today. Speak your truth now. Don't let resentment fester. Xu Lijing embodies this instinctively—she fought at the café, she confronted Sheng Jia on the spot, she cried and raged and demanded fairness in real time. Sheng Jia represents the opposite. Dormancy. Waiting. Remembering every slight and choosing the moment to strike with maximum precision. "Sometimes violence may be more useful than human words, and some truths can't be reasoned with," she says, and it's not just about physical violence—it's about emotional strategy. She doesn't explode. She preserves. She lets the other person think they've won, and then she dismantles them. What fascinates me is that the story doesn't declare one approach superior. Song Ji'an calls Sheng Jia's way chilling, and Sheng Jia calls Song Ji'an's way naive—but both are clearly reacting to their own histories. Song Ji'an has never needed to wait because nothing bad has happened to her that required patience. Sheng Jia has never been allowed to be direct because directness got her hurt before. The grandmother is the symbol that binds both philosophies together. Xu Lijing's explosion is grief for her grandmother. Sheng Jia's dormancy is protection against the kind of loss that took Xu Lijing's grandmother. Two responses to the same human condition: the world is unfair, and you either meet it head-on or you lie in wait. The story seems to suggest that neither approach is wrong, but each comes with its own kind of exhaustion.
... Read More
I have strong feelings about the dialogue in this batch, and mostly they're positive. Song Ji'an's voice is distinct — she's warm, slightly clumsy, persistent in a way that feels genuine rather than manufactured. Her lines never sound like a rich girl trying to sound relatable. When she says "Sorry, sorry, I'm not very familiar with the new car," after crashing into a trash can, it's perfectly in character. She's not performing; she's just herself, even when she's being ridiculous. Sheng Jia's dialogue is sparser, which works because her character speaks through action more than words. But when she does talk, it cuts: "You don't want to go home, and you happened to see me, so you want to find something to do for yourself?" This line is devastating in its accuracy. She sees right through Song Ji'an's excuse, and instead of being offended, Song Ji'an literally gets on the scooter and says "Then I'll trouble Student Sheng Jia to take me for a few laps." The supporting characters are interesting too. Auntie Zhou nags with actual warmth — "An'an, why didn't you answer the phone... I was so worried, I almost called Song Ningqiu" — and you immediately understand this is someone who loves Song Ji'an genuinely. Auntie Liu, the driver/bodyguard, is silent and professional, almost ghostlike. And that night nurse at the CDC who looks up at Sheng Jia but "didn't ask any more questions" — that single detail says everything about how this healthcare worker has seen enough to know not to judge. The author's narrative voice is mostly restrained, which suits the material. There are moments of dry humor that land perfectly, like the internal monologue about Song Ji'an's riding skills crumbling three minutes into the scooter ride.
... Read More
There is a monkey in this story and I think we are supposed to take it seriously. Danggui is sixteen years old, which in monkey years is ancient. She has white fur around her eyes but otherwise looks young — eight or nine years old, the narrator says. She is wild, untamed, bares her teeth at people. But she comes to Sheng Jia. She takes the pear from Sheng Jia's hand. She sits beside her on the threshold in the rain. And Master Feng says: "She actually likes you quite a bit." This is not accidental symbolism. Sheng Jia is like Danggui — guarded, selective about who she lets close, appearing cold to most people. But there is something about her that draws certain creatures (and people) in. She does not chase. She does not perform warmth. She simply exists, and the right ones find their way to her. The rain itself is doing thematic work. It starts raining the morning Sheng Jia goes to the temple with her mother. It is still raining when she leaves. A car splashes her with muddy water — and the narration explicitly says: "This will evoke some bad memories for her, making her unable to help but frown." The rain is not just weather. It is the environment of her interior life — damp, persistent, hard to shake off. Then there is the lathe — the osmanthus-flavored rice wine latte that appears every day at noon on Song Ji'an's desk. Osmanthus is a flower associated with autumn, with nostalgia, with things that are fragrant but distant. Song Ji'an smells it every day. Sheng Jia notices. Neither of them says anything about it for chapters. This is the central metaphor of the book in miniature: two people circling something sweet and unspoken, aware of each other's presence but never quite naming it. And Sheng Huaiying's QR-code Buddhism — praying to whatever is closest while scanning to pay — is the book's commentary on how modern people use tradition as a tool rather than a belief. But Sheng Jia? She doesn't pray at all. She sits on the threshold. She watches the rain. She doesn't ask anything of anyone. That is either strength or emptiness and the book seems unsure which.
... Read More
Okay so I have to talk about how this whole arc from the Xu Lijing scandal through the monthly exams is structured because wow. The way the author threads the scandal through the exam period is honestly genius. Think about it — most stories would either resolve the scandal before the exams or make the exams totally irrelevant. But here? The classmates are literally complaining that they didn't get to enjoy the gossip fully because the exam came first. That detail alone tells you everything about how grounded this world is — students care about drama AND grades, both at once. Then the dinner scene at the high-altitude restaurant happens, and somehow the plot keeps feeding you more. Su Zhaolin appears out of nowhere with some dramatic confrontation with a glamorous woman, chases her out with champagne, and then vanishes. I was left SO MANY QUESTIONS. Who is that woman? What did Su Zhaolin do? Is this connected to anything bigger? The author doesn't explain any of it — just shows it happening and moves on like, yeah that happened, next. And then the night ride. Two girls on an electric scooter, circling the highway, neither speaking until Sheng Jia reaches her neighborhood. That's not a plot twist, that's a plot EXPLOSION disguised as nothing happening at all. The way the author uses silence as a narrative device here — the driving around and around mirrors Sheng Jia's internal spiraling — is exactly the kind of thing that makes me want to re-read three times. My only gripe? I want to know what happens next with the scandal fallout. The monthly exam is over but the underlying tensions haven't resolved. That's good tension though, right? That's the author keeping the hook in my gut.
... Read More
"Sheng Jia by day and Sheng Jia by night seemed like two different people, one cold and aloof, the other cold but understanding." I keep coming back to this line. Two DIFFERENT kinds of cold. That distinction matters more than the author probably intends. By day she's the unreachable top student who tells Song Ji'an 'we're not familiar enough for you to share snacks with me.' Brutal. Clean. Effective. By night she's communicating with a mysterious handler, orchestrating something involving Xu Lijing, checking calendars marked with release dates. Who is she actually protecting — or punishing? And the mother-daughter dynamic?? Sheng Huaiying is possibly one of the most realistically written flawed parents I've read. She puts a plate of pears outside Sheng Jia's room like some tentative peace offering, and Sheng Jia's response is to leave a hundred yuan bill — half her paycheck — on the couch. Not gratitude. Not love. A TRANSACTION. She literally reframes maternal care as a商业 exchange because it's safer than acknowledging she wanted those pears. The backstory about Sheng Huaiying going crazy with a kitchen knife to protect Sheng Jia from Wang Jian's violence — that's the ONLY time the mother looks like a hero. Everything else is neglect, laziness, obsession with face and mahjong. And Sheng Jia KNOWS this. She understands it too well. 'Choosing the wrong path when young needed a vent.' She literally theorizes about her own mother's psychology instead of just feeling angry. That's how deeply wounded she is. Then there's Song Ji'an, bouncing around with milk candies and red envelopes, completely unread Sheng Jia's signals. I want to shake her. But also... I get why Sheng Jia pushes her away. You don't let people close when you're carrying this much.
... Read More
Let's talk about atmosphere because this author really knows how to paint a scene. The story starts with Sheng Jia looking up at a clear, beautiful sky but feeling terrible. Instant contrast—external beauty vs internal turmoil. That's set early. Then we're in the back street, all tension and violence, but described with such clarity. The alley, the wounded girls, the pocket watch glinting—that's cinematic. But what I loved more is the shift to the school. Walking with Song Ji'an, 'green shade above their heads casting patch after patch of shadows. Sunlight broke through the leaves and sprinkled on their bodies and faces.' Just pure imagery. It's not overdone; it mirrors their relationship—dappled light, hidden depths, but warmth. The Elite Class 1 Senior Three is introduced with details about homework piles, difficult test papers, the competitive yet isolated atmosphere. It feels real, like a pressure cooker. And the infirmary scene—brief, clinical, but Sheng Jia's bleeding hand against the white sheets? Symbolic of her hidden wounds. The world feels lived-in, not just a backdrop. Every location reflects character states. I want to live in this school.
... Read More
The dialogue in this book is absolutely razor-sharp. Let me just drop some highlights: "Aren't you afraid?" — Sheng Huaiying, barely above a whisper, after mentioning her husband's release date. Three words that carry a lifetime of terror and regret and love and failure all wrapped into one question she's been dying to ask for years. "He's coming out in a year." / "I know. So?" — The most devastating exchange in the entire chapter. Sheng Jia's 'So?' says everything: I'm not afraid, I've made my plans, I won't be here when you get out. It's not defiance — it's survival. "I just want to resolve the conflict between us. I don't want her causing me trouble in the future." — Sheng Jia to [R]. Read that again. 'Resolve the conflict.' That is the most calculated, chilling way to phrase whatever vengeance she's plotting. She sounds like a corporate lawyer, not a high school student. "Scum should stay in prison and reflect for the rest of their lives." — Narration, but feels like it could be her manifesto. No ambiguity. No mercy. Just absolute moral certainty. And Song Ji'an's voice is such a contrast — bubbly, generous, oblivious. 'Auntie Zhou made these, want to try some?' vs. Sheng Jia's frozen rejection. The author gives each character a completely distinct verbal fingerprint, and you never confuse who's speaking. The narrative voice itself is interesting — it's detached enough to observe Sheng Jia clinically but sharp enough to catch every micro-expression. The toothpick gripping scene where Sheng Huaiying's hand goes numb? That's not dialogue, that's visual storytelling at its finest. And the author doesn't need words for that.
... Read More
Okay so let me just... take a second. The reveal at the end of this batch. Song Ji'an has been sitting on this thing this entire time. She's been writing that ‘project report' at the café, all serious and focused, and Sheng Jia literally walked in on data about bonuses in those documents and immediately connected it to the mysterious scholarship sponsor. That's a sharp girl. And then the final line — ‘The mysterious enterprise, is it your family?' — absolute gut punch. Like, we knew something was going on, but we didn't know it was THIS specific thing. The way Sheng Jia asks it so flatly, without the usual edge, makes it even more intense. She's not accusing her angrily, she's just… assessing. Calculating whether this changes what she knows about Song Ji'an. And Song Ji'an's surprise that Sheng Jia figured it out so easily? That says everything about how much attention Sheng Jia pays to her now, even when she pretends she doesn't. The marathon subplot tying into all this — the financial pressure, the desire to be useful, the desire to prove herself — it's all one web. I'm genuinely intrigued about what happens next when they actually HAVE to talk about this instead of orbiting around it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or