Deliberate Fall - Reviews

Deliberate Fall
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Can we just take a moment to appreciate the electric scooter as the central symbol of this entire story? Song Ji'an bought it after studying for three whole days, and it cost her three million — wait, no, thirty thousand. Thirty thousand yuan for her, which is apparently nothing. For Sheng Jia, that same amount represents six months of night shifts cleaning hotel suites that each cost five figures per night. The scooter is simultaneously a toy and a lifeline, a gift and a reminder of everything that separates them. And then there's the door in the hotel. I keep coming back to this image. Sheng Jia sees Song Ji'an through a crack in the door, surrounded by laughing friends, and that door literally represents the barrier between their worlds. Behind closed doors: warmth, money, ease. In the hallway: work, exhaustion, survival. The cheapest vaccine at the CDC is another brutal little symbol. Song Ji'an offers five hundred yuan earlier and Sheng Jia chooses the ten-yuan option. She won't accept charity, she won't even accept kindness that might come with strings attached. And Song Ji'an's face — that hesitation, that question written all over her features: "If I help Sheng Jia pay for it, will she be angry?" This book understands class dynamics better than half the novels out there. It's not just "rich girl helps poor girl." It's about dignity, about what kind of help can actually be accepted without shame, about how the wealthy genuinely cannot comprehend the calculus of someone who counts every single yuan.
... Read More
I need to talk about the pear scene because my heart literally cracked. Sheng Huaiying leaves a plate of sliced pears in the fridge for her daughter. Just... a plate of pears. No note, no words, just the quiet gesture of someone who doesn't know how to say anything else. And Sheng Jia sees it and thinks: "She seemed to see the maternal love that she had craved but rarely received as a child." CRAVED. Not wanted. CRAVED. And what does she do? She takes the pears, eats them quietly on the sofa, and leaves exactly one hundred yuan on the couch for her mother. Half her wage from that night's work. She converts love into a receipt. She turns care into a ledger entry so she never has to admit she needed it. I literally had to put the book down. And then immediately picked it back up because I'm obsessed. Meanwhile there's this whole undercurrent of romantic possibility with Song Ji'an that Sheng Jia is systematically crushing. That girl sends her a pink pig profile picture, gives her twenty yuan in red envelopes, offers homemade candies, and gets shut down every single time. "We're not familiar enough for you to share snacks with me." Oof. The cruelty isn't mean — it's protective. Sheng Jia can't afford to need anyone. Can't afford distraction. Can't afford the vulnerability that comes with connection. The tragedy is that she's seventeen, preparing for the most important exam of her life, living with a mother she barely knows, carrying secrets she can't share, and her only warmth comes from a plate of pears she pays for like a stranger.
... Read More
I need to talk about this beach scene because WOW. The author really knows how to paint a picture and I was completely transported. Let me just quote this because it deserves it: "The seawater at night was also surging onto the beach with the tide. Tonight there was a beautiful moon, shining on the sea surface, creating shimmering waves. The daytime heat was well dissipated by the seawater at night. They sat by the sea with a comfortable temperature of only twenty-six or seven degrees." Twenty-six or seven degrees. That level of specific detail — it's the kind of thing that makes you feel like you're actually THERE. You can feel the cool air on your skin, hear the waves, see that moonlight on the water. And then Xu Lijing pops those sparkling water bottles — that sound of "pop" when the cap flies off, I swear I heard it in my head. The orange flavor, the lychee flavor, the way the carbonation fizzes. It's so sensory. But here's what makes this scene truly exceptional: the contrast. These three girls, setting up a canopy, stringing lights, playing Bluetooth music on a deserted beach, drawing in the sand — it's almost painfully idyllic. Like a Studio Ghibli moment. And that's what makes the ending hit so much harder. Because you KNOW, if you've been reading this far, that this peace is fragile. The beach is remote specifically because no one goes there. Their secret base exists away from the world for a reason. And then the wave. Oh the wave. "Unexpectedly, a wave hit, turning all three of them into drowned rats." I laughed out loud but also felt something ache in my chest, because you could feel how rare and precious this moment of unguarded joy was for Sheng Jia. She doesn't even realize her lips are rising until after the fact. The setting isn't just backdrop here — it's practically a character.
... Read More
Let's talk about what's actually at stake here, because it's NOT just a high school drama. Wang Jian — the abusive father, the convicted robber — walks out of prison in ONE YEAR. Sheng Jia knows this. Her mother knows this. The entire household is living on borrowed time. And Sheng Jia has already made up her mind: he does NOT get another chance. Period. But HOW she plans to ensure that remains the central mystery of the book, and it's making me incredibly nervous. She's working with someone called [R], who seems to have resources and connections. They're tracking Xu Lijing's movements. Sheng Jia claims she wants to 'resolve the conflict' — but with someone who deletes their message histories and speaks in coded questions, 'resolve' is a dangerously loose term. The internal stakes are just as real. Sheng Jia is Rank 1 in her grade. The college entrance exam is her escape route — her ticket out of this apartment, out of this neighborhood, out of the life her mother has created. If she falters, if she gets caught up in whatever scheme she's running with [R], everything collapses. She literally told herself: 'By the time he comes out, my college entrance exam will be over, and I won't be staying at home anymore. So I shouldn't see him.' She's planning her own disappearance before he even returns. And the external stakes? We don't know yet what [R] wants from her. Why is this anonymous handler invested in Sheng Jia's mission? What happened between R and Xu Lijing that makes this personal? The unanswered questions are piling up faster than I can process them, and honestly I don't care — I NEED to keep reading.
... Read More
Okay so this part with the calendar literally stopped me cold. Sheng Jia staring at that circled July 8th date? Chills. The whole narrative is built around this ticking bomb, and the author doesn't even have to say it outright — she just shows us the marked date and walks away like, yeah, that's your conflict right there. Wang Jian comes out in a year, and Sheng Jia has already decided 'scum should stay in prison and reflect for the rest of their lives.' That's not a teenager talking. That's someone who has calculated, weighed, and chosen. And then there's [R]. Who is this person? The messaging dynamic is fascinating — R asks probing questions like 'Did she take the bait?' and 'Do you think I believe that?' while Sheng Jia stays cryptic, deleting messages like she's covering tracks. She's running some kind of operation alongside this mysterious contact, tracking someone called Xu Lijing, and claiming she just wants to 'resolve the conflict.' Right. Sure. What kills me is how the mundane and the dangerous sit next to each other. She's doing English practice with fifteen-yuan headphones while simultaneously plotting who-knows-what. The contrast between her day life (top student, college entrance exam pressure) and her night life (secret communication, potential revenge) creates this incredible tension. Every chapter feels like walking a tightrope, and I'm completely hooked on finding out what her endgame actually is.
... Read More
Let me just say — the pacing in these chapters is absolutely ruthless and I mean that as the highest compliment. Chapter 14 starts with aftermath of the Xu Lijing scandal, transitions into the monthly exam, ends with the three girls being manhandled by Auntie Liu into a car like they're kidnapping victims and I was CACKLING. The exam section is brief but effective — six subjects in two days, the difficulty catching everyone off guard, Sheng Jia's mysterious calm responses. Quick, punchy, over before you can get bored. Chapter 15 is where it gets interesting structurally. The restaurant scene lasts about three pages — establishes wealth gap, establishes Sheng Jia's discomfort with expensive things, gives us Xu Lijing's ambition to transfer classes. Then BOOM — Su Zhaolin appears. Two pages of pure chaos and the author just drops us back into Sheng Jia's perspective like nothing happened. Then the hotel scene. Then the scooter ride. The scooter ride alone takes up half the chapter and it's just... driving. Driving and silence and the occasional word. And somehow it's the most emotionally charged sequence in the entire book. Chapter 16 splits into two POVs — Sheng Jia alone in her neighborhood, then Song Ji'an in the car. The structure here is basically: intimacy → separation → reflection. Sheng Jia walks into darkness after the warmth of the scooter ride. Song Ji'an looks back at her shrinking figure. Both girls processing the same moment from opposite directions. That structural choice — showing the same emotional beat from two perspectives in sequence — is chef's kiss. If I had one complaint, it's that Chapter 16 cuts off mid-sentence with Auntie Liu's advice about alternatives to financial help. I know it's batch 9 and we're moving to the next section, but that cliffhanger is going to haunt me.
... Read More
The pacing in this batch is deceptively loose. It starts with what feels like domestic comfort — Song Ji'an figuring things out, the study group forming, Xu Lijing being Xu Lijing, jokes about rich second generation projects, the café owner teasing about raises. It's warm. It's easy. You're smiling. And then BAM, the marathon flyer lands on the table and suddenly everyone has a deadline. The race against time for the exams, the race against themselves in the marathon, the race to figure out what's happening with the scholarship. The structure mirrors the marathon itself — there's a stretch of comfortable rhythm, then a steep hill, then a sprint finish. The exam results scene is perfectly placed right after the marathon discussion; it raises the stakes without us even noticing we were holding our breath. And the chapter ending on Sheng Jia's question? Chef's kiss. You want to immediately open the next chapter. Not because it's a cheap cliffhanger, but because the emotional math hasn't been solved yet. All those threads — the money, the distance, the unspoken feelings — they're all tightening at once.
... Read More
Let me tell you about the stakes in this book because on the surface they look small — high school exams, part-time jobs, transferring classes — but underneath? The earthquake is massive. Sheng Jia's conflict isn't one thing. It's layered like an onion made of trauma and determination. On the surface: she needs money, so she works nights at a hotel while maintaining top grades. That's impressive. But then you read her internal monologue and realize the real battle — she's fighting the version of herself that wants to envied other people's lives. She literally says she's 'working so hard to avoid envying other people's lives.' That's not ambition, that's survival mode with a side of self-loathing. Her relationship with her mother Sheng Huaiying is the ghost haunting every page. Sheng Jia tried to hug her as a child and was pushed away. Later, when her mother tried to embrace her, Sheng Jia 'never returned the embrace. Because she no longer needed to rely on anyone.' That line hit me like a truck. She chose independence because love came with rejection. She built a fortress and she is NEVER letting anyone inside it. And then Song Ji'an shows up. Song Ji'an represents everything Sheng Jia's fortress is built against — ease, warmth, the ability to lean on someone without feeling weak. The night ride scene is the conflict crystallized: Sheng Jia physically leans on Song Ji'an for the first time in seventeen years, and her own body betrays her exhaustion so badly she falls asleep standing up. Song Ji'an feels it. Song Ji'an notices. Song Ji'an wraps her hand around Sheng Jia's waist and says you can sleep. The stakes here aren't about winning an exam or transferring classes. The stakes are whether Sheng Jia can allow herself to need someone without feeling like it makes her weak. And I am SHOOK that the author is building toward this with such patience.
... Read More
I have to be honest with you — I read the part where Sheng Jia brings Song Ji'an her latte and I literally sat there staring at my phone for like ten seconds. "Because every day at noon, there's a osmanthus-flavored rice wine latte on your desk." I smell it every day. That is the most devastating thing anyone has ever said to another person in a novel. Think about what that means. Sheng Jia notices Song Ji'an's latte every single day. She smells it. She registers it. She files it away somewhere in her brain that she probably doesn't even know exists. And then when Song Ji'an asks how she knew her order, Sheng Jia just says it like it's nothing — but it's everything. This whole chapter is built on tiny emotional landmines that go off quietly and nobody hears them except the reader. Sheng Jia sitting alone on the temple threshold in the rain, not thinking about anything, just emptying her brain because her mind is always somewhere else. The fact that she lets herself be vulnerable for exactly three seconds in that car before putting the armor back on. The way Song Ji'an says "Then I'll have to consider it" when Sheng Jia offers to buy her coffee — this is someone who has been hurt before and knows what it costs to let someone in, but is choosing to try anyway. And then there's the mother-daughter moment with Sheng Huaiying. Sheng Jia tells Song Ji'an that if her mom saw her like this she'd worry she was being bullied, and then the narration tells us directly: "That was a lie. Sheng Huaiying wouldn't care about these things." So Sheng Jia is performing vulnerability for Song Ji'an. She is curating exactly how much of herself to show. That is heartbreaking in a completely different way — it means she has learned early that people only care about certain versions of you, so you give them that version and keep the rest locked up. The CP energy in this book is not about grand confessions or dramatic moments. It is about two people who are both hiding things, both watching each other, both trying to figure out if the other one is safe. That is so much more dangerous than any confession scene ever could be.
... Read More
Let's talk about what's actually at stake here, because it's not just a scholarship. Sheng Jia's entire survival strategy is built on the premise that she has to be self-sufficient, that needing anyone is a weakness she can't afford. And Song Ji'an is systematically proving her wrong at every turn. The exam results establish the academic stakes — Sheng Jia is holding onto first place, barely, and that matters for her future. But the deeper conflict is relational. Song Ji'an just revealed (indirectly) that her family has enough power to sponsor scholarships at a public high school. That means Song Ji'an operates in a world of influence and money that Sheng Jia has never had access to. And yet — Sheng Jia noticed the bonus data in Song Ji'an's project report before anyone else did. She read between the lines. She's not blindly accepting the kindness; she's actively trying to understand the terms. The question hanging over everything is whether Sheng Jia can let herself be cared for without feeling like she's entering a transaction she'll lose. And the marathon? That's the physical manifestation of this conflict — two people running the same route, side by side, but coming from completely different starting lines. How do you finish together when you've never been on the same track?
... Read More
I need to talk about the nighttime scenes in this batch because the author really knows how to paint with light and shadow. Binhai Highway at night — circular route, two kilometers, streetlights casting long shadows from the tiny electric scooter, the salty humid sea breeze mixing with summer heat. I literally felt the wind on my face reading this. And then the CDC: "quiet and deserted in the late night. Only a small amber light was on in the duty room." This detail hit me in the chest. That amber light in an empty clinic at midnight — it captured the entire mood of Sheng Jia's life in one image. But the scene that wrecked me was the ending. The car from the villa driving Sheng Jia home, Auntie Liu silently illuminating the road with high beams until Sheng Jia disappeared into those dark buildings, and then — "The light behind her also disappeared, and Sheng Jia was completely plunged into darkness. She seemed to have gone from one world to another. She returned to her world." No warm Auntie. No villa. No sea breeze. Just residents wailing like ghosts and wolves at night and... the sentence just trails off into darkness. The broken streetlight in her neighborhood, the fis — I assume the text got cut off but it doesn't matter. I was already destroyed. The visual contrast between these two worlds is basically the entire aesthetic of the book. One world has amber duty lights and clean hotel hallways; the other has broken streetlights and sounds that sound like ghosts.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author generates suspense without a single explosion, argument, or dramatic confrontation in these eight chapters. The tension is so thick you could cut it with a knife. The external conflict is almost comedic in its scale — a girl gets splashed with muddy water and can't catch a taxi. But the author elevates this tiny inconvenience into something that matters because of what it reveals about the power dynamics between Sheng Jia and Song Ji'an. Who has the cards? Who is playing whom? Sheng Jia engineers her own rescue by positioning herself at the temple at a specific time, banking on the rain and Song Ji'an's route. But Song Ji'an is also calculating — she notices the latte, she remembers the schedule, she leans in and says "Friends" like it is the most natural thing in the world. The internal conflict is where the real stakes live. Sheng Jia hates being dirty. She hates being vulnerable. She hates that a car full of strangers saw her like that. But she also needs help — and needing help is apparently the most terrifying thing in the world for her. The line "I'm too dirty" is not about mud. It is about shame. It is about a girl who has built her entire identity around self-sufficiency and just had it ripped apart by a puddle. And then there is the unstated conflict — the one between Sheng Jia and herself. She spent Wednesday hearing about Song Ji'an's weekend plans and instead of feeling excluded, she calculated how to be there. Why? What is she hoping to find at the end of that road? The story has not told us yet and that is what keeps me turning pages. The stakes in this book are not about life and death. They are about something far more intimate: who gets to see the real version of the other person first, and what happens when that person sees you at your most undignified and chooses to stay anyway.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or