Deliberate Fall - Reviews

Deliberate Fall
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to just — I need a moment. Song Ji'an. Song. Ji'an. How is the author letting this character exist with this much depth and I'm supposed to just act normal about it? Let's talk about Sheng Jia's inner monologue when she watches Song Ji'an and Xu Lijing laughing together. This passage destroyed me: "In her eyes, it seemed that ever since she met Song Ji'an, she had been shining brightly, so dazzling that it was almost burning her eyes. At least Sheng Jia knew that she would never be able to show such a radiant expression." She's not just admiring Song Ji'an. She's GRIEVING for the version of herself that could be radiant and carefree. The girl who grew up without needing to be 'the best Sheng Jia' just to survive. And then Song Ji'an notices her staring and SMILES at her. Not a pity smile. A warm, casual, 'what's wrong?' smile that completely unravels Sheng Jia's composure. But here's what really gets me — Song Ji'an's POV section. She's sitting in the car with Auntie Liu, and she's worried about Sheng Jia working too hard. She considers getting her a job at the Song family's mechanical museum. Then she immediately stops herself because she knows Sheng Jia would never accept charity. The fact that Song Ji'an UNDERSTANDS this about Sheng Jia — that she knows her boundaries, her pride, her unwillingness to be indebted — shows how deeply she's paying attention to her. And the ending of Chapter 15? When Sheng Jia leans on Song Ji'an's shoulder during the scooter ride and says thank you? And then Song Ji'an feels the vibration of Sheng Jia's voice through her shoulder and thinks about resonance? That is NOT just friendship energy. That is something else entirely and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
I need to vent about the cake scene. Seriously, author, why are you so good at these quiet emotional moments? So Sheng Jia rejects Song Ji'an pretty harshly, right? She says she doesn't need her as a friend or a hospital companion. I was sitting there like, oof, that's cold. But then Song Ji'an doesn't get upset. She just… waits. And when they reach the classroom, she pulls out this box of little cakes her mom made, and says something like, 'treat it as a thank you gift, not a friend gift.' I literally had to put the book down and stare at the ceiling. That level of grace? After being shut down so clearly? It's devastating and beautiful. Sheng Jia accepting it silently says so much without words. She's not used to kindness that comes without strings. And Song Ji'an's innocence—it's not childish; it's a choice. She sees Sheng Jia's pain and decides to reach out anyway. That's the kind of emotional depth that makes me want to hug both characters. Later, when Sheng Jia disappears before Song Ji'an can find her, there's this ache, you know? Like she wants connection but is terrified of it. The subtext is screaming here. Every glance, every pause between them is charged. This isn't just plot; it's emotional storytelling at its finest. I'm already invested.
... Read More
I want to talk about how remarkably restrained the dialogue is in these chapters and why it works so well. Sheng Jia barely speaks. Like, at all. When asked about the exam, she says 'I don't know.' When Song Ji'an offers help with the menu, she says 'Okay.' When she finally thanks Song Ji'an on the scooter, it's just 'Thank you' twice, separated by silence and sea breeze. And yet — her silence IS her voice. Every unspoken word carries more weight than the actual dialogue. Compare that to Xu Lijing, who is ALL dialogue. 'Order whatever you want.' 'Should we toast again?' She rattles off menu recommendations effortlessly. She's loud, performative, socially fluid — and she's also genuinely warm in her own way. Song Ji'an occupies the middle ground. Her dialogue is natural, casual, laced with teasing ('So today is your celebration feast?') but also punctuated with these incredibly soft moments. 'You can lean on me and sleep. I know the way.' That's it. Four words. No flourish. No drama. Just availability. And the narration itself has this wonderful dry humor scattered throughout. The line about classmates regretting that the scandal peaked before the monthly exam because 'they couldn't enjoy the gossip to their heart's content' — that's the author winking at us. She knows these are teenagers and she's not pretending otherwise. Su Zhaolin's scene has zero dialogue but maximum personality. She argues, she sits in silence, she opens champagne, she chases a woman out of a restaurant. We don't hear a single word from her and we know EXACTLY what kind of person she is. The dialogue here proves that what characters DON'T say matters more than what they do. Especially Sheng Jia, whose voice is defined by everything she refuses to express out loud.
... Read More
Okay, so I have to talk about Sheng Jia and Song Ji'an because, honestly, they're my favorite pair right now and I can't stop thinking about them. Sheng Jia is this incredibly sharp, guarded character who has clearly been through some shit—her family situation is terrible, she's got a bleeding wrist, and she handles bullies like she's doing choreography. When she threatened Xu Lijing with the pocket watch, I was like, wow, this girl is dangerous. But then Song Ji'an shows up, all bright and cheerful, and suddenly Sheng Jia's world gets interesting. Their first conversation? Sheng Jia basically interrogates her while Song Ji'an just takes it in stride. I love how Sheng Jia says, 'I know who you are,' so abrupt, but Song Ji'an isn't fazed. She's curious, not intimidated. That's a huge character moment for both of them. Sheng Jia is so used to being alone, using people or keeping them at arm's length, but Song Ji'an is just… there, offering cakes and wanting to be friends. And when Sheng Jia rejects her flat-out—'I don't need either'—I thought Song Ji'an would bounce back, but no, she just smiles and follows her. That's when I knew Song Ji'an is special too. She's not naive; she's just genuinely kind, which is rarer. The way they walk together after the infirmary, silence between them but comfortable, tells me everything. Sheng Jia is lowering her walls, even if she won't admit it. This isn't just a friendship; it feels like the beginning of something deeper, maybe even romantic tension, but I'm not sure yet. What do you think? Is it too soon to ship them?
... Read More
There's something about this abandoned open space behind the small grove of trees that stays with me. The author describes it almost casually—a place where students go to escape reality, clear their minds—but it becomes the single most emotionally charged location in these chapters. That's because the setting isn't just a backdrop. It's a liminal space. Not quite school, not quite the outside world. A place where the rules of the classroom don't apply, where Xu Lijing can cry without being watched by teachers, where Song Ji'an can overhear something she was never meant to witness. And the visual composition of that scene is cinematic. Xu Lijing on the cement steps, tear-streaked face, covering her bruised eye socket. Sheng Jia standing beside her with that cloth bag still on her shoulder, expressionless. Then the wall between them and Song Ji'an, who is hidden behind it like a ghost. When Xu Lijing's friends pull Song Ji'an out from behind the wall, the whole image shifts—from private grief to exposed confrontation in a matter of seconds. But what really makes this setting work is the contrast with the playground. The playground is where the established friendships happen—Meng Yeran and Zhou Yin playing badminton, the sound of shuttlecocks piercing the air. It's sunny, social, safe. The clearing is the shadow version of that: a place where conflicts surface, where people fall apart, where truths come out that would never be spoken under fluorescent classroom lights. The author builds two worlds within the school grounds, and the movement between them is what gives the narrative its pulse.
... Read More
Stakes aren't just about life or death; they're about identity, and this story nails it. Sheng Jia's entire survival depends on maintaining her image: top student, teacher's pet, harmless. But the back street fight exposes her competence, her ruthlessness. If that gets out, everything collapses. 'Once this image was cracked, it would be her who suffered the losses.' That line haunts me. The external conflict with bullies is clear, but the internal conflict is sharper: she wants normalcy but must stay dangerous. Song Ji'an's presence threatens that balance—she sees the real Sheng Jia and isn't afraid. That's the core tension. Will Sheng Jia let her in? Will her secret destroy her carefully built world? The pocket watch moment raises stakes exponentially; it's leverage, yes, but also a vulnerability. Xu Lijing now knows Sheng Jia investigates people. The game has changed. Every interaction carries weight. The author makes you feel the tightrope walk. I'm hooked.
... Read More
Okay, so let's talk about the hotel scene because honestly this was my favorite part of this batch. The setup is just *chef's kiss* — Sheng Jia is working a cleaning job she's clearly embarrassed about, and who does she walk into? Song Ji'an, sitting on a sofa looking slightly defeated. The author could have made this awkward and then dropped it, but no. Instead, Song Ji'an somehow ends up waiting for her after work with a tiny electric scooter. This is the kind of plot turn that makes you want to shake the main character and say "JUST ACCEPT THE HELP." And then the whole arc continues through the CDC visit, the scooter ride around Binhai Highway, and finally dropping Song Ji'an back at her villa before Sheng Jia heads home to her... well, whatever nightmare that dark neighborhood was. The plot doesn't need massive twists here — it's a slow burn, and that's exactly what it should be. Every scene builds the proximity between these two girls. Song Ji'an keeps finding reasons to be near Sheng Jia, and Sheng Jia keeps finding reasons to push her away. Classic, yes, but executed with enough subtlety that it doesn't feel lazy. My only complaint: I wish we got a bit more from Sheng Jia's perspective on WHY she's so resistant. We get hints — the cheap vaccine, the resentment about the scooter cost — but I wanted more interiority. That said, the author is playing the long game, so maybe that's intentional.
... Read More
Xu Lijing has never lost a fight. Like, ever. And the moment she loses to Sheng Jia—accidentally getting hit in the face, having to look in a mirror and see her own bruised eye socket—that's when everything unravels. Because her fighting ability isn't just a skill. It's her identity. It's how she proves to herself that she still exists, that she still matters, that the people who called her a violent madwoman were wrong. When she loses, she doesn't just lose a physical confrontation. She loses the last proof that she's in control of anything. So she cries. Not because of the injury—she's too tough for that. She cries because the mirror showed her weakness, and weakness is the one thing she can't afford when she has no grandmother left to defend her, no parents to listen to her side, no one who believes in her except a dead woman. And here's the thing that makes the stakes so high: Sheng Jia could have walked away. She didn't have to explain anything. She didn't have to sit down and tell Song Ji'an her whole history. But she did. And I think the reason is that Sheng Jia understands exactly what Xu Lijing is losing. Sheng Jia has her own dormancy, her own strategies, her own way of protecting herself. But she recognizes in Xu Lijing someone who is fighting a war with no visible enemy—fighting grief, fighting memory, fighting the silence of people who've stopped believing in her. The real conflict here isn't Xu Lijing vs. Sheng Jia. It's two damaged girls testing whether honesty is possible between them. And the stakes? If they fail, they go back to being alone. If they succeed... well, the story hasn't told us that part yet, has it?
... Read More
I'm not even exaggerating when I say Xu Lijing's dead grandmother is the most powerful presence in this entire passage. She's not even in the story alive anymore, yet every single one of Xu Lijing's actions traces back to her. The girl who beats up boys who bully her friends because her grandmother told her she was doing the right thing. The girl who, after her grandmother dies, has no one left to vouch for her, and so decides to become the violent madwoman everyone already accuses her of being—because it's easier than being misunderstood by people who don't matter. When she confronts Sheng Jia, crying on those cement steps, I felt something genuinely ache. This is a girl who has never lost a fight in years, who depends on physical dominance as a way of controlling a world that keeps taking things from her, and she's sobbing because someone she barely knows saw her vulnerable. And the reason she's so obsessed with this fight with Sheng Jia? It's not really about the café incident. It's about the fact that Sheng Jia knows her soft spot—her grandmother—and used it against her. That's a violation deeper than any physical blow. Then there's Song Ji'an's relationship with Meng Yeran, which is briefly but effectively sketched in. Twenty-plus years of friendship, family business ties, occasional childhood playdates, and now they're just naturally falling back into rhythm. Song Ji'an complains, Meng Yeran smirks. No performances between them. I keep coming back to the contrast though: Song Ji'an gets to have this easy, established friendship while Sheng Jia seems to orbit alone, and Xu Lijing clings to memories of a dead grandmother. Who gets to be loved in this world?
... Read More
Let me just start by saying: the description of Fajin Temple in these chapters is one of the most atmospheric pieces of writing I have read in a long time and I am not being dramatic about it. The author establishes the location in layers. First the journey — forty minutes on a small motorcycle, the coast, blue sea water behind the temple. Then the sensory shift: "the smell of incense completely covers the salty smell of the sea." That single line does so much work. It tells us this is a place where the mundane world (the ocean, the ride, the rain) meets something older and more sacred. And then it gets even better. Sheng Huaiying praying to whatever Bodhisattva she can see, asking to win back money at mahjong, scanning a QR code to donate — this is such a specific, grounded, alive detail. This is not a generic temple scene. This is a woman who treats spirituality like a vending machine and the author loves her for it. The humor here is so well-calibrated. Then the rain starts again. Sheng Jia sitting on the threshold, not going in, just watching drops fall from the eaves. The courtyard is empty because of the weather — and that emptiness is everything. This is the only time in these chapters where Sheng Jia is truly alone with her thoughts, and the author gives us that silence like a gift. The monkey scene is absurd in the best possible way. A sixteen-year-old macaque named Danggui who has her own territory on the mountain and comes to her human friend when she is tired. "She actually likes you quite a bit," Master Feng says. And I keep thinking about how that applies to Sheng Jia on a symbolic level — even a wild monkey recognizes when someone is safe to be vulnerable around. The contrast between the temple — quiet, ancient, rainy, incense-filled — and the modern world outside (smartphones, QR codes, taxis, Netflix) is something the author never spells out but feels in every paragraph. This is a story about people trying to find something real in a world that keeps accelerating.
... Read More
Can we just talk about how good the group dynamics dialogue is? Xu Lijing saying "the wool comes from the sheep" and immediately demanding ice cream as compensation after Sheng Jia gets a raise? That's not just comic relief, that's a perfectly calibrated character moment. She's loud, shameless, and absolutely delighted to bother people — and she's also the one who notices Song Ji'an typing and actually asks about it instead of just ignoring her. Zhou Yijia going full chuunibyou mode with the "let the heavens grow cold, let the kings perish" line had me wheezing. And Song Yi's entrance — literally walking in and saving the conversation from awkwardness by pivoting to the marathon — that's such a specific kind of social intelligence. But the real dialogue highlight is the Sheng Jia / Song Ji'an exchange at the very end. Three sentences. Three sentences and you can feel the entire history between them. "Because that day when you were writing your project report at the café, there were data related to bonuses." Sheng Jia doesn't soften it. Doesn't wrap it in empathy. She just states the logic, plain and clean, like she's handing Song Ji'an a mirror and asking her to look. And Song Ji'an's response — earnest disbelief, genuine confusion — shows she still doesn't fully grasp how deeply Sheng Jia watches her. Their voices are so distinct you could tell them apart blindfolded.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment for how brilliantly written the dialogue is in this batch? Every character has such a distinct voice and I'm obsessed. Xu Lijing is pure fire — "Before, I didn't know what to do tomorrow every day, but now I suddenly know what I want to do!" That burst of declaration, right after they've just won something together? That's not just dialogue, that's a character revelation dressed up as excitement. And then her whole monologue about wanting to become a lawyer: "I've been clumsy since I was a child, so I have such a bad temper. I can't win arguments with others. I'm not that eloquent, so I can only use my fists to protect myself." This is the most vulnerable she's ever been on the page and it lands because it's spoken with the same directness that defines her. But the real masterclass is Sheng Jia's dialogue — or rather, the strategic absence of it. When Song Ji'an offers to pay her back and Sheng Jia hands over three hundred, she says almost nothing. "This is what you deserve." Two words. Cold, clean, exact. And Song Ji'an's response — pushing it back with that clever, almost playful deflection: "If you want to thank me, you have to think of other ways, right? Just owe it to me first" — THAT is such a Song Ji'an line. It's manipulative but also genuinely warm underneath, and the way she's clearly learning smugness from Xu Lijing is hilarious. And then Sheng Huaiying at the end: "Wherever you go, Mom will follow you." So simple. So devastating. The mother doesn't say "I'm scared" or "I can't do this anymore." She just offers the only thing she has — presence. And Sheng Jia's internal response: "But Mom, I'm not your child, I also want to follow my mom." UNHINGED. I am undone. The narrative voice here is just so precise about what characters choose to say versus what they swallow.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or